Older Than They Think: Live-Action TV
- Warp drive of Star Trek fame already occurs in Fredric Brown's stories from the 1940s (the warp/fabric image of space-time probably dates back even earlier, from the first efforts to explain relativity to people who don't know about tensors).
- Dr. McCoy's famous line "I'm a doctor, not a _____!" from Star Trek actually originates in the 1933 film The Kennel Murder Case, where a coroner insists repeatedly "I'm a doctor, not a ____!" (reporter, detective, etc.).
- The Borg's famous line "Resistance is futile" in Star Trek: The Next Generation was used earlier in Doctor Who, Lost in Space, and probably other sci-fi. (The variant "Resistance is useless" was used by the Vogon guard in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.)
- One episode of The 4400 had as its plot the possibility of the entire premise of the show being an illusion, causing complaints from Buffy the Vampire Slayer fans that it was stealing from the latter's episode "Normal Again". Or from Red Dwarf's "Back To Reality", or from Star Trek: The Next Generation's "Frame of Mind". Or Neverwhere. As it happens, the plot (Cuckoo Nest) is actually among The Oldest Ones in the Book, with classic examples such as Ambrose Bierce's 1886 story An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge, or Chuang Tzu's tale of the man who dreamt he was a butterfly.
- In the Star Trek franchise, the Vulcan salute, and its accompanying farewells, "Peace and long life" and "Live long and prosper", are both derived from Jewish benediction services. (This was confirmed by Leonard Nimoy when he hosted a retrospective on Star Trek in the early 1980s.)
- (Cf. Deuteronomy 5:32-33)
- The concept of a virtual reality called "The Matrix" was used earlier in Doctor Who in the 1976 serial "The Deadly Assassin", twenty three years before its better-known movie namesake. The concept was first used in Simulacron 3, a novel by Daniel F. Galouye, written in 1964.
- And even that is just a high-tech version of Plato's allegory of the cave.
- Doctor Who gets this a lot:
Doctor Who: "You belong to us. You will be like us."Star Trek: "You will become like us. You will service us."Doctor Who: "Resistance is Useless" (September 1967)Star Trek: "Resistance is futile."
- In-fandom, when new series fans gush over the genius of some ideas and concepts without realising many of then existed in the old series. So horror elements written by Robert Holmes (half of which he borrowed from old horror movies anyway) and later reused by Russell T Davies or Steven Moffat are seen as their "genius". Even if the writers have themselves, and to their credit, frequently acknowledged that some of these elements are tributes to the writers whose stories they grew up with (there are very few cases of Davies or Moffat blatantly taking credit for major characters or concepts that originated in the original series; media that refers to Davies as the "creator" of Doctor Who are simply clueless). Of course, the most extreme example of this is when new series fans preface their fanfics with "Doctor Who belongs to Russell T Davies and/or Steven Moffat"...
- The inverse is also true; if you want to base your criticism of some plot point on the claim that nothing like it would ever have happened in the original series, you'd better make damn sure it didn't. It's worse than that, for some fans of the new series. Upon being informed that there was a show prior to 2005, they will balk and call you a liar, and dismiss the evidence as being made up.
- Or, alternately, they will actually stick to the opinion held by some diehard fans of the classic series that the 1963-89 and 2005-present series are completely different shows, even though rock-solid connections were established within the first few weeks of the revival.
- The reintroduction of the Cybermen in the new Doctor Who story "Rise of the Cybermen" prompted some claims that the monsters were a rip-off of Star Trek's Borg — in fact, Doctor Who fans had been making exactly the opposite claim ever since the Borg were first introduced more than 20 years after the Cybermen first appeared in the 1966 story "The Tenth Planet".
- The idea of the Doctor's history being changed leading to a chaotic world has been used in Turn Left and The Name of the Doctor. Sounds like a great and original idea? Actually it was used in the Doctor Who Magazine comic "Time and Time Again", made to celebrate the 30th anniversary in 1993. Here the Black Guardian prevents the Doctor from leaving Gallifrey, leading to various creatures fighting over Earth.
- "The Name of the Doctor" gets a lot of this, also taking elements from "Alien Bodies", "Unnatural History", "The Room with No Doors", and "Timewyrm: Revelation". In fact "Timewyrm: Revelation" has inspired a lot of other stories.
- The episode "Dalek" was widely credited with making the Daleks scary again after a fairly lengthy period of having undergone Villain Decay; in particular, it demonstrated that the Daleks could actually fly, in reaction to the standard joke of the best way of defeating Daleks being to climb a flight of stairs. In fact, several of the elements that "Dalek" apparently 'introduced' to the Daleks — including flight — actually originated in the 1988 serial "Remembrance of the Daleks".
