Speculation for Matt Smith
's first few outings as the Eleventh Doctor.
WARNING! THERE MAY BE UNMARKED SPOILERS!
Big Bad Spec
The fifth series will feature the Black Guardian in the Finale
The First Doctor's most iconic villains were the Daleks. The Second Doctor had the Cybermen, the Third Doctor had the Master, the fourth had Davros, the fifth had the Black Guardian, the sixth had The Rani, and the seventh had Fenric. The New Series finales featured The Daleks, the second finale featured the Cybermen, the third finale featured The Master, the fourth featured Davros. The Black Guardian vowed to return angrier than ever, and it's high time he returned to menace the Doctor.
- Which kinda strengthens the 'Woman in White is the White Guardian' WMG.
- The Black Guardian didn't show up in the finale, but we still don't know who the Big Bad of Season 5 really was so... I haven't watched the classic series at all so someone will have to tell me, does the "Silence-Will-Fall Voice" fit with being the Black Guardian?
- Jossed for series five, but who can tell for the Moffatt run in its entirety the Black Guardian won't show up?
- This troper remembers Jabe (way back in Series 1) telling the Doctor "the Eternals fled this reality in despair" after the Time War. I don't think they'll be showing up any time soon.
- No, she never said that in the episode. I think that was the 2006 annual.
The Dream Lord is Series 5's Big Bad
. He's trying to bring about the end of the Universe.
- There's no freak natural phenomena going on here.Someone, some sentient being, is trying to destroy the Universe. How do we know this? Well, someone keeps talking. We keep hearing this little nugget in the TARDIS during "The Pandorica Opens":
Mysterious Voice: Silence will fall...
- The destruction will be caused by the TARDIS exploding. We saw the fragment in "Cold Blood", we saw the painting at the beginning of the episode.
- Someone has taken control of the TARDIS and is making it explode—and when I say "someone", I mean "Someone". When the TARDIS starts going apeshit and exploding (thereby causing the destruction/erasure of the entire universe), the Doctor tells River that it must be some kind of fault. River disagrees:
River: Someone else is flying it. An external force.
- So, who can operate the TARDIS well enough to cause it to explode and destroy the Universe? The Dalek Supreme has something to say on this topic:
Dalek Supreme: Only the Doctor can fly the TARDIS.
- But I hear you saying "Bronzethumb, you sexy devil, River can fly the TARDIS too!" Yeah, well...
River: I'm flying [the TARDIS] perfectly! You taught me!
- So it would seem that only the Doctor and people taught by the Doctor can fly the TARDIS, and as far as we know, the only person he's taught is River. Which means that only the Doctor or River could be controlling it now. The Doctor... or an alternate side of the Doctor's personality.
- Hence, the Wild Mass Guess: The Dream Lord is trying to destroy the Universe.
- Why? Because he's a dick.
- How is he able to do all this when he's only a manifestation of the Doctor's dark impulses? ...yeah, okay, good point self. Maybe he was able to manifest his own form at some point in the Doctor's relative future. Or perhaps he's inhabiting the TARDIS—telepathic circuits, remember? This would also fit with the fact that the voice declaring that "silence will fall." is heard inside the TARDIS (which is supposed to be shielded from most assaults) right before the screen cracks, and at the end of "Amy's Choice" The Doctor saw the Dream Lord's face in the TARDIS console.
- Or maybe the Doctor was lying.
- Notes for this theory: River said she was taught to fly the TARDIS by the best in The Time of Angels. Yet she also says "Pity you were busy that day." How to reconcile this statement with the one in the Pandorica? Perhaps the Dream Lord taught her, somehow?
- She says in "The Pandorica Opens" that the Doctor taught her to fly the TARDIS. Later in her personal timeline (i.e. "The Time of Angels"), she says that someone else taught her to fly even better than the Doctor does. She almost certainly met this other TARDIS driver in the intervening time period.
- In addition, consider the following: Every enemy leading up to this point has been accounted for, except the Dream Lord. The Atraxi, Daleks, and Homo Reptillia are part of the Alliance, and we know they aren't the real Big Bad. The fish-vampires are still presumably in Venice and their matriarch has been killed. The invisible monster Vincent Van Gogh faced wasn't malevolent, just injured. The TARDIS-like spaceship basically imploded at the end of The Lodger. This means that the real villian behind the destruction of the TARDIS must either be the Dream Lord or someone entirely new to Series 5, which seems unlikely. Barring the return of an old villian like Rassilon or the Master, it seems to follow that it's probably the Dream Lord who is behind this
- Agreed, but the Dream Lord may be working with other monsters, such as Prisoner Zero and the Starwhale. (He also may have worked with the Krafayis before it perished). Note that although Eleven thinks he knows evil when he sees it, and is convinced that the Dream Lord represents his dark side, none of the threats present in "Vincent and the Doctor" and "The Lodger" are actually malevolent, and the Dream Lord does nothing more than tell him the truth and manipulate his consciousness. Also, as far as Big Bang II is concerned, the Pandorica may serve no function other than that of a Void Ship. Eleven thinks it contains a memory of the universe, when in reality, he contains a memory of the universe.
- To append to everyone elses' comments: in 6, we have River learning how to fly the TARDIS form the old girl herself. The TARDIS knows how important River is, so thus she educates River when the Doctor was incapacitated.
- Let us take a step back and look at the Season 4 episodes Silence (!) in the Library and Forest of the Dead. River mentions the crash of the Byzantium so there is a connection to Series 5, and possibly beyond.
(Picnic at Asgard) We get this narration, presumably from River's blue book:
River: Everybody knows that everybody dies, and nobody knows it like the Doctor. But I do think that all the skies of all the worlds might just turn dark, if he ever, for one moment, accepted that.
- That is exactly what silence falling looked like, with all the stars going supernova. And what about the Doctor accepting stuff? That means the manifestation and victory of his cynical, apathetic side, the one that doesn't care. In other words, the Dream Lord.
- Who else has the Doctor taught how to drive? Does the name Donna Noble ring any bells. I can't remember the exact episode, but the Tenth Doctor teaches Donna how to fly the TARDIS.
- If we assume that the Dream Lord is an earlier form of the Valeyard, we could take this theory: the Dream Lord wasn't trying to Ret Gone existence. In truth, he made sure he could reboot reality. This would be for the sole purpose of finding a way to reaching into his own past, and averting the Time War. No matter what the consequences are.
- The TARDIS is being controlled by something/someone of the same species as House - he can control the TARDIS and fly it
The Black Guardian will return... in a younger (possibly) female form
Because frankly, The BG's powers of manipulation would increase exponentially if he was in a young attractive form. It's already been stated that he's an anthropomorphic personification of chaos, so why shouldn't he be able to change his shape at will, and therefore change genders? If the BG had sex appeal, I have a feeling that the Doctor and company would be in real trouble.
The Eleventh Doctor's ultimate enemy for the upcoming series would be an evil future/alternate dimension Twelfth Doctor.
- Why? Rule of Cool that's why. Plus, when you've got a previous special wherein the fricking MASTER made a Heel-Face Turn, anything is possible.
The Bow Tie is behind it all!
- Let's examine the facts. When the Doctor heads onto the roof in The Eleventh Hour, he only has regular ties around his neck. Then when he puts on his jacket, the bow tie appears from nowhere. It's actually an alien parasite that wants to destroy the Doctor for as-yet unknown reasons. In episodes where he wears a different coloured bow tie, the tie is on board the TARDIS manipulating things. It was the bow tie's voice that said 'Silence will fall' in The Pandorica Opens, and it's moved on to manipulate the Silence order in Series 6.
Cracks in Time
The first allusion to the Cracks in Time...
...was Martha being married to Mickey in the season 4.5 finale, with no mention whatsoever of Tom Milligan, her previous boyfriend and fiance. Because the cracks ate him.
The Doctor canonically remembers people who've been Ret Conned
by the cracks, so him not noticing this is probably just oversight.
- Or it was a result of the Dalek invasion. Thanks to the cracks, it would do the opposite of this WMG-get Tom and Martha back together.
- In that case, after the cracks were themselves Ret Conned, Martha would be with Mickey again. I guess Martha and her husband need to show up at some point for us to know which.
- ...or, people occasionally realize they don't actually want to marry their fiancee, and end up with someone else. But that's crazy talk.
The crack appearing in Amy's bedroom was no coincidence.
When Amy and the Doctor are talking at the end and she asks him why he's inviting her specifically, there's a machine behind him that displays a pattern rather similar to the crack that appeared in Amy's bedroom, and which he fumbles to turn off while protesting that it's entirely because he's lonely. She is somehow linked to the cracks in time - and the Doctor knows this.
- Confirmed, sort of. The Tenth Doctor could see everything in the universe except things that were "in flux". The Eleventh Doctor can see everything in the universe except the things he does not want to see. In an unreleased scene, he tells Amy that he brought her with him because she could see what he missed. Series 5 may illustrate the process of Eleven calculating the truth. Note that he hasn't calculated it fully yet, and the song "Chances" by Athlete featured in "Vincent and the Doctor" indicates he's never going to figure out the truth through calculation.
- Series Five has likely confirmed that Amy is linked to the cracks in time. At first, the Doctor is either ignorant or only subconsciously aware of this possibility. After Amy tries to snog the Doctor in "Flesh and Stone" however, the Doctor realizes that Amy is linked to the Time Cracks. However, the Doctor still seems to be only subconsciously aware of what caused time to crack in the first place.
- Mickey Smith is Human!Eleven, Grendel (from Beowulf) is Prisoner Zero, Odo (from Deep Space Nine) is the Ninth Doctor, and a person who does not look like you is Dobby the House Elf.
The cracks in the universe are a consequence of...
...the not-quite-closed Time Lock in "The End of Time". It was re-sealed by the Doctor, but not completely.
- ...or the Doctor messing with Time in "The Waters of Mars". I really hope he will face the consequences of his actions. This would also explain the multiform's satirical voice when he says "The Doctor and the TARDIS doesn't know, doesn't know, doesn't know..." and the fact that he recognizes him as a Time Lord too.
Amy is leaving Cracks behind
Both in Starship UK and Churchill's war room they appeared just as the Doctor and Amy leave; since that the first Crack open in her room, maybe she was affected by it and it's now leaving a trail of Cracks.
The Cracks will open the way back for the Cybus Cybermen
It's already been confirmed that the Cybus Cybermen will be back for the season finale, and the situation with the Cracks will likely to be adressed in that story as well. These 2 things obviously will obviously be related.
Sometime late in the season, the Doctor will temporarily lose the TARDIS and be forced to crack the universe to get it back or avoid being trapped.
Prisoner Zero's taunting is awfully specific; s/h/it says "the Doctor in the TARDIS doesn't know" what caused the cracks. Does that mean the Doctor not
in the TARDIS does
know? And if he doesn't have the TARDIS, he needs some other method of time travel...
- ...and now the Weeping Angels also use the "Doctor in the TARDIS" construction, in a setting where it seems very likely that the Doctor is crossing his own timeline (he comes back to tell Amy to remember what he said when she was seven, and he's wearing a jacket again despite having lost it to the Angels a few scenes earlier).
- ...and now the Doctor reaches into one of the cracks and pulls out a piece of shrapnel from what is evidently the TARDIS exploding. Looks like we're well on the way to this being Confirmed.
- Not quite. After instigating "The Big Bang" the Doctor tells Amy that he is unsure of what exactly caused the Time Cracks but is "working it out". Many possible clues about what might have triggered the TARDIS explosion should be obvious to Eleven, but Eleven misses the obvious all the time. He probably won't fully discover what's going on until the TARDIS explosion is seen again in the Series Six Finale.
The cracks aren't coincidence. They're being created by Amy.
This combines with the theory that Amy isn't human. Amy lost her memory and got stuck on Earth as a child. Something will trigger her memory. You may ask, "what alien could unknowingly create cracks in the universe? Well this is a Wild Mass Guessing, so you know exactly what the next is going to be.
The cracks are temporal black holes
Time travel is messed up due to the timestream being drawn into them and the TARDIS not being able to detect this.
The doctor couldn't come back in 5 minutes due to the fact that the cracks are wider at two points in time, 1998 and 2010.
The TARDIS is responsible for tearing the cracks in reality
- In the second and third episodes, after the TARDIS has dematerialised, we see the cracks. It is TARDIS's departures into the Time Vortex that are causing the cracks.
- But what about the crack in Amy's bedroom, you ask? This is why: The Doctor will attempt to take Amy back the day after she left, but overshoots. So when he leaves, he will create the crack.
The cracks will cause time itself to fracture
- We've already seen someone slip through the crack in Amy's house. When there are enough cracks that the universe can't take it anymore, time will fracture, causing history to be jumbled up. Incidentally, this means there's the potential for, say, Rory, Liz 10, and Winston Churchill to meet.
- Confirmed. The entire universe, apart from the Earth and Moon, essentially suffers a Ret Gone. The multiverse too, if the Cyberleader is to be believed. It's better, now.
The event that's causing the cracks is the Time War.
- Because what could be more universe-shattering than that? This would also explain why the Daleks are apparently back in the finale.
- Jossed. The event that caused the cracks was the explosion of the TARDIS.
- And who said TARDIS explosions didn't happen during the Time War.
The cracks in time are caused by Tabuu
or a relative
The method is pretty much identical- opening holes all over the place, sucking areas into Subspace- or "sub-time"! Presumably the finale will send the Doctor through the Great Maze of various time periods, returning everything that's been removed from time to its proper place.
The cracks in time and space are being caused by the Snarl
escaping its prison.
One part Continuity Snarl 1
, one part Eldritch Abomination
. It's been bound in this "Pandorica" place, and it's so massive and powerful that when it starts to escape, cracks appear all across space and time.
The Gate note
is Amy, and somehow, her getting married will break open the Pandorica, unleash the Snarl and literally unmake creation.
- Considering that the Doctor actually discussed the continuity issues of the Cyberking in Victorian London, this actually seems quite plausible. Not necisarilly THE Snarl, but something like it.
The cracks in time lead to The Void.
Meaning anything that went through them could also possibly come back, as they could be two-way. A Season Finale
with New Daleks vs. Old/Void Daleks vs. Cybus Cybermen vs. Weeping Angels vs. everyone else, anyone? The Void and The Pandorica could in fact be one and the same, and much
more besides the above enemies could be inside...
- Assuming this is true, then it still doesn't help in Rory's case, because if he wasn't already dead before falling in then he would have likely been immediately massacred by Daleks, Weeping Angels or whatever else that would stumble upon him. Or he'll Come Back Wrong and have to be killed in the finale.
- River, River, I'm looking at you...
C'mon, you know it's coming...
- Well, it is caused by the explosion of the TARDIS, but it's implied (so far) that something else made it blow up to begin with.
- "House" anyone?
The Valeyard is behind the cracks.
This goes with the theory that the Dream Lord is a future-echo of the Valeyard, and that there are two Doctors running around because of the Wibbly Wobbly timey wimey.
- Originally, the Doctor did pick Amy up when she was seven. Little Amy in the garden hearing the TARDIS engines wasn't a dream- it happened, but the cracks unwrote it.
- In Flesh and stone, River and the Doctor leave amy to go and get the ship working. The Doctor had recently lost his jacket to the Angels. Just after they left, the Doctor returned to Amy, but seemed... different. AND had his acket back, and his sleeves rolled up. A continuity error? I doubt it, after the fuss they went to making sure you knew he'd lost his jacket. This new, different Doctor tries to get Amy to remember what he told her when she was seven. This is the version of the Doctor she travelled with as a child, the one she first met. The Doctor she's been running around with is a copy, introduced by the time Cracks unwriting/rewriting,altering bits of time and space, possibly even so-called fixed points, like the Dalek invasion of Earth.
- The Doctor we've been watching is turning into the Valeyard, and he will have to battle his original self.
- With two Doctors around, one of them will self-sacrifice (Probably the one we've been watching) to close the cracks permanently.
- This may also fit with River's killing of 'the greatest man she ever knew', meaning that in the finale she will be forced to kill one of them to prevent the unraveling of the universe.
