Nightmare Fuel / Total Drama
aka: Total Drama Island

The Nightmare Fuel page is for post-viewing discussion, so all spoilers are unmarked per wiki policy.

Note to editors: Nightmare Fuel has long been subject to rampant misuse, so be sure your example actually qualifies. Valid examples are things that continued to affect the troper posting the example after said troper finished consuming the work. Don't post things that merely scared characters in-universe, might be scary to someone else, or involved phobia objects. Anything that's Played for Laughs is unlikely to qualify. No speculation or hypotheticals, please.

Adding dubious examples in a misguided attempt to make a work look Darker and Edgier than it is only makes the troper community look easily frightened.
The Ridonculous Race has its own page.

    open/close all folders 

  • Cody's weird stretchy expressions. The face he makes whenever he's flirting with Gwen makes him look like a rapist. The way his mouth stretches and the gap in his teeth goes all huge and his eyes go small.

  • In "Who Can You Trust?" one of the challenges was to prepare fugu blowfish sushi and give it to a teammate without poisoning them. As it was, Trent made the mistake of allowing Lindsay to prepare the sushi for him. After eating a blob of what was left of the blowfish, he fell down, started to puke, and turned blue. As if that wasn't bad enough, the next thing we see is Chef in a nurse's uniform about to give him CPR, then the screen goes black and all we can hear is Trent dry heaving.
  • Izzy's swelled-up face after her poison ivy spa treatment in that episode. She's barely recognizable as human.

  • Kelsey from the Aftermath shows just how obsessive with Trent she is. Not to mention her poem...
    "Your hair is black...
    My heart is blue...
    I'll stuff you with rags...
    And sew you up too!"

    World Tour 

    Revenge of the Island 
  • Dakota turning into a mutated monster, with plenty of Body Horror to spare. While it can be debated that the other contestants, such as Alejandro and Ezekiel deserved their fates, her only crime was being a bit of an Attention Whore. Most of the time, she's actually Spoiled Sweet.
  • Scott's fate near the end of the season. He has a toxic marshmallow burn into him after his elimination is announced and ends up covered in a cast on the catapult with Fang the shark, who was eager to maul him all season. The next time he is seen he's placed in a machine, and he can't move or speak.reference to  Similar to Alejandro, his condition also appears to leave him far from recovery. Although by the next season, he's fully recovered.

    All Stars 
  • Alejandro got so injured in the 'World Tour' final that he needed mechanical assistance to survive and recover; at 'All Stars' first episode, we realize he had been inside that robotic suit for A WHOLE YEAR. Did his parents know where he was the whole time? And if they did, they even care? Probably not if they allowed their son to spend a whole year in these conditions.
    • Chris mentions that the communication chip broke while he was in prison, leaving Alejandro trapped, alone and unable to speak for as long as several months.
  • Without Cody around, Sierra is losing what's left of her sanity, and finds Cameron a suitable replacement, going as far as imagining Cameron with Cody's aspect. After a full episode of being in very good terms with her, Cameron starts fearing Sierra, knowing already about her stalker-ish ways and how far she can go with them. Later on, she acts more and more delusional even when Cameron's on the other team.
  • Ezekiel is back on the island, and with a murderous vendetta against Chris, who, at the end of 'Zeek and Ye Shall Find', ends terrified of him. Even if this can be seen as karmic retribution from all the stuff Chris did to him (he even mentions them in this episode), the point is that now there's a feral killer on the loose, and one that still conserves enough human-like intelligence to set up a trap and capture those who might try rescue his prey. Zeke also has acidic spit, thanks to the toxic waste exposure.

    Pahkitew Island 
  • Chris' Perpetual Smiler face in "Blast From The Past"
  • Scarlett Fever, through and through.
    • The entire island going haywire and almost self-destructing.
    • The robot animals under the island, with glowing red eyes and parts of their "skin" missing.
    • Scarlett pretending to still be on the other contestants' sides in order to trick them into entering a room full of Chris-bots (which are creepy enough by themselves), where she promptly traps them in.

Alternative Title(s): Total Drama Island