- And the Doctor Who Website page for "Remembrance of the Daleks" (http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/classic/episodeguide/remembrancedaleks/detail.shtml) says it is a myth that the Daleks first flew here. Thought they don't mention it there, in the second Dalek appearance, though this was in a comic, the Daleks were flying using transpolar discs.
- A lot of elements of New Who came from the Doctor Who Expanded Universe such as a robot duplicate of a companion living for centuries, a time rift in a major city.
- The Goo Goo Godlike Creepy Child going around asking people if they are its mother in "The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances" is (by Moffat's admission) based on the Goo Goo Godlike Creepy Child going around asking people if they are its father in the audio "The Holy Terror".
- The murderous snow and killer, razor-toothed snowmen controlled by a collective intelligence from "The Snowmen" are almost identical to murderous snow and killer, razor-toothed snowmen controlled by a collective intelligence battled by Susan Foreman and her school friends in the Telos novella Time and Relative (the primary difference being that the book's snowmen originate from Earth itself and the story is much Bloodier and Gorier)
- An episode was planned for Series 1 where Rose was going to discover her entire life had been manipulated to make her the perfect companion, a plot point originally done with Sam (as a Fix Fic on Depending on the Writer misery) in the Eighth Doctor Adventures.
- A Doctor Who story where Humans are the real monsters? Sounds like something from New Who? That was done in the first story featuring a meeting between humans and aliens (not counting the main characters), the eighth story "The Sensorites".
- The running gag where the Tenth and Eleventh Doctor constantly get Accidental Engagements to various historical figures (Queen Elizabeth I, Marilyn Monroe, etc...) - oversexualisation of a character happy to live with No Hugging, No Kissing for decades, or just an homage to the moment in the original series where the First Doctor gets accidentally engaged to an Aztec woman? And in "Seasons of Fear" the Doctor mentions getting accidentally engaged to Edith Swan-Neck.
- Everyone knows companions were always screaming, ankle-twisting bimbos whose functions were to say "what is it, Doctor" and bend over in low-cut tops until the Doctor got sick of them and unceremoniously dumped them to get married to some random alien she'd swapped about two words with, until the new series came along with innovations like 'personalities' and 'the Doctor feeling sad and lonely after the companions leave'. Everyone knows it, even though it's utterly untrue - the stereotype is formed from an Accentuate the Negative grab-bag of the most annoying writing fumbles of the most annoying companions in their most annoying episodes, as well as a deliberate quirk of the Fourth Doctor (who acted like he didn't care when his companions left due to his generally solitary nature and general tendency to mask negative feelings behind lots of smiling). The first adult female companion on the whole show was a strong yet feminine female character who used her brain, got her hands dirty and shared one of the most profound Doctor/companion relationships with her Doctor, one that set the precedent for his entire personality as well as did horrible damage to his mental health when she left it. And the Doctor was often shown as really upset when his companions left, the first time this happened the next episode showed him to be slightly in denial.
- The 2011 episode The Doctor's Wife is widely praised for its innovation in giving the TARDIS a mind and for taking the Doctor wherever he "needs" to be to sort out trouble. In reality, the TARDIS being sentient is one of the show's earliest concepts (The Edge of Destruction, its third serial) and the notion that it instinctively "knows" where to bring the Doctor has been around at least as long as the 1966 story, The Ark. In this story, the TARDIS returns to the same location 700 years later, and it's implied it chose to return.
- You still see people claiming that WKRP in Cincinnati was inspired by the 1978 film FM. In fact, the WKRP pilot was filmed months before FM was released.
- A beautiful, intellectually unremarkable young woman befriends and comes to rely on a group of brilliant-but-awkward geniuses who work at a university, one of which develops a crush on her. The Big Bang Theory, right? Wrong — it's a movie called Ball of Fire, released in 1941 and starring Gary Cooper and Barbara Stanwyck.
- Much has been made of how innovative the format of Law & Order was when it first debuted, but there were two obscure earlier shows that had essentially the same structure: Arrest and Trial (1963-64) and The D.A. (1970-71).
- The middle section of Babylon 5 — the part with Nightwatch and the Ministry of Truth — has been accused of being an Author Tract against the War on Terror and the Bush Administration in general. The last episode aired in fall 1998, almost three years before 9/11.
- One forum poster on Television Without Pity compared the Dollhouse episode "Echoes" to the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Naked Now". That show was itself a Whole Plot Reference to the Star Trek: The Original Series episode "The Naked Time".