- I'm not sure your two theories are mutually exclusive. In "The Big Bang", it is revealed that the reason why there are two Doctors around is a Stable Time Loop, so those two Doctors become one again once the Stable Time Loop resolves. The Doctor still sacrifices himself to the Time Cracks, but is revived when Amy remembers him. As for your theory that the Doctor is turning into the Valeyard, and will have to battle his original self: The Doctor's affect throughout the series (or at least the last four episodes) seems to indicate that he's fighting against something inside of himself. When the Doctor flies the Pandorica into the TARDIS explosion, his affect indicates that (perhaps due to realizing that there is now no longer any point in trying to stop the TARDIS explosion and whatever is "coming out") he has resigned himself to letting the TARDIS explode, because he knows that the TARDIS explosion is needed to power Big Bang II. When the Pandorica closed around the Doctor, and the TARDIS burned up at
the same moment, the TARDIS resembled a star as it burned (which indicates that the TARDIS had been stabilized by the Pandorica, which works even when the Doctor's not in it). The Doctor finally admitting to himself that he could not stop the TARDIS explosion allowed the TARDIS explosion to happen properly. This is why the burning TARDIS explodes even more once the Doctor crashes the Pandorica into it.
From what we've seen, the cracks apparently affect all universes,hence the Cyberman's statement of "all universes will be deleted." We also know that, even when they were removed, some alterations remain-if that weren't the case,all crack-related episodes would have never been and there would be an Angel in Amy's brain.
So who's to say this hasn't happened in other universes? Every Retcon
to have ever happened,without in-universe explanation, is the result of the cracks. Similarly,the effects of the Time War caused several crack-like events, causing more retcons throughout existence. It may even be how the multiverse came into being.
People taken by the cracks are not actually erased from time.
Thinking about it, if someone was retroactively erased from time more than other people's memories of them should be influenced. They will have had an effect on other people's actions and decisions, so the entire life on someone who knew them should have changed too. The Clerics, the army of Weeping Angels and Rory are not lost completely, only the memories. (This still allows for the angel to be removed from Amy's mind at the end of Flesh and Stone, as it was, in a way, a memory in her mind's eye.)
- Jossed-the Doctor explicitly mentions that, if a crack takes you, you never existed. Not to mention, if the universe wasn't erased from time during Total Event Collapse, things wouldn't get as screwed up as they were.
The cracks are caused by the TARDIS exploding
That is the "Big Bang" in the finale.
The TARDIS is shown to be malfunctioning again and again - the Doctor misses Amy by 12 years when he tries to fix it, which is understandable, but then misses her again by 2 years when he just goes to the moon for a spin. A couple of episodes later, Churchill tells the doctor he's late by 3 months. There may be other examples. The Doctor is confused every time he hears about this, because he knows he's doing his usual thing. It's not the Doctor who is messing up, it's the TARDIS, which is very old and is finally running down.
Then, in Cold Blood, we see the Doctor getting a shard of the TARDIS from a crack. Besides, what kind of explosion can cause damage to space-time itself? A time-vortex, like the one the TARDIS uses, exploding. We've seen it used to bend time to create and maintain a paradox, which means it can have an effect on space-time, not only move through it. How far-fetched is it to think that the TARDIS going KABOOM can crack the fabric of time?
- Not very far at all. The possibility was mentioned in the original series, called a time ram. The worst case is when a TARDIS collides with its own past/future self, adding the grandfather paradox to the mix. The result has been described as an explosion that can annihilate ever last star in half a galaxy, an explosion powerful enough to outshine ten million supernova. Ripping the fabric of space and time to shreds would fit right in. (And consider, in the Last Great Time War, such explosions may have become a routine tactic, when Gallifrey seemed in danger, ripping open cracks out of which crawled nameless things.)
- Revision: If the TARDIS won't blow up because of a malfunction, it will be caused by whatever comes out of the Pandorica, which is apparently strong enough to scare the crap out of all of the villains combined. The other bits still stand.
- First half confirmed. Second half seemingly Jossed, though we won't know until next season why precisely the TARDIS exploded.
The cracks aren't erasing people from time......
Just erasing them from people's memories. What they're really doing is DISPLACING them. I got this idea from this very wiki, which mentions a rumor that Rory will reappear as a Roman Centurion, but what really got me thinking about it was the Weeping Angels in Blink. What brought them to Earth? Why were they so weak? It's simple, the cracks displaced them throughout time, with that one group ending up on Earth, severely weakened (hence the lack of neck breaking, and no picture jumping). This means that those who are taken by the cracks, anyone who knew them forgets them, and that person is placed in a new place, with no memories of who they were, and possible new memories to slot them into their new place in time. Of course it's all just conjecture, but it's interesting no?
It would also explain how River might still get her pardon (They don't remember who was sent, but they know the Face of Boe sent someone on the mission with River) and how Amy's life will still be intact despite having Rory literally ripped out of it.
The cracks in time will delete some of the Doctor's past incarnations, allowing him to regenerate more times.
In Venice, the Doctor's library card only showed his first incarnation, and the TARDIS printer only showed One and Two. Excluding the montage of regenerations in The Eleventh Hour, it's possible some or all of the past regenerations will be removed from time, leaving his actions, memories and experience intact (and remembered, because the Doctor is essential to the universe) but restoring his body's ability to regenerate. The TARDIS has been similarly deleted, explaining why it has regained the St. John's Ambulance badge One had on it.
- Well, both those instances are easily explainable. The First Doctor could have gotten a library card, and none of his later incarnations bothered to renew it with a new picture. As for the TARDIS printer, he only gave it time to print off his first two forms, if it had gone longer it probably would have printed Three, then Four, etc. etc.
The cracks in time have been caused by the Doctor driving around time with the brakes on.
Well, what happens when YOU drive your car around with the handbrake on? You wear things down.
The rips in time will explain the UNIT dating problem.
There's a rip under the UNIT base which randomly shifts it across the 1970s and 80s, and no one ever notices because of the Monster of the Week
requiring UNIT's attention.
The cause of the big explosion that made the crack...
Is the resulting paradox from Amy returning to her own time. Let's think about this. Amy has been on adventures through different points of history, partly helping to save the world. However, a lot of them involved Rory, either as motivation, or him actually helping out. And now he's gone, never existed. Amy is currently safe since she's not in her own time, and the universe doesn't have to make sense of how her history is meant to actually work now. However, through some inkling to go home, she does, then BOOM!.
- The cracks are the result of the paradox of the cracks consuming Rory? The paradox is only a paradox so long as the cracks already existed. Either its a complete mindfuck self fulfilling prophecy of a paradox, or it would just make more sense to resolve that paradox by not having an explosion in the first place.
- Oh come on, they're paradoxes. The laws of time and causality do not apply to them in the slightest. That's why they're paradoxes.
Warren Earp was lost down a Time Crack.
That's why he didn't exist in Real Life
The mastermind behind the whole exploding TARDIS business is the Black Guardian
Based solely on that if you went to the Doctor Who wiki
and hovered on the "enemies" tab, their order matches their appearance as new series finale baddies.
- The enemies tab has since been removed. Plus, if not confirmed, it's very strongly implied it's a religious group called the Silence.
Davros blew up the TARDIS.
It sounds just like him, listen to it then Davros's voice, really, go do it.
- Again, if not confirmed, it's very strongly implied it's a religious group called the Silence.
As of the end of Season 6, we now know that the Silence are not Omnicidal Maniacs
, but Well Intentioned Extremists
who believe that the Doctor will destroy the universe by asking/answering the First Question (Doctor Who?
), and that killing him will prevent that. And
, we know they can send signals into the TARDIS, since they were able to keep Amy's Ganger stable the entire time it was onboard, no matter where in time and space it was. So, perhaps in their attempts to kill the Doctor, they hijack control of the TARDIS and trigger a Phelbotinum Meltdown
to kill the Doctor, or possibly strand him away from the planet where the Question is meant to be asked (though from what we've seen of the Silence, the former seems like the more likely). They just misjudge how strong the explosion is, not realizing it'll result in the very end of the universe they're trying to prevent. And after the universe is rebooted, they learn from their mistake and decide to try a smaller scale assassination, which is what leads to the whole plot with River/Melody.
Silence didn't cause the TARDIS explosion. Doctor did...
...and he did it on purpose. Think about it: Donna will die if she ever remembers the Doctor. Living in a world where everyone remembers that Daleks moved and invaded Earth, something is bound to remind her sooner or later. So, in order to save her, Doctor makes the TARDIS explode, causing the Cracks in Time, which erase the said Dalek invasion, thus preventing anyone from reminding Donna of it. Or maybe, the Silence did cause the explosion, but it was the result of Doctor's Batman Gambit
You'd think that a rusty old Type 40 TARDIS wouldn't have nearly the power to end reality, or the Final Sanction
should've been a piece of cake. So why was it able to? When the Silence detonated the TARDIS, the Time Dissonance
of Sexy and probably using the timey-wimey power source caused the explosion to reach her entire history. Why did it seem like the TARDIS only exploded on a linear perspective? The TARDIS is capable of maintaining paradoxes, so it didn't collapse itself, plus the whole cracks in time thing makes no logical sense anyway. Note how every time the cracks appear, it's during or right after an episode? That's because said event is being negated as Sexy's timeline is unravelled. Since the Doctor and Sexy saved all of reality multiple times, time and space began to disintegrate. Alternatively...
The TARDIS exploding can't destroy the universe-something else helped.
The TARDIS being a universe-level doomsday device an extreme oversight of the designer, and a boneheaded move by the Silence
, so why can it do this? It can't. By itself, all the TARDIS exploding would do to reality is prick it. The problem was that the universe had already suffered massive
tears, lacerations and general bad juju-mainly surrounding the Time War. The Silence could not grasp the true timey-wimey tears
left by this Cosmic Horror Story
of a battle, so they thought that one more dent wouldn't hurt. In reality, history was basically a severely cracked and damaged pane of glass, significantly lowering the threshold before everything falls apart. Rebooting the universe helped to restore the glass. This could also explain why the Time Crash
is significantly more common post-Time War: the conflict made creation incredibly fragile
The Universe being destroyed was due to Anti-Time
- There was still some in the TARDIS, the paradoxes and explosion spread it through history.
The Rory rumoured to appear in the finale is...
the original Identical Grandfather
. Let's see:
a) RTD had already Technobabbled
an explanation in "Journey's End". Wouldn't it be cool for Moffy to Arc Weld
a throwaway line into the season's twist?
b) It's Crazy Enough to Work
So, the finale is approaching. Any idea?
- And it's Jossed!. It's the real Rory, too. In a manner of speaking.
The Other Doctor/10.5/Valeyard? is behind everything in series 5
Because its so crazy it might be true. He's probably the one manipulating the Daleks too. Thats why they win.
The Dream Lord is the Celestial Toymaker
As the preview for Amy's Choice
would suggest, this "Dream Lord" is perfectly capable of creating alternate realities to trap the Doctor, Amy, and Rory in for what looks like no reason other than teh lolz. Also (of course this is from the Expanded Universe
so its canonicity is up to you) the Celestial Toymaker has been called the Crystal Guardian who governs dreams and games. And it's about time he showed back up too
- Jossed. He's the dark side of the Doctor's mind.
The Doctor will die to save Amy.
I'm playing along with the other WMGs of two timelines here. In The Time of Angels
, when the Doctor stops for Amy when she can't move, she says "I don't need you to die for me, Doctor, I am not that clingy". That was a foreshadowing. In the series finale, the Doctor from the alternate timeline will perform a Heroic Sacrifice
to save Amy.
- Confirmed, except because of his actions during the "rewind," he gets better.
The Doctor in tweed isn't the Doctor at all.
And who can take others forms and knew Amy when she was 7? Either Zero has escaped again, or is using the link to project to Amy from it's cell. Given that they took 12 years to catch it, I don't see them being in any rush to carry out the execution. And even if they did, we don't really know how their connection works. Either way, Zero has something larger planned for the Cracks, and is attempting to activate some sort of command or ruse it planted in Amy's mind when she was still a child.
The real Amy Pond is dead.
She was killed after the Doctor left her house for the first time. She's really an artificial being created by the Alliance to work as an information gatherer in order to get the Doctor into the Pandorica.
- In that case, why didn't the Alliance just shut down/turn to "obedient mode" the Artificial!Amy?
- Perhaps because they needed her to be as close to the "real" Amy as possible so that the Doctor wouldn't be suspicious?
- But when they eliminated her through Rory, the Doctor is already restrained and knows of the Alliance's plans. Perhaps they killed her because she would resist her programming even harder than Auton!Rory.
- On the other hand, Amy's room is full of her art about the Doctor, also her two favorite childhood books. It looks more like the room of an 8-year-old girl than a 21-yo one. (Except for the wedding dress, which could have easily been placed there by the Alliance.) My theory is this: young Amy was kidnapped/killed, then a few days before the arrival of the Doctor kissogram Amy and Rory were placed in Ledgeworth, and a perception filter was applied to other inhabitants of the village. The fact that we know plenty of Amy's childhood and her present self, but nothing in-between seems to support his. Prisoner Zero was also part of the plan, he made sure that the Doctor gets interested in Amy and is informed about the Pandorica arc. When Rory is absorbed by the crack, he gets erased from history because he never existed in the first place. In essence, it's nothing more than a perception filter shutting down. (Still working on why the clerics get erased)
Alternately, the real Amy Pond is gone.
The Doctor came back for her after being released from the Pandorica by his future self.
The Eleventh Doctor will spend some time stranded on Earth along the lines of what happened with Three
The violent regeneration pretty thoroughly trashed the TARDIS and it's in for a crash landing at "The End of Time Part 2". Just the damage we saw could well be enough to justify building a new set for the interior of the TARDIS and stranding the Doctor on Earth for some time while he fixes the TARDIS.
- Jossed. While the TARDIS did get repaired (with a new control room), she did so herself and was fixed within a day. He gets stranded later on in "The Lodger", but that's not in the same league as Three's three-year exile.
The Eleventh Doctor will probably also be in pretty bad shape for his first appearance.
- Confirmed. Still a lot better shape than Ten was, however.
The Dalek Civil War will make an appearance in series 5
In the trailer for series 5, we see two Daleks. The first is clearly dark grey (much like the Renegade Daleks); though we only see the head of the second, it's clearly white (much like the Imperial Daleks)
- Jossed. There's some Daleks from the Medusa Cascade; they're loyal to both the Dalek Supreme (or "Supreme One") AND Davros, so they fit neither Renegade or Imperial. The taller ones with colour schemes were a new post-Time War breed created through a Progenitor device. In other words, prior to series 5, these five Daleks did not exist.
Alternatively, there will be a new Dalek Civil War
Between the Dalek Rangers
and Void Daleks. Admit it, it would be awesome.
- Confirmed. Ish. The Doctor Who Experience (a "walk-through episode" in the UK) has a battle between the old Daleks and Paradigm Daleks as a setpiece.
- In terms of series 5 itself, Jossed. The old Daleks willingly let themselves be killed by the Progenitors, due to their inferior DNA.
- "Silence will Fall", actually, confirmed.
- It's on, at the very least, Jeff's laptop and a bunch of the coma equipment. Some sort of Blue Sun / FatBoy Industries type company, perhaps?
- Jossed. Looks like it was a red herring.
- Not necessarily. Matt Smith has said there are not one but FIVE arc words. So assuming that the Silence the cracks and the Pandorica were three of them that leaves two extra. And the arc ISN'T over as the identity of who created the Cracks will be revealed in series 6.
- Wasn't another of the Arc Words suppose to be "time can be rewritten?" Shouldn't that count as well?
The Arc Words
of Series 5 will be "fairy story/stories"
Every episode so far up to Ep. 5
- Jossed, but they did have a very important part to play in the finale.
The duck pond is important.
Seriously, how could it not be?
- Perhaps not the duck pond itself, but what it was (A duck pond with no ducks in it) that turns out to be the important thing. A theme in this series, perhaps?
- There were ducks in it before they were sucked up by the cracks. Because there were ducks in it, it was a duck pond. The cracks erased the ducks, but not the fact that it was a duck pond. The cracks Ret Gone people, but you can realize that they existed if you figure out the plot holes it leaves in your life.
- Some ducks are aliens (like the bees), and they left because of the scary cracks.
- Maybe "How do you know it's a duck pond?" will eventually turn into "How do you know you're Amy Pond?" somehow.
