Season 1, episode 9 has two. The first one is delivered by Team Guido: they've managed to beat Nancy and Emily to the Fast Forward, an in-game device that allows a team to skip all other tasks and proceed straight to the Pit Stop. You'd expect: Team Guido to hop on the next passing cab or train to the Pit Stop to arrive there in first place with a good lead on the other teams. Instead: They decide to rest in a hotel, confident that their lead is big enough to lounge around for a couple of hours. This causes them to arrive at the Pit Stop in dead last place. Yes, behind even Nancy and Emily, the very team they beat for the green pass. Clearly, they'd never heard the fable of the Tortoise and the Hare.
The sole reason Team Guido wasn't eliminated in the same episode is because Nancy and Emily made a worse decision. After failing to get the Fast Forward, they have to return to completing the usual tasks. The Detour gives them a choice between searching streets for a specially-marked private car to drive to their next destination or take a slower-moving bus to the same destination. They opt for the first choice, which while relying heavily on luck, is understandable enough. Unfortunately, luck is not on their side, and they're on the verge of giving up after several minutes of fruitless searching. You'd expect: Them to do what Kevin and Drew did earlier in the episode and switch choices. It isn't too hard to find a bus. Instead: They give up entirely on the Detour and take a taxi to the destination. Even though they arrive hours ahead of Team Guido at the Pit Stop, they're penalized 24 hours for failing to complete the Detour, which is enough to eliminate them. Since Team Guido was the team everyone wanted to see eliminated and Nancy and Emily the ones everyone wanted to see come out ahead, the latter's gaffe was all the more heart-wrenching. The urge to shout at the TV screen, "Just take the damn bus!" was overwhelming.
Separated Couple Tara & Wil were by far the smartest and most well travelled team on Season 2. The only hiccup in their game was their physical skills. You'd Expect: Not making an alliance with the physically strongest team in the game, a team with no communication skills, no travel experience, and not that bright to boot, and dragging them into the Final 3 when they probably would have been dead meat otherwise. Instead: They do just that, making an unnecessary alliance with Chris & Alex, who proceed to pass them up on the run to the Finish Line, stealing the grand prize right out from under their noses.
On Season 10, the Cho Bros., Erwin & Godwin, take this even further by making the "Six-Pack" Alliance with two other back of the pack teams. You'd Expect: The physically fit brothers to ditch the dead weight once they got into the top 6. Instead: They sit around at tasks, after already finishing them, waiting for their alliance members to finish. Unsurprisingly, they finish 5th.
In Season 12, episode 8. Kynt & Vyxsin were saved by a non-elimination leg, requiring them to do an extra task in addition to the regular leg. Naturally, this would put them behind (even if they don't know the precise rankings), and when they get to the U-Turn, the only competition they've seen was Nathan & Jennifer. You'd Expect: They U-Turn Nate & Jen. Even if they finished the task before Kynt & Vyxsin, they're still the safest bet to prevent the possibility of fighting to avoid last place. Instead: They U-Turn Nicholas & Donald (a team that turned out to be ahead of them), based solely on their placing in previous legs. This costly mistake along with Kynt forgetting the receipts in the next task sealed their fate in that leg.
Season 13, episode 2: The detour is a choice between a beach task and going to a shipyard to track down a specific container. Kelly & Christy chose the former, and after completing the task reread the wrong clue, which told them to find the container. You'd expect: That the words "container" and "yard", the apparent lack of such things, or at least several other teams coming and going in front of them without making any effort to find a container would tip them off really quick that they might have read the wrong clue. Or hell, just realize that something is wrong and reread the clue to check. Instead: Kelly & Christy look for that container in the water, on the sand, they use their hands to dig for it, they decide that all the other teams giving them weird looks and leaving are just "giving up", and the fun goes on and on and on... Additionally: This is only the worst of Kelly & Christy's mistakes. They managed to make a bonehead move almost every leg.
