YMMV: According to Jim
- Critical Dissonance: Despite getting mostly negative reviews by critics, the show was popular enough that it aired for eight years.
- Hilarious in Hindsight: In the season 3 finale, Cheryl is taking a pregnancy test at the beginning, and her and Jim are discussing what it'll be like if the test is positive, (though Jim is less optimistic about another kid them he lets on) Jim says "I hope it's twins!" which is pretty hilarious since Cheryl eventually DOES give birth to twins later on in the series.
- Ho Yay: Between Jim and Andy.
- Most Annoying Sound: The Devlins, the single most irritating couple you'll ever meet, perpetually happy and overly friendly people who never get mad at anyone for anything, laugh at everything and make terrible jokes, and tend to show up unannounced.
- Uncanny Valley: There is something creepy in Cheryl's smile.