- Ooh! Fridge Brilliance! The duck pond is definitely a metaphor for Amy, but the ducks are something else (when I started typing I was thinking Rory, as in "Who are you [duck pond/Amy] if you're missing something so important to who you are [ducks/Rory]?" but I just realized it could also apply to the Doctor. And again, I'm realizing that the fact that she didn't notice that the ducks were missing probably means its Rory.
- In a sense, this has turned up again. Just like the ducks (possibly) left their duck pond, the Saturnynians had to flee their home because of the Time Cracks. Maybe it was foreshadowing the then-future episode?
- Or maybe the ducks were sucked into the Crack.
- I'd like to add that, like those above, I just KNOW this is important, although I can't yet say exactly how! I'm not even sure if the duck pond and its lack of ducks is itself important, or if it merely served as a kind of 'pointer' to make it easy to remember the point in time. The moment I am getting at is in The Eleventh Hour, when the Doctor and Amy were.... erm....discussing the duck pond (as the end of the world rushed toward them), and then the Doctor started clutching at himself and saying 'No! It's too soon! I'm not done yet!!' . My weird head later combined this with his words from The Impossible Astronaut : 'Ah, humans, I thought I'd never get done saving you....'. This looks suspiciously like a link to me. [I know it just looks like the final remnants of his regeneration, which is how I interpreted it the first time I saw it, but it's actually a bit weird as it had been a while since he had last done any of that convulsing and clutching stuff, particularly since the knock with the cricket bat, which he claimed had set him straight. ]
A Multi-Form's tail goes on forever.
I've seen it asked at least once what, if anything, Prisoner Zero is hanging from. Given it's Starfishness
, if not outright Eldritch Abomination
, the tail goes on forever. It's not really hanging from anything, it just hangs. If you were to follow it's tail, it would go on into space, unless you blinked or looked away, even for a fraction of a second, in which case it would disappear, since the tail only seems that long when observed. This could probably go on the spoiler-free page, but it hates me for some reason.
Something is already badly wrong with time.
A crazy theory that some have picked up... It seems a reasonable enough assumption that the first bit is set in 1996, then 2008, then 2010. But some have noticed that Rory's badge has a date of issue of 1990. A reasonable assumption would be that it's a production error, and that that date is supposed to be his date of birth or something... but what if it's not? Being set in the early 90s doesn't really mesh with the omnipresent camera phones, the mentions of Bebo and Twitter, etc... unless time is badly messed up for some reason or other, and it's set in a "Nineties" with 2010 technology setting. This could also tie in with Amy's Kissogram job... it's actually kind of quaint and innocent, since nowadays most people would just find it acceptable enough to hire a stripper.
- This has Eleven's personality written all over it. The clerics said that the Crack seen in "Flesh and Stone" made them feel weird and sick, which is how the Doctor seems to feel during the entire second half of Series 5. Eleven's snog with Amy in "Flesh and Stone" marks a turning point in his character (and the Series itself) in which his TARDIS stops allowing him to sublimate his lust into anger, and starts compelling him to visit more tranquil locations and people. The tranquil locations he is compelled to visit are markedly sunnier than Leadworth, which is overcast for most of the Series. Moreover, the characters who live in Leadworth seem deeply depressed and inhibited. After Eleven closes the Cracks with Big Bang II, Leadworth becomes markedly sunnier, and its inhabitants become markedly more cheerful. The TARDIS may have deliberately crashed in Leadworth, because Leadworth is the perfect home for the Eleventh Doctor. However, the Atraxi scanned Eleven and discovered that if they allowed his interaction with the people in Leadworth to follow a natural course, the TARDIS would explode the universe. What the Atraxi (and the rest of the Alliance) did not realize was that this explosion would either result in rebooting the universe, or temporarily removing Eleven from from his body in a Small Bang I of sorts. The Alliance therefore made the mistake of tying the mechanics of the Pandorica to Eleven's superego, so that it would open when his superego cracked completely. The Pandorica's stasis-locking of Eleven could not stop him from destroying the universe, but it did prevent him from rebooting the universe when he was imprisoned inside it initially. Assuming the Pandorica is actually a Void Ship, Eleven was able to circumvent this problem by using the TARDIS explosion to desintigrate the Pandorica, and using the TARDIS explosion to power Big Bang II. (This may symbolize Eleven using his ID to power his superego). Eleven seems to hate Leadworth before Big Bang II, and love Leadworth after Big Bang II, because before Big Bang II, Leadworth is a personification of Eleven's repression issues, which drive him to risk suicide in Upper Leadworth, and in Big Ban II. Big Bang II seems like the resolution of the War's first battle. Expect the next resolution to deal with actual humanoid relationships.
- This would explain why "The Eleventh Hour" was criticized as banal, insipid, and homophobic. (If you ask this troper, "The Eleventh Hour" is insipid in an incredibly good way. Even the homophobia may be good, because it appears to be internalized within Eleven and Rory. Internalized homophobia is an important and troubling issue to the teen/young adult demographic that the Eleventh Doctor appeals to. However, unless the producers are lying, Rory's name tag cannot be used as evidence for this theory, as it is merely a production error according to Word of God. (Then again, Word of God also thinks that Amy does not fancy the Doctor). The fact that Word of God would deny that Amy fancies the Doctor indicates that Series 5 has too many Gods, too many target demographics, and/or too many canons (one canon for each target demographic.) On second thought, there's no such thing as too many Gods, canons, and/or target demographics. Giving Series 5 multiple canons allows it to be interpreted in multiple ways. Try watching "The Lodger" twice, first with the perspective of a child, then with the perspective of a teen. See the difference?
- I'm sorry WHAT? Homophobia? The hell?
- Google reveals no reviews mentioning homophobia in Eleventh Hour (particularly not when combined with "insipid" and "banal", which only leads back here).
- Imagine if the arc is about time fractures that mess up dates, a plot point specifically written to Lampshade the UNIT dating controversy. Otherwise... Maybe the card was a mistake in Prisoner One's disguise.
- Episode 3 suggests this may be the case, a big deal is made of the fact that Amy doesn't remember the Dalek invasion of a few years back, possibly because it hasn't happened yet. Also, this season the Doctor seems even worse than usual at getting to the date he was aiming at.
- Not to mention that the Ood have advanced hundreds of years faster then they naturally should have been able to. It was brought up in End of Time, but The Doctor pretty much dropped it when The Master showed up.
Something is very wrong in Leadworth, and it has to do with Time being held unnaturally in stasis.
- Leadworth is characterised as "the village that Time forgot".
- In the dreamverse, the old in Leadworth were preying on the young to stretch out their unnatural existences.
- Rory's badge is 20 years out of date.
- Leadworth cannot engender life: the duck pond has no ducks.
- It all adds up to Leadworth being held unnaturally in stasis—out of Time, if you will.
- Leadworth seems to be culturally frozen in the year 1996, despite having the technology of 2010. This may be because Leadworth is the closest thing Eleven has to an ideal permanent residence (The neighborhoods of Craig and Vincent are likely second-best). Eleven has a love/hate relationship with all of the places in which he lives, especially the TARDIS herself. His hate for the TARDIS' destinations manifests itself as Time Cracks that suck the life, passion, happiness, and existence out of every place he goes. The technology of these places remains modern, because Eleven has no problem with the strength of his neocortex (other than the fact that his amygdala keeps interfering with its functioning).
The episode titles for Series 5 episodes 8-13 are...
Something along the lines of "The Ground Beneath Their Feet", "Cold Blood", "Vincent and the Doctor", "The Lodger", "The Pandorica Opens" and "The Big Bang".
Jack Will Become The Beast Beneath
At some point between going from how he looked at the end of Children of Earth
to the Face of Boe, he will become the Space Whale that rescues the children of the UK. the evidence for this is simple:
- We know Jack will go through a massive physical transformation as a result of just being sooooo old.
- Jack has hinted that he has had past...err...contact with space whales.
- After the events detailed in Children of Earth, Jack will likely feel an obligation and duty that will make him friends to all children, and feel especially obligated to the children of the UK.
- The Space Whale's plan consisted of going to earth, being captured, being used a means of transport, and then being painfully tortured over the course of several centuries until someone awesome rescues him, which follows the standard arc of most Jackplans.
- Or even more depressing, Jack due to his actions in the sixties led to multiple deaths latter on including his own grandson. Will be driven to protect the Children of Britain. He knows already what is going to happen to him but takes it as a form of penance, hundreds of years of agony for the deaths of Ianto and his grandson. And for how many other people killed by his actions or inaction no matter how necessary .
Amy Pond lives in a psychiatric hospital, dreaming that the Doctor returned for her
The Doctor wasn't 12 years late, more like 120. Amy is deluding herself, imagining all the adventures we see. The cracks tend to show up to remind her of the most traumatic experience of her childhood.
- All previous "new Who" companions had a downer ending. After Donna, it will be rather hard to raise the stakes, but this might just cut it.
- How is Martha choosing to leave of her own accord because she's sick of pining over the Doctor a downer ending? She left of her own free will and had (still has as far as I'm aware) the ability to contact the Doctor if she needs him.
- The duck pond doesn't have any ducks, because it's just a figment of her imagination.
- If this theory is not true, some villains might still mess with Amy's brain, leaving her to believe it is, ŗ la Captain Sisko in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.
- Alternatively, she might be a lonely girl starving to death in an empty house.
If there is a Star Whale, then there also is a Star turtle
The Doctor isn't miscalculating arrival times.
Rather, the TARDIS is actively hunting the cracks.
- Alternatively, the Doctor and the TARDIS are arriving at the given time perfectly, but the rest of space-time is out of shape, events are not when they are supposed to be. I know, I know, it is through the events that time is really measured, not by the internal clock of the TARDIS, but we have seen some Timey Wimey on this show before.
- Or perhaps the Doctor is subconsciously seeking out ideal locations. Eleven's TARDIS behaves as if it considers the needs of Eleven's subconscious to be more important than the needs Eleven's higher brain. Eleven's omniscience may allow him to seek out the best possible location for him to be in the universe at any given time (It's always England because deep down, England is Eleven's favorite place.) The TARDIS follows the instuctions of Eleven's subconscious rather than what he thinks he wants.
- Possibly confirmed. The TARDIS later states that she always goes where she needs to take him.
Go, go, Dalek Rangers!
- Supreme (white): The Big Bad
- Strategist (blue): The Dragon
- Scientist (orange): The Evil Genius
- Drone (red): The Brute
- Eternal (yellow): The Dark Chick
Jackson Lake will return in Series 5
Jackson Lake. Amy Pond. River Song. Might be just a coincidence, but there is seemingly a pattern emerging with companions named after bodies of water. Might have something to do with the Doctor drawing Amy's attention to the Duck Pond with No Ducks In It.
- Added: I was pointed out to Adelaide Brooke too.
- Jackson hasn't come back, but the bodies of water are indeed significant— River Song = Melody Pond!
After the Events of Victory of the Daleks.....
...The Dalek Rangers
threw the most awesome victory party the universe has ever seen, in celebration of finally pulling one over on the Doctor. I only bring this up because the idea of the Daleks OF ALL RACES
doing your typical wild party antics with those screeching voices of theirs amuses me.
- "THE BOTTLE HAS SPUN! DALEK ETERNAL MUST SNOG DALEK STRATEGIST!"
- Someone has to draw that now, complete with Dalek Scientist scuttling around at top speed with a lampshade on its head.
- Truth or Dare with Daleks. I swear, that would be the best party ever.
Scientist: DALEK ETERNAL, TRUTH OR DARE?
Drone: WHO IS YOUR CRUSH?
Eternal: ...CAN I DO A FORFEIT?
One of this series' themes is provoking the Doctor to anger
So far, in every episode there has been an attempt, either intentional or not, to provoke the Doctor and make him angry- perhaps he will truly crack in the finale? (pure coincidence that the more blatant theme is 'cracks')
- In "The Eleventh Hour", Prisoner Zero taunts the Doctor- 'the Doctor in the TARDIS doesn't know'
- In "The Beast Below", the Doctor is unintentionally (noone knew who the Doctor was, therefore had no need to provoke him) angered to the point of willingly killing an innocent creature (tbh, this episode could do with some expansion on the theory)
- In "Victory of the Daleks", the Doctor is successfully and definitely intentionally provoked by the Daleks until he angrily states 'I am the Doctor, and you are the Daleks!', triggering the progenitor device.
- In "The Time of Angels", it is explicitly stated that the Angels are attempting to provoke the Doctor to make him angry, though it doesn't work.
Amy does not remember the events of the Dalek invasion of Earth because the invasion has been erased from history.
At the end of "Victory of the Daleks", the Daleks escape into the future. This means the surviving Dalek ship can travel through time unhindered, and could return to capture Davros and Dalek Caan before they build the New Dalek Empire, averting the creation of the half-human Doctor clone and the genocide of the Dalek race. They would do this in order to enlist Davros' aid in building the new Dalek race, and to make use of Caan's precognition. The Doctor remembers the invasion for the same reason he remembers the Master's enslavement of the Earth. With the events surrounding the stolen planets never happening in the new timeline, Donna Noble is no longer half-Time Lord but has clearly parted with the Doctor for some other reason at some point between the altered events and present (as she is not present currently). However, as the Doctor is seemingly unaffected by changes in the timeline, he still remembers events as they should have been instead of how they now turned out. Therefore, he still believes Donna would die if she remembered him, and did not realise something was wrong with the timeline until Amy informs him that she does not remember the Dalek invasion.
- Well, since the Cracks erased the Dalek Invasion, as well as the Cyberking incident, I would consider it confirmed.
- Ever since "The Big Bang" it seems The Doctor Retcon'd a lot of earths recent history. For instance, later episodes show that no-one on earth seemed to remember the Daleks, Sycorax, or Torchwood. Possibly indicating that the Doctor either erased these events outright, or simply reworked the collective memory of everyone on the plant, which really wouldn't be all that difficult for him.
The events of "Blink" were an Evil Plan
on the part of the Angels.
Now that we know that anything that holds the image of an Angel becomes and Angel, it would seem the Angels in Blink
succeeded in getting into the TARDIS after all. How? Those pictures Sally Sparrow took of them, then gave to the Doctor.
Now they're sitting in the depths of the TARDIS somewhere, forgotten and waiting for the perfect time to attack. Assuming that during Blink
they still had the problem of the Angels dying in the Maze of the Dead, they had this plan: because they don't know how to fly the TARDIS, the Angels from the pictures and the Angel from the Byzantium plotted to bring the Doctor to them. Then while he's running around trying to climb up to the ship, they take control and use the TARDIS energy to feed their army. Then they have two sources of energy instead of one, doubling their chances of success.
- No, that's not it. The Angels in Blink are also part of the time loop. Sally Sparrow gives the Doctor the pictures. He takes them. The angels get out. He and Martha get zapped back in time, defeat the angels, get the pictures... I'm not entirely sure that works, but I think there's a way to do it so that the Doctor and Martha are not part of the time loop.
Prisoner Zero gave Amy brain damage
There is no way having an evil alien developing a mental link with you when you were a child and keeping it until you were an adult would not negatively affect the way your brain developed.
Amy gave The Doctor brain damage
There is no way a Scottish redhead hitting you on the head with a cricket bat when you are still in the first 24 hours of your regeneration would not negatively affect the way your brain developed.
The Clerics are a future version of The Church of the Assembly of Man from The Return
I have no justification of this other than it'd be cool
Time can be rewritten? More like time just was rewritten.
All right, so in "Flesh and Stone", the Doctor who told Amy that it was important that she start trusting him and to remember what he told her when she was seven was not the Doctor from that episode's timeline
. Note that in that scene alone, the Doctor was wearing his tweed jacket again, the one the angels stole a few scenes before. That Doctor is from the future. Considering how much Nine and Ten harped on how crossing your own timeline is bad, what he told Amy there must have been really damn important to the future.
This troper's theory: Future!Doctor went back in time to set things in motion so that Amy would trust him and so she would remember what she told him all those years ago. Because he can't remember
. All those cracks in time eating people's memories and erasing existences, one of the cracks is going to erase a bit of his memory (the Moff is being misleading by saying time travelers just have different perceptions of time-space, the sneaky bastard
) and Amy will have to be there to remember it for him.
- And lets face it: if Steven bloody Moffat wrote this year's Story Arc, how could it NOT make liberal use of the Timey-Wimey Ball?
