- And now you know why Andy Waltfeld spends his time on TV Tropes instead of making coffee.
- For this troper, the canon ending is split between this and Dynasty Warriors: Gundam 2, where Athrun runs around beating the crap out of anyone who even looks at him funny, Shin Asuka can make a case for his worldview without resorting to random screams, Kira himself thinks that what he's doing may not be right... and Lacus is painted as possibly-evil. This may also be a case of Author's Saving Throw.
- for [[Main/kknd2 this troper]] Dynasty Warriors: Gundam 2's Shin ending makes the most sense. The big fight happens, and Shin manages (by taking them off their high horses for a second to think about what they are doing) to best Kira and Athrun, while admitting that he is not purely in the right either. Everyone stops the fighting because they step up and admit that none of them is right. Bam, your logical happy ending.
- Alternately, the guy who died wasn't Mu. IIRC all we know about the extent of his memories is that he remembers being on the Archangel with his friends, not being in the final battle. Mu could have been replaced with a double sometime before the Battle of Jachin Due.
- It's even easier than that. We already know that the Atlantic Federation has the technology to clone humans (see: the whole mess with Al Da Flaga) and to maniuplate memories (see: the Phantom Pain trio, particularly Stella). It's not to much of a stretch to believe that Neo is a clone of Mu with Mu's memories implanted (to make him badass as only Mu can be), and then with Neo's memories on top of that (in order to maintain his loyalty to the Atlantic Federation). If they figured out how to fix the short telomeres problem, or alternately figured out how to artificially age him to the "real" age of his genes, then no one would even ever know that he was actually a replacement.
- Goddamit, Neo was a testbed for Full Frontal!
- It's explicitly mentioned in Turn A that the space colonies fitted themselves with solar sails and headed into interstellar space. But the emergent Newtype phenomenon may involve the whales - the only non-human Newtype in Gundam was a dolphin in ''Gundam X, after all...
- This gets really funny/sad if you catch a little coincidence with the main three pilots: what other mecha anime is generally angsty, deals with PTSD, and contains a Shin, an Asuka, and a (in katakana) Rei? With names like that, the poor bastards were doomed from the start. Even better, Maaya Sakamoto went on to play another fiery female pilot with Zettai Ryouki for said show's Big Damn Movie.
They'd let the power go their head and become a righteous little bastard, of course.
And what sort of person would let any kid, even a good one, get away with so much? Right, a mentor who is only using that kid for their own ends.
That's essentially why Shinn derailed at the end of the series. He's had an authoritive older figure that he greatly admires tell him that he is special and incredibly talented, rewards him with super powerful weapons, gets him out of trouble when he committed treason because they 'needed his strength', 'entrusted' with bringing peace and told that his motivations are just. Naturally, Shinn realizes he can get away with anything because he's always right, and everyone who disagrees must be wrong. He never reigns in his anger because he's rewarded for his results in battle. He's essentially kid who's been spoilt silly and then given keys to a super weapon. Durandal, of course, isn't doing this because he thinks Shinn is so wonderful and perfect, but because he's very easy to manipulate. All he needs to do is butter him up, convert him to his side, and sic him on the enemy. He's basically got a dangerous attack dog that will never, ever question him. If Shinn ever died in battle and Dunrandal won, there's no question he'd move to the next young cadet.
- That was Durandal's MO with prety much everyone, and for the most part it worked, Athrun is pretty much the only one who gets out of it, and only because he both had the experience of going trough a very similar thing with his father, and because the alleged deaths of his friends, coupled with being branded a traitor, pushed him well beyond the reach of Durandal's almost mind control powers. Shinn on the other had didn't have any such experience, obeying and blindly following Durandal had brought him nothing but rewards, he was a deeply troubled teen who rather than getting help for all his troubles had only been pushed further and further along the path of anger and self righteousnes, during the first ten episodes or so pretty much all we see him do is lash out at others and wangst in his room, all that changes as the series advances is that he is pretty much given acceptable targets to lash out again and convinced that his lashing out and attacking/killing anyone who disagress with him or Durandal is justified, because they are right. So yeah, poor kid never had a chance to stop his "character derailment".
