History YMMV / BattleFantasia

* GuideDangIt: Getting the secret routes in each character's story mode. The game tells you which fight is the one that will lead you to the extra route- but what exactly do you have to do? The game doesn't give you a hint.

* BrokenBase: The announcement of a PC port of the game in July 2015 was controversial, to say the least. Fans of Arc System Works are divided as to whether the port is a good opportunity to experience a lesser-known gem, or if the game is outdated, unnecessary, and a waste of effort that could instead be going towards bringing more recent and popular titles such as ''VideoGame/GuiltyGearXrd'' or ''VideoGame/BlazBlueChronophantasma'' to PC instead (both of these titles were later ported to PC).

* BrokenBase: The announcement of a PC port of the game in July 2015 was controversial, to say the least. Fans of Arc System Works are divided as to whether the port is a good opportunity to experience a lesser-known gem, or if the game is outdated, unnecessary, and a waste of effort that could instead be going towards bringing more recent and popular titles such as ''VideoGame/GuiltyGearXrd'' or ''VideoGame/BlazBlueChronophantasma'' to PC instead.

* PortingDisaster: The Revised Edition on PC was handled by [=DotEmu=], a company notorious for poor "ports" that are just the original versions running in emulators. The game has periodic fits of stuttering, very laggy netcode, and at launch had limited resolution options, with the game scaling from 720p no matter what.

* PortingDisaster: The Revised Edition on PC was handled by [=DotEmu=], a company notorious for poor "ports" that are just the original versions running in emulators. The game has periodic fits of stuttering, very laggy netcode, and has limited resolution options, with the game scaling from 720p no matter what.

* NeedsMoreLove: Nobody cared about this game in Japan because it was basically being used as a release stopgap for ''VideoGame/BlazBlue'', and nobody in America knows it exists due to a very limited release (also caused by its localizer and distributor putting its full attention to ''VideoGame/BlazBlue''.)

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Not a strong case, but Cedric's femenine enough to trick people with a first glance. Also Ashley, if only because of his name.

* CrowningMomentOfFunny: When Marco arives to an empty church and claims he has to save the game in case something bad happens so he doesn't have to start from the beggining. He hums a little tune and then a dialog box appears: "Nothing was saved".

* NeedsMoreLove: Nobody cared about this game in Japan because it was basically being used as a release stopgap for ''BlazBlue'', and nobody in America knows it exists due to a very limited release (also caused by its localizer and distributor putting its full attention to ''BlazBlue''.)