Recap: The Simpsons S 8 E 14 The Itchy And Scratchy And Poochie Show

Episode - 4F12
First Aired - 2/9/1997

The Itchy & Scratchy Show is in a crisis of quality, after Roger Meyers sees a slight drop-off in ratings and Bart and Lisa admit that the show is getting a bit stale, so the writers create a new character (a dog named Poochie) and hire Homer Simpson to be the voice actor. But when Poochie's in-your-face, Totally Radical style makes the show worse, Homer must do what he can to save the new guy.

This episode contains examples of:

  • Answer Cut: After Poochie's debut, Lisa comments that what matters is what the fans think. Cut to Comic Book Guy calling it the "Worst Episode Ever!"
  • Bait and Switch: At first, Poochie's debut episode gave the impression something would happen at a fireworks factory.
  • Bus Crash: Poochie's fate.
    Note: Poochie died on the way back to his home Planet
  • Character Shilling: Homer suggests doing this as one way to boost Poochie's popularity.
  • Cool Shades:
    Roger Meyers: He's supposed to have attitude!
    Artist: What do you mean, attitude?
    Meyers: You know! Attitude, attitude, uhh... sunglasses!
  • Early-Bird Cameo: The female executive, who reappears in several future episodes, was later reworked into Leslie Neagle.
  • Executive Meddling: invokedThoroughly parodied.
  • Get On With It Already and They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: In-Universe. The Itchy and Scratchy episode grinds to a halt as Poochie acts all cool and in-your-face.
    Milhouse: [crying] When are they gonna get to the fireworks factory?!
  • Green Aesop: Spoofed — "Always recycle — to the extreme!"
  • Hate Dumb: invokedAs stupid as the Poochie ratings stunt is, the fans who complain about it get their fair share of mockery too.
  • Leaning on the Fourth Wall: A Running Gag involving Roy:
    • When Bart and Lisa learn throung the newspaper that a new character named Poochie is going to be added to The Itchy & Scratch Show:
      Lisa: Adding a new character is often a desperate attempt to boost low ratings.
      Roy: (walks in) Yo, yo! How's it hangin' everybody?!
      Marge: Morning, Roy!
      Homer: Yeah, hi, Roy.
    • When Homer resolves to salvage Poochie:
      Homer: I won't let them treat Poochie like dirt anymore just because he's the new guy.
      Roy: Right on, Mr. S!
      Homer: Put a sock in it, Roy.
    • When Poochie is killed off:
      Bart: Tough break, Dad. I guess people just weren't ready for Poochie. Maybe in a few years.
      Roy: (walks up to the family) Good news, everybody. I'm moving into my own apartment with two sexy ladies.
      Marge: Oh, then I guess this is good-bye, Roy. Maybe we'll see you in a few years.
  • Magic Realism: The focus group leader asks the kids if this is what they want out of Itchy & Scratchy when said kids answer with equal excitement to two proposed premises — Itchy and Scratchy dealing with real life problems, or Itchy and Scratchy becoming Denser and Wackier. The response to the combination of the two scenarios is lukewarm.
    Milhouse: And also, you should win things by watching.
  • Put on a Bus: Roy's fate.
  • Remember the New Guy: The Simpsons' house guest, Roy.
    • Also parodied in the Itchy and Scratchy Show.
      Itchy: Look, Scratchy. It's Poochie.
      Scratchy: What was his name? I forgot.
    • What Could Have Been: Originally, Roy was supposed to appear in "Time and Punishment" from "Treehouse of Horror V" as part of an alternate reality where Homer is the father of an annoying teenager.
  • Shoo Out the New Guy: Poochie's fate. In fact, the trope was originally named "The Poochie". (Poochie would appear twice more on Itchy & Scratchy, though. In the non-canon Treehouse of Horror segment "The Terror of Tiny Toon" he's promptly hit by a police car as he's skating down the street. In another short, he's at Scratchy's funeral.)
  • Spoof Aesop: At the end of the episode, the family and pets gather around Homer, who says, "Well, I guess I learned my lesson. The thing is, I lost creative control of the project... and I forgot to ask for any money. Well, live and learn."
  • Take That and Biting-the-Hand Humor: The entire episode is a burn against TV executives who use cheap gimmicks to keep long-running shows fresh (including putting in committee-created "cool" characters, like Poochie and the Simpsons' unexplained house guest Roy) and the fans who complain when shows either change their dynamic or start to go stale.
    • Roy in particular was an explicit reference to Fox at one point having tried to convince the Simpsons writers to add a new character living with the family to "spice up the show".
  • Trivially Obvious: After the screening party, Carl tries to compliment Homer's work.
    Carl: Yeah, you should be very proud, Homer. You, uh... got a beautiful home here.
  • Wag the Director:invoked Homer attempts this in his last ditch effort to save Poochie.