- Same guessing troper here. In "The Eleventh Hour" when little Amy is sitting outside, waiting for the Doctor to return (about 15:50 into the episode), the camera pulls back into the house, watching her from the kitchen window. A figure runs past the camera, obvious humanoid, probably not Prisoner Zero. The Future!Doctor messing with Amy's timeline some more perhaps?
- I think it could be a production error, but every single thing about the Doctor is different. Wearing a coat (a different coat from the rest of the episode, unless Iím mistaken, compare here◊ and here◊ with here◊, his future jacket appears somewhat darker), sleeves rolled up, and what looks like a different watch. Everything is different about the Doctor's mood. Even the way he kisses Amy on the forehead. This Doctor has certainly known Amy for longer. And they've got people on the set who keep track of these things. They write it down. They take pictures between takes and cuts. Getting one thing wrong? Itís likely. Getting everything wrong? Not so much. Thereís no other explanation.
- As of the season finale, confirmed! Although he wasn't trying to get her to remember what he told her because he didn't know; he was trying to get her to remember what he was planning on telling her years ago (Timey-Wimey Ball), so that those memories (when triggered on her wedding day) would bring him back into existence.
Amy pond is an Autassassinophile
Also know as danger fetishist. So far, in the two situations where she has been terrified and very nearly killed (Vampires of Venice and Flesh & Stone) she has responded by enthusiastically getting off with the nearest bloke. I can't be the only one thinking this.
The Doctor will rewrite time so that he did come back for Little Amy.
This also explains the otherwise-puzzling shot of Little Amy sitting on her suitcase and hearing the TARDIS materialize
- That shot is cut immediately to adult Amy waking up. I presume that was her dream, a rehash of an old memory interrupted by the sound of the real TARDIS.
- This Troper thought the same thing, but who knows? Maybe this series theme will be the Doctor rewriting time in various places, including in the forest and back with little Amelia.
- Sort of confirmed. He did go back in time for Amelia...so he could plant a story in her head that would be triggered on her wedding day, to save him from oblivion.
Amelia Pond didn't live with "just an Aunt."
Her parents (and possibly siblings) were swallowed by the crack in her wall, and thus never existed. Same for the ducks from the duck pond.
- That... is some freakily plausible Nightmare Fuel.
- So the reason the Aunt Amy says takes care of her isn't there is because her family all just fell in the crack a very short time ago and all Amy now knows is that there's something wrong with that crack in her wall. Sweet dreams.
Amelia Pond is a Time Lord superweapon.
Wayback in their first proper appearance,the Time Lords were summoned by the Second Doctor
to fix something.Thier response was to
- 1.Execute a renegade Time Lord
- 2.Force the Doctor to regenerate.
- 3.Delete an entire military regime and all its soldiers from history.
- So the reason Amy Pond recalls no Daleks is because she erased them from history,just as the Time Lords intended. PS.She's the Nightmare Child (since she's the only companion we see as a child or having a nightmare).
Since Amy cannot remember the Daleks stealing the Earth despite it having been a completely worldwide event that was unescapable, then everyone else (except the Doctor) probably also doesn't remember. Besides the great continuity issues this raises (Donna, the 10th Doctor's clone, Davros, etc.), since Wilfred clearly remembered what happened before during "The End of Time" this means that whatever happened to cause the erasures must have started after that. This means that part or nearly all of that episode may have also been wiped from existence, which probably doesn't mean good things to come for the Doctor, especially if the Dalek Rangers
The Doctor told seven-year-old Amy something very important that she has to remember.
In "The Eleventh Hour," there was one scene near the end of the episode wherein we cut into a shot of little Amy while the TARDIS makes The Most Wonderful Sound. This, plus the context that a future Eleven comes back and tells Amy to remember what he told her when she was seven, probably means that the Doctor travels back in time to little Amy which would be instrumental to stop the whole "Time is Running Out," problem.
- This troper thought he was referring to the line "Everything's gonna be fine."
- It was a different Doctor telling her to remember it, though. The one who came back had his jacket on, which he'd very clearly lost moments before. I reckon the Doctor who came back to her, and treated her in a much more kindly, fatherly manner, is a version of the Doctor who had travelled with Amy as a child, the events of which got unwritten from time, and he's still trying to get her to remember them.
- Confirmed. Mostly. See a few entries up.
Amy is Turlough's daughter.
Both are ginger. Both have rather snarky personalities. And honestly, Amy is how I imagined a genderflipped
Turlough to be. It's canon that Amy's an orphan, it could be that she was the result of a one night stand Turlough had with a an Earthling. Now, how to prove Turlough would be on the planet around the time Amy was conceived...
Rory is The Master.
In all (or almost all) his oldWho appearances,The Master gets into swordfights, losing only to the Doctor.
Rory got into a swordfight.Also:Rory seems distinctly unfreaked out by the TARDIS "It's another dimension."
,because he already knows how it works and exactly
what the Doctor would say.
- Jossed. Rory got erased from time and The Doctor kept all his memories of him. Had he been the Master he would have lost them and who knows what would happen to his mind if that happened.
The Dream Lord was not in control
The Doctors mind was in control of most of the situation most of the time. There are hints it's his dream, such as him being able to complete the sentences of the Ecnodeen. The Doctor is play acting...he's aware of what is going on and manipulating events so that Amy is forced to make this choice. He creates a safe situation where Amy can feel how much Rory means to her. Only one situation comes out as not making sense if the Doctor were in complete control, which would be when the Ecnodeen corner him when he's alone at the butcher shop. Perhaps the Dream Lord and Ecnodeen had some free will and actually cornered him, and he needed to stay in the dream for it to keep existing. Even the last shot at the end makes sense, he sees his dark side in the deeds he has committed to push Amy to make her choice.
The Dream Lord was also feeding off Amy
- Because if he was only after the Doctor, he wouldn't have spent so much time and energy messing with Amy's head. Rory was really the only one who had so little dark in him that the best the Dream Lord could get out of him was Englands dullest village.
The Dream Lord was really concentrating on Amy, not the Doctor
- As the Dream Lord kept saying, it was all Amy's choice, he just taunted the Doctor to distract him from that fact.
The Dream Lord is the TARDIS
Formiddable psychic power, age measured in centuries, access to Doctor's darkest secrets... yup, definitely rings a Cloister Bell.
- So...the dreams were all because the TARDIS's consciousness! The dust that had knocked the three into unconsciousness DID get into the TARDIS's engine, and since it has been said the TARDIS is a sentient being, it manifested itself as the Dream Lord.
- This theory would explain why the TARDIS seems to do the Dream Lord's bidding. In the scene in "Vincent and the Doctor" where the Doctor introduces Vincent to the TARDIS, the Doctor does not quite look in control of the situation, which may indicate that the TARDIS decided to invite Vincent inside. The TARDIS misbehaves more severely in "The Lodger". Rather than directing Eleven's subconscious to a certain location as it seems to do in "Vincent and the Doctor", it takes him to a place he never consciously intended to go, and throws Eleven out until he takes action in stabilizing the TARDIS (by stabilizing the crashed Time Engine). If the TARDIS is as lust-powered as it behaves, then Eleven could have stabilized it by actually going along with what it wanted in several episodes (if not the entire series). These episodes include: "The Eleventh Hour", "Flesh and Stone", "Vincent and the Doctor", "The Lodger", and "The Pandorica Opens". Eleven finally stabilizes the TARDIS (at least temporarily) in "The Big Bang".
The first ten Doctors never existed, Eleven really is Amy's imaginary friend, and the Crack in Reality can work in reverse.
(from a comment on FFR)
Eleven, along with all his memories, were created by Amy when she wished for someone to fix the crack in her wall. Because she was constantly exposed to the fracture in reality in childhood, the crack in reality absorbed images from her imagination and created the Doctor. No one can remember the events from previous series because they never actually happened.
- This kind of thing could tie in with River Song saying "After all, we're all fairy tales." at the end of Flesh and Stone.
- One can only wonder then what was going through her mind then to create the events of A Fix With Sontarans...
- Semi-Confirmed, argubly.
The Doctor thinks Amy's uncertainty about the wedding will cause the universe to split, at a weak point where it can't afford to.
The schism into two parallel universes, one where the wedding occurred and one where it didn't, is happening at the same moment as a lot of other timey-wimey stuff, creating a perfect storm that threatens to end the universe. The Doctor thinks that by making Amy travel with him and Rory until she's absolutely committed to him, he can prevent the "no wedding" universe from coming into existence. Of course
, he's wrong. He'll get Amy sorted out, then Rory
will cause the rift.
- ...Cold Blood may well have just done this. No Rory, no wedding, no character development for Amy, etc. Cue massive paradox that causes gigantic rifts and cracks in time!
Series 5 was written to parallel Leonard Cohen's Anthem
Stand-alone episodes are based on individual lines/verses, and the arc itself is based on the chorus. The song was chosen because it contains a bunch of Nu Who motifs already.
- The Beast Below: We asked for signs, the signs were sent: the birth betrayed, the marriage spent. Yeah the widowhood of every government — signs for all to see.
- Victory of the Daleks: Ah the wars they will be fought again (Both WWII and the Time War).
- The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone: While the killers in high places say their prayers out loud
- The Vampires of Venice: But they've summoned, they've summoned up a thundercloud and they're going to hear from me.
- Amy's Choice: The birds they sang at the break of day. "Start again," I heard them say. Don't dwell on what has passed away or what is yet to be.
- Arc: Ring the bells that still can ring/Forget your perfect offering/There is a crack in everything/That's how the light gets in.
- Also the theme - "there is no drum" (The theme song is missing the old backbeat)
The Rani will return.
Old villians left, right and centre have been returning and its never said in the show whether she died, so its possible.
The reason the Angels didn't move before Flesh and Stone is because of the camera man.
In Attack of the Graske, the camera man is confirmed to be in-universe, as the Doctor addresses him: (Including you, mate. Where DO you get the energy?). Therefore, we can conclude that the reason the Angels didn't move during Blink when Sally/Cathy/Larry couldn't see them is not because the audience was looking at them, as was originally thought, but because the camera man was looking. Whereas, in Flesh and Stone, the camera man looks away (though of course the audience can't see this, as he's behind the camera), and thusly the Angels move.
- Jossed. The Doctor was talking to the audience member with the remote/mouse, not any camera man. Who looks directly into a lens to speak to a camera man?
The future Amy and Rory Team TARDIS saw will play an important role in Cold Blood
Why point them out? Why show Amy and Rory (and subsequently us) them if they aren't important. And yeah, the Doctor may say Never the Selves Shall Meet
but surely he remembers that that actually saves the day
in Mawdryn Undead
. I think that whole scene was to set up a Chekhov's Gun
- Technically confirmed. Well, it's the absence of the 2020 Rory that's important.
The Pandorica is...
Amy herself. She's said that the cracks in time seem to be following her. We'll just have to wait and see.
- Not quite, but she did wind up inside it for a couple of thousand years until Amelia touched it to restore her.
- It seems more likely that Amy is the main reason the Pandorica unlocked itself from the inside. In "The Pandorica Opens", the Pandorica seems to unlock every time the Doctor gets an impulse, so when Amy snogs the Doctor in "Flesh and Stone", the kiss may have resulted in the Pandorica unlocking.
- That second bullet is completely Jossed like it isn't even funny.
The Doctor is Merlin and River is the Lady of the Lake
The Doctor like Merlin seems to age backwards, successive regenerations tend to make him younger, he's pretty much magic, and he often disappears for considerable periods of time.
The Lady of the Lake, learned magic from Merlin, who then lusted after her, and eventually she used her magic to entomb Merlin in a tree or under a Stone. Merlin did not try to counter this. River, has a water themed name, likely learned about sonic screwdrivers and TARDIS piloting from the Doctor, and killed a very good man who was hero to many. As for lusted after, they do seem to have some sort of romantic relationship, what with they're very romantic dates to singing towers and picnics at Asgard.
The Pandorica is rumored to be, confirmed actually if you can trust the Doctor Who Wiki, Stonehenge. It is also mentioned on the wiki to be some type of prison (imprisoned under a stone get it). Rory is rumored to have been rewritten in time as a Roman Centurion. King Arthur is argued by some historians to have been a Celtic King who fought the Romans.
Now Merlin is said to have taken joy in deaths and final goodbyes because he lived backwards in time, so they were like first meetings for normal people. The Doctor first met River from his perspective when she died. Merlin also found first meetings and births tragic for similar reasons, so if River's first meeting of the Doctor from her perspective is the Pandorica, and she kills "the best man she ever knew" and there is sorrow in the first meeting.
Alternatives involve Pond as the Lady of the Lake.
- Wasn't it Nimue/Vivian that Merlin taught magic to, not the Lady of the Lake?
- I get my knowledge of Arthurian myth from The Other Wiki but it claims that the characters were conflated in some sources.
- King Arthur, if he ever existed, came after the Roman occupation had ended, and fought against the Saxon invaders; that's as old as the story can possibly be stretched, certainly not to the Roman times.
- Depending on how much we can take from the original run, it was already established that the Doctor was Merlin — or an alternate-dimension version of the Doctor was. That storyline was a bit confusing.
Rory is not coming back, and Amy will be killed in the finale.
Any future appearances will be a hallucination / impostor taking his form. The reason there was no information available about Amy's maritial status in The Beast Below
was because to the future timeline he never existed, and Amy may have never married.
He's gone, pretty much set up to be the Adric of the new generation, and is never coming back.
Amy may well not survive the finale either, which would make two dead companions in the span of one season for the Eleventh Doctor. Moffat may well be trying to break The Doctor more than RTD ever did... 06/26/2010 could be the date of Amy's death
, not her wedding.
- Jossed. Rory, is back, as a human and everything. Amy's killed in the climax of the first part, but she was Only Mostly Dead.
The Dreamlord is not part of the Doctor.
When in the butcher shop, the Dreamlord derisevly says that the Doctor is 'probably a vegetarian,' when he is obviously not (as recently as the Eleventh Hour he eats bacon and fish sticks with little moral hesitation). Something that was literally a manifestation of his darker side would not make such a glaring mistake, hence the Dreamlord is something external to the Doctor which nevertheless knows a great deal about him.
- Except the Doctor's tastes and preferences change from regeneration to regeneration, and he was trying to figure out what food he liked then. He threw out the bacon, don't forget, and for some reason fish is considered something vegetarians actually can eat (not vegans, however, but that's digressing). We haven't seen Eleven eat anything else yet, so he could be vegetarian, theoretically, if he dislikes other meats. Plus, given the inevitable rise to "Dream Lord is the Valeyard" theories it could also be a shout-out to Six, the Doctor who met the Valeyard, being vegetarian.
- While we don't see him eat it, the omelette that the Doctor cooks in The Lodger has ham in it. That makes a shout-out a more likely explanation.
- During The Two Doctors, the Sixth Doctor vows to become a vegetarian after meeting an Androgum (and seeing Two turned into one as well). This does not stick forever (Nine had steak in Boom Town) and wouldn't fit with the Dreamlord's comment anyway; the Doctor swore off meat because he was thoroughly disgusted by what he'd seen his previous self become. The Dreamlord's comment implied moral condescension, not personal distaste, while the Doctor vowed to become a vegetarian in much the same way that a drunkard may swear, "I'll never drink again."
- It's possible that the Doctor is either wrong or completely lying at the end of the episode, explaining the dreams as being caused by "sleep dust" or whatever. He seemed a bit ''too'' quick in explaining that...plus the last shot of the Dream Lord in his reflection...
Amy will eventually remember Rory
And this will be the key to bringing him back. Not sure how it will happen, but since the cracks are connected to her, I can't help but feel she the key to solving the problem one way or another
- Of COURSE Amy will be the key to solving this season's problem. She's been the reason for most of them already.
- In The Lodger She finds the engagement ring, and the crack gets bigger. I think perhaps the opposite is true.
- In the end, she does remember him, and that memory is used by the Autons to create a Rory mannequin, which ultimately helps solve the problem and bring him back for real. So...confirmed?
Anything that is inside a crack becomes a dream
In Amy's Choice, the TARDIS is blown up in a dream. Later (Cold Blood), a hunk of blown up TARDIS turns up in a crack.