- On the flip side, this explains why Kira and co were unaffected by the mind control, as Kira's Ultimated Coordinator trait serves as an amplifier for Lacus' own mind control capabilities in the same way Rey amplifies Durandal, and thus Lacus was able to maintain a strong control over the rest of the crew and prevent the influence of Durandal's words from spreading within her own territory. Due to the bond shared with Lacus, Kira was also able to inherit the ability to at the very least influence people's minds, and while Athrun's mental defense was able to hold off Durandal's control, the resulting exhaustion left him helpless against Kira's weaker influence, thus leading to him switching sides. Also, in the dual between Kira and Rey, while equal in piloting capabilities, Rey lacked the ability to counter against Kira's inherited psychic abilities. Despite sporting a strong mental defense thanks to Durandal's prolonged influence, Rey eventually cracked under the continuous psychic bombardment of Kira, who was trained under the guidance of Lacus in the arts. Basically, Gundam SEED Destiny was one massive cover-up on a psychic war that occurred between two exceptional minds, Durandal and Lacus. People of unprotected minds have been known to go insane upon hearing the recordings of exchanges made over the communication devices of mobile suits.
- It scares me how much that makes sense...
- Or, you know, you are entirely right and it is NOT true love, at all, more like Shinn taking advantage of Luna's frail emotional state, which he caused to begin with, and her need for support, on top of being on the rebound. Likewise, Luna was in a bad place so she latched onto the first person to offer her comfort, so it's just a screwed relationship of codependence, which fits Shinn down to a t, Luna not so much, but as mentioned early, she was emotionally fragile at that moment.
- Or Shinn and Luna were both feeling emotionally vulnerable and needed something to cling onto. Relationships start fast in wars, largely due to the stress of the moment. Look at the number of infantrymen who came back from WWI and WWII married to nurses or locals who they'd often known for at most a few days or weeks. Now contrast that with Shinn and Luna, who have been friends for years and who, in a moment of emotional need turned to one another. It doesn't hurt that Shinn apologised to Luna for shooting down Meyrin.It's one of the few times in the show that Shinn's apologised for anything and Luna knows it, which helps explain why she isn't furious at him. And on top of that, they don't actually kiss (thus signifying that they are in a relationship) until a couple of episodes later. Shinn and Luna may be annoying in terms of plot, but it makes perfect sense in the context of the war.
- That's actually potentially likely. She's at least deceitful towards him. Early she repeats the official story (Athrun was always fighting for Zaft, and there was no TSA or near genocide at the end of SEED) but her talk with Talia reveals she knows what Athrun was really doing at the end of the last war.
- A possible variation of this: LOGOS is actually a loosely-affiliated network of rich and powerful naturals who just don't give a damn about anyone else. Much like the colonial powers of preceding centuries, the members of this group are a high-class clique who use the colonies to make money - no matter the moral consequences. Hence, they were anti-coordinator. But, they're anti-coordinator in the same way that former imperial governments were racist (i.e. not the same way as, say, the Nazis were racist). They don't want to wipe anyone out - they just want to oppress and exploit them for every penny. Azrael and Djibril were the only ones who really wanted them all killed off, largely due to their own messed up child-hoods. This group has existed since long before the space age, as mentioned previously, but existed in different incarnations, not as a single monolithic conspiracy. It didn't get a name like LOGOS until later - that is, unless Durandal made that up as a part of his embellishment. Basically, Durandal took this "gentlemen's agreement" and Flanderized it into an ancient conspiracy that sought only to make money through wars. While this is not an outright lie, every falsehood contains some cleverly disguised truth. The known members couldn't try to set the record straight due to their true nature not being all that great, either.
