Double Subverted: That was just a nasty rumour her enemies spread.
Parodied: Alice has Fertile Feet and flowers spring up wherever she walks. Heavenly harp music plays everywhere she goes. She can make the most vicious Complete Monster repent and become The Atoner with nothing but a "Now now, behave yourself."
Zig Zagged: Alice is revealed to act like The Messiah because she's atoning for past wrongdoings, but it turns out to be just a rumour. Then she starts being aManipulative Bitch towards her friends, so they assume she's not so nice after all, until they find out it's actually one of her enemies impersonating her to ruin her reputation. Her enemies' treatment of her causes her to become cynical, but she remains a kind and caring person deep down.
Averted: Alice is a decent person, but not to the point of being messianic.
Alice's Incorruptible Pure Pureness inspires the people around her to give her lives for her so she can be safe, therefore Alice is causing the people she cares about to die or suffer in her place. She feels resentful towards herself for this as a result.