- MacGuffin: In her review of Dune, she introduces "Lord MacGuffin" a character who specifically describes her definition of what a MacGuffin is. He even tries to inject them into the review itself.
The Spice must flow. Nostalgia Chick:
What? Lord MacGuffin:
The Spice must flow. Nostalgia Chick:
See... I don't understand what you mean. See that's my problem with this movie in general is the fact that- Lord MacGuffin: [Pulls out a handgun, cocks it, and points it at the Chick] The Spice. Must. Flow.
- He is later seen with a jar of mayonnaise, which is later revealed to have been filled with plot device and turns it into a portal. It also enables Lord MacGuffin to return from the dead.
- Made of Plasticine: The friend from Teen Witch, after she trips over a stepladder.
Nostalgia Chick: What, are her legs made of balsa wood?
- Mad Scientist: Discussed in detail in her special on Hollywood Science.
Where did you learn your science ethics, sir, the University of Mengele
- Male Gaze: She has a quick rant about how even though Jessica Rabbit is an interesting, noir-like character, all she's remembered for is the giant boobs.
- Mama Bear: Do not screw around with Lindsay when it comes to her friends or co-workers. She quickly came to the defense of Nella after the Grease review, was quick to correct anyone who thought Doug was making fun of her abortion in the Christmas special, heavily flamed a troll who put up vicious rumours about Elisa, and when some My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fans came after Allison Pregler because she did not mention the show when she did a review on an old made-for-tv My Little Pony movie, Lindsay had this to say:
Lindsay: Guys. It ain't that they're grown men watching a cartoon. Good on 'em. It's that they're crazy obsessive and trying to spread the goddamn gospel, like crazies on the corner. THEY WILL NOT SHUT UP AND LEAVE US WHO DO NOT GIVE A SHIT ALONE. People inform me that I should be glad because it's a show made for girls that doesn't suck and has mass appeal. I might have been interested, but Jesus Christ, you people, BACK OFF. I'm with Lupa; if there was a shit to be given, my box of shits have long run dry, as has my box of fucks. I am out of fucks to give. You guys can have your fucking show. Please don't assume that anyone else gives a fuck about it, lest the backlash get backlashier. Let me reiterate in case I was not clear, for apparently clarity is not my strong suit. It's not that it's grownups watching cartoons. It's that (some of) you are crazy, tunnel-visioned, DEFENSIVE (did I mention defensive? God, if there's one trait that grates on me...) and annoying as hell. Sane ones, if you exist, tell your crazy friends to shut the fuck up. Stop being so goddamn defensive. Enjoy your goddamn show; leave us out of it. Jesus.
- Manipulative Editing: In The Fifth Element, a lot of Leeloo's more badass scenes aren't shown because that would ruin the Real Women Don't Wear Dresses joke.
- Manly Tears: "Bruce Willis cries like George Washington. Those aren't tears, that's just testosterone overflowing through his eyes."
- Mars Needs Women: "Everyone wants to get into Thumbelina's tiny cotton panties. Frogs, beatles, fleas, lican, the Dark Lord Xenu, dark matter... everyone. And she's a pretty passive player in all of this."
- Meaningful Name: Nomi Malone in Showgirls. "Geddit? No-Mi I'm alone. Genius!" Said with almost manic sarcasm.
- Mega Twintails: Andrew Dickman's splash art for the videos draws her pigtails as huge and puffy.
- Memetic Badass: In-Universe. Every time she says James Cameron, a choir pops up.
- Men Are Generic, Women Are Special: Mocked hard in the Critic/Chick duet. Chick gets more to say about her gender stereotypes, but Critic has the last word with "stiiiiiill got that peeeeenis!"
- Men Are the Expendable Gender: She notices that only the men get their hearts ripped out in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom.
- Men Buy from Mars, Women Buy from Venus: Mel Gibson is able to read girl thoughts from a bath filled with feminine hygiene products, so she's able to read boy thoughts from a bath with junk food, beer and a lad's mag.
