main index




Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
Recap: The Simpsons S 10 E 8 Homer Simpsons In The Kidney Trouble
Production Code: AABF 04
Premiere Date: December 6, 1998

While driving home from a Old West tourist trap, Homer ignores Grampa Simpson's pleas to let him use the bathroom, which causes the old man to blow out both of his kidneys. With Grampa at death's door, Homer decides to give a kidney to his father — then runs off when he becomes afraid of what being an organ donor will do for him.

This episode contains examples of:

  • Artistic License - Biology: A "kidney blowout" due to holding in urine for a long time is physically and medically impossible, as the kidneys (much like the liver) is just a filter that makes body waste. If any organ in the urinary tract was going to suffer from having too much urine in it, it would be the bladder (and he would have pissed himself before dying of sepsis). And if Grampa's urinary system was compromised and Homer didn't want to donate a kidney, couldn't they have put Grampa on dialysis until a donor could be found? You know "urine" trouble when Seth MacFarlane can realistically portray the trials and tribulations of dealing with kidney failure (as seen in "New Kidney on the Block" and "The Kidney Stays in the Picture".
  • Continuity Snarl: Grampa is said to have two functional kidneys, but in "Old Money"note , he told Bea he had one kidney (unless he meant one that was functioning).
  • Even Evil Has Standards: The Frenchman may have stolen his accordian (actually a concertina) from a blind monkey, but, he (and the other passengers on the Ship of Lost Souls) would never dream of leaving their fathers to die in the hospital after promising them a kidney.
    • Neither would Bart, a boy once hailed as "America's Bad Boy."
  • Jerkass: A lot of viewers hated this episode, as it showed Homer at his most selfish (bailing during his father's kidney transplant operation). Even the other characters said so.
    • Jerkass Has a Point: His fear were pivoted by the fact Dr. Hibbert (and everyone else) outright lied to him about the dangers of the operation so he'd agree. When they can't make him donate willingly, he outright steals his kidney while he's unconscious. While it's Dirty Cowardice at its finest, would you trust your body in the hands of a quack that deceives and outright mutilates you without your consent?
  • Laser-Guided Karma: Homer getting crushed by a car.
  • Morally Ambiguous Doctorate: Homer's cowardice is partially pivoted by the fact Dr Hibbert lied about the dangers of the operation to make him go through with it. When he fails to get Homer to willing go through with it, he outright steals the kidney from him while he's unconscious.
  • Noodle Incident: A whole Ship of Lost Souls full of them, barring the French man with the accordion (see Even Evil Has Standards above).
  • Potty Emergency and Potty Failure: Played for Drama; because Homer wouldn't stop to let Grampa use the bathroom, Grampa's kidneys exploded and is now near death.
  • Take That: Another one against the Catholic Church. When Marge asks Reverend Lovejoy to perform the last rites for Grampa, Lovejoy retorts, "Marge, that's Catholic. Why don't you ask me to do a voodoo dance?"
The Simpsons S 10 E 7 Lisa Gets An ARecap/The SimpsonsThe Simpsons S 10 E 9 Mayored To The Mob

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from
Privacy Policy