Furthermore,if later on the Doctor is eaten by a crack, that will explain why young Amy dreamt about him.
And why monsters have nightmares about the Doctor.
And maybe even why the ood had bad dreams
- Could be some sort of.. I dunno, psychic feedback? That sounds like DW technoexplanation. But also, this could make the Dream Lord a much deadlier villain. Because now he exists.
Amy Pond is in a parallel universe
Somehow, during the regeneration, the Doctor managed to break through to another universe. Due to the fact he had just finished regenerating, and into a madman no less, he didn't realise this. Breaking through to the other universe caused the cracks, and it explains why Amy can't remember the Daleks.
The two problems with this are River and Churchill. River could have moved between universes, if a future doctor told her she had to, and how to do it. And as for Churchill, this universe may have split after WW2
, so when the Doctor travelled back in time it was to a time when the two universes were together.
- River and Churchill could be explained, actually. Maybe Amy's Universe had it's own Doctor who had similar - but not identical - adventures.
- In that case that universe is in more trouble than I thought; having two doctors has got to have repurcussions somewhere; maybe that's contributing to the cracks.
The cracks have started to affect the Time War.
The Fall of Arcadia was one of the major events of the Time War, yet in "Vincent and The Doctor" it's mentioned that The Doctor took Amy to Arcadia. Therefore, the cracks have erased the Fall of Arcadia from history, and since The Doctor had fought on the frontlines there, his memories of it were erased as well.
- Interesting! Maybe if his memories return, he'll get more angsty and less manic, like his predecessors who had never come to terms with the fall. Also, maybe the cracks reach further back, and that's why, per "The Lodger," he can't remember why he's called The Doctor.
- Or maybe he took Amy to Arcadia, Greece...or Arcadia before the Time War?
- Or a different Arcadia? There's 15 New Earths, why not two Arcadias?
- Or Arcadia, the burnt husk of a planet where once a mighty civilization lied?
The 'Time Capsule Tardis' in The Lodger was built by the Ood.
No real reasons for this, barring true conjecture. The controls seem very Ood, placing your hand against the controls. A Timelord was too powerful for it, but humans too weak. And the Ood's technology was advancing at about 10x speed. TARDISes were in the path of technology they'd develop, given they could already psychically see across time.
The Doctor makes things up to explain what he doesn't have a clue about
Back in Flesh and Stone
the Doctor (metaphorically) threw three-year worth of continuity into the Crack when he said that the Angels can choose not to move when they think they're observed. Which goes against everything we know about them.
But look at what evidence he'd got. As far as the Doctor knows the Angels have a habit of turning into stones when the only witness around is not looking. Not exactly familiar with the Fourth Wall
and the thousands of tropers behind it, he jumps to the best conclusion at hand. Sensible enough?
Just wait for the next time the stakes rest on his educated guess.note
- Support: In "Amy's Choice," Amy questions The Doctor on whether cold burning suns could actually exists. He's particularly flustered at the time and snaps at her: " I don't know! Why do people always think I know these things!?"
- Who says that Ten was right? As far as we can tell, everything he knows about the Angels in Blink he learned from a Stable Time Loop. There's no good reason that any non-essential knowledge Ontological Paradoxed into existence need be correct.
The prisoner within the Pandorica is...
They were ALL Jossed by the episode.
- Soaked in the blood of a billion galaxies? Anyone remember that alternate universe he destroyed in Turn Left?
- Technically, it was Donna who destroyed that universe by killing herself. Plus, the Reality Bomb was stopped before detonation, therefore, the only destroyed universe was destroyed because of Donna.
- The universe was already fading before Donna killed herself, so Davros would still have gotten quite a lot of galaxies
- Rule of Cool. What can I say, I really want to see Moffat tackle that plotline.
- ...The nightmare child or one of the other players in the time war
- The time war did some major damage, possibly destroying a billion galaxies(or one galaxy at a billion points in time). Since the Daleks are already present there, it's not them. It is possibly trying to erase the time war from time so it can escape.
- ...The Doctor.
- Or that alternate timeline version of him that everyone is convinced is out there, or future version of him that's another nod to the Valeyard, and just a future version of him that's not evil, but it was the only way his enemies could finally whoop him.
- The quote from the Next Time trailer is an incredibly apt description of the Doctor:
There was a goblin. Or a trickster, or a warrior. A nameless, terrible thing, soaked in the blood of a billion galaxies. The most feared being in all the cosmos.
- Every Doctor Who villain in the known universe would absolutely show up if they know that someone already had the Doctor locked up in a cage.
- It explains how River could kill the greatest man she'd ever known — a hero to millions — and still be relatively flippant about it: she killed "the Doctor", but not THE Doctor, and got locked up by people who didn't realise the difference.
- This one's confirmed...in a certain sense.
- ...The Black Guardian.
- Stolen from elsewhere on this page.
- Hey, someone had to say it!
- The Doctor was imprisoned in the Pandorica... Perhaps the Doctor is Cthulu and Cthulu is the most benevolent Old One?
- ...Chuck Norris.
- Now """THAT'S""" someone to be scared of!
- Chuck Norris wouldn't let a silly little thing like the Pandorica detain him.
- Hence why he's breaking out. From his perspective, it only held him for like half a second.
- He somehow survived, and is pissed at the Doctor for leaving him behind.
- The Void itself
- Remember the thing the daleks and Cyberman were sucked into? It'll be back. And EATING THE UNIVERSE. It'll be a convient way to bring back the OTHER Doctor and the daleks and cybermen in them as well
- Everyone and everything the Cracks have consumed
What was in the Pandorica? Nothing. It's an empty cage. But once it's open, the epic alliance of villains trap the Doctor inside
and then close it up again. (so those who guessed that it'd be the Doctor were almost
The Dreamlord is driving the Tardis
Why? No clue. But perhaps with The Doctor stuck in the Pandorica, he'd be able to escape. Or, it's Jenny. or Jenny will come back and save him?
How they escape
After the end of The Pandorica Opens.
- River: Vortex manipulator.
- Confirmed, but the Doctor himself rescues her with it.
- The Doctor: Auton!Rory lets him out (the Doctor says it's easy to open from the outside).
- The rumors that there is a second Doctor are true. He will let himself out.
- It's both, actually. A future Doctor hands his sonic to Rory.
- Amy: Disney Death?
- No. She's really dead, but Only Mostly. The Pandorica's puts her in stasis before she receives a living DNA sample from her younger starless-timeline self.
The Pandorica Opens during Amy's time
The idea that it's during Roman times is just part of the Kansas City Shuffle
. That's why Stonehenge looks old, when it didn't get that way until later. What evidence do we have that it's the past?
- The Stonehenge was old even in the Roman times; it's the oldest known structure in the area, as old as the pyramids of Egypt (which too are a millennia older than the Roman Empire).
- For the purpose of this WMG, we're subscribing to the popular theory that Stonehenge was still a complete circle in Roman times, that was later sacked and then partially restored.
- From where?
- The space-time coordinates Vincent painted: the Big Bad is controlling when time-travelers end up, so River and the TARDIS could've been manipulated.
- The Romans: fake.
- The absence of modern-day people: The villains killed them all (and shot down any planes).
- Jossed. The Doctor states it's 102 AD by looking at his timey watch, and Rory says on several occasions he waits for centuries to reunite with Amy in 1996. Did the villains (oh, wait, WHAT villains?) manipulate the museum exhibits about the Lone Centurion too? Did they create a fake Blitz to bury Rory in? And I don't see how co-ordinates on a PAINTING can mess up the Doctor's sense of history.
- The Romans ARE fake, however. They're Autons.
The TARDIS fragment was fake
Why not? Everything else was.
Little!Amy's "dream" of the Doctor coming back for her wasn't, and this is the cause of the cracks
The Doctor, possibly at some point in his own personal future, goes back to little!Amy out of guilt or a desire to "rewrite" time so that he didn't actually disappear for twelve/fourteen years. He took her on marvelous adventures in a timeline parallel to the one we're watching for fourteen-ish years. The two of them ended up on the Byzantium - causing a paradox which caused the cracks in time, as per the rest of the theories on this page - and got separated while fighting/running from the Angels. Tweed!Doctor is this alternate-timeline Doctor who mistook "our" Amy for "his" Amy - the one he's been traveling with. He told her something when she was seven, possibly along the lines "I will always come back" or "I will always be here for you" that alternate!Amy would have immediately understood, but Amy Prime has no hope of getting.
- The two Doctors, two Amys ending is foreshadowed by Amy having a different name when the Doctor sees her again. There is an Amelia Pond, traveling with the other!Eleven and an Amy Pond, who we have been following.
Alternately, whatever Tweed!Doctor told her when she was seven was eaten by a crack
And that's why it's so crucial that she remembers it, rather than him telling her. The same way he later tries to get her to remember Rory after his death and absorption into the crack.
Jack showed up for the finale again in Series 5.
Well, part of him.
- Please explain?
- I'm assuming the original writer meant that the hand we see from the unnamed handsome Time Agent was actually Jack's.
Amy never had an aunt and was raised by the Dreamlord.
There's alredy a theory that Amy's aunt was swallowed by a crack, but I don't believe she ever existed. In the first episode, seven year old Amy was all alone,at night, I don't recall ever seeing a trace that anyone else lived in the house. And when River goes to the house, it doesn't seem as though anyone was in it, plus she is never mentioned when the Daleks, Cybermen, etc talk about how they used Amy's memories to build a scenario. This is even stranger when you consider the other companions' parents:
Jackie Tyler became a recurring character.
Martha's father appeared several times, and her mother played an important part in the Harold Saxon plot arc.
Donna's mother also appeared a lot, and Wilfred got given a starring role in The End of Time
But we never see evidence of Amy's aunt.
On to the second part of the theory.
So far, every previous episode of the series which didn't either mention or show cracks (not including the first parts of two parters) has contributed a character to the final. A lot of them don't even do anything important; really, what purpose does Queen Elizabeth from The Beast Below
serve? She's just there. And the crack at the end of The Lodger
didn't do anything other than make the viewer worry. Basically, every episode has a connection to The Pandorica Opens
Except for Amy's Choice
. And I'm not sure I buy the story of the Dreamlord being the Doctor. I think he was the one piloting the Tardis with River inside.
And these two link together like this; he tricked Amy's mind into believing that she had an aunt, when she didn't. He never actually appeared to her, he just made sure she was able to stay alive until the Doctor came. Somehow, and for some reason, he was using her to lure the Doctor.
I'm not going to push this as a theory, but I wouldn't be surprised to learn that that half of Amy's house doesn't exist; all we ever see is the passage, her bedroom and the kitchen. Everything else is just empty rooms, as the Doctor pointed out.
- There's even this stairway going to... the ceiling◊. Not weird and suspicious ''at all''.
- What the Heck!? How come I never noticed that before? It's like there's a 'real' perception filter around that door...
- Obviously, we were all distracted by a hot redhead in a police outfit...
- Trap door to the attic. Though I got to agree, we should have noticed that. Now we need to get a boombox and a recoding of a Dalek yelling "Explain" (because I really, really like it), take that picture, print it up, corner Stephen and play the recording while showing him the picture to confirm it.
- Wasn't Amy's aunt seen in the beginning of "The Big Bang", when Amy is 7? She's the one who talks about "star cults".
Amy is dreaming in reality.
Another dreamlord theory.
Amy is asleep, and has been asleep for the entire series. She may still be a little girl who only dreamed she grew up.
However, she is not having a regular dream, rather the dreamlord is controlling it. The village where she lives, the Doctor, Rory, and everything and everyone else, are real. The dreamlord possibly has more power than he seemed to, and can influence people in the village's thinking. Amy's house isn't really there, or it's just old and abandoned, hence the empty rooms. The Amy everyone sees is simply the dream version of her. That's why her life "makes no sense": everything personal about it is a dream.
The Dreamlord is behind everything.
At the end of Amy's Choice, we see the Dreamlord in the Tardis Console. Somehow when the Doctor exploded the Tardis in the Dreamworld the Dreamlord got trapped in the Tardis in the real world. The cracks are actually openings into the Dreamworld that the Dreamlord managed to place across the Universe. When the Tardis explodes the entire universe will be sucked into the Dreamworld the same way The Doctor, Rory and Amy were able to escape the Dreamworld by exploding the Tardis. Once this happens, seeing as the entire universe is inside the Dreamworld, the Dreamlord can manipulate the universe any way he pleases.
Prisoner Zero is behind everything.
Given Moff's love of the Timey-Wimey Ball
and the Stable Time Loop
, this could be the event explains why he was a prisoner in the first place.. People have been created from Amy's memories, just as Zero disguised himself using them in the season opener. The Davros-like voice saying "Silence will fall"? He's using the Doctor's memories too. He makes the link while people are asleep, and in "Amy's Choice" all three characters were asleep for a long enough time.
- It's been hinted that he's a member of the Silence. And since he's Prisoner Zero, that could mean he's either the first prisoner the Atraxi caught, OR he's the leader.
Human!Ten is behind everything.
Rose dumped him, because adventuring with the Doctor is quite different than settling down with him. He got to Waters of Mars
-level of madness, but had the ambition of a human instead of the wisdom of a Time Lord. Ten punched the first crack to this universe and began his quest to rip the Time Vortex apart and ascend to godhood. (He didn't see the gap year finale, but since he has the Doctor's memories from the end of the Time War, he knows of the possibility.)
- The whole scheme is centered on Amy, and the Doctor's greatest weakness (and strength) is always his companion.
- The Doctor speculates in the Dream Lord episode about there being only one person who hates him so much, and is implied that that's the Doctor himself. Now, Human!Ten * is* the Doctor, (has his memories) additionally he was screwed over by the the Doctor. (stranded in a human body, with no TARDIS) Add Ten's emotional instability in late gap year to the mix, and you have the ultimate Omnicidal Maniac.
- Someone was trying to build a TARDIS...
- He sends his greatest enemies on a wild goose chase after the real Doctor while he enacts the last phase of his plan.
- His voice is disembodied because he transmits it through the cracks.
- He can be the "good man, a hero to many" who gets killed by River.
- I'm not going to rule out the theory River killed the Doctor (or his clone), but she was already in jail at the beginning of the episode. It could have been for something else, I guess.
- In * Silence* in the Library, Ten doesn't trust River, also mentions the possibility of River taking the screwdriver from his dead body. Maybe she did...
There will be two Doctors in the last episode.
People keep pointing out how the Doctor sometimes changes his clothes mid-episode, and there are theories explaining how we could have ended up with a duplicate.
The Doctor is now locked in the Pandorica. But what's to stop this second Doctor sorting things out? No-one woud have to realise, at least not until the end of the episode where he would have to get them to let him out of the Pandorica (this works best if you assume the duplicate is his future self).
- Confirmed, but the truth is more mundane. It's a set of Stable Time Loops in which the Doctor uses the Vortex Manipulator to go back in time, give Rory his screwdriver, and let him out. (Among other things.)
Dreamlord aka Valeyard is now an independent entity like the 4th/5th doctors Watcher
From the Angel episode: "What happens when dreams no longer need their dreamers?"
The Dreamlord is of course a Dream of the Doctors'. + Thematic element of all the Romans and such being
a dream of Amy's (whatever she might be).Not sure what this has to do with the lack of ducks in the pond though.Naturally,the Dreamlord (aka Valeyard) aka The Doctor is what's driving the TARDIS at the end of "Pandorica Opens." PS:The reset button will be everybody just...waking
Themes of this Season
Looking over the episodes of this season, I've been noticing a few trends.
- Growing up/Evolving/Change- Amy grows up, Liz 10 doesn't, and the dream pensioner's aging rates are slowed down. The Dalek are reborn, the Angels are restored, the Saturnynes change humans into themselves. The Silurians stay exactly the same due to their hibernation. The emergancy hologram changes forms to suit it's needs. And, of course, Regeneration.
- Disguises/Masquerades- Prisoner Zero's disguises, the star whale deception, the Daleks pretending to be servants, the Angel pretending to be dormant. Vampires pretending to be aristocrats, two dream worlds, the hidden Silurians, the invisible Krafayis, the emergancy hologram and the second floor. Not to mention the Pandorica.
- Senses- The Doctor adjusting to new taste buds, his HD memory, Amy's "Notice Everything" moment, Amy being blinded, and having to feel her way through the forest, the vampires tasting they're victims blood, The Doctor feeling the oddity of the ground near the drilling project, etc.
