- When Phoenix starts singing "Old Souls" Winslow is so moved by how well she sings his music that he starts crying. It is the only time in the entire movie something really goes right for him and immediately afterwards it starts going horribly wrong for him again.
- Winslow watching Phoenix and Swan from the rooftop, in the rain. He can't even die to escape the sadness and horror.
You gave up your right to rest in peace when you signed this contract.
- Winslow not wanting to have his teeth removed and knowing that he can't stop it from happening.