YMMV / A Midnight Clear

  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: It's a very perverse and depressing one, but Mother taking down the Germans during the "battle" shows that, despite spending the movie in a state of Heroic B.S.O.D., he is capable of bravery when his buddies are in danger. Or when he thinks they are.
  • Crowning Moment of Funny: Will's cynical narration about the army invokes this in a Black Comedy manner.
  • Crowning Moment of Heartwarming: The middle act, before it becomes a Tearjerker. The Americans and Germans setting aside their differences, making friends, getting in a snowball fight and singing Christmas Carols.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Will describes the incompetent Major Griffin as a former mortician apparently racking up business for his army counterparts. John C. McGinley, who played Griffin, stars as a doctor in Scrubs. One of the characters in the latter is an incompetent doctor who becomes a mortician.
  • It Was His Sled: Go ahead, find someone who don't know how the deal with the Germans ended. People are more likely to know about the bloody mess created by Mother than anything else from the film.
  • Nightmare Fuel: Posthumous Character Eddie, who loses his left arm and suffers severe facial wounds in an ill-fated patrol before the events of the movie. A flashback shows him in a field hospital, heavily bandaged, with one open eye staring hauntingly into the camera, and by default, the viewer's soul. We are not shown his face, which somehow makes it worse.
    • The dead American and German, embraced by frostbite, is just eerie...
  • Tearjerker: The final act.
    • The "battle" sparking a firefight that leads to all the Germans being killed.
    • Father Mundy's death.
    • The Bittersweet Ending: The four survivors of Intelligence never make contact again when the war ends, with the exception of Mother sending a lone $10 dollar bill to Will every Christmas, to pay off a bet.