Double Subverted: The aforementioned level in Jerkass was just an act and was Alice's way of dealing with her problems.
Parodied: Bob tries to get someone's attention, but when Alice enters the room everyone rushes to check on her.
Zig Zagged: The audience felt sorry for Alice, and then she became successful and Took a Level in Jerkass, only to find it was Lonely at the Top so the audience felt sorry for her again, but this time it was her own fault, and then she lost everything, being an unconditional sympathy magnet again.
Averted: The audience is indifferent to Alice.
"We need a character to draw in sympathy, otherwise we're going to be seen as too goofy."
The author puts in every Common Woobie Trait he can think of and shows positive results of other characters pitying Alice to make sure the audience does as well.
Lampshaded: Another character refers to Alice as "Poor girl."
Exploited: Alice tells everyone the tragic truth about her abusive father, but only to get free hugs.
Defied: The author goes out of his way to make Alice as self-sufficient and well-off as possible, and shows negative results of other characters pitying her, in hopes the audience will not.
Discussed: "Alice certainly has a pretty rotten life. It'd be sick if someone was watching her for that reason."
Conversed: "You ever notice how some fictional characters get more offers for hugs and protection than real people?"
Alice is aware that people are only drawn to her because of her suffering, causing her to become depressed.
Alice's weakness draws people to protect her, and the people who protect her smother her in it...
Then Alice realizes that they're drawn to her because nobody should be left to suffer, and helping others is the right thing to do. She accepts their help and overtime becomes a stronger person who can stand on her own two feet.