YMMV / Crystal Castles

For the musical duo:
  • Awesome Music: "Not in Love" definitely counts. Robert Smith of The Cure on vocals, Alice Glass' breathy ones joining in at the bridge, and Ethan Kath's newly polished production skills really make it for this one.
    • "Alice Practice", the song that introduced them to the world. Basically what would happen if you captured a chiptune band and a female-fronted hardcore punk band and made them fight. It's glorious.
  • Broken Base: Post-Alice departure, some fans are divided on who to side with regarding quarrels between Ethan and Alice. Alice has claimed that Ethan stifled her creative input, while also saying she's the one who wrote most of the lyrics for the group's songs, while Ethan has maintained that he's the one who has had most of the creative control, even prior to Alice joining him to form Crystal Castles (and has kinda passive-aggressively mentioned how some of CC's more popular songs did not even feature Alice's vocal work).
  • Covered Up: Their drastically altered version of "Crimewave" from HEALTH's self-titled LP is better known than the original. Compare and contrast.
    • Also happened after the release of "Not in Love", as many people didn't realize it was originally a Platinum Blonde song.
  • Hell Is That Noise: There's that strange noise that repeats throughout "Plague" that sounds almost like a warped whale song. It sounds a bit like CC watched the trailer for Prometheus and went home to make a song.
    • The entirety of "I Am Made of Chalk".
  • Nightmare Fuel: Once again, "I Am Made of Chalk". It's probably one of the weirdest songs they've put out, consisting almost entirely of modulated wailing and screaming. The amount of speculation as to just what the song means makes it reach levels of Mind Screw equal to the work of Swans.
  • Tear Jerker: "Tell Me What to Swallow"

For the video game: