troperville

tools

toys


main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
This is a "Wild Mass Guess" entry, where we pull out all the sanity stops on theorizing. The regular entry on this topic is elsewhere. Please see this programme note.
Redwall
Martin The Warrior is an animal reincarnation of the Avatar.
As well as all of the creatures he chose to succeed him. After he died, his spirit still roams Redwall, giving visions to the good guys and scaring the crap out of the bad guys.

The sword is his relic. In one case, one of his successors magically learn his skills by touching his sword.

So as well as Martin the Warrior, we have:

  • Matthias (From Redwall)
  • Mattimeo (From Mattimeo) Does not count as a reincarnation, because he has had little, if any communication with Martin's spirit.
    • Plus he was alive at the same time as Matthias, who was definitely a reincarnation of Martin. This also eliminates Martin II, Matthias' grandson.
  • Dandin (From Mariel of Redwall)
  • Samkim (From Salamandastron)
  • Dannflor (From Marlfox)
  • Deyna (From The Taggerung)
  • Triss (From Triss)
  • Bragoon, Sarobando, or Horty (From Loamhedge)
    • Judging by the rest of the examples, none of these three qualify. Some of the main qualifications for being Martin (in all the books that I remember) include successfully wielding Martin's sword, which Bragoon does but Horty does not (he wounded his footpaw by stabbing himself with the sword while he was showing off); getting a vision from Martin, which none of the three get, though Saro jokes about Martin warning her and Bragoon to leave years ago; and surviving till the end of the book, which Horty does but Bragoon and Saro do not.
  • Tam (From Rakkety Tam)
  • Bowlaynee (From Doomwyte.)
    • What about Arven (From "The Long Patrol".)?

Martin's Sword is not magical
There's no magic in the sword, as speculated by many of the characters. Martin simply uses it to speak to others because he had a strong connection to it in life. (See: Martin the Warrior and Mossflower where the plot boils down to "Vermin steals Martin's sword; Martin kills everything in a ten mile radius with his bare paws and retrieves it.") The sword doesn't actually contain his spirit or imbue the wielder with Martin's power or anything like that; he just has a much easier time speaking from the spirit realm to those who are holding his sword.
  • It's just (in DnD terms) a masterwork adamantine greatsword. Its only special quality appears to be cutting through steel, and meteors are said to be a common source of adamantine.
  • This theory was basically proven in The Rogue Crew with Uggo Wiltud. Despite being granted the sword, he doesn't gain any special powers, he doesn't become more confident or badass, and he barely even knows how to wield the damn thing properly. He only kills one vermin (by accident) the entire time he's holding it, and shortly afterwards, he drops it. The last novel blatantly stated that it's not the sword that matters, but the beast wielding it.

Matthias is distantly related to Martin the Warrior
Blood ties are extremely important in the Redwall 'verse. Martin is able to speak to Matthias through visions even when Matthias isn't holding the sword because they are distantly related. This explains why Martin's contact with other wielders of his sword (besides Mattimeo and Martin II, who are both descendants of Matthias) is much less direct.
  • This raises the question of how they're related. Martin was the last living member of his family and it's been stated that he had no children.
    • Eh. He settles down and hangs up his sword at the end of The Legend Of Luke. Maybe he fooled around with somebody on the side?
    • Maybe they're descendents of Gonff? The last one known to exist was Dandin; maybe he and Mariel had kids and one of their descendents came back to the Abbey.
    • John Churchmouse grew up in St. Ninian's, where Gonff moved to after Redwall was built. That could make Tim and Tess, and thus Mattimeo and Martin II, descendants of Gonff.
    • On the other hand, it's a canonical fact that Matthias is actually Martin himself, reincarnated in order to save the Abbey from it's first Vermin Horde in generations. Martin/Matthias has no conscious memory of his past life, but there are examples of moments where his past self wakes up long enough to encourage him to get back up and fight. Presumably, his original identity as Martin reasserted itself after Matthias died of old age.
      • Actually it's not that simple, Matthias is a reincarnation, yet the two exist as separate entities. Since Martin's ghost was active while Matthias was still alive, unless he's a split personality that seeps into other's dreams O_o, and to make it clearer, in Russano's dream showing all the ghosts of the Redwall warriors, Martin and Matthias were there as separate characters.

Martin's sword is a Piece of Eden.
Think about it: Everyone who holds the sword becomes a great leader, unless they stole it, in which case they promptly die. Also, everyone who wields the sword instantly becomes an expert in its use.

We know from the second Assassins Creed game that one of the pieces is sword-shaped. Somehow, before his death, Martin managed to unlock the secrets of the sword, and give it simple instructions. Now it protects the abbey, using induced visions to guide prospective owners and torment anyone who threatens the people Martin swore to protect. It also gives free sword training brain downloads on contact.

