The Rainbow is an unmanned TARDISIt makes perfect sense! One of the Time Lords was experimenting with a new kind of TARDIS. He built a remote control which would operate it. He did this hoping to merge his original TARDIS with this one in order to hide from the other Time Lords, because no one would ever thiink to look for him inside a rainbow! But he was killed by the Doctor before he could complete his work, and right when he was just about to test it. The handheld controller he made for it was lost and the prototype Rainbow TARDIS was left open. The last known setting he had put it on was set for Ponyland.
Dream Valley used to be just like Mordor.Hear me out on this one. The current, Sugar Bowl niceness of Dream Valley is actually a relatively recent change made by the ponies, themselves. Predating that, the various evil overlords, demons, and other borderline Eldritch Abomination monstrousities were in complete control. In fact, them and their empires were the population. The primary source of sports and reaction were constant wars of Evil Versus Evil. They usually held them on Tuesdays. So this is why the ponies have to deal with so many villains all the time.
Taking the above a little further: Ponyland is Mordor!According to Hydia, the matiarch of the witches of the Volcano of Gloom, the sugary-sweet goodness that is modern Ponyland is a fairly recent development brought on by the ponies. Given how many Eldritch Abominations and other horrors hide under the surface, that makes perfect sense. The setting used to be a place where evil overlords ruled the land for centuries. Thus, we can conclude that Dream Valley was built over the site of ruined Mordor. The ponies migrated from wherever they lived originally, needed a plot of land to call their own, bought Mordor cheap from the Gondorians, and settled. I defy anyone to come up with a better explanation.
Megan is at fault for all the evil roaming Ponyland, but not intentionally.Each time she or one of the ponies passes through the dimensional rift between present day Earth and Ponyland, it allows dark creatures to cross into Ponyland. Nice Job Breaking It, Hero!.
- So where did Tirac come from? Firefly only crossed the rift for help to stop him.
- Unlikely, these villains have always lived in the world where Ponyland is. However, it does seem like a new evil always appear after the previous one is defeated.
The Dream Valley of My Little Pony 'n' Friends (and by extension, the movie) exists in an alternate dimension than the Dream Valley in the My Little Pony TV Specials within The MultiverseExactly What It Says on the Tin
All the segments take place in the same world. Just different parts of it.Despite what that one song might tell you, it is not a small world after all. If the ponies, glo friends, moondreamers, and potato head kids were all just in different places on the same map, it would certainly explain a lot.
Ponyland and Dream Valley are an especially weird part of the World of Redwall.Just because "Bright Lights" showed anthropomorphic rats and mice and Catrina in "Escape from Catrina" is an anthropomorphic cat. Oh, and at least in the Redwall cartoon, the size of the horses fits. That doesn't prove anything, but hey, why not? Alternatively...
The Rainbow doesn't lead to another dimension, just another planet. And it's named Eternia.In one episode of Filmation's He-Man cartoon, a space shuttle reached Eternia by flying through a rainbow coloured wormhole. Additionally Marlena's ship is called the Rainbow Explorer. And every MotU-cartoon so far (except for New Adventures) has had anthropomorphic cats.
- If it was another planet, then wouldn't that be Earth?...
- I meant it leads to another planet FROM earth and Dream Valley is on this other planet, namely Eternia.
The rainbow leads through space and time and Ponyland is a future, terraformed New Texas.Do I have to explain that?
Knight Shade's father is a Little Pony.It explains why he is much smaller and overall doesn't look much like his mother or other horses from Bright Valley.
"Ponyville" exists in this continuity.We just only see a couple or so parts of it. In this case, it would be one part of Dream Valley, which itself is one part of Ponyland (either that, or Dream Valley would be considered to be "out in the country"). Additionally, it would most likely be an original one specific to this continuity (i.e., and none of the ones from later incarnations), although it is possible that the one from My Little Pony Talesnote could also be the one in this series, but that only assumes that they're both in the same continuity, but at distant points in time (since "...Tales" is essentially "G1.5").