YMMV / Fate/Prototype

  • Base-Breaking Character: Fans either love or hate Manaka, there is no in-between. Either she's a badass and refreshingly fun Big Bad (and Villain Protagonist in Fragments) who spins around many typical tropes and whose child-like craziness makes quite the contrast with the usual angsty villainesses who need tragic reasons to ever turn to the bad side, or she's a stupid and flat Villain Sue without any qualities to compensate for how much of an asshole she is to anyone not named Saber and who gets away with way too many things. Might have been a reason for why her character was cut in the final draft that became Fate/stay night.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse:
  • Fan-Preferred Couple:
    • From Prototype:
      • Proto-Saber/Ayaka is popular enough. But some fans prefer Proto-Rider/Ayaka instead. That or with Proto-Lancer.
      • Proto-Saber/Proto-Archer is also well-liked. Although it's very much different from the dynamic that their FSN-Counterparts have.
    • From Prototype Fragments:
      • Some like pairing Archer with Assassin. His immunity to her poison makes him one of the few people who could get near her.
      • Berserker and his Master are very often paired up together, unsurprising considering that they're one of the the Master-Servant pair with the best relationship in the war.
  • Foe Yay:
    • Lucius Tiberius from a flashback in Fragments is overflowing with joy at fighting the Dragon Arthur.
    • Proto Mordred also has some umhealthy desires for their father.
    Mordred: Father. I'll destroy everything that you love! You won't need anything, won't desire anything. I'll make you love me till you scream out in despair!
    • Weaponized with Brynhild. The more in love she is with her opponents the stronger she gets.
  • Ho Yay: With a Cast Full of Pretty Boys, who's even surprised?
  • No Yay: From Fragments, Assassin and Zombified-Tatsumi
  • The Scrappy: Paracelsus. While other Casters were indeed on the side of evil, the former Jumping Off the Slippery Slope one too many times made him just detestable. It doesn't help his case that he is not as over the top evil as Gilles, or as flamboyant as Shakespeare, making him less interesting or fun, and far easier to hate despite his very pretty looks.
  • Tear Jerker: Much of the ending of Fragments. It's not that Arthur killed Manaka because he found out her true intentions, and he hadn't been fighting his way to reach her with that in mind, either. But when he arrived just in time to witness her father butchered, scores of young girls throwing themselves to the mouth of the Grail and a young Ayaka screaming and crying in fear as her own older sister dragged her by the hair to throw her to her death as a mere sacrifice, there was just no other way. Unusued stills from the Prototype OVA hammer home his misery at what he had to do by showing his face after running Manaka through, cast in shame by his hood with a look of the purest melancholy emptiness. This action would even cause him to slip off the wagon somewhat in becoming an a shade nihilistic.
    • Brynhildr is a tragic heroine whose entire legend centers around her love, and in turn, any man who matches the quality of her lover, Sigurd, in life, she will call Sigurd and desperately try to kill them. So, why is this tragic? There is one man she doesn't call Sigurd. In the climax of the battle for Tokyo, Brynhildr's rune is going out of control and, in a moment, of clarity, she calls Arthur by name and begs him to kill her. He accepts, but as she fades away, her affections haven't daunted — but she's not calling him Sigurd. Cut to years later in Prototype, and the Servants who were trapped in the Grail are risen by Manaka as undead Alters, Brynhildr included. Her goal, just as ever, is to kill the man she loves...but this time, the name firmly in her mind is Arthur. Against all odds, against the very foundation of her existence and legend, Brynhildr truly fell in love, with a man she honestly saw as himself...and no one will ever know it.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/YMMV/FatePrototype