- Oh my God, they killed Kenny! It could just be a coincidence... One of the catchphrases of The Goon Show was "You dirty rotten swine you! You deaded me!".
- In-universe example from Dexter. When the Bay Harbor Butcher sent a manifesto to a newspaper, Batista noticed a literary reference:
Batista: "You can't depend on your eyes when your imagination is out of focus."
Masuka: He's a Trekker! That shit's straight from Deep Space 9.
Batista: What? Mark Twain said that. It's one of his most famous quotes.
Other officer: Twain was never on Deep Space 9. He was on Next Generation.
Batista: He didn't say it on Star Trek.
Other officer: Okay, so what's it from?
Lundy: A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court.
- In 1969, a new comedy sketch show debuted that completely tore apart the format of traditional sketch comedy, replacing conventional sketches with sketches that simply stopped mid flow, sketches that ran into each other and a whole lot of silliness. It is Spike Milligan's Q series which preceded Monty Python's Flying Circus by a few months (to be fair, the Monty Python team were working on their show at roughly the same time). The Pythons acknowledged The Goon Show as a major influence, so it's unsurprising that Flying Circus would bear similarities to another work of Milligan's.
- Q5 started just as Python had been given their show but didn't really have a concrete idea of how they were going to accomplish what they wanted with it. It's mentioned in interviews and in Michael Palin's diary that there was at least one conversation between them about how they'd seen Q5 and thought, "That's what we were going to do, isn't it?"
- Comedians Olsen and Johnson had been doing this sort of thing for years when they brought it onto the Broadway stage in 1938 with Hellzapoppin'. There was also a 1941 film version.
- "Four Yorkshiremen" did not originate with Monty Python. It was from At Last The 1948 Show, and the original performers were John Cleese, Graham Chapman, Tim Brooke-Taylor, and Marty Feldman. Tim Brooke-Taylor, known from The Goodies, has said that people refuse to believe he co-wrote the sketch. (He tries to tell that to young people nowadays, and they don't believe him.)
- Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers was often called a "ripoff" by uninformed Voltron fans due to the similar design of the Dino Megazord, unaware that both series were Americanized adaptations of Japanese shows and that the Super Sentai franchise that Power Rangers is based on is a year older than the franchise to which Go Lion, the Japanese version of Voltron, belongs. Also, both shows were made by Toei.
- Although, Toei does acknowledge that the Dino Megazord's design (technically the Daizyujin from Zyuranger) was made as a homage to Voltron (Go Lion). Source in Japanese.
- It's also common for fans of Power Rangers to later discover Voltron and mistake it for an animated ripoff of the former.
- Some Power Rangers fans who later discover Super Sentai accuse the latter of being ripoffs of the former.
- If you saw Masked Rider and thought it was a Power Rangers ripoff, you should know that Kamen Rider is about two or three years older than Super Sentai. Undoubtedly its debut was met with the usual cynicism: "Oh, so they took Kamen Rider, made some stupid ripoff where there's five of them in silly rainbow colors so they can sell more toys, then made it Lighter and Softer so kids will watch? Toku is ruined! It Will Never Catch On!"
- Calling any Henshin Hero related property a ripoff of PR, as if the Toku genre wasn't, well, a genre (and as if we haven't been hearing the word "Shazam!" since The Forties.)
- As for a team of heroes with colour-coded uniforms and code names (red Hero, blue Lancer, and green Smart Guy) who use high-tech weapons and vehicles to battle an invading alien empire? Try Captain Scarlet and the Mysterons out for size.
- With the Vampire Diaries TV adaptation airing in the midst of the Twilight-craze, many twitards believed Vampire Diaries stole most of its elements from Twilight. The Vampire Diaries books were made in the nineties. It is not an unreasonable suspicion, however, that the popularity of Twilight had something to do with the Vampire Diaries being adapted now. The TV show is virtually In Name Only in relation to the Books though, and many changes did undeniably make it more similar to Twilight (though those things being unchanged would have encouraged even more comparisons to Buffy the Vampire Slayer).
- A similar phenomenon occurred with True Blood. The Sookie Stackhouse books were written a couple years before the Twilight novels, and True Blood premiered about two months before the first Twilight movie. Although it is likely that the popularity of Twilight did have something to do with the timing of the adaptation.
- There are those who think TV series based upon vampire culture is a recent innovation, but True Blood and Vampire Diaries are only recent examples of the genre. For example, there was Kindred: The Embraced in 1996, Moonlight, and Forever Knight, to name a few, not to mention, of course, the Buffy/Angel franchise launched in the early 1990s. And before any of the above was Dark Shadows — not a stupid film starring Johnny Depp, but a 1960s soap opera that featured a vampire named Barnabas Collins as its dark and brooding protagonist. It was revived decades later in the 1990s.