Season 15, episode 6. Just shy of the pit stop, the teams are instructed to go down a tall water slide (the Leap of Faith at the Atlantis resort in Dubai). Mika has a heavy fear of heights and water, which naturally makes her afraid to go down the slide. You'd Expect: That even though she might be fearful, that she would just suck it up for two seconds of her life and go down the slide. Yes, fears are not an easy thing to deal with, but part of being on the race is facing fears and overcoming challenges. Plus, there are a million dollars on the line here. Instead: She refuses to go down the slide despite the fact that they are still second to last and absolutely lets all her fears get the better of her, as if going down a slide requires making some sort of life sacrifice. Even after Canaan tries telling what's at stake and going so far to try physically forcing her down the slide, she still doesn't budge. They end up stuck there long enough that another team arrives, and are told if they don't go down within two minutes, the team behind them gets to move ahead. You'd then Expect: That this would be her final warning and a last nudge to tell her that they have a chance to run one more leg if she just faces her fear like she is expected to. Surely she wouldn't let them get ahead that easily, right? Heck, the team behind them even taunts her, which in any situation should be a good time to let her show them who is really the boss. Instead: She STILL doesn't go down the slide, knocking them down to last place and getting them eliminated. In most cases it would be excusable if you were too afraid to do something, but this is a show that is all about putting you in fear-indulging situations, and it's one of the much tamer tasks than you usually see on the show too. Why exactly did she sign up for this again?
Season 16, episode 9. Of the 5 teams left, Brent & Caite are in second place at the U-Turn, having the good fortune to have two strong teams behind them, each one having three first-place finishes on their track record up to that point. You'd Expect: They U-Turn one of those two strong teams. Instead: They U-Turn Carol & Brandy for "being rude", Carol & Brandy being arguably the weakest team out of those behind them, with not a single first place finish under their belt. This basically meant Brent & Caite wasted their U-Turn to help their biggest rivals while shooting themselves in the foot.
Season 20 Premiere. Misa & Maiya finally get out of last place on the second to last task and have to go to the Pit Stop. They get to the open field where it's located, but don't see the Pit Stop You'd Expect: Them to check the rest of the field for Phil, who is within view. Instead: They leave the field after looking forward and Joey & Danny are able to pass them and Misa & Maiya get eliminated.
Season 22, Episode 2. Idries and Jamil have an intense fear of water and got to the detour involving going underwater. You'd Expect: Seeing what the detour was (dive down in snorkle gear - Pick A Pearl - or wear a diving helmet - Take a Trunk - and go underwater), the twin doctors would opt for the Take A Trunk detour. Instead: The brothers attempt Pick A Pearl, let their fear overcome them, argue about taking the 6-hour penalty, attempt the Pearl detour again, then opted to switch detours, which at that point, they blew an hour and a half lead over two teams and got eliminated.
Season 22, Episode 4. After getting horribly lost and struggling at the Detour, Jessica & John arrive at the roadblock last holding an Express Pass and see only Chuck & Wynona there. You'd Expect: John listens to Jessica and uses the Express Pass, considering she wanted to use it during the leg in Indonesia because she knew they were way behind. Instead: John blows her concern off again, and says that he can beat Chuck & Wynona at a luck-based task, in which you can't say you can beat another team. Jessica stands by and watches Chuck & Wynona check in at the Pit Stop, ensuring that Jessica and John get eliminated with the Express Pass in their hands.
Indonesian Pit Stop Greeter: (Aside Glance, followed by folding over and losing it)
Season 26, Episode 2. Starting off Leg 2 in last place due to getting horribly lost in the first leg, Libby & CJ have bought tickets to get on the bullet train to Nagano. They opt to take a selfie here, a new element this season. You'd Expect: Take a quick selfie and then get on the train, keeping time in mind. Or get on the train right away. Instead: They take a few seconds too long with the selfie, and the train leaves without them. Cue #SelfieFail. They are eliminated at the end of this leg, by the way.
Season 28, Episode 3. Cameron & Darius start Leg 3 in last place but are able to make up their deficit and complete the Roadblock with a safe buffer, but Darius can't find the vendor to get the clue. You'd Expect: Darius to talk to the vendor right next to him to at least check if it's them, since he was already there and wouldn't lose any time. Instead: He checks literally everywhere except where he just was and loses his buffer costing him and Cameron the race
In Season 29, Episode 2. Shamir hurts his privates after his rappel suit gets too tight. Thankfully, the medical team deems him fit to continue the task. You'd Expect: Shamir to fight through the pain and go straight back to the task and if the pain persists or gets worse, get checked out again. Instead: He hesitates for a while to go back to the task allowing all the other teams up there to pass him and doesn't go back up until the only team behind them (Jessie & Francesca) catch up to him. The only thing that saved him and Sara from elimination is Francesca missing a spot forcing her to repeat the task