- Bringing about your own end- Prisoner Zeros connection with Amy, the Star Whale's charity causing it to suffer, Bracewell's attempted suicide, the Angels feeding on the Ship's energy, Rosanna sending the girls after the doctor and commiting suicide, Amy and the Doctor's suicides, Rory's sacrifice, the emergancy hologram's desire for a pilot, and, of course, Vincent...
- All of these themes may be united by the following over-arching message: The world is filled with scary things, many of which are inside yourself. Ignoring the monsters (on the inside especially) does not make the monsters go away. It simply makes the problem worse. The Angels can kill you, but the Cracks can erase your existence. Addressing an issue and facing the consequences is better than avoiding the issue and letting it grow like a cancer.
Rory will be just fine.
Obviously they have to fix the cracks, so he will stay in existence. In Cold Blood, the Doctor pretty much stalled because of the giant crack, which allowed Restac time to catch up with them. With the distraction gone, they would have been outta there by the time she showed up and Rory would be alive. Logically speaking (if that's possible for a WMG).
- The Rule of Drama dictates that Restac catches up with them, no matter what.
- I'm calling it now, Rory will end up being saved in the finale. We all know (obviously) The Doctor will stop/fix the cracks at the end of the season and somehow Rory being taken by the light from that crack will be what ends up saving him from dying.
- Because otherwise all this 'Amy's wedding' foreshadowing will be COMPLETELY meaningless. And much of Amy's growth in character will be undone.
- But how will the Doctor prevent the Cyberking, Daleks and Weeping Angels from being brought back by the crack as well? That said, I've actually got an idea:
- The Crack leads to another dimension (unlucky Rory, being trapped with the three worst things in the Whoinverse). A part of The TARDIS was retrieved from the crack, implying the Doctor will go into the Crack. So if it's another dimension, then Rory can be saved without anything else escaping via TARDIS, even though it is also implyed that the TARDIS is destroyed, which could explain the reason behind the Blue Peter TARDIS Console Design Competition.
- Alternatively... We never saw Rory's body disappear, just it being enveloped by the crack's energy. The cracks seem to do different things. While evidence of his existence may well have been erased from the timeline, the crack actually brought Rory himself back to life. ... forever.
- He is fine, but it takes three or four episodes to actually take.
The doctor earns his title as a lonely god
Silence falled. The Tardis, Galaxies and Stars exploded. Everything is over. Only the Pandorica and the Doctor still exist, because... well, i have no idea. But now there is a lonely being which remembers all reality. And maybe the Doctor remembers desperatly enough, so that his memories held the Nothingness at bay. And a part of his memory is running around and will save the world from the Big Bad
. There we have our second Doctor. But now he can't never open the Pandorica or he will release his other self, which is now the cornerstone of all reality. The Doctor in the Pandorica is sealed forever. A truly lonely god.
- No chance, that it happens like that. I just wanted to add it, because i like the part about the Lonely God.
The TARDIS is evil
Remember the psychic pollen? The stuff that draws out your darkest side, created the Dream Lord, all that? Got into the TARDIS's rotors? Oh, yeah, and remember that the TARDIS is sentient
? The TARDIS is currently under the influence of its evil side, its equivalent of the Dream Lord. When it started behaving weirdly, taking River Song to the wrong time, locking her in, and then exploding in a cataclysmic universe-destroying explosion—nobody was messing with it. It did all that itself. For the Evulz
- Holy crap, this is brilliant! It makes so much sense!
- It actually does, I agree. Matt Smith apparently said in one panel that the Big Bad of the season was in the first episode "but not in a conventional way," the TARDIS has certainly taken some abuse from the Doctor over the years (intentional or not, that could cause some bitterness), and... the TARDIS never died in the 2015 Leadworth dream. It could still be dreaming while its dark side takes over.
- If the TARDIS is evil, why did BBC America re-air an episode seemingly designed to repair mental imbalance in its audience? I'd say the TARDIS is approximately half-evil, half-good.
- First off, what? Second off, did he say "the first episode", or "The Eleventh Hour". Because, as you all seem to forget (I blame the cracks in time) 11's first episode WASN'T The Eleventh Hour, it was The End of Time. Ten regenerated in that episode, and we saw 11 for the first time. Taking that interpretation of his words, it opens up the Big Bad List to every Time Lord (everyone from the Meddling Monk to The Master to The Rani), Handy (10 and Handy are both 10, so that could be the meaning of "not in the conventional way), Captain Jack Harkness (the man REALLY wants to die, I wonder what happens when an immortal fixed point in time actually finds a way, going by the last few times someone messed with a fixed point, it can't be healthy for anything), The Dreamlord (The Dreamlord is The Doctor, The Doctor was in both The End of Time and The Eleventh Hour, this is the most likely), The Valeyard, who may be the Dreamlord, time itself (because, well, what else hasn't tried to kill the Doctor yet?) or even Donna.
Mr. Pond is the season villain
The cast page for The Big Bang has been posted on the other wiki, and it looks rather... domestic. The only non-mundane things are the Doctor (duh), River Song (hardly indicative of much), and a "stone Dalek", which is handled by their usual Dalek prop handler, and seems to not even have a speaking role, though we don't know that for sure. Given the events of The Pandorica Opens, this seems rather odd.
But their is one incongruity. Mr. Pond is played by a "Helco Johnston". A quick Google search, as well as one of IMDB reveals no such person. Now, conceivably, they hired a really obscure actor, who doesn't even show up on Google. But I'd call that unlikely, especially with a name as unusual as Helco. This is clearly a pseudonym, and possibly an anagram, though for what I have no idea. But there's clearly something to conceal.
I'm guessing that Mr. Pond is a character we've seen before. If so, he's probably not a hero. I can't think of any heroic character whose identity they wish to conceal, which leaves villains. They'd only go to these lengths if it was someone important, so I'm guessing he's the main villain. I'm not just basing this on meta evidence. Amy says that she doesn't have parents. What does that even mean? And now he turns up. For the finale. I'd guess that he's going to play a major role, and not as a protagonist.
If anyone can crack the anagram or whatever it is for Helco Johnston, I'd be quite appreciative.
- "CLOTHES ON JOHN"? ...so Captain Jack is gonna turn up and not take his pants off?
- Yes. The new Whoniverse is a Mirror Universe. In the Series 5 Whoniverse, Eleven was biologically programmed to seduce people like Rory Pond or Jack Harkness. In the Series Shag Whoniverse, Jack Harkness is the only person who can refuse to have sex with Eleven, and Eleven is the only person who can refuse to have sex with Rory.
- CHEST JOHN LO NO — Captain Jack will appear and have a shirtless scene, but not a pantless scene?
- OK. The big name I get out of it is Elton John; that leaves you with COSH, which doesn't make any particularly good words, which is unfortunate. You can also get STONE (which seems to link with the stone Dalek that's been seen) and that leaves you with LOCH JOHN. So god knows what's going on.
- JOHN LOCH?
- For the record, cosh is a perfectly fine word itself, meaning, among other things, to knock someone unconscious with a blunt instrument. So clearly the universe will be saved by Amy knocking Elton John's character out with a cricket bat. Presumably to stop him chasing the Doctor with a hatchet while singing Anthem.
- CHLOE JOHNSTON - doesn't have the hugest filmography, but at least she shows up on IMDb. As for MR. Pond, maybe he is a hermaprodite.. or a shapeshifter.. and a monkey-robot-pirate-ninja as well.
- CELT HO JOHNSON - a slutty druid, fits well with the Stonehenge.
- Jossed, and Amy's dad is played by ''Halcro'' Johnston, and he has been in some minor parts.
- Eh, it was a reasonable theory. Wikipedia was wrong, so it was based on incorrect information, but I feel my conclusions were reasonable given the available information.
- You were almost correct actually! You just got the wrong Mr. Pond! The mid-series cliffhanger involves Rory Pond snogging Eleven against the wall of the TARDIS. His reason? He thinks that he and Eleven need to move past their internalized homophobia. Technically, Eleven has already moved past this mentally, but he has not accepted Rory's existence emotionally. The Whoniverse is not fixed. It is a Pete's World with all the sadness dumped into the Series 5 Whoniverse. Even after the "Flesh and Stone" kiss, the Eleventh Doctor felt comfortable in his role. For Eleven, the "Flesh and Stone" snog was a localized Time Loop and out-of-body experience, so Eleven had as much time as he wanted to examine the situation. He determined that there was a 50% chance of Amy's plotline having a happy ending, and decided that 50% was acceptable odds. Eleven may have been a lot more scared of the snog with Rory (which I like to call the "Stone and Flesh" cliffhanger). This would explain why it was uncertain for a few weeks in October of 2010 whether or not the Eleventh Doctor would reprise his role in Series Seven. Note that Eleven was a lot more committed to portraying the second half of Series 5. Luckily he's decided to portray Series Seven despite the fact that it climaxes with his worst nightmare.
- Mid-series cliffhanger nonsense Jossed.
- As of "The Wedding of River Song" we've got another Mr. Pond, who has far more potential for villainy than the other two...
Amy is really a dream construct, to trap the Doctor.
- The Pandorica was based on her mind, and she seems to fit perfectly for what the Doctor needed when he found her: someone to constantly take his mind off of his troubles.
- Plastic!Rory was a fake, who believed he was real, so it's not out of the question.
- Planted by the Daleks or one of their 'allies'(they're also going to turn on their so-called alliance).
Mr.Pond is the Dream Lord.
Helco Johnson is either an obcusre actor or is concealing who will really play him. Helco Johnson's letters form Jones. Who played the Dream Lord. Toby Jones. Also, notice how Mr.Pond has no first name given, and no first name like the other cast.
- Wouldn't that make the Doctor Amy's father? If so, perhaps Amy will have a child named Susan later?
- Jossed. Nope, they're clearly different actors. No aliases like Anthony Ainley.
Mr. Pond is Darth Vader...
...and he will get a Luke, I Am Your Father
moment with Amy. (Who is apparently a regenerated and unknowing Princess Leia) Maybe we get to see Karen Gillan in a metal bikini.
- Also, Rory might be Luke, which will boost the squick-factor of their relationship to the skies.
- Note that the cracks are affecting EVERY universe, even the SW one. These three character fell through a crack into the Whoniverse and forgot who they were.
- The first crack was created when the Emperor hit the reactor. Good news for the Endor Holocaust Theory.
- Jossed. Amy recognises her father in "The Big Bang" right away.
Rory always was a Auton
Bit of the Timey-Wimey Ball
here. The trauma of killing Amy causes Auton!Rory's memory to partially short out, forgetting that he killed her. He lives the next 2000 years, then assumes his identity as Rory in Leadsworth and asks Amy to marry him, joins the Doctor again only to be killed and erased again- and then to copied again by the Alliance. This explains why he remembers being killed. Rory no doubt visited Amy's house often and the Alliance would have copied his memories too. This also explains why his hospital badge said 1990- as an Auton Rory doesn't age and he could have been in the hospital that long. He'd likely get a lot of comments about how good he looks for his age though....
- In "Eleventh Hour", Rory mentions how Amy asked him to dress up as the Doctor when they were kids. Now, a 20-ish guy playing with young Amelia is a bit weird...
- The nice Daleks saw Amelia playing with her Ken doll and thought they could do "better"...
The Doctor will stay stuck in the Pandorica for 2000 years and be released by a 7-year old Amelia Pond
This is how the "little girl" will save the universe. He will then tell Amelie the thing that he told Amy to remember in "Flesh and Stone".
- This actually seems pretty possible, considering Amelia appears to be in a museum of some sorts with the Pandorica. Although we don't know where or when this museum is. What came to mind was
River: Two things always garunteed to show up in a museum, the homebox of a category 4 starliner, and sooner or later, [the Doctor].
Rosanna: You should be in a museum!.
- Though they're most likely not realted to the Pandorica at all, it might be a bit of foreshadowing.
- Semi-Confirmed. Young Amelia rescued her future self from the Pandorica instead.
The Doctor will get River's Vortex Manipulator and travel back over his own time line to fix things
This explains the shadowy figure in "The Eleventh Hour", the "other" Doctor in "Flesh and Stone" and various other minor "continuity errors" over the season.
- Semi-Confirmed with extra mind-screwy goodness. He does use the Manipulator, but the Shadowy figure and Jacket!Doctor was his timeline being rewound due to his Heroic Sacrifice.
The black TARDIS or its creators will still show up for the finale.
Every episode in the season has thusfar had an influence on the finale within the main plot of the story.
- the eleventh hour set up the basic premise, introduced Amy and Rory, whose interaction was vital in the finale
- the beast below gave us elizabeth X, who appeared in the first part
- victory of the daleks gave us churchill and the new daleks, both making appearances in the finale
- The time of Angels and Flesh and stone gave us foreshadowing of the finale and the effect of the cracks in time and space, which shows that Rory should not have been able to survive.
- The vampires of Venice and Amy's choice both had the underlying story of connecting Rory and Amy again and to set up the adventures of Rory with the doctor.
- The hungry earth and cold blood gave us Homo Reptillius and the death of Rory
- Vincent and the Doctor gave us the painting that led to River breaking out of prison
- And then came The Lodger. The only influence this episode had on the finale was Amy finding the engagement ring, something that happened in a single scene and had no influence on the rest of the plot. This is the only episode in the season where the main plot did not work towards the finale. Maybe it has yet to show up.
- The lodger had part of a house being a tardis, and a staircase into nowhere (although IMO the one in amy's house◊ looks like there is another floor there - you can see the two ceilings aren't the same height)
- Given that in The Pandorica Opens the Doctor said that Amy's house was too big and had too many rooms, and that Steven Moffat has said that the Big Bad is in the first episode, but not the way you'd expect, I'm guessing that Amy's House is the Big Bad.
- look at her front door. The window pattern makes it look very much like a police box
- So the big bad is a minotaur and her house is the house?
- Nope, Jossed. However, the black TARDIS does not appear again until the series 6 premiere.
The thing that the Doctor told Amy when she was seven will be told to Amelia in The Big Bang.
We know that Amelia is going to be in The Big Bang, right? And if the jacket!Doctor theory is true, he must have been from the future, since the Doctor from the past didn't tell Amelia anything that she would need to remember. So, in The Big Bang, the Doctor talks to Amelia and tells her something important, that Amy needs to know in order to save the universe. He then goes back in time to make sure that she remembers it when she needs to. The reason she couldn't remember it in Flesh and Stone was because the Doctor telling Amelia hadn't actually 'happened' yet, due to Timey-Wimey.
- Confirmed. The Doctor needed Amy to remember the TARDIS, and by extension the Doctor, so she could bring them back on her wedding day.
Prisoner Zero is somehow related to the silence.
Not necisarrily the Big Bad
as in the theory above, but related. The key detail being something that I only realized in a Late to the Punchline
. The line that it said early on "The Pandorica will open, and Silence will fall." The key word being AND. The Pandorica was designed by the Alliance to prevent the Silence from falling. That line would imply that Zero knows more about what's going on then they do.
The ring survived because Rory put it in the same force-field thing that kept the recorder from becoming anti-matter in The Three Doctors.
They look rather similar, don't they? Thin bars of metal attatched to a thick base with ropes perpendicular to the bars tied around them. 11's is just smaller than 3's (but let's not go there.)
Bracewell went back to working with Churchill after Victory of the Daleks
In the final episode, we see him showing the painting to Churchill. He says it's a message for the Doctor. If that scene is supposed to take place BEFORE Victory of the Daleks, why doesn't Churchill mention it to the Doctor? If it's after, then Bracewell is still working for Churchill, with all the knowledge of the Dalek tech. He could well have built a few more things along the lines of the spacegoing Spitfires which will show up in future episodes.
(As a Steampunk and Spitfire fan, I really want this to be true.)
- This is true, since if you look closely Bracewell is wearing a leather glove on the same hand the Daleks shot.
That voice that came from freaking nowhere in The Pandorica Opens and said "SILENCE WILL FALL" was the Dream Lord.
- And he's gonna say it again in the next series. Just thought I'd throw that out there.