That's why they had no members in the PLANTS or ZAFT-aligned nations, they either didn't have any members who fit the criteria (a natural with no love for the coordinators and wanted to get rich), or the members sensibly fled before the crap hit the fan.
- Although I stand by the rest of my variation, strike the last bit of my above addition: According to the Gundam Wiki and hints from the creators, ZAFT may have allegedly had a member of LOGOS in their midst the entire time: Gilbert fucking Durandal. As well, he was the one who manipulated Canard Pars into wanting to kill Kira (in the manga spinoff), and he may have had a part in the Ultimate Coordinator Project. That Magnificent Bastard...
- Also, she's the Author Avatar of Morosawa.
- First, the bombing of the UN meeting on the moon. All of the delegates were killed except for Seigel Clyne, who was delayed by a shuttle malfunction. This provided the excuse the sponsor nations needed to declare war. Rau could have sabotaged the shuttle, or arranged for it, as well as directing the terrorists who carried out the attack.
- Second, the nuclear attack on Junius 7. It was not the only agricultural PLANT colony, but it just happened to be the one where Lenore Zala, wife of PLANT Defense Chairman Patrick Zala, happened to be on that day. This led to Zala eventually having a complete breakdown and trying to glass the entire Earth. Rau could have found out Lenore Zala's travel plans and directed Muruta Azrael to have his men target that PLANT specifically.
- Third, the deployment of the neutron jammers in Earth's crust. Prior to this, ZAFT always showed immense patience and restraint when dealing with the Earth. Even when the Earth Forces were revealed to be behind the attempted assassination of the PLANT Supreme Council (which succeeded in killing only one chairperson) a few months before the actual beginning of the war, they still did not react aggressively. When the war did start, they only deployed the jammers on their cruisers. Deploying them on Earth caused a massive energy crisis resulting in millions of deaths, but it also allowed ZAFT to start making headway against the massive numerical superiority of their foes. Rau could have suggested the strategy intending to sway public opinion on Earth against the coordinators.
- Fourth, the use of the Cyclops superweapon on the Grimaldi front. This ended a theater of the war, as the supply base that was its objective was destroyed, and also resulted in massive casualties on both sides, including every single one of the Atlantic Federation's Mobius Zero corps, except for Mu la Flaga, who Rau would later complain was always getting in his way. Rau could have suggested the tactic to Azrael, hoping to both escalate the war and eliminate the obstacle Mu and his comrades represented, as they were essentially if not literally newtypes and stronger than almost any coordinator.
- Fifth, the destruction of the Silverwind. The Silverwind was a civilian passenger ship carrying Lacus Clyne on an inspection of Junius 7, lost with all hands and passengers except for her, as she was put into an escape pod beforehand. If the ship were chartered early enough, Rau could have gotten wind of its course and asked Azrael to ensure a ship with a strongly anti-coordinator crew just happened to be in the area. If Lacus were killed, it might have had the same effect on Siegel Clyne as Lenore Zala's death had on her husband.
- Also, there are the events he is known to be responsible for. The destruction of Heliopolis, reportedly an accident partially caused by the use of heavy weaponry inside the colony by ZAFT forces, reduced Orb's influence in space and threw the troublesome neutral nation into political turmoil. The Cyclops system used at JOSH-A, which eliminated much of the more moderate Eurasian Federation's military power and reduced their influence. And, of course, the renewed deployment of nukes against the PLAN Ts and GENESIS against the Earth by Rau's puppets Muruta Azrael and Patrick Zala, once the war escalated to the point where Rau knew they would be used for genocide.
- Alternately, Le Creuset was just behind the nuclear attack. Tensions were already at a boil and all Rau had to do to make it boil over was give Azrael a way through ZAFT's defences. Azrael's foreign policy can best be summed up as "when you have enemies, you shoot them," something that Le Creuset would have figured out after about ten seconds interacting with the man. The rest of the war was easy to improvise: latch on to the ZAFT commander with the biggest grudge against the Naturals (if it hadn't been Patrick he could have easily selected somebody else; with Rau's brains behind them they would have been Commander-in-Chief soon enough), and ensure his rise to power while still feeding Azrael information. With both sides led by hardliners he didn't need to engineer anything else beyond the eventual use of the superweapons; there certainly wasn't going to be a compromise as long as Azrael was alive. Same basic idea, just more Manipulative Bastard and less Chessmaster.