- Men Don't Cry: She did call Goliath a pansy for his "My... angel of the night" line, after all.
- Mid-Review Sketch Show: To the point where it's actually rather weird to see her doing a straightforward review now.
- A Mind Is a Terrible Thing to Read: She looks ready to kill herself in frustration when she kidnaps Todd again and listens to his brain, only to find out the only thing in there is Lupa.
- Minor Flaw, Major Breakup: In Sleepless In Seattle vs. When Harry Met Sally, she calls snoring in bed a deal-breaker. In the next episode, the Disposable Fiancé is allowed to be disposed because he's political. She'd also break up with a guy if he let himself grow too much body hair.
- Misaimed Fandom: Pointed out In-Universe.
- She joins the long list of people who point out the flaws in Taylor Swift's logic in "Love Story":
- Misaimed Marketing: As it completely goes against the original message, all the tie-ins to The Lorax get a lot of time devoted to how stupid they are.
- Missing Mom: She theorizes that the Disney company usually commits matricide right after their hero/ine is born.
- In Pocahontas: "And if you're wondering where her mother is, just remember that this is a Disney movie, and Disney movies have... PUPPIES!."
- Misplaced Wildlife: There are no moose in Southeast Virginia.
- Mr. Seahorse: Gleefully got the Critic pregnant through fairy magic in the FernGully: The Last Rainforest review.
- Mood Dissonance: On the Mood Whiplash-ing song in Mulan:
"We were too busy being outrageously horny to notice the smoky red sky of decimation in the distance."
- Mood Whiplash: the TLC video, just the TLC video, damn!
- In The Hunchback of Notre Dame, to demonstrate how Disney held themselves back from brilliant darkness by way of the gargoyles, she edits together Frollo being judged by the eyes of Notre Dame followed by the statues clicking their fingers in "A Guy Like You", and "Hellfire" to all the pop culture references.
- Money, Dear Boy: She's visibly distressed when she discovers George Carlin did the voice of the misanthrope ape in Tarzan II.
- This was the theory of Todd and Lindsay to try and explain all the cameos of talented people in the Transformers III movie.
- Moral Event Horizon: Parodied In-Universe with this:
[over the phone] I don't know what's going on where you are, but here in Minnesota there's pandemonium everywhere, everything is falling apart, and the big ball of twine is on fire!!!
- Moral Luck: She discusses this when reviewing Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings movies; particularly the risk (at the time) of making three high-budget, three-hour-long movies instead of two like most studios wanted, and the way they chose to portray Gollum. While beloved now, she makes it clear that mainstream audiences at the time could have very easily not been interested in a big-budget High Fantasy Trilogy and/or detested Gollum, so the same filming and characterization choices praised now would have been reviled.
Chick (regarding Gollum)
: A hair in either direction and we'd have another Jar-Jar Binks
on our hands.
- Most Writers Are Adults: Comes up in her reviews of City of Angels and The Christmas Shoes, her theory for this being the innocent, mature, perfect children there are how the writers want children to act.
- The Mountains of Illinois: Discussed in her very first review, Pocahontas; she's baffled by all the sheer cliffs in the area around Jamestown.
Nostalgia Chick: Have these people ever been to coastal Virginia?
- Musical Episode: Her review of Les Misérables ended with the entire TGWTG team singing "One More Day".
- In Grease, they break into "You're The One That I Want".
- And The Little Mermaid ends with the TGWTG girlsnote singing (except for Nella, who is voiceless and just mimes) "Part of Your World".
- My Friends... and Zoidberg: While talking about the design of Pocahontas:
Nostalgia Chick: And this can possibly attributed to the fact that her design was based on the looks of models such as Naomi Campbell, Christy Turlington, Barbie... and Janice from the Muppets.
- My Little Phony: Nella's Epic Poney Soap Opera. It contains a Bastard Boyfriend Anti-Villain Domestic Abuser, an inevitable saintly wife who is The High Queen and a Love Martyr to boot, a naive innocent woobish son with a few schoolfriends with disabilities and a schoolteacher who is also "sometimes a whore, but one with a heart of gold".
