Useful Notes / Hole in Flag

http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/350px_RomanianFlag_withHole.jpg

"Dear comrades and friends, citizens of the capital of Socialist Romania! First, I wish to extend to you, participants of this great popular meeting, and all residents of the Bucharest municipality, warm revolutionary greetings, and wish you success in all your endeavors. I wish also to thank the instigators and organizers of this great popular demonstration in Bucharest, and I consider it an...what? Wait, no! What? Comrades! Comrades, stay quiet! Comrades?..."
Nicolae Ceaușescu's final speech

The "Hole In Flag" revolutions - or the "Revolutions of 1989" or the "Autumn of Nations", or simply "the Fall of Communism" - were a wave of revolutions that swept Europe in 1989-91 and signaled the end of the Cold War. The Trope Maker is arguably Hungary, cutting the communist emblem out of the centre of their flags during the 1956 revolution.

For a fuller discussion of what led to the sudden and completely unexpected fall of Soviet Communism, you are directed to the page on the History of the Cold War.

Suffice to say, President Mikhail Gorbachev attempted to reform the USSR, promising Glasnost (openness) and Perestroika (reconstruction), but was unprepared for the tide of emotion he unleashed in the Soviets' satellite states and the USSR itself. Poles, Czechoslovakians, Hungarians and many more all thought that Gorbachev would tell their own repressive leaders to extend the same policies. "Gorby save us" was the common cry.

One by one, beginning in Poland, the Communist governments were presented with peaceful demonstrations of their citizens on an unprecedented scale and for once decided to grant their demands instead of crushing them with tanks. Elections were held (except in Romania, where there was a coup instead) and the Communists were kicked out of power (except in Bulgaria, where they were democratically re-elected as the Bulgarian Socialist Party; and in Romania, where the National Salvation Front, the second-tier Communists who had led the coup against Ceaușescu, won hastily-organized elections. Both parties lost power in 1996, and peacefully stepped down).

In November 1989, the most visible and memorable event marking the end of communism occurred in Germany. After Hungary opened its borders with Austria, allowing East German tourists a quick means to leave for the West, Erich Honecker attempted to clamp down on the new exodus. However, rising protests eventually forced him to resign. In November, the Politburo of East Germany decided to calm things down by opening the border with West Germany. At a press conference on November 9, Günter Schabowski was given a note indicating that the border was to be opened, but no further instructions on how to handle the information (the opening was to occur the following day, giving the Border Guards time to prepare). He was pressed for an answer when asked when the border was to be opened, and assuming the wording meant the same day, he declared that the Berlin Wall was open effective immediately. With nearly the entire country hearing the announcement live, millions of Germans flooded to both sides of the Wall, demanding to be let through. With no one willing to authorize deadly force, the Border Guards allowed them to pass through. Thousands of families were reunited for the first time in decades amidst vast parties across the country. Germany commenced a massive recycling project, ripping down the Berlin Wall (the most published photos being of Germans with sledgehammers) and the entire Inner German Border. Within a year, after the borders became meaningless, East Germany was added into the Federal Republic of Germany, bringing an end to the last visible reminder of World War II.

The USSR held on for two more years before finally imploding in 1991 as its constituent republics (including Russia itself) all declared independence, leaving Gorbachev president of exactly squat. Yugoslavia also held on until 1991, when social and ethnic tensions exploded into The Yugoslav Wars - any pretense of Communism was quickly forgotten and aggressive nationalism became the order of the day.

One feature of the demonstrations that became a potent symbol of the revolutions of 1989 was the flag with a ragged hole where the communist emblem had been. In Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Albania and East Germany, pre-war national flags had been adorned with red stars or the communist state coat of arms, and these were torn or cut from the flags by demonstrators. The page image is the Romanian flag (not to be confused with the Chadian flag . . . . or a defaced Andorran flag).

All this dramatically changed the situation in the West. No longer living in a world where the main bad guy wore red, held big parades, and lived in Moscow (or at least frequently visited it), thriller-writers — who had lived their whole professional lives in a world with an identifiable Big Bad — had to find a way to adapt; so did armies and spy agencies; but ordinary people were able to breathe easier, no longer living under quite so urgent a threat of nuclear annihilation, and the United States inherited sole-superpower status, enjoying a quiet decade in The '90s.

As for the people of the ex-Communist states?

Poland, Czechoslovakia (now the Czech Republic and Slovakia, the Czechs having thrown out the Slovaks), Hungary, Bulgaria, Romania, and Albania have benefited enormously from the collapse of Communism, now enjoying securer economies and (more often than not) social liberalization despite the occasional Why We Are Bummed Communism Fell moment. Right now, the question for these countries is whether or not to continue being in the EU, which Eurosceptics find too liberal and infringing for their tastes.

East Germany, although a pretty good place to live in many regions, is still the least developed part of Germany and suffers from very strange politics. The Communist government's official policy was that all East Germans had been patriotic resisters during the Second World War and no one was to say anything more than that. This put the problems of the 1930s and 1940s on ice with Nazis being punished and nothing more, rather than systematically getting rid of them to ensure a cultural shift like in the west (although the west infamously hired many ex Nazis as a pardon, so YMMV is that was more effective), and today East Germany has a disconcertingly large number of both neo-Communists and neo-Nazis. Many of these Neo Nazis are the younger generation born after Communism whose community couldn't deal with liberalization and blamed the far left regime before for their problems, while Neo Communists see the DDR is a preferable alternative to the EU.