- Could also be the voice of Prisoner Zero or some other chaos-focused villain. Perhaps the voice is meant to sound like a combination of chaos-focused villains seen previously in Series 5. Or perhaps it is the voice of the TARDIS. She may not be a villain, but she certainly seems chaos-focused.
Rory really was Rory.
More specifically, Auton-Rory was the real Rory, at least in some respects. Remember how the Doctor was talking about impossible things that we can't explain and we just call them miracles, applying that to Rory's apparent resurrection? Well, it kind of ruins that scene if Rory was just a duplicate. Considering the Doctor's test of character, and the fact that Auton-Rory could even resist his programming, the conclusion is obvious. Upon his death, Rory's soul fell through time and space and ended up in the plastic centurion body. That's why he was able to resist total Autonification, that's why he was still so human, and that's also how the hell he even remembered being plastic. How and why did this happen? Who knows, it's a miracle!
- But that's the point, the Doctor got it wrong. Indeed the whole plot of the ep was the Doctor getting things wrong. The Pandorica is a trap for him, Rory ia Nestene duplicate, the Romans aren't real romans and the aliens aren't coming to take the Pandorica there coming to put him INTO it.
- So? This doesn't really have anything directly relating to the alliance's plot, and besides, why couldn't the Doctor be wrong about the how but not the what? And again, explain how Auton-Rory wasn't really Rory when he remembers being plastic after Big Bang 2.
- Indeed the Doctor can be wrong about the how but not the what. Often he seems to be aware of the results of his actions, but is mystified about what motivated his actions in the first place. He may have known what procedure would work to instigate Big Bang II, but the look on his face right before the Pandorica closes indicates that he hasn't a clue about what is powering Big Bang II/The TARDIS explosion (it's probably him), and is becoming extremely confused by the TARDIS explosion's effect on his brain.
- I'm pretty sure this is exactly what happened. The Doctor says that when the Nestene Consciousness created Auton-Rory out of Amy's memories, they got more than they bargained for and resurrected the actual Rory as an auton. It wasn't a miracle. It was just a side effect of Amy being a Time Crack Baby.
- Either it was a side effect of Amy's connection to the Time Cracks, or because she was so close to him. She knows a lot about her childhood friend and fiance, enough data that when the Nestene made an Auton based upon him, it was so close as to basically be him; close enough for Time Wimey at least.
When the Doctor Rebooted the Universe, he brought back Gallifrey and the Time Lords
Agreed. Although there's an audio drama that implies the Doctor turned human at some point, and this troper can see several humans that look like Time Lords. Perhaps Time Lords are supposed to be our higher selves (with the exception of imagination, which is supposed to be human). Modern humans who look like Time Lords when one makes eye-contact with them are probably the most Time Lord humans can get.
- Jossed. All the Time Lords are still dead, as confirmed by "The Doctor's Wife".
The Atraxi's prisoners are numbered in ascending order of scariness.
Prisoner Zero was the least dangerous, and so had the least security and was the first to escape. Soon, we will meet...PRISONER ONE! RUN!
- Prisoner number one was briefly contained in the Pandorica.
- Was Prisoner One the Eleventh Doctor?
- And Prisoner Two will be the Valeyard.
- The fact he is numbered "Zero" that blows my mind in a Schrodinger kind of way
The TARDIS protecting earth was deliberate.
We know that the TARDIS is sentient. We know that it sealed the console room and stuck River in a Time loop to save her. Though it could be just protocol, it is more likely that without the Doctor there, the Tardis' priorities as its last acts were to protect the Doctor's companion and protect the Earth, becoming a substitute sun and providing radiation and gravity to allow humanity to keep living as long as it could.
- The TARDIS could have also been shielding Earth from the destruction of the Universe. The Doctor says the Earth was at the eye of the storm, but it could have just as well been that the Tardis knew the Doctor was on Earth and it's last act was not to protect humanity but to protect the Doctor.
- The TARDIS may have deliberately attempted to protect Earth because she knows that the protection of Earth is required for the Doctor to stay sane (or about as sane as the Doctor is supposed to be). When the TARDIS explodes, she deliberately protects all of the Companions and Allies of Eleven that remain in existence (assuming they were not all swallowed by Time Cracks) because she knows that the continued existence of these humans and humans in general are a psychological need of Eleven. The existence of most (if not all) of Eleven's Companions and Allies are tied to Eleven's deepest need. The TARDIS may be a Kinky Sex Machine Matchmaker.
The Pandorica is a void ship
In "Doomsday", isn't it explicitly stated that nothing can get inside a voidship and you could survive the end of the universe and the beginning of the next inside one?
- I suppose. And that has to do with the Pandorica how exactly?
The Cybermen featured in The Pandorica Opens and Blood of the Cybermen are not from Mondas or the Alternate Earth.
They are in fact a union of the two factions, having registered each other as being the same, with the same goals, they teamed up. The two shared their technology, the Mondas Cybermen benefiting from the Alternate Earth's conversion tech, armor and weaponry, and the Alternate Earth Cybermen gained the Cybermat, which replaced the Cybershades they used in The Next Doctor
The chickeny monster thing from "Vincent and the Doctor" is a Shout-Out
Specifically, to Discworld
. I mean seriously, a brilliant Mad Artist
is the only one who can see an invisible chicken monster that's slow driving him mad(der)? That's straight out of Thud!!
- ...damn, that actually makes sense!
Three of the Five Arc Phrases from Series Five are:
"The Beast Below"
"Silence will Fall"
"The Pandorica will Open"
The other arc phrases may relate to quotes from Eleven that sound significant, such as: "I WAS NOT EXPECTING THIS!" and "What's coming out?"
As well as arc phrases, there also appear to be arc scenes in which the external conflict of the plot seems to mirror what may be Eleven's internal conflict. One of these scenes is the part of "Time of Angels" where Eleven is being attacked by Angels from both sides and fails to escape because he is unable to keep track of both sides at once. Another one of these scenes is the part of "Vincent and the Doctor" where Eleven is running from an invisible Krafayis that seems to terrify him (perhaps because it's invisible).
- The "what's coming out?" actually has the potential to be utterly freaking terrifying, if it gets used in the next season. I can't even remember where it was FROM, but still.
- What "comes out" can be seen in this full version of Bang Bang II: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXSxz3yYk9s. This clip suggests to me that the force that caused the TARDIS to explode may be an infinite power source that can be used for both good and evil. Indeed, Eleven has already used it for both good and evil. In his quest to become the Ubermensch (as evidenced by this fan-vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsABkKMfZrI&NR=1&feature=fvwp), he exhibits a lot of righteous fury in the first half of Series 5. In the second half of series 5, the TARDIS compels Eleven to go to more tranquil locations and make new friends with potential benefits. The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone two-parter serves as the dividing line between the two halves of the series: Eleven is on the verge of a tantrum in the first half, and is on the verge of "something else" in the second.
- I think it's from The Pandorica Opens.
Amy's Choice is about The Doctor performing an Inception
With the intent of making her choose Rory over him, because The Doctor is tired of all the romantic drama he had to suffer through as Ten. He intentionally drove through the psychic pollen because he didn't have one of those PASIV suitcases on him. The Dream Lord was intentionally created by him (though not controlled) as a way of creating a situation that would make Amy choose Rory and show Amy how untrustworthy The Doctor really is.
- The Twelfth Doctor may be devious and deliberate, but the Eleventh Doctor seems to do things by accident. I think it is more likely that the TARDIS performed an Inception on Amy.
- There is no Twelfth Doctor. Matt's signed on until at least series 7.
Amy and Rory's dream lord counterparts in Amy's Choice are their baby and ponytail respectively
There is not enough darkness in their hearts to give their counterparts sentient form, but they are still there, taunting them about how different their lives would be without The Doctor.
Big Bang II never happened
It may occur in 2012 though, at least fictionally.
Series 5 was designed to isolate Whovian speculators
The Pandorica could be the most powerful Continuity Lock-Out
The Reapers have been erased from time through the cracks
The reapers, if you don't remember, came through time paradoxes and destroyed everything to stop a timey-wimey ball from destroying everything. Since they destroy everything influenced by the paradox, then there's no one to remember them for the Big Bang II. After all, the Doctor does say to Amy that if she remembers her parents, she can have them back. So if there's nobody who remembers the Reapers, there's no one to bring them back.
The TARDIS is behind the cracks in time... only it's not the TARDIS.
Now stick with me: In The Eleventh Hour, the TARDIS crash landed in Amelia Pond's backyard. The Doctor and Amelia talk, open the crack, close it, and the Cloister bell rings. Now, when the cloister bell rings, it is not because its about to fly away, but because it was being attacked. By what, you ask? By the faux-TARDIS from the Lodger, which took its place. To recap The Lodger; Someone was trying to build a TARDIS, but there were two things wrong with it; 1: The TARDIS needed a pilot, and B: ... No, 2: TARDI are GROWN, not built.
Once the TARDIS in The Lodger got a taste of the power it could have working with/for The Doctor, it needed more, and rather than give up The Doctor because of The Power of Love
, it actually went back in time, and replaced the real TARDIS while The Doctor was talking to Amelia.
To prove this point, if you would remember, at the beginning of the episode The Lodger, The Doctor is inexplicably thrown out of the TARDIS by a burst of air, which one would assume was because of the time loops. But, if you believe this theory, you could say that it was actually an action done purposely by the faux-TARDIS to get The Doctor to meet it's past self, so it could go back in time to replace the true TARDIS...
This theory, while far out, explains why both Prisoner Zero in The Eleventh Hour, and Angel Bob in the Weeping Angel two parter both said "The Doctor <in the TARDIS> doesn't know what's going on." Now, as a throwaway line, that doesn't seem like much, but they are actually telling The Doctor, "Helloo! You are IN the problem!"
- Additionally, The Moff has said that the culprit behind the cracks has showed up in The Eleventh Hour, although not obviously. How much more do we need?
- And in the preview for Series 6, there are shots of the TARDIS from The Lodger. (while the way it looks is constant with The Lodger, and not how it looks through the rest of the series, it may be explained.)
- And there is talk that Craig will be returning for Series 6.
- Jossed as of season six. Although, it's now even spookier given how the Silence remained secret. They were in The Eleventh Hour, but you've forgotten you saw them, kinda like the way the angels move.
Amy Pond is a future Doctor who's been under the Chameleon Arch.
For a large part of The Beast Below, Amy's behavior bears a striking resemblance to the way The Doctor acts when he's exploring. Then, in the voting booth, the machine declares that she is 1306 years old. The episode in set in the 29th century, so even if it's 2899, that would still put her birthdate as 1593. At the end, she refers to a creatur that is very kind, very old and the last of its kind being unable to ignore a child crying. She explains that she's seen this from her interaction with the Doctor, but what if it's from personal experience?
- Except that it was only the 29th century when Earth was roasted. It's been implied that Liz X has been reigning for close to 300 years, and she's the one who set up the whole system. Ergo, The Beast Below doesn't take place in the 29th century but the 32nd.
- But that still makes her birthdate to be 1893. Basically, it's either this or that computer can't do a simple calculation.
- We're never told if Liz X actually took command before the solar flares struck Earth. If Amy was born in 1989, then the age given in The Beast Below would place the year as 3295, which is three centuries after the 29th century.
In The Beast Below, we see how the Valeyard could have been 'created'.
When The Doctor is about to turn the Space Whale into a vegetable
, he says "And then I find a new name, because I won't be The Doctor anymore."
. In some alternate reality in which Amy didn't realize that the Space Whale came to stop children from crying
, the Doctor did
do it. He changes his name to The Valeyard, does increasingly nasty things, justifying them the way he did the events in The Beast Below. The Valeyard from the old stories is the 12th regeneration of that
Doctor, but our
Doctor. Because of Amy (and perhaps the cracks-in-reality thing going on), though, that Valeyard never comes to pass. He still exists in the old stories, for no other reason than he's just enough of The Doctor to not muck with history by removing his origins.
We haven't seen the last of Dr. Ramsden.
She won't necesarilly be plot relevent, besides as a side character to Rory, but did anyone else find it strange that Prisoner Zero claimed to have killed her and the nurses, and yet there were no bodies in the ward? No one even commented on it when barracading themselves in there. Add in that Zero has shown a tendancy to avoid unnecessary bloodshed, the Doctor even trying to bargain with it early on, and it really seems the claims to be less then reliable.
The cracks in time will re-write the events of the Time-war
Hence reviving the Time Lords. It's possible. After all, we already know, according to the Doctor, that time is not as linear as all that. It is possible that the cracks could erase certain events that would have led up to the war being time-locked, but have still allowed for the doctor to go on all his current adventures.
- Jossed. The Time Lords are still lost as of "The Doctor's Wife".
The Weeping Angels could always move as stone
Human mothers can be known to do magnificent feats when their children are endangered, such as lift cars, which is not possible in usual life. In psychology, this is called the "fight or flight" response. Well, why is it such a stretch to say that, in a crisis, the angels could still be stone, but move, though significantly slower than their real-body? In "Blink" whenever they moved, we heard the song of wings-not the crunching of stones. Just as they can consciously turn themselves stone, they can consciously move as stone-after all, they still can't be killed. Not blinking won't even save you now.
There was only one original Weeping Angel.
It reproduced by images, which then later themselves reproduced by images, and so on. And since each generation of copies may likely be weaker than those before them, the older copies would be much more powerful, not to mention the original.
The Dreamlord was real
for details. Summary: the Doctor was wrong when he said the Dreamlord wasn't real and so when he prepared to blow the TARDIS up, it actually did explode, causing the cracks in reality and TARDIS shrapnel. Everything that happened since then has been an alternative reality.
- Jossed. The explosion was in Leadworth, 2010, not in orbit around a cold star.
The TARDIS - and Steven Moffat - have grown tired of the sonic screwdriver's inability to bypass a deadlock seal and the Eleventh Doctor's new screwdriver is now able to do so.
The Doctor explicitly states in "The Pandorica Opens" that he can easily open the Pandorica, despite the specific mention of deadlocks. Also, Steven Moffat actually introduced the concept in "The Empty Child" and is presumably sick of the writing team's reliance upon them - particularly the work of Russell T Davies which included the mention of double, triple and maximum deadlocks - presumably stuff the Doctor SERIOUSLY can't open (the Torchwood SUV is triple deadlocked, even!) Therefore, to force the storylines to be more complex, Moffat has ended his own era and and the new screwdriver has been upgraded to deal with those bothersome deadlocks.
As of the New Series, The Doctor is now calculating his age using Earth Years. In the original series, he was calculating his age using Gallifreyan Years
One year is the amount of time it takes a planet to orbit its Sun Once. So a year on one planet is highly unlikely to be exactly the same length as a year on another planet.
Given that, there's a fair possibility that once Gallifrey was no more, The Doctor - who has always been more at home on Earth anyway - began using the Earth calendar to keep measurement of his age. So presuming that Gallifrey has shorter years than Earth, he could easily have been 953 years old in Gallifreyan Years during "Time and The Rani" and then later have been just over 907 years old in Earth Years in "Flesh and Stone".
- Alternatively, maybe he used Earth years to start with (he was rebelling against Gallifrey and it's laws for a fair bit during the Classic series, wasn't he?) and because Gallifrey got destroyed, he decided to remember his planet through little things- like using the Gallifreyan calendar. This would work if Gallifreyan years were longer than Earth years.
- On a related note, how exactly is a year calculated on a planet with two suns?
- Depends on the type of Binary System - Most have a primary that has a secondary orbiting it like a planet, thus if the planet is orbiting the primary, then it is following the orbit of the primary. If it is orbiting the secondary, it still would follow the orbit of the primary, as well. Now, if the primary and secondary are orbiting in the center, and the planets are orbiting around both, it is probably a work of astronomy to determine the exact time one full rotation would be, as these masses would not make for stable orbits...
The Doctor was doing an alien tribal dance at Amy and Rory's wedding.
Specifically, the Barcelonian Sacred Dance of Joy, traditionally performed at weddings by the family of the bride to bring good luck to the newlyweds.
- So does this mean the Doctor considers Amy to be family?
- Well, he is her imaginary friend...
- and her son-in-law.
River meets the Doctor when...
He's imprisoned somewhere and she frees him. In Pandorica she is alone and mutters that she doesn't know why she let him out.
Rory used to dress up as the Doctor for Amy.
