These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
YMMV: Drake & Josh
Alternative Character Interpretation: Do Walter and Audrey show signs of being responsible parents by grounding Drake and Josh when they do something terrible? Or are they just stupid based on how they never see Megan for what she really is or care about what the boys get put through?
Is Drake's stupidity merely a mask so he can focus on his music? Or is he genuinely that stupid? Sometimes episodes provide cases for both.
Creator's Pet: Megan being a massive Jerk Sue who made her brothers miserable for no reason yet got away with everything and infuriated the fandom to the point they legitimately wanted her killed off. For some reason, Dan was completely unaware of this.
Ensemble Darkhorse: Crazy Steve was meant as a one time gag, with the seemingly stoned (and mulletted) Gavin being the recurring weird buddy. Jerry Trainor hit that role so well that he was kept on and was brought on to iCarly as a main character.
Mindy also appears to be a textbook example, as she returned some time after her initial appearance and took on a much larger recurring role dating Josh.
Trevor, Drake's dim-witted friend, who appeared in one early episode before becoming The Ghost for the rest of the series.
Fridge Logic: Sure it's obvious how Drake got arrested but how did Josh get arrested in Merry Christmas Drake & Josh?
Butt MonkeyRunning Gag. The cops mistook Josh to be one of the party crashers, much like he was also arrested in Theater Thug.
"Funny Aneurysm" Moment: Jokes about Drake's vanity becomes this when you realise that Drake Bell was involved in a car accident during production of the series, and had to have cosmetic surgery as a result of it.
The Dune Buggy episode, where most of the humor comes from Drake injuring himself in a bad wreck, becomes this for the same reason.
Seeing Drake wrestle with his girlfriend Lucy (Gabrielle Christian) can be a little unsettling when take her other role into context
In the football episode, Zeke's short-term memory loss as a result of a concussion is played for laughs. Watching it years later after the effects concussions have had on former NFL players have become common knowledge makes it not so funny.
In the episode "The Demonator," Josh's crazy WWII vet of a grandpa mistakes Craig and Eric for Germans and repeatedly attacks them. The gag becomes considerably less funny a few episodes later, when a one-off line by Drake informs us that Craig and Eric are Jewish.
Hilarious in Hindsight: Watching the early episodes, where the characters laugh at the mere thought that someone would find Josh attractive over Drake becomes very funny when you remember how Josh Peck looked when the series ended...
Plus how he looked in his cameo at the very end of the Victorious episode "Wok Star", too.
Second Verse Curse: The theme I Find A Way has a full version. The one in the opening credits is only the minute-long version.
The Scrappy: Megan is hated by many. She's a Villain Sue in a show without any heroes, so all her schemes target her two brothers, Drake and Josh. Megan never gets caught, never gets punished, and there are quite a few examples of her benefiting from her schemes, just plain coming out on top in an episode she's barely in. The writers tried to balance this out by giving Drake and Josh a few Kick the Dog moments towards her, making her schemes more Disproportionate Retribution than anything, but by then Drake and Josh's pranks were seen as justified revenge for everything she had done to them so far.It doesn't help as well that Megan basically was the instigator for later characters that have the same behavior as Megan in Dan's shows after this one.
After Flanderization Drake becomes a Scrappy. He becomes near sociopathic while his intelligence drops to the point where you question how he can even get dressed in the morning. The fact he also dates girls solely for their bodies is unfortunate as well.
Drake and Josh's parents. No more needs to be said.
I have to disagree. What makes them Scrappies?
Their parents are Scrappies due to their obliviousness to Megan's Obviously Evil actions, ignoring their side of the story whenever something screws up, and punishing them over and over again while they reward Megan over and over again.
Unpopular Popular Character: By the end of the last season, Josh is looking good. He lost all of his weight, he has a job, he has serious, long term girlfriends, and in general became just as hot as Drake, but more successful at life. Somehow Josh is still treated as if he is the loser of the two. Charisma probably goes a long way.
The problem isn't that he isn't hot, it's just that Josh has really terrible luck, and when you couple that with Rule of Funny, he ends up becoming the butt monkey of the two. (Though Drake has his butt monkey moments)
Everyone who confuses Josh for "the theater thug". EVEN THE POLICE confuses him for the Thug... while the thug was right next to him!! Played for Laughs, since even Josh himself seems confused by how so many people keep mistaking him for the real guy. What's more, "FBI's Most Wanted" specifically said if you see the theater thug, "do not confront him because he's known to be extremely violent. Just contact the police". Whenever people think Josh is the thug, they run over and beat him up...
In the episode My Dinner With Bobo, Dr. Favisham has locked the boys in his closet to keep them from saving Bobo. He asks to see their cellphones to prove that it has Bluetooth.
You'd expect: That Josh would see through this, keep his phone away and try to get him and Drake out of there while Favisham was distracted.
Instead: When Favisham opens the door, he holds his phone out, and Favisham takes it then proceeds to lock the door again. Seriously, you can immediately tell that things are going to go bad right when he opens the door. Drake even lampshades this by saying, "Yeah, nice going, BLUETOOTH!"
Also, in Alien Invasion, the titular characters had enough of Megan's pranks on them that they decided to get even with her by making her believe that there are aliens.
Instead: They just prank her with all they got. Megan gets back at them by hiring someone to dress up as an alien.
In "Peruvian Puff Pepper", the titular duo and Megan are taking part in a Salsa contest, it soon turns out that Megan is apparently using a Peruvian Puff Pepper for the contest.
You'd expect: In the case that Megan might be using it for a bigger plan, and especially after they research it on the Internet and find out that the Peruvian Puff Pepper is only available in "South Am-ar-eek-a", that Drake and Josh would throw it away or sell it to somebody else taking part in the contest.
Instead: They decide to use it in their Salsa, and when it's revealed that the Peruvian Puff Pepper causes kidney failure and chapped lips, they are disqualified. Thus, Megan wins once more.
Also, in the movie "Drake & Josh Go Hollywood", Drake and Josh are kidnapped and held in a private room. Josh pulls out his phone.
You'd Expect: For Josh to keep quiet, wait, and then use his phone to call the police to save himself and Drake.
Instead: He doesn't hide his phone, and one of the bad guys walk into the room that Drake and Josh are in, takes his phone, and walks out. Wait to go there, Josh.