YMMV / DC: The New Frontier

  • Nightmare Retardant: Batman's first costume is supposed to look intimidating, but due to Darwyn Cooke's Lighter and Softer art style he still looks pretty cuddly.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character:
    • Despite all the buildup as a major character, Superman is quickly knocked out by the Center and is missing until the end.
    • Robin only appears briefly, and is just used as a plot device for Batman to tell Superman about his new Lighter and Softer style.note 
    • Aquaman only makes a brief appearance at the end.
  • The Woobie: Poor Martian Manhunter.