When Rory meets the Doctor he recognised him much faster than the other two people who do and his response in a very awkward and slightly frightened "he was a story, he was a...gaaame." Amy a few episodes later tries to shove her tongue down the Doctor's throat and seduce him. Amy bosses Rory around a lot and in A Christmas Charol we learn that Amy and Rory seem to have a thing for dressing up. So, what kind of "game" was the Doctor for Rory?
- This isn't WMG at all, Rory flat out said in the "11th Hour" that "you made me dress up as him". It seemed, based on context, that this was part of Amy's childhood game, however one has to wonder if the "game" didn't grow up along with Amy and Rory. That might explain Rory's awkwardness with the Doctor in the beginning, which always seemed to go a bit beyond simple jealousy.
The Eleventh Doctor's going to cut off and retain all his limbs in his first full episode.
It'll be soon enough after his regeneration to regrow them and so he'll have enough bio-matching receptacles to doge another four regenerations. Considering Ten's last thoughts were about not going, this probably carried over and is at the forefront of Eleven's mind.
River Song has a BDSM Dalek fetish
The Dalek from the museum knew it, and rather than shoot her and indulge it, let itself be killed.
The "Dalek Rangers" are actually from the Peter Cushing Movie universe.
It would explain why the progenitor didn't recognize the other Daleks, and the Dalek timeline is already messed up enough as it is.
The Daleks from ""Victory of the Daleks" were from "The Parting of The Ways"
This is why the Progenitor did not recognise them- they were grown from humans. When Rose destroyed the Dalek fleet
, the immense power involved tore open the Time Vortex for a moment, allowing a heavily damaged ship to fall through.
The ENTIRETY of Series Five is a gentle Take That
to Russell T Davies' tenure as Executive Producer
Not insultingly so, mind you, since it's important to remember that Steven Moffat does respect the guy, but still
- The Doctor's known Amy since she was little, which actually gives her an understandable reason to feel a connection to the Doctor beyond "Hot Guy With The Ultimate Sports Car." Additionally, everyone who doesn't realize the Doctor actually exists treats this attitude as an obsession bordering on genuine insanity, a reaction strikingly absent from Rose's unsettlingly arrogant clinginess.
- Probably not, given that Moffat seems to like Rose a lot, some "clingy" jokes aside.
- The "Cracks in Time" Myth Arc has the rather convenient side effect of completely erasing the fannish silliness that was The Stolen Earth/Journey's End and the historically incompatible ending to The Next Doctor.
- Not only are the old-style Daleks killed off — violently — the new ones promptly run away and are only seen sparingly afterward, in contrast to Davies' overuse of them.
- That's...not what happened. At best, that's a white lie. "Running away" sounds like a loss.
- Shipping is punted out the window and then shot at, with lasers. The Doctor reacts with abject horror to Amy's come-ons (which, on her part, are pretty poorly thought out), doesn't appreciate Amy's fangirlish insistence that he and River will eventually get married, and generally takes any chance he can get to tactfully imply that this incarnation doesn't find Interspecies Romance appealing in the slightest. He does enjoy flirting with The TARDIS, though.
- It was more blatant in series 6, but River was hardly subtle in her implications either. Not to mention, when Amy asked River if it was the Doctor, she responded ambiguously, but hinted towards the postiive.
- Then there's A Christmas Carol, in which, as though waking up in the middle of a terrible fanfiction, the Doctor finds himself suddenly and inexplicably paired up with Marilyn Monroe. He does his best to escape the situation as quickly as possible.
- And then he apparently marries her out of spite when his companions weren't paying enough attention.
- What has that got to do with Russell? Even tangentially? Or the production series 5? It's not even the A-plot either.
- The finale, which first parodies Davies' writing style by having the Doctor fight everyone, ever, then deconstructs it by summarily forgetting about them and centering the actual antagonistic tension around exactly one Dalek and confining everything to a couple rooms in one building, while a Negative Space Wedgie makes even the setting increasingly minimalist. The lesson being, "Epic" doesn't have to mean "Big".
- PARODY? WTF? It's clearly playing the "gather all enemies against the Doctor" completely straight. The only thing it really deconstructs is how the Doctor isn't especially a hero to everyone.
The good man that River kills.
Isn't the Doctor. It's Rory. Firstly because the Doctor is plainly going to survive. And secondly because it's just so obvious that it can't possibly be the Doctor. It's like reverse psychology or whatever. Make it seem like she's talking about the Doctor when it's actually not.
Fair warning, I haven't seen "A Good Man Goes To War" yet because I live in the US, so Idunno if this is late to the game but...yeah.
- Jossed. Technically, no-one is killed, but what she's accused of murdering is the Doctor.
the silence are suicidal zealots.
their first attempt to commit suicidal genocide on a cosmic scale was to blow up the tardis, making every star everywhere everywhen to blow up,making sure that the universe would never house any lifeform.
but the doctor twarthed their plan of cosmic annihilation and restored the universe in a second big bang.
the silence didn't give up for much, and trigerred a second plan, more subtle which consists on making the the doctor's death a fixed point in time ,and making sure that himself and his companions will try and suucced into averting his death, creating a total collapse of reality and destroying the entire universe eventually.
However,the doctor survived again and their plan was foiled ultimately,but the silence is still lurking in the shadows waiting for the next oppurtunity to blowup everything into oblivion.
the cracks in time were portals to the tardis heart.
we know that the tardis heart is able of desintegrating anything or anyone unfortunate enough to fall in it.
so,the tardis explosion made that every rift connected somehow to the time vortex would open directly inside of the tardis heart,erasing everything in its proximity from history due to the artron energy overload.
the silence are dangerously genre sawwy enemies who fakes stupidity to dupe the doctor.
let's see in the series 5,they wanted apparently to annihilate the whole universe,
sure it's a mighty goal and everything, but it doesn't lead to anything, and they didn't seem like the daleks (willing to destroy everything because you see it as inferior to yourself)
so what's the gain?
in fact, they knew the doctor has some kind of cosmic karma armor thet protects him from harm and enable him to win most often than not also he will be involoved personally with their fall.so, what they do? turning thet advantage on him of course!
they gambled with blowing up the universe and themeselves with it because they knew from the start that the doctor will find a way to save the day and they even manipulated the doctor enemies from behind the scenes to enact a specific scenario in which the doctor will be able to save the day but with one condition: erasing himself from history, so that the rebooted universe will be without a doctor to counter them and stop them eventually.
but the doctor was restored thanks to amy.the silence went to their next plan:making the death of the doctor a fixed point in time by locking in an overly complicated stable time loop with river in its center.the doctor survived at the end by tricking out time and closed the loop.
but you'll say to do all that they need to know a lot about the doctor?the answer:they do,because they were with him in the tardis even before the first episode of the show!!
they kew from his visits on earth that he was a poweful being with nigh-godlike technology, but with an influencable mind like humans and surely many other races in the universe, so they assigned spies to follow him everywhere and to explore the tardis and even give some post-hypnotic suggestions to the doctor and his compaignons in order to manipulate them.
they found at first that he was useful for their plans and let him do all the hard work for them (fighting the daleks,locking the time war,...), but the more he approched the fatidic day the more he becomes menacing for the silence,until it ends with ten and his time lord victorious thing.with him becoming more difficult to influence and whithout eventually any universe menacenig big bad in view besides them,they thought that the doctor has outlived its uselefulness and decided to get rid of him.
also a last note,the silence never stated explicitly that they were limited to earth and to human history.nothing says that they couldn't already be in effective control everywhere in the universe from the begining of time orchestring all the races of the cosmos in a great unknown plan that would encompass the entitre universe, and that the doctor himself would be merely a pawn working for the silence,
and his "whacking kick in the backside of the silence" being merely a tactical loss of negligble effect for them in the great scheme of things ,making them the biggest and scariest magnificent bastards in any tv show ever.
P.S:they needed all the incarnations of the doctor prior to eleven,which makes it obvious that the universe will reboot with having a doctor but only up to ten,in this new universe the doctor failed to regenerate and died in a fiery explosion and the tardis burned in the reentry due to shield failure.the eleven of this reality summoned by amy's mind is a copy of the doctor from the previous universe with all his memories from his birth to "the big bang 2" being intact.
the silence scheme to kill the doctor is a stable time loop.
the very reason the silence wanted to kill the doctor is to prevent him from kickstarting the chain of events that led him to turn the human race against them,but it was their assination attempt that triggered the chain of events leading to their defeat later.the silence shot their own foots.
Amy is now a Weeping Angel-hybrid
In Let's Kill Hitler, the voice interface that the Doctor asked to look like Amelia mentions fish fingers and custard. It is not explained how the Tardis or the voice interface knows about this, nor is it implied that the Doctor merely hallucinated it (he seems perfectly fine after that). The image of an Angel becomes, itself, an Angel. When she had the Angel in her eye in Flesh & Stone, it actually converted her, at least in that respect. Or, when all of the Angels were sucked into the crack in time, one of them managed to escape and influence Amelia as a little girl, thus explaining why the image of Amelia becomes her.
The old lady in 'The Eleventh Hour' is Amy, locked in the past by a Weeping Angel.
Moffat has said that a scene in Eleven's first episode reveals the fate of Amy Pond. (I'm paraphrasing.) In a blink-and-you'll-miss-it scene, the old woman that lives with Jeff immediately recognizes the Doctor and calls him the Raggedy Man. Eleven has never seen her before in his life. Despite the fact that the Doctor's future was eaten (along with Martha's) and he was sent to the 1960s, and he was still able to use the TARDIS, there will be some timey-wimey reason that Amy will be locked in the past, and unable to return home. She moves to Leadworth, and once again becomes the girl who waits.
- This troper just had a Funny Aneurysm. Well played.
- Wait, that can't be right. Jeff's grandma says she knows the Raggedy Doctor from Amy's childhood drawings; there's no indication that she knows him from anywhere else.
- River has already told Amy that she often had to lie (pretend not to recognize Amy, pretend to be sad at the Doctor's death, etc.). Amy could have been doing the same thing. Also, River and the Old Woman (Mrs. Angelo - Angelo was also the name of a cleric in The Time of Angels, the first time Amy meets River) in 11th Hour seem to own the same brooch.
The foods that eleven tried after regenerating weren't random.
- He first tried apples, because ten liked them. But that wasn't right. Then he tried yoghurt and bacon, and after that, beans, before setteling on custard and fish fingers. Consider this: both yoghurt and custard are diary products, and both bacon and fish fingers are meat (or, at least, dead animal) fried in butter or oil. (I don't know what amy used.) I don't know if this is important, but it is interesting that eleven knew in wich direction he had to search. I can't explain the beans in tomato sauce, though.
[[Mother3 The Absolutely Safe Capsule
is the basis for the Pandorica.]]
Think about it-the Pandorica is a nigh-perfect prison, capable of protecting everything inside it-even when the universe gets erased around it.
The Absolutely Safe Capsule proved to be so successful at its job that it and Pokey survived the heat death of the Earthbound universe, causing it to float into the Void. After uncountable aeons
of floating from universe to universe and living through their entire histories like nothing, it ended up in the Whoniverse. The Alliance analysed the design, and planned to use it on the Doctor. The reason the Doctor was even able to get out is because they weren't able to fully scan it, since that would require doing the impossible and opening it.
The Dream Lord's appearance was inspired by Kotris
Vincent Van Gogh did not commit suicide.
As we saw, Vincent could see things which other people can't. This could extend to being able to ignore perception filters. Thus he might have stumbled onto something no one else could. Perhaps he caught sight of a Silence and didn't forget that it existed when he turned away. Perhaps he discovered some supernatural or alien plot and tried to stop it. Whatever Vincent found, he was killed fighting them and the perpetrator(s) made it look like suicide.
The Dream Lord will return
...but not quite the same as he first appeared in Amy's Choice.
The self-titled "Dream Lord" is nothing more than the Doctor's darker side. Meaning he's still around. So if another psychic dream-state is initiated (possibly in the same way, if under different circumstances), the Dream Lord will come back to wreak havoc.
I now postulate that because the Dream Lord is essentially the Doctor, then the Dream Lord is also capable of regeneration like the Doctor is. Unlike the Doctor, who regenerates in order to escape death, the Dream Lord isn't so fragile. But it only makes sense that if the Doctor regenerates, then the Dream Lord regenerates with him.
Alternatively, he's been defeated once so far, in his first appearance. It's likely that each "defeat" results in the Dream Lord's "death" and regeneration. Also, notice that the Dream Lord is middle-aged or older, not too unlike the first Doctor when we first saw him. So the Dream Lord will regenerate, and he will show up a la The Nth Doctor
, and he will most likely be younger. (Although, since he's the Doctor's opposite, it's not unreasonable if he ends up older.)
Bottom line, it may or may not be in the upcoming season, or it may be later on. But mark these words: the Dream Lord will return, some day, and he will have regenerated. He's not done holding up the mirror to the Doctor just yet.
The Dreamlord is not the Valeyard
Because the Doctor has previously met and had a confrontation with the Valeyard. The Doctor will actively prevent the creation of the Valeyard, so his dark evil side takes on a different form; the Dreamlord.
The TARDIS exploding wasn't intended to end everything.
From what we've seen of the Silence, they don't seem like omnicidal maniacs.
Yet they're responsible for the cracks. Why did they do this? All part of their Evil Plan
. They knew the Doctor would save reality,
because they were behind it and the Pandorica. The fact that Amy Pond was capable of remembering the Doctor back into existence was an extension of their ultimate plan-to learn and perfect rewriting reality. To become a more powerful force, even gods.
Their sudden prescene could be an example of this-before Series Six, they could've been a primitive race. Now,they're manipulating humanity. And in a few more attempts...
- Alternatively, going on a theory that they're actually good guys,it was a plan to get the Doc more regenerations, as they believed that being basically recreated out of Amy's memories would set him back as the first, while still preserving his previous incarnations due to the Doctor himself remembering them. And whoever posted above that this had reset his regenerations was a Silent attempting to gain redemption in the eyes of the fans.
- If the Silence are good guys, they may have altered history so they can be Earth's protection. That way, even in the event of the Doctor's death, the universe will be safe. Or they're one of many individuals who think the Doctor is a threat to the universe. Their plan would mean the universe wouldn't stay destroyed, and be reset in the end. However the Doctor would be Deader than Dead, aka Ret Gone. Everything he's doen to save reality, however, would remain. So the universe remains safe.
- Seems partly confirmed: their ends are good, but their means are extreme and backfire horribly.
An incarnation of the Doctor, made up of all the evil that is within him, right between his eleventh and twelth regenerations? Sounds like an almost textbook definition of the Valeyard to me. Especially with The Stinger
in the end of the episode that shows the Dream Lord is not quite gone...
At some point in the future, dissident members of the subject races of the Human Empire, including the Ood and the Hath, will join together and travel back in time to 20th century Earth to avert the empire's creation. And the Doctor will stop them.
That's why that playback of invaders the Doctor saved the Earth from includes those two. Corollary: If the Doctor hadn't interrupted the playback by stepping through it, it would've shown Twelve and Thirteen.
- Wasn't it a hologram? Which is basically a screen projector without the screen, a physical being couldn't disrupt it through touch.
The Dream-Lord is the Valeyard.
- Not so much a wild-mass guess, as a logical assumption based on the information provided. Both are described as manifestations of the Doctor's dark side- the psychic coral merely acted as a conduit for the Valeyard to manifest himself prematurely from the stated point where the Doctor is meant to regenerate into him (between the 12th and 13th Doctor's- whom the 11th Doctor isn't that far off from). Notice how in The Ultimate Foe, the Valeyard manifests as a dark-haired and darkly-clothed man in contrast to the blonde, garishly dressed 6th Doctor, whereas in Amy's Choice he takes the form of a short, plump and plain man, in contrast to the 11th Doctor's tall, dark and handsome appearance, which he makes numerous mocking references to in the episode, amid his standard taunts.
- I think it's more that the Dream-Lord is a manifestation of what becomes the Valeyard: not so much good-versus-evil, as a gradual degradation. Taking into account the events of "The Waters of Mars" — or even going back to "School Reunion" — it seems to me this has been a long time coming.
The Doctor doesn't actually hate the foods made by Amy in The Eleventh Hour
It's simply that they were prepared by a little kid, who likely was a bad cook to begin with.