A drama/comedy/fantasy series on Lifetime
Deb (Brooke D'Orsay) is an attractive, ditzy blonde who is auditioning for a job as a game show hostess. She is engaged to be married to her lawyer fiancÚ Grayson (Jackson Hurst). She goes off to her audition to be a model on The Price Is Right
, talking to her friend Stacy (April Bowlby) on her mobile and filing her nails, all at the same time. Poor Deb. If she had looked up for only a minute, maybe she would have noticed the grapefruit delivery truck parked in the middle of the intersection up ahead...
Meanwhile, at a law firm (the exact one Grayson got a job at, we learn later) in the same city, a literal 'Plain' Jane (Brooke Elliott), is preparing for her day. She is mousy, overweight, has many self help books, has a witty assistant Terri (Margaret Cho
), and a business rival Kim (Kate Levering) who is busy showing off her new purse. Jane steps out of her office just in time to see an armed gun man come in. Apparently, Jane's boss was dating the gun man's wife. She tries to calm down the situation, but trips over a purse (Kim's, no less), and the paranoid gun man shoots her dead.
You're probably asking, 'What the hell, the two main characters die in the first episode?' but rest assured, here is where it gets good.
Deb gets stopped on her way to heaven by angel Fred (Ben Feldman), because she has never done a good or bad deed in her whole life."It doesn't mean you're a bad person. Probably just really shallow," he tells her. Outraged, Deb pushes a return button, and is sent back to Earth...in Jane's recently vacated body.
Now poor Jane/Deb has to deal with being a skinny girl in a fat girl's body, work as a lawyer with Jane's legal smarts (strange fact, Deb has all of Jane's knowledge of courtroom operations, but no memories of Jane's past), handle working in the same room with her (ex?)fiancÚ, and just get used to her new life, including dealing with things from both her and Jane's pasts.
P.S. Because of what Deb/Jane did, Fred was sent to Earth as her guardian angel, or as he calls it, her babysitter. Along the way, he gets a crush on Stacy, whom Jane lets in on the big secret...
The show was cancelled, but Lifetime reversed the decision and aired season five in 2013.
This show contains examples of the following tropes:
- Acquired Situational Narcissism: Stacy develops this while she has a supporting role on a tv show.
- Amoral Attorney
- Bait and Switch: In the fifth season premiere, it seems that Owen is dead, and Old Jane has taken over his body; however, it turns out that Owen is alive, which Jane finds out after asking a small series of questions when he comes into her office. Old Jane shows up at the end of the episode in a model's body.
- Blondes Are Evil: Subverted. The initial impression from the pilot and from what Deb!Jane says is that she'd pretty much brush off Jane in her past life. From what we meet of her past friends, they're also fairly shallow and not exactly great people. The subversion is that Stacy, her closest friend, is entirely sweet and well meaning. And it's brought up in one episode that Jane (a brunette) pre-Debization was fairly distant and reclusive, going as far as buying off her mother versus Deb being incredibly close to her parents.
- Played straight in second season: Kim dyed her hair platinum blonde.
- Betty and Veronica: Jane and Vanessa halfway through Season 2. Shown in a dream sequence in Episode 12.
- Jane and Kim in Season 1 fit this even better.
- Owen and Grayson for Jane's Archie throughout Season 4.
- Brainless Beauty: Deb was one, and Stacy can fall under it, though both have started picking up lawyer terms due to Jane's brains.
- Bunny-Ears Lawyer: Even literally.
- Butt Monkey: Grayson claims himself to be this, given that some of his cases included representing an ape, a transexual, and a couple who owns a haunted house.
- California Doubling: Atlanta for Los Angeles.
- The Cast Showoff: Brooke Elliott has a really good singing voice, and the show wastes no opportunities in reminding the viewer.
- Likewise, the karaoke scene in "Home and Away" was a good show of Ben Feldman's (Fred) singing voice.
- Catch Phrase: Deb!Jane tends to post-fix questions with, "right?" somewhat regularly.
- Celestial Bureaucracy: How the afterlife is run.
- Cloning Blues: Invoked in "Chinese Wall". Though in this case the clone is a dog and it's the master that's blue. The dog is "imperfect" in that it no longer responds to the master's commands.
- Cloud Cuckoo Lander: Stacey occasionally falls into a ditzy version of this. Jane comes across as this to her boss, though primarily due to her lateral thinking.
- Contrived Coincidence: Happens all the time, especially when Jane needs inspiration to solve her cases. Also happens when she and Grayson gets closer: you can be sure that in the following minute (if not seconds) something will pop and stop their interactions.
- Curse Cut Short: Fred's cry of "Je-!" when Stacey uses Mace on him. Beyond the humour of the scene itself, what makes it hilarious is that Fred is an angel.
- In "Dead Model Walking", after unknowingly agreeing to a double-date with current boyfriend, rival, and ex?-fiance, Jane lets out a flat "Fun." Of course, the shocked expression on her face says that other F-word.
- Deadpan Snarker: Rosie O'Donnell's judge is pretty snarky.
- In fact, several of the judges on the show have a notable sarcastic edge.
- Dream Sequence: Quite a few, often involving guest stars as themselves.
- Dumb Blonde: Deb and Stacy. And often subverted; both of them are a lot smarter than given credit for. It's just that their smarts don't necessarily revolve around the sort of knowledge most people would consider worthwhile. Plus, Stacy figures out and accepts Deb's new body/situation pretty quickly.
- It becomes much more subverted in the second season where Stacy starts to get a lot more savvy and smart, even using her image as a dumb blonde to her advantage.