Yugoslavia, as mentioned above, disintegrated into civil war; Communist dictatorship had been the only thing that kept the various peoples of the region from killing each other. Oddly enough, the Serbs — who were more or less the rulers of peaceful, ethnic-cleansing-free Communist Yugoslavia — were the most eager ethnic cleansers in the post-Yugoslav situation.

Russia has languished from 1991 to the present — or perhaps it would be truer to say 1987 to the present. Between fifty years of Communism and ten years of war in Afghanistan, the country had fallen into the doldrums in the late 1980s, and has yet to find its way out. The end of Communist rule meant the return of religious worship, free speech, and free assembly, but it also brought corruption, organized crime, anarchy, and a series of wars with Chechnya, which first secured its freedom from Russia and then started trying to see how many Russians it could kidnap, kill, or rob. Putin gained his reputation by defeating the Chechens, and fear of a new round of Chechen-style chaos is one of the things that helps him stay in power.

The other ex-Soviet republics are all in awkward situations.

Belarus is a dictatorship under heavy Russian influence; the Central Asian states are dictatorships but without Russian influence, and the absence of Russian influence there is not necessarily a good thing. (Russian influence might have kept the dictator of Turkmenistan from building a gilded statue of himself that turns to face the sun, for example.)

Georgia, in the central Caucasus, has been dealing with serious political issues from 1991 to the present. South Ossetia tried to secede in 1991, Abkhazia in 1992; in both cases, the Georgians fought to keep them in the country, while the locals were backed by their cultural kin over the border in Russia (and, in Abkhazia at least, by the Russians themselves to an extent). Russo-Georgian relations have wavered between hot and cold ever since, with the low point being the Russo-Georgian War in 2008. (Georgia discovered that the Russians were staging non-peacekeeping troops in South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and attacked them on August 7th; the Russians, most of whose troops had already been moved into these provinces, held firm and counter-attacked on August 8th. If the Russian goal was to scare Georgia out of NATO, or get the Georgians to allow South Ossetia and Abkhazia to secede, it backfired badly...)

Armenia and Azerbaijan immediately started fighting each other over the ethnic Armenian region in Azerbaijan known as Nagorno Karabakh. The conflict ended with Armenian control of the region with a Russian backed cease fire. Border clashes still continue to this day. Both countries are currently doing okay domestically, but there is sharp corruption and economic issues in each nation. Armenia is mostly relying on its Iranian neighbor for a clear border with trade as it can't get exports from its Russian allies directly while Azerbaijan relies on its cultural "big brother" Turkey.

Armenia, Russia, Kazkahstan and Belarus (which ironically have high concentrations of Neo Soviets, unpleased with the results of post communist life) are currently within the Eurasian Economic Union, the closest thing to a neo USSR at the moment, but it's a very loose binding. Azerbaijan is definitely "Turkey aligned" and the other Central Asian nations are doing their own thing, so that leaves us too..

Ukraine and Moldova both have breakaway Russian territories in their east. Moldavia being well to the west of Russia, it's unlikely to face any land wars soon; but Putin annexed the Crimea from Ukraine in 2014 (in fairness, the Crimea had been conquered from the Ottoman Empire by Russians, not Ukrainians, and had been transferred from the Russian SSR to the Ukrainian one in 1955), and shortly afterwards the majority-ethnic-Russian Donbass — the easternmost part of Ukraine, just west of the Don — rose up against the Ukrainian government, in a spontaneous insurgency that just happened to have access to cutting-edge Russian tanks, artillery, and anti-aircraft systems, and to be led by a Russian general and manned in part by vacationing Russian soldiers. At present, this war may grind to a halt soon: neither Russia nor Ukraine can afford to continue the fight, and Russian attention is focused — with good reason — on Syria.

The Georgian, Ukrainian, and Moldovan economies are not very good. At least Georgia and Ukraine were initially ruled by cronyist dictators, then had those governments replaced by overly raw free-market economies (protectionism is historically necessary to let local industries develop); both are also primarily agricultural. But at least it was Soviet policy to build factories in the outlying, under-developed parts of the country — which is how Georgia's main exports are red wine, cheese, and SU-27s.

Georgia and Ukraine have also both seen "Color Revolutions" — Westernizing democratic revolutions, underwritten in part by George Soros, improving human rights but probably not improving the economy. The Russian wars against them after these revolutions were probably to keep them out of NATO: Russia's main asset in a conventional land war is strategic depth, and if Ukraine was in NATO, the US or German army would start the war just sixty miles from Stalingrad; if Georgia was in NATO, the Luftwaffe could take off less than an hour's flight from the Baku oil fields.

The Baltic states — Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia — were admitted to NATO in the 1990s, when everyone saw NATO as more like a country club than a military alliance. Now, they're in an awkward position for everyone: no Western army could defend them in case of a Russian attack, but Russia couldn't defend itself in case of a NATO attack out of the Baltics (especially Estonia) either, and neutrality doesn't seem to be in the cards. And Latvia has a large ethnic-Russian population who are mostly not citizens, and who the government really doesn't treat particularly well...

Suffice it to say that the effects of the Fall of Communism — especially on Russia and the other ex-Soviet states — have not yet been fully felt.

Alternative Title(s): Hole In Flag

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/UsefulNotes/HoleInFlag?from=Main.HoleInFlag