- Narm: Pointed out In-Universe.
- She's pretty shocked over the "They're not like you and me, which means they must be evil!" line in Pocahontas.
- She also doesn't seem to think much of Demona's "The access code is... alone" line in Gargoyles while talking about her in her "Top Eleven Villainesses" countdown.
- All the so-called "angst" in Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas comes off as emo to her.
- The death scene in The Man in the Iron Mask reminds her of the intentionally silly death in Megamind.
- "Beneath A Moonless Sky" from Love Never Dies is the funniest thing ever because it takes itself so seriously.
- Narrative Filigree: There's been a lot of character moments (for everyone, not just Chick) that are just there to be what they are, not necessarily to be expanded upon later.
- Nature Abhors a Virgin: "Fucking virgins! Why do we need them around anyway?"
- Needs More Love: The in-universe purpose of her three-part look on the Oscar shorts, a lot of which were better than some of the feature-length nominations.
- Never Live It Down: Lampshaded hilariously in the "NChick Labs". "We do not talk about the rape rap!"
- When Dark Nella starts reviewing TRON, the Chick says that reviews of sci-fi movies never go down well, "At least, not for me."
- Pushing Up Roses recalls that too: "Between The Little Mermaid and Dune, it's a wonder you're still alive!"
- She plays the "I'm so excited!" scene from Saved by the Bell a few times in the Showgirls review, mostly to remind us that Elizabeth Berkley has always sucked as an actress.
- Never Trust a Trailer: When learning that Xanadu had robots and ELO, she was pretty excited. Obviously, her hopes were dashed.
- She also talks about this in the "Disney Vs. Dreamworks" video, how "serious" animated movies will have a fun, feisty trailer to draw people in.
- The "Dark Nella Saga" trailer led viewers to assume that Dark Nella was going to be a clone created by Dr. Tease. In the X-Men review, however, the Chick vetoes the cloning plan and Dark Nella is actually the real Nella resurrected.
- Never Work with Children or Animals: In the Milo And Otis episode, she explains the logic behind this trope, namely that it's less about kids and animals being uncooperative and more about them needing special supervision and care and having lots of rules about what you can and can't do with them.
- Nightmare Fuel: Pointed out In-Universe.
- Nice Job Breaking It, Hero!: On Kirk in the second Star Trek movie:
Chick: How about your hubris leading to the untimely death of your best friend that will plague your smarmy ass with regret?
- "No. Just... No" Reaction: She shakes her head with a Death Glare when Nella tries "sexy dice".
- Non-Singing Voice: She's quick to notice that the grandmother's gritty voice in Mulan becomes much softer and higher when she's singing.
- Noodle Incident: In The Stinger for Daria, the Chick kills Nella and Elisa's excitement for Magfest by saying they're not allowed to go onstage because there was an unfortunate incident with a guy and he doesn't want them near him.
- Nothing Is Scarier: Just before Dark Nella makes her first appearance, the sound and background gets all out of focus and you can see someone following the Chick.
- Nostalgia Filter:
- Played with in the X-Men review. Whenever she has to smash the filter and talk about the show's problems, she'll be her usual self. When she's fangirling, she falls right in.
- She says people switch off their brains even more when it comes to Christmas songs.
- On Transformers: The Movie:
"Yeah, I know, people are really attached to this movie, but that is that whole purpose of lifting nostalgia goggles, is it not? I mean, the show is usually watchable at times and sometimes even enjoyable in its campiness. This movie? Less so."
- She believes that the status of Reality Bites and RENT as Generation X cultural touchstones pretty much disqualifies people who grew up in The '90s from complaining about millennials being "entitled".
"God, [the film adaptation of RENT
] wakes the inner, walker-wielding granny in me, yelling at these kids to Get Off My Lawn
. And these damn kids are from the generation before
- No Swastikas: The title card for Der Fuhrers Face has the Chick in the position of Donald Duck with his costume on, but the middle of the armband (where the swastika would be) is hidden by her pigtail.
