"Brendon, the Romantic Comedy is dead, Nick Nolte and Julia Roberts KILLED IT!"
— Jason, Home Movies
"Every romantic comedy should just be called Trying to Fuck. "This week, Jennifer Aniston and this guy are Trying to Fuck. Next week, Jennifer Aniston and this guy are Trying to Fuck. Will they fuck? Probably. From the writer of Meh and the director of Neh comes Bleeeeeeeeh."
"The underlying story is a simple one: A man and a woman who are obviously intended for each other are kept apart for an entire movie, only to meet at the end. We're supposed to be pleased when they get together, I guess, although the movie ends with such unseemly haste that we never get to experience them as a couple."
—Roger Ebert on 'Til There Was You