- Some people are now accusing the series Arrow of being a rip-off of Hawkeye from the movie The Avengers. This is despite the fact that Arrow is based off Green Arrow, a comic book character who predates Hawkeye by over two decades (and who arguably Hawkeye was influenced by). And was a regular on the same channel's previous superhero show Smallville, by the by.
- Alan Alda's depiction of Hawkeye Pierce in the TV version of Mash borrows heavily from Groucho Marx, to which a nod was made in the first-season episode "Yankee Doodle Doctor". By way of sabotaging an attempt by Army brass to propagandize the 4077th's "heroic doctors", Pierce plays Groucho in the Movie Within The Show, and Trapper John plays Harpo.
- When the Canadian show Ed's Late Night Party aired for a short time in the US on G4, many viewers criticized Ed the Sock for ripping off Triumph the Insult Comic Dog. Ed the Sock had actually been around on various Canadian programs since the early-90's and was possibly an inspiration for Triumph. This led to Ed resenting Triumph, and NBC insisting that the character shouldn't be anywhere near Conan's show when it taped a few episode in Toronto. Ed the Sock was scheduled to appear on Conan O'Brien but cancelled at the last minute. Three months later Triumph appeared on the show.
- In-universe example in Wizards of Waverly Place. Max has claimed his name is Tom Sawyer so his girlfriend doesn't know he's related to Alex.
Alex: That is such an obvious lie. It's the name from the Rush song.Harper: And the classic book.Alex: Wow. That song was good, I didn't know they made a book out of it.
- Rod Serling wrote The Twilight Zone episode "The Silence" without knowing that it was virtually the same story as Chekov's The Bet. There is an interview with Serling in the DVD set for the series in which he explicitly explains all about it.
- For those who may not be aware, The Ghost Busters came almost a full decade before Ghostbusters. Similarly, the cartoon version of the 1975 live action show debuted before The Real Ghostbusters (if only by a few days).
- Explained in-depth here.
- The classic Disney cartoon Lonesome Ghosts, in which Mickey, Donald, and Goofy portray ghost-hunters decades before either the TV show or the movie. The little known Disney Channel original series DTV even lampshaded this fact by running a video in which scenes from that cartoon are shown with the Ray Parker, Jr., theme song from the movie playing in the background.
- When the series premiere of The Walking Dead first aired, some viewers immediately accused the show of ripping off the "protagonist wakes up in a hospital after a post-apocalyptic event" scene from 28 Days Later. In fact, not only did the comic book series show this scene a full seven months before 28 Days premiered in U.S. theatres in June 2003, but both of those films copied it from The Day of the Triffids, which was written in 1951 (more than 50 years before either of the two works in questions).
- The 1949 book Earth Abides begins with a similar instance. The main character, Isherwood Smith, is bitten by a rattle snake and rendered insensate but immune to the apocalyptic plague that begins the story. When he recovers, he has no idea of what happened and is confused to find deserted towns only piecing the story together through newspapers.
- On Whose Line Is It Anyway?, one episode had the "unlikely location for a Film Noir" be a gas station. It's been done with two gas stations.
- The practice of following an episode with a preview that shows clips from the next episode didn't start in the '80s or '90s. Some film serials did the same thing at least as far back as the '40s.
- Here's a good one: Jon Stewart occasionally does a nasally, weasely voice on The Daily Show that many young viewers associate with his show (for an in-television example, Britta Perry does so on an episode of Community). However, older viewers will recognize it as a reference to a Johnny Carson voice / character, one that Johnny often went to when a joke fell flat ("Whoa, bomb-o!"). But here's the kicker, even older viewers will know that Johnny's voice was originally a reference to Jackie Gleason's Reginald Van Gleason III character ("Mmmboy are you fat!", as mentioned in an episode of the Sopranos).
- Everybody knows about the "Dick in a Box" sketch on Saturday Night Live, right? Well, The Drew Carey Show episode "The Dog and Pony Show" did the same thing almost a decade prior.
- The motive and method of the Big Bad in the Hawaii Five-0/NCIS: Los Angeles crossover was to save the planet by killing off much of humanity with an engineered plague. Tom Clancy came up with the same idea in the book and video game Rainbow Six.
