YMMV / Bump in the Night

  • Ear Worm: many of the Karaoke Cafe songs.
  • Nightmare Fuel: "Farewell, 2 Arms," in which Molly, tired of being weak and breakable, slowly has her body parts replaced with stronger toy parts. From a toy's perspective, that's creepy enough, but then she decides that she wants a new head. Mr. Bumpy's head.
    • She announces this by pulling her head off and throwing it at him.
  • Ugly Cute: Molly.
  • The Woobie: Squishington is sometimes this, one particular example being in the Christmas special when he feels depressed over his inability to tap dance due to his lack of feet.