Originally aired October 15, 2015
Written by Damian Kindler
Directed by Kate Dennis
Ichabod and Abbie battle Pandora's latest menace, a knife that causes its wielder to act on his dark impulses.
Tropes present in the episode:
- Jack the Ripoff: Nelson becomes a Jack the Ripper-like murderer after touching a Byzantine parang that has the power to turn people into serial killers.
- Time-Shifted Actor: Another actor plays Ichabod as a teenager in flashbacks.