YMMV: Bronies: The Extremely Unexpected Adult Fans of My Little Pony
- Broken Base: Many fans of the show were disappointed over how the documentary spend less focus on the history of the MLP franchise and the fandom as well as it's problem and the culture and more on individual fans and their experiences going to the Brony Con convention.
- Further split by the fact that some questioning if it was too early for the bronies to have their own documentary or even a documentary period. '
- Harsher in Hindsight: JanAnimations's role within the documentary (his animation being the "Let's Go and Meet the Bronies!" musical number) because painful when you learn him, as well as his other pony-related projects including Button's Adventures were put on hold because of Hasbro's obsessive Cease and Desists copy-right attacks.
- Suspiciously Similar Song: de Lancie's song during the animation is a parody of the song, 'My Eyes Are Fully Open', from Gilbert and Sullivan's Ruddigore.