- Years ago, there was a critically acclaimed British mini-series about the Julio-Claudian dynasty of Roman emperors, shot entirely on studio sets, with a script drawn from such classical sources as Tacitus and Suetonius and featuring a cast composed largely of classically trained stage actors, with particular attention paid to the lame, stammering Claudius' unexpected rise to power. The series was... Granada Television's The Caesars, which preceded the more famous BBC adaptation of I, Claudius by eight years. (Of course, the books by Robert Graves from which I, Claudius was adapted were older still, and may have influenced the scripts of The Caesars.)
- Season one of 24 introduced us to the Jack Bauer Interrogation Technique, where Jack threatens to shove a towel down a terrorist's throat until it began to digest before pulling it out. A similar scene played out in Buffy the Vampire Slayer where a cross was used to burn out a vampire's throat. The actual "technique" is probably Older Than Dirt.
- Ever since the mid-1980s, Jeopardy and Wheel of Fortune have been fixtures on nighttime syndicated television — two Long Runner game shows that are often paired with each other, extremely well-known, and not going away anytime soon. However, both of them are older than they let on.
- The current, Alex Trebek-hosted Jeopardy! began in 1984 as a revival of a show that originally aired from 1964 to 1974 with Art Fleming as host; Fleming also helmed a short-lived revival in 1978-79. (The 1960s version is spoofed in "Weird Al" Yankovic's "I Lost on Jeopardy", which predated Trebek's version by a few months.)
- Wheel was continuous. It began in 1975 as a daytime show for NBC hosted by Chuck Woolery and Susan Stafford — current host Pat Sajak took over in 1981, and Vanna White almost exactly a year later. Pat and Vanna made the leap to nighttime in 1983, hosting both daytime and nighttime until Pat stepped down from daytime in 1989. Daytime ultimately fizzled out in 1991 after two host changes and two Channel Hops, but nighttime is still locked firmly in place with Pat and Vanna. In Wheel's case, it doesn't help that the show constantly references what nighttime season it's on, and that Chuck Woolery would become more famous for his later work on Love Connection, Scrabble, and Lingo.
- Wheel also has one specific element that's Older Than They Think; namely, the Prize Puzzle, which awards a prize to the contestant who solves it. This was introduced in 2003, but a previous version of it was used for a few weeks in fall 1997.
- Speaking of Lingo… for most of the 2000s, it was a fixture on GSN, and arguably its most successful original game show. It was a revival of a little-known 1980s show that died off because its financially-troubled parent company wasn't able to pay contestants their winnings.
- And possibly more extreme than Jeopardy! or Wheel of Fortune is The Price Is Right, which began in 1972 as a heavily-souped up version of a 1950s game show hosted by Bill Cullen. The 1950s incarnation was far simpler, but still based around bidding on prizes.
- Going even further, the core format of Jeopardy! (in which the host gives the answers and the contestants provide the questions) had been used in the Lost Forever quiz show CBS Television Quiz.
- Tic-Tac-Dough is most known through its 1978-85 version, which spawned Thom McKee, once the biggest winner in American game show history. It was a revival of a 1950s game show, one of the casualties of the quiz show scandals.
- If you say Match Game to an average television fan, they will most likely think of questions pertaining to Dumb Dora, the snarky interactions of panelists Brett Somers and Charles Nelson Reilly, every third question having the answer "boobs", and a bright orange shag carpet set for the ultimate in The Seventies appeal. That was a revival of a far more formal 1960s game of the same name, and the creators didn't flip the Silliness Switch until about a year into the revival.
- A menancing but bumbling character who utters "D'Oh!" as a catch phrase when frustrated. Homer Simpson, right? No, Skipper from Gilligan's Island 20 years earlier.
- Even older than that, actually. Dan Castellaneta based the noise (rendered in scripts as simply "(annoyed grunt)") on an actor from old Laurel and Hardy films, the latest of which was from 1940.
- Many people think that Lexx is a cheap ripoff of Farscape, when actually Lexx aired 2 years earlier (albeit not on American TV).
- An in-universe example in Sleepy Hollow: It turns out Ichabod doesn't need the term John Doe explained to him because it originated in England long before his time. It may go back as far as the 14th Century.
- Eureka has an in-universe example. Carter mentions the telephone as a modern convenience that time traveler Trevor Grant would miss if he went back to the 1940s. Grant points out that it was invented in 1876.
- Sabrina the Teenage Witch and The Worst Witch both look like they were greenlit because of Harry Potter, right? Wrong. Not only is the source material much older, Sabrina had been running for almost a year when the first book came out, and The Worst Witch was already in production before the first book was released in North America. The latter predates Harry Potter as a book series by 23 years.