- "Not Making This Up" Disclaimer:
- In her Transformers: The Movie review, points out that, yes, girly shows really had character names like that, and that the point of the movie was to kill off the old cast to make way for the new.
- "Top Eleven Villainesses": she adds "No, really" after she says Ursula's design was based on a drag queen.
- In her Showgirls review, she subtitles the first reenactment scene with the line "actual dialog from the movie."
- "Top Ten Boy Bands of the 90s": Chick reels off a list of boy bands that existed during the decade and then states, "Guess which one of those I made up." The caption then says, "Hint: None of them."
- Also, when she talks about 2ge+her, the Affectionate Parody, she then says the only way to tell that they're a parody is due to the involvement of Kevin Farley.
- No Yay: Pointed out In-Universe.
Nostalgia Chick: Is she your daughter or your estranged ex who lost a lot of weight?
- Neutral Female: In The Lorax, she has a quick bitch about Taylor Swift not being able to plant the seed herself for... whatever reason.
- Nuns Are Funny: The whole premise for the Sister Act review.
- N-Word Privileges: Parodied in her review of Song of the South. Before she can get out the name-drop of Magical Negro, Nella (dressed like a stereotypical black maid) cover it up with the hoover. Chick complains that "[we're] not even allowed to use that now?" and Nella snidely repeats "we?".
- Of Corset Hurts: When the Makeover Fairy tries to get Nella into a corset, Nella understandably tells her how much she hates her right now.
- Of Corsets Sexy: Team chick like wearing corsets and bustiers sometimes, best paired with feather boas.
- Oh, Crap!:
- Nella gets a particularly muggy one on her face whenever she sees the Makeover Fairy nowadays.
- The Chick gets one where she realizes she's sung "Part Of Your World" way too enthusiastically for someone who can't stand the movie.
- Older Than They Think: Nella points out the "attitude" in direct competition with Disney goes back to the Looney Tunes shorts vs. the Classic Disney Shorts long before DreamWorks Animation existed.
- Ominous Latin Chanting: "DARK NELLAAAAAAAAAA!"
- One Head Taller / Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: Nostalgia Chick (5'2") and Todd in the Shadows (6')
- One-Winged Angel: In "Top 11 Disney Deaths", she gives the advice not to turn into a giant reptile as it never works.
- One True Pairing: The Chick has this opinion about Merry and Éowyn in The Lord of the Rings.
: Did you just spend most of this review
defending your One-True Ship?
- Ooh, Me Accent's Slipping: Lindsay usually talks in a fairly standard accent, but traces of a Dixie accent appear from time to time, especially when she gets excited (she was born in Tennessee).
- Organ Theft: Apparently the Chick's computer cost three organs on the black market. It's probably best not to think about who she got them from or how.
- Origins Episode: Not a video, but a blog post tells how Lindsay, Nella and Elisa ("Lisa") met in a Fanfiction.Net chatroom dedicated to The Phantom of the Opera.
- Our Nudity Is Different: In her review of Kate & Leopold, she lists "can't show your ankles" as one of the problems with Leopold's time period.
- Out of Focus: In her Babysitters Club review, she notes that Jessi, by complete coincidence!, is the only girl without a subplot. After a few less-than-stellar lines, however, she admits that this was probably a good thing.
- Overly Long Gag: "OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO..."
- Overly Narrow Superlative: She describes Bratz as "the worst, most racist movie that stars Jon Voight, came out in the summer of 2007 and was based on a line of toys." And yet it was still a Bait and Switch of Transformers, especially after mocking Michael Bay for three successive videos.
- Overshadowed by Awesome: In the Les Misérables commentary, Lindsay and Elisa talk about how Paw had the misfortune to be have a cold and to be coming on at the same time as Doug.
- Overused Running Gag: "PUPPIES!" was put to sleep after her countdown of animated villainesses.
