YMMV / And Shine Heaven Now

  • Die for Our Ship: Meta-example: Xuanwu tried to convince Erin to kill off Mamoru in the Eurekon arc so Usagi could get together with Seiya. Erin didn't go for it.
  • Shipping: Not only do the many fangirls have couples they ship, but while clinging to a host they can enforce them
  • Squick: When it's pointed out that Integra's pin used to belong to her father, Sailor Ghoul asks if he used to wear a sailor suit too. The others try hard not to think about this.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Stephen, usually a bit of a stubborn ass, but has his Woobie-ish moments, particularly when he was found post-turning, and where his Morality Pet Jon is concerned.

YMMV items found in the main Shineverse:

  • Archive Panic: Seven years and counting.
  • Better Than Canon: At least one troper thinks so.
  • Cargo Ship: Fangirls x Coffin, Girlycard x Walter x Coffin (kinda)
  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: The Captain takes advantage of being in the Major's body to sing ''Stayin' Alive''
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Enrico asks "[[ Wait, is that Integra's team getting completely demolished?]]" That very day England gets trounced by Germany 4-1, getting eliminated from the 2010 World Cup. (It counts cause the comic went up at midnight EST Sunday, hours before the game began.)
  • Fan Nickname: iJeeves, for the Jeeves I-Jin
  • Like You Would Really Do It: Wait...Marian's...
  • One-Scene Wonder: Integra's mother.
  • Puppy Love: Calvin/Susie.
  • Schedule Slip: Oddly enough, when this happens, it's usually because something is up with the host site. When Erin needs a break for schoolwork or her computer being on the fritz (again), she posts guest comics, and more recently a feature on Integra fansites.
    • Which has been pointed out by Jon Stewart here.
    • Though there was one time she deliberately postponed the plot for more Integra spottings: she felt uncomfortable posting a story about a fictional London burning at the same time as the real life London riots were happening.
  • What Could Have Been: The 'Storylines that Weren't'
    • How Reseda Met Helena: Exactly What It Says on the Tin. Never got past the concept and the idea of drawing all those Pimped Out Dresses was too daunting.
    • Madeline and Friends: Madeline's adventures in the Holy League. Never got past a cast of characters (Madeline, Pepito, and a Muslim girl codenamed Mitraille).
    • Catholintegra: Enrico finds an I-Jin of Gregor Mendel and tries to create a Catholic version of Integra. Dropped cause Caterina Sforza of Trinity Blood made a good Catholic Integra already, so it was retconned into an Iscariot in the far future being more successful in creating Catholintegra than Enrico was.
    • Let The Flames Begin: A Mirror Universe where instead of fangirls invading, flamers do.
    • Everything's Better With Yuri: A Gender Flip of Pip.
    • A Proper Lupin III Adventure: Hellsing is recruited to stop Lupin III from stealing the Crown Jewels.
    • Hellsing Heir Auditions: Integra seeks out someone to adopt as her heir. Dropped when the Grand Finale of Hellsing reveals that the head of Hellsing will be a government-appointed position from now on, starting with Penwood's grandson.
    • The Adventure of the Chinatown Pet Shop: Sherlock Holmes meets Pet Shop of Horrors.
    • Integra's Inferno: Integra does Dante's Inferno. Erin never worked out what she'd be searching for.
    • '99 cameos: Pippi Longstocking, Saint Tail, Scooby-Doo and the gang, and Ms. Frizzle's (now college aged) class were considered for cameos.

YMMV items found in The Eagle of Hermes:

  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: Technically occurs in Shine proper, but:
    Stephen: [shoots Alhambra] What's that, Sweetness? You say he talks too much? You think we should shoot him some more? That's my girl.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: "Is she seriously revising ancient alchemy on the fly?"