troperville

tools

toys

SubpagesAnalysis
Awesome
Characters
ComicBook
DrinkingGame
Earworm
FanficRecs
Franchise
Fridge
Funny
Heartwarming
HilariousInHindsight
Main
Quotes
VideoGame
WMG
WesternAnimation
YMMV

main index

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
random
This is a "Wild Mass Guess" entry, where we pull out all the sanity stops on theorizing. The regular entry on this topic is elsewhere. Please see this programme note.
My Little Pony

Wild Mass Guessing for My Little Pony generations other than the fourth. Guesses for My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic go here.

G3 takes place after an apocalypse.
As some have noticed, the ponies are segrigated by race and seem not to have heard of each other before meeting. Then little things start popping up.

  • No one ever considers leaving their respective cities unless forced on an adventure.

  • There's a sususpicious lack of ponies outside the settlements.

With all this taken into account, we can presume the cities are the last remaining vestiges of each race and fled there after the war to protect themselves. This continued on for so long that everyone forgot there was a war and stayed there out of tradition and cultural habit.

However, two know about their history. Spike says upon meeting Rarity that she was far from home and it's interesting that he should know what a unicorn is when no one else did. However, it makes sense considering his sleep lasted a thousand years, so a time before the war.

The other is Kimono. As the resident wisest pony, it would make sense for her to have tales and legends about her history passed down over the generations. Not to mention that her toy mentions knowing of tales when unicorns roamed the forests of Ponyland, which is the name given to the ponies' home in G1.

My Little Pony And Friends is actually a D&D session

Humans are the source of all evil!
Or, more specifically, humans are the source of the "villainous" entities in the Ponyverse. The Talesverse lacks both humans and the frequent assaults of said villainous entities. As both continuities are set in an explicitly magical universe, it could be argued that humans somehow subconsciously generate the evils when in an area with magic. In fact, one could conceivably do some Arc Welding and say that at some point between the two series, humans were barred from ponyland specifically because of this trait....
  • Actually, compound that: Some humans (mostly female) did not want to leave. So, they consented to being turned into ponies themselves! Morphic Resonance allowed them to manipulate objects with their forehoofs...
    • ...and maybe, if we allow for a few generation's difference, the Talesverse could eventually morph into Friendship is Magic! Okay, yeah, I'm just trying to unify the whole series, sue me.
      • That's plausible, after all Ponyville was founded by Earth Ponies, and everypony in My Little Pony Tales is an Earth Pony.

Generation 3 ended when the ponies fell under a reverse-aging spell they couldn't cure.
The first sign was Rainbow Dash's voice getting higher. Then every pony got smaller. Then they were babies. Sure, the ponies may claim they were "remembering" what they did at that age, but why is the same gang of seven all together in the baby series when that group of friends didn't form until the later G3 videos? They're really just describing the deja vu they experience as they try to deny the fact that they're about to shrink away to nothing.

G3.5 is AU or non-canon from G3
There are far too many continuity errors.
  • Sure. Everything has changed, all with the Core 7 and generation 3.5 semi-reboots. (Oh, should we count New Born Cuties?)

G3 ponies are magnetic, that's why they can use Invisible Anatomy
The toys have magnetic hooves so why not? For the things they hold that aren't magnetic.. Then maybe it's magic, or everything is magnetic in the Ponyverse?

G5 will be even better than G4
Because they'll know what they did right in G4.

G5 will recieve tons of hate from butthurt bronies regardless of its quality
Pretty self-explanatory. In fact, I'm sure this definitely will happen to some extent.

Glory and Moondancer are married
They did have a porcelain called "Wedding Prance" where they appeared to be getting married.

G3 is set after G4
It makes perfect sense: the two alicorn sisters went with the wild whipper. All the ponies with similar names are decendance of the mane six

Reeka and Draggle's father is the Moochic
The Moochic and Hydia are on the same vague power level, and are about the same size. And it's not as thought there are many humanoids around Dream Valley.
  • Why would the Moochick let his own children be abused? Wouldn't he show complicated emotion when told about the witches and the Smooze, if the witches were his ex and daughters? He is absent-minded, but he's not stupid or evil. Precisely because he isn't evil, Hydia would not have mated with him. The only way he could be the father is if he were to have switched sides, which would explain the daughters not moving in with him - as they would probably have been told he was dead if he did so, but it's still a stretch. And because the Moochick and Hydia are the same size, the daughters are too tall to have much genetic possibility of being both of their daughters, especially Draggle. Even with recessive genes and mutations, Megan's size would be about as tall as Draggle could be. Besides which, there are other humanoids around Dream Valley, and there is nothing indicating Reeka and Draggle's father is still nearby or even alive.

There will never be G5.
After the success of Friendship is Magic, anything else that Hasbro puts out might not be as good. And if videos like this are any indication, the fans will eventually be able to produce their own full episodes. With these, Hasbro will hire these animators and voice actors to continue the trend and thus continue G4 for a very long time.
  • Appears to be Jossed. There will be times that the fans will grow tired on G4. This is Hasbro we're talking about.

After G4 we'll hit another Dork Age
This seems to happen every few years. Hasbro will make the cartoons an All-CGI Cartoon and other changes will cause distress within the fandom. The ponies designs will be hated by all.

Ponies are segregated in G3 due to Fantastic Racism
In one of the G3.5 specials one of the ponies quite literally says that Sweetie doesn't belong in Ponyville, she belongs in Unicornia. Pegasus and Earth Ponies haven't interacted in so long that the latter forgot the former existed. Earth Ponies are afraid of Unicorns powers, Unicorns traditionally think they're better than other types.

If Hasbro creates a new My Little Pony movie, it will be Human-Focused Adaptation due to Executive Meddling
The human involved would either be Megan from the G1 cartoons or an Expy thereof.

G1 ponies have ridiculously short life spans (by human standards)
That's why we rarely see background ponies more than once.

Winking isn't so much teleportation as it is the unicorn equivalent of a Flash Step
Think about it. One of the downsides of winking is that a unicorn can't wink through walls or through nets, when theoretically they should be able to. One can conclude, then, that when a unicorn winks in or out, she's really just using her magic to give her an extra boost of speed. Since a unicorn can't walk through a wall at her normal speed, it makes sense that she wouldn't be able to wink through one, either.

G3.5 is a prequel to G3
  • Isn't it canonically set when the Core 7 ponies were foals? At least the toys were supposed to. That doesn't explain the lack of adults, why everyone looks like a foal, or why there's a mayor so young.

G3 and G3.5 is nothing more than a bad candy dream G4!Pinkie Pie has
  • Makes sense why names and general appearance are similiar
My Life MeWMG/Western Animation (Series)My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic

random
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy
12032
23