The Government is actually GulchersDirective 10-289 makes NO sense. Criminalizing hiring during a recession is insane, no matter your ideology. The Government is in on the conspiracy and is trying to hasten the demise of the state.
- Fred Kinnan, at the very least, certainly gives the impression of being "better" than the role he's playing in the Government. On a regular basis, he gets a BIG kick out of calling the other villains out on their hypocrisy, contradictions, and self-righteousness. Perhaps he's a Magnificent Bastard secretly in the employ of Galt, subtly nudging the "looters" to hasten society's destruction?
John Galt is a Time Lord....someone had to say it.
- No, they didn't.
- What is his TARDIS?
- His SPEECH...the very long one
- if it was bigger on the inside then I pity whoever had to sit and listen to it
- His SPEECH...the very long one
John Galt is Fontaine.
- No, he's Ryan.
John Galt is a Who."Who is John Galt" was a statement, not a question.
- John Galt was a pseudonym for the guy who was on first.
- As a statement, it seems more like an identification of who Who is. Don't make me spell it out.
John Galt is not John Galt's real name.Think of it. The question "Who is John Galt?" appears to be some kind of meme. Maybe the person we get to know as John Galt did "jump to the myth": He adopted the name after the meme was spread. He is not the only one who calls himself John Galt. There are others out there that have adopted that name (though this could even be the case if the John Galt we get to know is the original). It might be some kind of copycat phenomenon.
- Galt has some independent verification — although he might have planted that hobo, or the hobo's story. There are copycats, though, such as the John Galt Line. Notably, they all betray his ideology, albeit by varying degrees.
- Best WMG ever!
- Not really. Rorschach was a fascist. V been a leftist-anarchist would probably have been very collectivist. And Zarathustra, being a good Nietzschean, would consider absurd the objectivist ideas of an objective morality (he would see them as slaves).
John Galt's magical engine doesn't run on ambient static electricity.Galt combined a normal engine with his magical mind reading lock, and created an engine that's powered by ego. Hence, the people of the Gulch are now guaranteed all the energy they could want.
- Related to the above WMG, Spiral Energy
The story was a Shoot The Shaggy Dog StoryGalts Gulch is a blatant Egopolis only held together through the combined egos of the people there when they die everthing they achieved will fall apart. The Paragon and at worst, is the Dark Messiah and knows it. He believes the world's beyond his power to save and that attempting to do so would just be throwing his life away in the pursuit of an impossibility. So instead he chooses to save what small part of it matters to him most and try to give what remains the best chance they can of picking themselves back up from the ashes.
Dagny Taggart is Amy Pond.Because for twelve years she's been asking: Who is John Galt?
John Galt had the Ferris Persuader sabotagedHe manged to get cigarettes from Atlantis while in custody so he had an someone on the inside. Working from within he had the torture machine sabotaged and that is why he knew exactly what was wrong with it when it malfunctioned.
John Galt is an agent of ChaosThink about it – the world is spiralling downward, society and the economy is killing it self from with in, rotten thru and thru as the oak of Eddie Willers childhood and what is it that Galt do: He convicts the people that could turn this development and prevent society to implode on it self and humanity becoming nothing but neo-tribal tech-barbarians, to abound society and the rest of the world. Galt is not trying to create a heaven for the best and the brightest or not even to save them from a failing society that don’t care about them; he is trying to gather them to prevent them from saving the modern society. Also most of the people in Galt’s Gulch are highly individualistic and Galt not only convict them to follow him and his philosophy but also to abound all their fortunes and place in society. How dose he do that? With help of unnatural charisma gifted by Chaos! The real question is not Who is John Galt, it is What is John Galt, under that all to perfect human appearance…
John Galt is The DevilThe Faceless man that everybody wants to know, who appears covered in a Conspicuous Trenchcoat? Meets with CorruptCorporateExecutives, and talks them into joining his agenda by appealing to their greed and self-righteousness? Results in the Crapsack World quickly going From Bad to Worse? The one thing that doesn't make him a dead-giveaway is his good sense NOT to have a name that sounds like Devil/Satan/Lucifer. (This is mostly borrowing from his brief portrayals in The Movie Atlas Shrugged, for the record.)
- It is tantalizing to see it this way, because that would mean that Atlas Shrugged (and Rand's entire philosophy) is one giant Stealth Parody. Rand would essentially be mocking self-worshiping jerks by stroking their massive egos, stringing them along to look like fools in their blind devotion to her ideas. Given that she was a member of the controversial writer's guild and eventually signed up for welfare, one could stretch that she was deliberately setting herself up as a strawman, risking her reputation to depict the concept of rational self-interest as hypocritical and repugnant. It would be a historical Batman Gambit that gives Niccolò Machiavelli's satire theory a run for its money.
Rand did not intend all the superscience technologies in the book to be interpreted as potential future developments, but as physical examples of the abstract capabilities and traits of the human mind.
