Playing With / Written by the Winners

Basic Trope: The winners of a conflict glorify themselves and vilify the losers retroactively.
  • Straight: The Empire attacks and conquers The Kingdom. The historians later present The Kingdom as Mordor who planned to release The Plague, so The Empire acted purely in self-defense.
  • Exaggerated:
    • The Empire is the lone global superpower and The Kingdom is a tiny but resource-rich speck of land on the other end of the globe. Everybody believes that The Kingdom was a real threat so The Empire was justified in attacking it.
    • The Empire refuses to acknowledge that The Kingdom ever actually existed in its own right. As far as the imperial Propaganda Machine is concerned, they were just suppressing secessionist rebels.
  • Downplayed: The Empire's history books say that most of the Kingdom didn't really want a war, but their king and a few crazy nobles forced them into it.
  • Justified: The historians believe, “My Country, Right or Wrong.”
  • Inverted:
    • The Empire doesn’t care about its image, so the conquered peoples get to write what posterity knows about it.
    • Alternatively, due to any number of reasons (like the Empire having no written records or having those lost), the only accounts available ARE those written by the losers.
  • Subverted:
  • Double Subverted: …but that evidence was also forged.
  • Parodied: Just because they can, Imperial historians write that The Kingdom was populated by one-legged, two-headed people with flowers for hair who fought with golf clubs.
  • Zig Zagged: The Empire sets out to rewrite history, but their Blatant Lies spark off a rebellion and lead to a coup. Following this upheaval, the rebel leaders glorify themselves and vilify The Empire. Most citizens are aware of this, but don’t care because they hated The Empire anyway. …However, eventually some of the nastier things the rebels did to defeat their enemies come to light, including acts that make them Not So Different. This creates a rift between those demanding the full truth be told and those who prefer to ignore those travesties because they ultimately benefited from them. This leads to another revolution, the former heroes are overthrown, and these rebels set out to ensure their image remains clean…
  • Averted: The history of a conflict is written by an impartial observer (possibly by an even stronger superpower).
  • Enforced: “Just to show how evil The Emperor is, let’s give him a Propaganda Machine for Blatant Lies!”
  • Lampshaded: “History is written by the winners, remember?”
  • Invoked: “History will be kind to me, for I intend to write it.”
  • Exploited: The Protagonist doesn’t care if they have to slaughter everyone in that village to get the Spy, because if the Empire said that they found the village already slaughtered nobody would believe them.
  • Defied:
    • “This folder contains the full truth I discovered about the war. Five hundred such folders are currently on the way to every major publishing house in the world.”
    • The historian cites both the reports made by the historians from The Empire and those made by The Kingdom apologists, compare them, analyze how does the historical evidence supports the claims made by both sides, and concludes what is right and what is wrong about each view, without fully taking a side.
  • Discussed: “If we die now, his truth will be the only one remaining.”
  • Conversed: “I mean, what’s the point of fighting in the first place, if they cannot win and will be remembered as villains for all eternity thanks to the winners’ propaganda?”
  • Implied: Imperial-friendly accounts from the time since it conquered the Kingdom are readily available to anyone inclined to read them; those friendly to the old Kingdom are restricted.
  • Deconstructed: The Empire tries to rewrite the history of a recent war but its citizens lose patience at such blatant lies and spark a rebellion.
  • Reconstructed: …after the coup, the rebel leaders glorify themselves and vilify the previous government even further.
  • Played for Laughs: The Kingdom is treated as having the stuff of a joke.

Back to Written by the Winners
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/PlayingWith/WrittenbytheWinners