- Also, the more Deb learns and experiences Jane's life and hears about Jane's life before Debbization, the more the viewers start to see how Deb as an outside observer makes rather insightful observations on her life. Indeed, there are signs that ditzy but well meaning Deb may actually be making a better life for Jane than Jane ever was. Such as re-connecting with Jane's absent dad and getting Jane's mom to go into therapy for bi-polar disorder.
- Paul, Jane's latest guardian angel is basically the  to Stacy.
- Fake Nationality: Emily Kuroda is a Japanese-Americans playing a Korean-American
- Flashback: Used to flesh out Deb and her relationship with Grayson before her death. Also used with stories or phrases Deb told Grayson and that Jane repeats; this confuses Grayson immensely.
- Feigning Intelligence: Stacy.
- Genius Ditz: The ditz part comes from Deb, the genius part from Jane. Though as with Dumb Blonde, Deb isn't necessarily as ditzy or dumb as usual per the trope. She's just that way compared to Jane and in fact can be pretty insightful.
- Getting Crap Past the Radar: Fred, upon seeing Stacy, talks about how he'd like to do her groceries, shingle the roof of her house, hunt wild animals and bring her meat. Deb!Jane chastises him and tells him to keep his meat to himself.
- In "Chinese Wall", Terri bluffs her way into a dog show by saying she's an editor with the magazine, Doggy Style. Kim asks afterwards if that's actually a real magazine. The reply is "Yes, it's just not about dogs."
- Identity Amnesia: Used by Deb!Jane as an excuse why she's different after Deb!Jane got shot.
- Meaningful Name: Plus-sized Jane as in 'Plain Jane'.
- New guardian angel Luke Daniels counts as well. Luke and Daniel being books of the Bible. And for a triple, his earthly disguise is that of an angel investor.
- Grayson Kent's name is clearly a reference to Nightwing and Superman due to his strong moral compass.
- Laser-Guided Amnesia / Ret Gone: In regards to Fred towards everyone but Deb!Jane after he romances Stacey.
- And while not brought up Luke as well.
- Love Dodecahedron: Not as much as other series but still a pretty large one considering Deb's past relationships and Old!Jane's past relationships Deb!Jane has to consider both.
- Meganekko: Stacy wears a pair while helping Grayson on a case.
- Mood Whiplash: After a heart felt speech to save the home of an old lady who refused to move due to sentimental value, having lived there with her husband, had given Kim and Grayson cookies, etc., from developers, she profusely thanks Grayson and Kim for their help and hopes they'll help her again in six months time when her case goes on appeals. And then, making sure they promise to keep helping her and what have you, tells them something under lawyer-client confidentiality...reveals that in actuality, she doesn't want to move and have developers wreck her house because that would uncover the body of her dead husband. Whom she killed. It's not really clear if this is supposed to be funny, shocking or what, but it changes the mood considerably.
- Mr. Fanservice: Paul's relevance in seasons 5 and 6 pretty much revolve around him getting shirtless scenes (when he is not simply in his briefs).
- Our Angels Are Different: Fred, Luke (in Season 4) and Paul (in Season 5).
- Phony Psychic: "Make Me A Match" features two of these, or so you think. However, while the two act like phonies and the entire cast of characters sees them as such, to the viewers, they actually are legitimate (for the most part).
- Pstandard Psychic Pstance: Whenever Deb gets an unusual flash of knowledge from Jane's mind, she tends to act like she has a mild shock/headache.
- Really Gets Around: Parker, Parker, Parker, pretty much the only women in the building he hadn't slept with were Jane and Teri.
- Refuge in Audacity: In "Fifty Shades of Grayson" Kim goes into labor during a trial. She somehow manages to convince the judge to allow her to continue the trial over video while she's in labor.
- Ripped from the Headlines: Several of the cases that Jane's law firm handles are based on real life cases. For instance, Mary Ann Nealy, in the season 1 episode "Second Chances" is partially based on Sara Jane Olson. However, in keeping with the fact that this is a Lifetime series, the defendant is more sympathetic and gets a happier ending.
- Secret Keeper: The only ones that know Jane is Deb are Stacy and her guardian angels, Fred (Seasons 1-3), Luke (Season 4), and Paul (Seasons 5-6) and in the sixth and final season Grayson
- Sleeping with the Boss: Kim in Season2 through early season 4 with Parker the managing partner.
- Wham Episode: The season 4 finale. Deb!Jane kisses Grayson on the day that she's due to marry Owen. Owen sees them and has a heart attack. Meanwhile, Old!Jane pushes the Return button and comes back in Owen's body.
- Also season 6, episode 9. Grayson defends a murderer and is shot.
- What Happened to the Mouse?:
- Parker started off as a cheating womanizer. Once his relationship with Kim kicks into full swing, however, his wife isn't brought up even when Kim shows up at his home or when he's drinking over having broken up with Kim temporarily. Only the womanizing aspect remains and even then it's been downgraded mostly to him simply disassociating himself from past girlfriends.
- The fate of many characters is unknown at the end of the show, namely Fred (who really should have huge problems after what he did) and Old!Jane (who didn't even make an appearance in the last season). Not to mention the real Ian Holt, who was crudely executed for a crime he didn't commit, and whose body is now inhabited by someone else's soul.
- What the Hell, Hero?: Delivered by Old!Jane to Deb!Jane when she found out that her mother died, and that Deb!Jane didn't have the decency to call and warn her (and, as she points out, she could have perfectly done so).
- Your Cheating Heart: Parker, the boss, is doing this. Not just with one mistress but three in his office alone and that isn't counting the one whose husband shot Jane.
- Grayson kisses Jane at her wedding to Owen and he has a heart attack seeing it
- Due to the nature of the show many of the cases they have to deal with involve this.