- Painting the Medium: In the X-Men The Animated Series review, without Nella the Chick's reviewing style becomes overly dull and analytical, which is shown by the video being washed out and lower quality. As soon as Dr Tease injects her with Truth Serum to liven it up, it goes into full colour and higher quality.
- Padding: She sees both Spice World and Xanadu as being filled with it:
Nostalgia Chick: For the love of God! Cut half of this shit out, guys, c'mon!
Chick: Cos every movie needs an aliens-watching-TV scene.
- Pandering to the Base: Self-admitted. Lindsay has said that after Jem she stopped taking requests and that show in particular she just did to shut people up.
- Papa Wolf: Because of the Fan Dumb in the Comically Missing the Point example above, Mr. Ellis got involved to confirm that his daughter is an awesome woman and that she and Nella are best friends.
Probably the #1 fan of the "NOSTALGIA CHICK", for I go back farther than anyone else knowing her, for I helped "make" her some 26 years back. You guessed it, I am her dad. James Carroll Ellis. Since leaving home for NYU, and then on to USC, I have watched her mature into a young adult while establishing a wonderful fan base and friends, which is deeply appreciated and I simply say "Thank You". Her talents are obvious, having many, just like her ol dad. As for NELLA, SWEET, SWEET, NELLA, Lindsay and Nella, (Antonella) have been and are the best of friends. Any remarks, suggestions, and/or references to her were done as a professional actor, and certainly no malice was intended. She (Nella) has visited our home many times, and she is a superb beautiful human being. The world would be a better place with more NELLAS.
- Paper-Thin Disguise: Mocked in the Mulan review:
Just put your hair back up, it's like the gender equivalent of Clark Kent's glasses
- Parental Neglect: She theorizes that Thumbelina's mother just lets her get into trouble because she's bitter that she got the short end of the stick.
- Like so many others, she wonders where Beast's parents are when he's a teenager on Christmas.
- Parody Commercial: Because of all the Product Placement in You've Got M@il, she does her own commercial of her Visa Credit Card.
- Passing the Torch: Nostalgia Critic tells her she must carry on the nostalgia lineage when he forces her into reviewing Cutthroat Island after he merges with the plot hole in To Boldly Flee.
- "Nostalgia monopoly, suckas!"
- Periphery Demographic: Pointed out In-Universe on Dragonheart - "Let's face it, we're all here for Connery."
Chick: But you saw it. You know you saw it.
- Perverse Sexual Lust: With All Women Are Lustful in full force, plenty of it going around:
- In the Top 10 Hottest Animated Guys video, we get good details on the three leading ladies' animated hottie preferences: Elisa likes them stoic and brooding like Goliath and Batman, Nella just goes crazy over Thomas and Dmitri (the latter partly because he resembles the former), and Chick has had childhood crushes on Aladdin and... Batty.
- Both the Chick and Maven drool over Will Smith.
- Pet Homosexual: She basically demands Rantasmo be one of these to her. He grudgingly obliges. ".....gurrrrrrl!"
- This is from the Disney Needs More Gay Characters episode and is played to make a point. Chick believes she is entitled to a "sassy gay best friend", but when she tries to have girl talk with him, he tries to change the subject to more relevant gay issues.
- Petting Zoo People: "Why does Mirage have a cat head? Who cares?"
- Pink Means Feminine: Loves to complain about this. "Because she's PAAAAANK!"
- Please Don't Leave Me: Referenced at the end of the first "Thanks For The Feedback". Critic's had a Am I Just a Toy to You? breakdown and stormed off, Chick's ran away in relief but then "baby come back, you can blame it all on me, I was wrong..." starts playing when they're both offscreen.
- Plot Armor: Nella concedes that Kirk always got out alive and everyone else died because he was the main character.
- Plot Hole: In her review of She-Ra: Princess of Power - "By the honor of plot holes, I have the Plot Device!"
- Trying to figure out all of the ones in Hercules drives her crazy.