- Several websites (notably, the Animesuki forums) make a reference to Lacus Dust, which explains why Kira became a John Cena-esque God-Mode Sue in the later episodes of both SEED and SEED Destiny. It can also explain why both Andrew and Mu (and if we go outside of CE, Zechs) came back from the dead. I don't know when the Lacus Dust jokes began, but I think that Sunrise might have adopted the Lacus Dust concept and adapted it as GN Particles for 00.
- In other words,
a wizardLacus Dust did it.
- In other words,
- Prior to his attempted sacrifice, Neo may be acting more like La Flaga, but he still lacks the memory and emotional depth of his predecessor. He may like Ramius and Kira, but that's largely based on the fact that they seem to know about his past, something he has to be curious about. It's only after he flies into the Tannhauser's blast that he regains his memory and acts like Mu again. I'd contend that what we've actually witnessed is not so much the return of Mu's memory, as it was the death of the "Neo" persona. Having learned to care about Ramius and the others aboard the Archangel, Neo, previously a cold-blooded Manipulative Bastard makes a Heroic Sacrifice, and in the shock of the positron blast, dies, mimicking La Flaga's Character Development in SEED and allowing the latter to come back to life. He didn't lose Neo's memories of course, but the actual personality (best defined by manipulation and self-loathing)? It died.
- I was lurking at the Easymodo archives, and one of the posters suggested that although Durandal lost the war, he was more or less proven right about the Destiny Plan theory. He very much forced Kira and Lacus to become what they didn't want to be; in Kira's case, becoming a soldier, and in Lacus's case, becoming the new ZAFT chairwoman. In other words, they were destined for their roles.
- So by having his entire plan destroyed—meaning no one else will have to fullfill the role he believes they should—but getting two people to do something they didn't want to he won the argument? That makes sense. Besides how do we even know that "soldier" and "politician" are what Kira and Lacus are best suited for? They're good at it, but that doesn't necessarily equate to "perfectly suited for it genetically". And oh yeah—they're doing it because they want to, not because their genetics told them to.
- Kira and Lacus: How Morosawa views her marriage.
- Athrun and Cagalli: What Fukuda and Morosawa's marriage is currently (i.e., on the rocks), and Cagalli leaving Athrun could be a reference to the rumored (and never proven) affair between Fukuda and Cagalli's VA, Naomi Shindo.
- Shinn and Lunamaria: Let's just say that Fukuda and/or Morosawa became jealous because Kenichi Suzumura and Maaya Sakamoto are now Happily Married.
- If you look at it there's a significant period of time where we don't see any trace of Rau le Creuset, and it's because of this time gap that I developed this theory, Rau developed Newtype Powers, then had an Awakening that was so powerful he broke the fourth wall and was able to see hat he was in a TV show, using his newtype powers he was able to influence the writing so that he could at lest try to wipe out everything, Unfortunately it only worked halfway, resulting in his death. This is even supported by some of his dialogue in the last few episodes of SEED if you listen and take it as a character that became self aware.
- I've seen somewhere that Gundam 00 was supposed to be a deconstruction of the Gundam franchise, at least in the first season. I've also read that Shinn was supposed to be a deconstruction of the traditional Gundam protagonist. Does that mean that GSD did the deconstruction first (before G00), much like how Evangelion deconstructed the Super Robot/mecha shows? Speaking of the connections between GSD and Evangelion, here's the relationships that I can think of:
- Shinn = Shinji Ikari and Asuka Langley Sohryu (the former's angstiness and the latter's hotheadedness)
- Rey = A gender-flipped Rei Ayanami
- Durandal = Gendo Ikari