- The shale-oil drilling process is an example of human ingenuity, which can turn worthless raw materials into sources of great prosperity. The Colorado oil shale hills were believed to be worthless, until Ellis Wyatt developed a process which allowed him to profitably extract huge quantites of fuel oil from them. Without Wyatt's process, the land is worthless: "I'm leaving it as I found it. Take over. It's yours."
- Rearden Metal is an example of human determination, as Hank Rearden did not have a revelation as to its design, but developed it over the course of his adult life. When the Looters force him to give it up, they rename it "Miracle Metal", as they are too small-minded to understand the amount of effort that Rearden put into its development.
- Galt's Motor is an example of human creativity, which has no real limits. Galt created the motor through his own efforts, without support from anyone, and it is fully capable of providing limitless power to the entire world-it is literally the motor of the world. It could have prevented the societal collapse which ocurrs at the novel's climax, yet it has been stopped and left to rust in an abandoned factory. The factory was once the most prosperous in the country, but was inherited by incompetent minds which instituted policies which led to its collapse.
- The Gulch mirage is an example to how intellect may be overlooked by the masses, yet discovered by the determined, as society at large is unaware of Galt's Gulch, yet Dagny penetrates it due to her determination to find Quentin Daniels.
- Project X is an example of how human intellect may be turned to destructive purposes through coercion, and how those intellects are ultimately destroyed by their creations. Stadler, although an incredible mind, believes that the only way he can prosper is by forcing others to support him. Ultimately, he dies along with his creation when Cuffy Meigs clumsily attempts to claim it for himself.
- The voice activated door locks are the ultimate example of Rand's philosophy. When Dagny speaks the words of the Strikers' oath, that she will no longer sacrifice herself to others, nor allow others to sacrifice themselves for her, she is permitted to enter the core of the Strikers' society, a power plant where all of the valley's energy is generated, with enough to spare to power the entire world.
- Palm-activated door locks are an example of the sanctity of the human mind-to attempt to force it open and claim its contents against the owner's will will only result in the destruction of all that it holds. Galt's New York laboratory has one of these locks-only his hand can open it. When the police arrive and force the door, all of his work is destroyed without a trace.
- The torture machine is an example of Rand's concept of the Sanction of the Victim. In the novel's climax, the Looters take John Galt to a secret location and attempt to force him to save them and their failing society. The machine breaks, and none of the Looters know how to fix it. Galt then calmly and eloquently instructs him on how it may be repaired. The Looters are literally unable to even harm Galt without Galt's intellect to make their machine work.
John Galt is V. from V for Vendetta.
- What's especially interesting about this theory is how much Alan Moore seemed to be mining Atlas Shrugged for material, regarding the character of V...all the way down to V taking control of the airwaves to proclaim his manifesto to the people of Britain and call for revolution against the tyrannical government. (Not bad for a man who tries to give the impression of hating everything Rand stood for....)
Atlas Shrugged is the mirror universe version of Captain PlanetThink about it. The characters are all archetypes and symbols rather than real people, with the protagonists being invincible due to representing the philosophy the work exists to advocate, and the villains are cartoonish moustache-twirlers doing things For the Evulz rather than for the reasons or with anything but exaggerated versions of the methods their real counterparts do, preventing any sympathy or two-way dialogue from occurring. The two works' political associates are even typically found on opposite sides of the American political spectrum. Übermensch/charismatic proto-Kamina of the book, invents an engine that provides limitless energy. The "atmospheric static electricity" was a coverup for the real mechanism: the engine is actually powered by the Spiral Energy carried by Galt's ego, and later, by the rest of the heroes living in the Gulch. This engine becomes the prototype for the invention of the Lagann units. The Collectivist Government are in league with the Anti-Spirals. They both try to repress humanity's latent evolution, exceptionalism and awesomeness. After the old collectivist society collapses, Galt's Gulch survives, takes over the world through Spiral technology, and rebuilds civilization according to Spiral Objectivist virtues, acquiring the attention of the Anti-Spirals. For added hilarity and insanity, John Galt is Simon's ancestor.
Atlas Shrugged takes place in the same universe as Nineteen Eighty Four and Oceania is really just another People's StateTrue, in Nineteen Eighty Four, we're told that the whole world has been taken over by Ingsoc and related philosophies. But who told us that? The Party and Goldstein's Book, which was written by the Party. The Party, however, is a completely unreliable source of information that routinely lies about everything, including the world outside of Oceania. It's entirely possible that Oceania, which they claim spans a third of the world, is really just confined to Great Britain. This is backed up in Atlas Shrugged in Fred Kinnan's speech about the People's States of Europe.
"Do you hear them raising their voices about the chain gangs, the slave camps, the fourteen-hour workday and the mortality from scurvy in the People's States of Europe? No, but you do hear them telling the whip-beaten wretches that starvation is prosperity, that slavery is freedom, that torture chambers are brother-love and that if the wretches don't understand it, then it's their own fault the suffer."Sounds an awful lot like the Party.