- Political Correctness Gone Mad: Disney changing the design and name of the lead in The Princess and the Frog.
- On A Fairytale Of New York:
In a holiday so filled with pretense, it's nice to have a song that lets us use words like “slut”, “bum”, “faggot” and so on.
- Poor Communication Kills: The Grease 2 makeover only happened because the Makeover Fairy thought she was getting Todd the right manliness level for the Chick, and Todd thought she was getting him perfect for Lupa.
- Poor Man's Substitute:
- Elton John? Well there's always Barry Manilow.""Can't afford to get
- She calls Tim Curry the poor man's bad guy in all things.
- Porky Pig Pronunciation: She chokes on the word "nice" in her "Top Five Least Worst Disney Sequels", so settles for "less mean".
- The Power of Friendship: The only plus she can give the Spice Girls is at least they were marketed on them being friends.
- The Power of Rock: From the "Top Ten Songs About Fucking":
Chick: And I think what we've learned from this is that, music can have an effect on people, it sways their mind, feeds their libido, sways their emotions.
- Power Perversion Potential: She theorises about the possible unmentioned extensions of Dragonheart's "dragon and human share their pain" plot.
- Precious Puppies: "Puppies!" ("YAAY!")
- And is there a puppy more precious than Mignon, Chick's Boston terrier? Try watching a video featuring her without gushing.
- Present Company Excluded: After calling pugs barely even dogs, she hugs her Boston terrier (who she dressed up as a princess) and reassures her that she's not a pug.
- Pretty Fly for a White Guy: The rap sequences of Teen Witch.
- When she's calmed down from the unholy terror that is Shark Tale, we get this lovely quote:
''This is what happens when white shut-ins try to be hip... and do so with fish."
- Primal Scene: Two unseen people creaking the bed is what gives "Baby Scarred For Life" her name.
- Product Placement:
- On the McDonalds in The Fifth Element: "Why do I suddenly want french fries?"
- "Identify with this product, little girls. Be a Jem girl."
- In What Women Want, she visibly drinks alcohol and eats chips while wondering why every movie lead is now an ad exec.
- Likewise, she opens the You've Got M@il review with a glowing endorsement for Starbucks coffee liqueur - "providing my stimulants and my depressants in one useful dose." The credits feature "I except my check any day, Starbucks."
- Pseudo Crisis: Played for laughs in her review of Anastasia:
Chick: [very seriously] Hi, I'm your Nostalgia Chick. And my glasses have been taken by communists.
* scary music plays*
Chick: [with glasses on again] But it's okay because I got new ones.
- Punctuated! For! Emphasis!: "The. Spice. Must. Flow."
- On X-Men 3: "FUCK. THAT. MOVIE."
- Nella in Grease 2: "I! Deserve! Better!"
- On Disney sequels: "BRAND. NAME. RECOGNITION."
- In Pocahontas: "Blow. Shit. Up".
- Puny Humans: Dark Nella is not very impressed with us. Watching TRON does nothing to heighten her opinion of the human race.
- Purity Sue: Points out In-Universe that Cinderella's traits are just that she's nice and pretty.
- Rape Portrayed as Redemption: Inverted. To finally get over her rape by him from three years ago, she rapes Spoony and tells him to "cry it out bitch" when he's having a breakdown about it.
- Raised Catholic: Her parents had lots of horror stories to tell her about eraser-throwing, ruler-whipping demon nuns in the classroom.
- A Rare Sentence: Team NChick's Elisa tweeting about her role as Dr. Tease:
I never thought I'd see the day when I received an email from my mother with the subject line 'Your "death" by the evil intergalactic clone'.
- Reality Subtext: What drives half of the humor in the Chick -> Todd storyline In-Universe. In real life they're a sickeningly adorable couple, in-show she's hopelessly deluded that he'll one day love her back.
- Really Gets Around: The Chick says Kirk is just a manwhore who would stick his peepee into anything with a hole in it.
- Red Eyes, Take Warning: She makes a Running Gag of freaking out at one of the My Little Ponies having red eyes.