If Matthias is a reincarnation of Martin, then Cornflower is a reincarnation of Rose.
Hey, it's only fair.
  • The names even match. Good one!

The Woodlanders ARE in a Religion.
A horrible Xenophobic religion!

Stoat eats birds? HE'S EVIL! Rat is farming peacefully? HE KILLED THE POOR BEAST IN CHARGE OF THE FARM! Fox fishing peacefully? SHE IS DOING IT EVILLY!

Martin was highly racist about "Vermin" because he was 'enslaved' by the bad kind of fox, and he had bad luck and ran into another "Vermin" who he instantly said was evil due to childhood traumatic experience, killed him,and made up a lie to justify the means. He was EVIL. Evil! that's all he had to say! "He was attacking an innocent mouse! what else was I to do then to slay him?"

He came across a Wild cat who was simply playing a "game" of King of the Hill with a castle with a group of woodlanders, fed them LIES about the Wild cat to, again, justify why he must kill her. Using his mastery of speech, which he excelled in after a 'crusade against evil' spree of lies and hatred, he then got his ass handed to him only to survive because of the plot or by whatever deity is sponsoring him.

The stories are all LIES told by the main character, who was told MORE lies to by the Abbey-Beast to fuel the vicious cycle of hatred in Martin's happy little Abbey!

In Veil's case, he was the son of a "Vermin" and therefor treated like crap and probably not fed or taken care of properly; therefore, he 'Stole' food and played 'tricks', which were not for the Evulz but for attention. He is dying; he NEEDS food, water, and friends. In the end, he did something that a beast other than woodlanders from around the Abbey saw, so they could not change that tidbit in the story; instead, they twist and turn the words and actions of the poor little guy to make him seen as people have said 'Horrid little bastard' so if somebeast from that area reads it, they will assume its the 'Real' Story and thus spread the facts. Even though grandpa and Nana were there and they are still alive to tell the tale that they saw him do something for the greater good, they lied just for a good story and Veil was a 'Horrid little bastard'.

Look at other "Vermin" in the story: the odds, the unbelievable feats against them in favor of the good guys, they are IMPOSSIBLE!

This is to embellish the views of the Cult and spread the glorious word of Martin! and you fell for it, hook, line and sinker.

So, who will you be cheering for? The good guys, or the 'Vermin'?

  • Um... do keep in mind, that Woodlanders fear and judge vermin for a reason. Namely because they DO do evil things. Throughout the series Vermin kill and enslave whenever they can sometimes just for the heck of it, and for fun. That is "unjust prejudice?" I admit you can't judge all vermin, but Woodlanders don't take any chances, so vermin have to earn their trust before obtaining their friendship, which has happened a few times.
    • I think the original poster means, it's a "Hobbit" kind of writing. In the original The Hobbit, the Gollum scene was later retconned to be Bilbo retelling the scene to make himself look better. (Because Tolkien realized when writing Lord of the Rings it contradicted Gollum's character) The original poster is trying to say that, the books are from Martin's point of view. Though I don't know if s/he is actually being serious or not.

There were at one point humans in Mossflower, but they either died out or emigrated to somewhere very far away.
Even taking into account that most of Redwall's setup, including the horse and haycart, has been retconned, the "feral cats" in High Rhulain openly say their ancestors were kept as pets by "creatures more powerful than themselves", and the Coin in The Sable Quean had to come from somewhere, Mossflower's animals don't seem to bother with currency, and they claim the "strange markings" on the Coin were worn off to the point of unreadability, so it's not impossible it was made by humans.

Redwall is an Eldritch Abonimation that makes vermin Always Chaotic Evil while Woodlanders are stuck as Always Lawful Good.
It warps nature of the world and is under a guise of Martin the Warrior or his sword or both.

Redwall takes place on Earth thousands of years into the future
A result of human/animal gene splicing/intelligence enhancement, an apocalypse that wiped out the human race, and evolution

ALL the Swordbearers, not just Matthias, are the reincarnation of Martin.
It would explain the Instant Expert routine; they retain the knowledge of weaponry from all of his/their previous lives. Also, it could explain why there's only ever been one female Swordbearer (and this troper is now tempted to write a fic exploring Triss's potential resulting gender identity issues).

Vermin are Always Chaotic Evil because of their reproductive biology.
There is evidence in the books that vermin are psychologically and biologically very slightly closer to their Real Life animalian counterparts than the woodlanders. Thus, I posit that their reproductive systems are also closer, meaning the females tend to produce large litters, unlike the woodlanders who usually seem to have only one or two at a time (barring a few throwbacks, which would explain Rosie and Tarquin producing twelve kids in one year, or Log-a-Log Furmo's eight). Since they require more meat in their diets than the herbivorous/piscetarian woodlanders, the laws of trophic energy transfer conspire with their higher birth rate to mean that the country could never support them if they all survived to breed. Thus, they become highly aggressive and competitive, and usually keep their population growth down by battling amongst themselves. Every so often they build up to levels high enough to form a horde, which then gets wiped out by the woodlanders, leaving only those whose genes have something to offer in the way of skill or luck and ensuring that the next generation get the good genetic material. Veil was the only vermin infant whose birth was actually mentioned and he was an only child, but it's not unusual for small or frail mother animals, particularly first-time mothers, to produce one big healthy cub rather than a litter which are likely to be sickly and difficult to care for.

Sunflash the Mace started Urgan Nagru down his path.
Early in 'Outcast of Redwall', Sunflash scared a family of foxes away from two families of hedgehogs and moles. In return for their lives, he sent them north. In 'The Bellmaker', Urgan Nagru's backstory says that he came from the north. Though he should have reached Mossflower Wood before Southsward, he remembered his family's deal with Sunflash, and skipped over it in an example of honor among thieves, or just hoping that by going further south, Sunflash would never find him.

Hares eat as much as they do because ...
... they're trying to absorb enough nutrients that they don't have to resort to coprophagy as real hares and rabbits do. Or they're trying to get rid of the taste when they do have to do that.

The Redwallers believe that eating cures depression.
It would explain why many of them are described as being chubby, fat, or flat-out obese. It would also explain why Redwallers have a knack for hosting feasts shortly after someone's death and seemingly mentioning the dead character's name only a few times later in each novel. And given the high death rate in Mossflower, it makes sense once you think about it.
  • Adding to this, take into account that Brian Jacques grew up during the period of war-related rationing in the UK; food was in very short supply when he was a kid, particularly sweets and fruit (and what are the Redwallers' favourite foods?) A reliable, healthy, and tasty food supply probably really was very important to him, and thus to the characters he created.
    • Either that or, since all the food is fruit- and vegetable-based, it was a conspiracy to get vitamins into his kid readers.

Martin is/was an Exalted.
This sort of ties in with the idea that each of his successors are his reincarnations - perhaps his sword contains his Exaltation, and that's why they seem to attain mastery so quickly. I think he's either a Dawn or a Zenith, based on his abilities.

Thousands of generations before, a Hate Plague broke out.
It affected every species, and affected individuals went berserk. Mercifully, they adapted ere long. They adapted in different ways though. Cats, rats and most mustelids all have it but it does not affect them as much; it just makes them more easily angered. Their cultures did grow more ruthless, though. Lagomorphs, badgers, and most rodents don't normally get it, but those who do only have it flare up in extreme fight-or-flight—it's called the Bloodwrath.

Redwall takes place in the far flung future of the Rats of NIMH.
Humans have died out and human level smarts have somehow passed to most animals.
  • Though that would only make sense, if the rats were the only ones that grew in intelligence, I don't remember NIMH ever experimenting on Foxes, Moles, Squirrels etc... well, maybe they did?

Lord of the Rings, and Harry Potter and Redwall all take place in the same canon.

In the far far past, Dragons, hobbits, dwarves, elves... etc... lived on the Earth, then called Middle-Earth. But the world evolved. The world modernized into a parallel world to ours, where the fantasy creatures still existed but were hidden from the non-magical beings, jump about 2000 years later, a cataclysm caused all the humans and fantasy creatures but one to die out, aside from that one person, all that was left were the animals. The very last human left was the wizard Radagast the Brown who used the most powerful magic to stay young for millenniums. He cast one last spell on the world's woodland creatures to start a new way of life before he passed on.
  • OR Radagast turned humans and fantasy creatures into animals as an attempt to save them. Which was successful.

Silvamord was infertile.
She seems to resent Muta and Truffen in particular over Truffen's parents, and it's one of many possible reasons for her constant conflict with Nagru.

Gabool was high as a kite throughout the entire book.
Come on, insomnia, paranoia, flirting with an inanimate object?

Martin is the Lord of Hope.

Much of the Accidental Innuendo was not accidental.
The man was a sailor, he couldn't be that naive.

Something in the soil at Redwall makes the food grown there highly addictive.

The "good will to men" and/or "Peace on earth" cartoons are prequals to red wall.
to those who have seen nether, there both anti war cartoons were humanity drives him self to extinction and all that are left are animals, smaller ones like mice and rabbits, that talk about men, how they saw them, what happened to them as a narration. Redwall happens to be a long time after the events of the cartoons (the cartoons are less then one generation away from the event) and the story's and myths of men are long gone.
Realm of the ElderlingsWMG/LiteratureReplay

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
23401
3