"And what's with your demon eyes?!"
- Reed Richards Is Useless: In her review of Teen Witch, the Chick points out Louise could use her magic powers to fix the world but instead uses it on petty gain.
- Rhymes on a Dime: As it's based off Dr. Seuss, the beginning and end of her review of The Lorax, the latter promoting the merits of drinking until you puke.
- Rooting for the Empire: In-Universe. The good guys are so insufferable in Hercules that she wants Hades to win.
- Rule-Abiding Rebel: Her video on RENT sees her discussing the phenomenon of "bourgeois theatre", specifically the youth-oriented "we have been left behind by the system" musicals that have proliferated on Broadway since The '60s. In her argument, while they purport to be countercultural, their values tend towards the middle-class status quo upon further examination, serving mainly to validate the views of their mostly Bourgeois Bohemian audiences rather than challenge them. She segues from there into Augusto Boal's Marxist concept of the "theater of the oppressed", which argues that, barring a genuine revolution to break the dominance of the ruling class over access to media, the Rule-Abiding Rebels are the only members of the counterculture who can possibly get their works disseminated to a mainstream audience. In addition to the subject of the episode, she also cited Les Misérables and Hamilton as examples of bourgeois theatre, though she comes down substantially harder on RENT for doing this because, while Les Mis and Hamilton were honest about being such, RENT explicitly positions itself in opposition to the values of the culture around it and yet fails to walk the walk.
- Rule of Funny
- Running Gag: ... because, well, her Labyrinth review has a literal one across the bottom of the screen.
- In her video on The Smurfette Principle, "And she's PAAAAANK!"
- Referred to in "The NChick Labs". The Makeover Fairy shouts "PAAAAANK! PAAAAANK!"
- "Say that again.", generally followed by massive violence.
- She also has "PUPPIES!"
- BIG LIPPED ALLIGATOR MOMENT! (Pointed out In-Universe.)
- The Xanadu review has it keep coming back again and again, despite her yelling at it not to.
- It's only a model.
- "That's what she said."
- Thrusting her hips every time there's a rape implication in what she's reviewing.
- Going into Perverse Sexual Lust-induced bliss whenever there's a good male singer.
- She has, on more than one occasion, referred to breasts as tracts of land.
- Tracing a tear down her cheek whenever there's a scene she perceives as narm.
- Dark Nella stuffing her in the fridge at the end of the episode looked to be heading this way, but didn't make it to the Rule of Three.
- A soundbite of children going "YAY!".
- In her Hocus Pocus review, Dramatic Thunder happening every time she says the word "virgin".
- In Mulan: "Horrific implication time!"
- Smiling wildly while holding two thumbs up, done either genuinely or sarcastically.
- In the VLogs, they use JewWario's "I like it!" from Kickassia a lot.
- She has a counter for the amount of deaths in Transformers: The Movie.
- Repeating really stupid lines in slow motion so she can react to them properly. For example: "They're not like you and me, which means they must be evil!", "Everyone got AIDS and shit!" and "Ursula's crazy sister!".
- Happens more in crossovers and yearly specials, but she'll be disinterestedly drinking something or playing on her phone any time something "important" happens.
- Drinking a cup of coffee that didn't exist in the previous shot.
- Phelous will always come in when she needs a brilliantly silly singing or announcing voice.
- Inserting sad or smiley faces into usually horrific pictures of history.
- John Malkovich as a very unsatisfied customer dining at the Olive Garden and overpronouncing everything he says.
- Using classical music as deliberate Soundtrack Dissonance for when the Chick is really speechifying.
- In her Lord of the Rings movie reviews, FORCED PEEJ CONFLICT and the Frodo Fall Counter, the latter of which happens so many times in each film that it might as well be an intentional running gag.
- In “True Lies”, snarking on her stalker ex “Gary” who works in the NSA and monitors her illegally.
- Russian Reversal: "In Soviet Russia, Chick remembers you!"