When Nightmares are the Monster of the Week
, you WILL have horror by the bucketful.
- Everything the Smooze does.
- On that note, each nightmare the Mane cast has is made of this.
- A Blank Story – Part 1 and 2 Zomponies! and Grey Hoof's ultimate punishnment
- The song from "Melody of Agony – Part 1 and 2" To clarify: Anyone known for their loyalty, such as Rainbow Dash, suffers tremendous terror and pain just from hearing it. When it plays again, everyone affected suffers so much agony they're forced into a coma, the song strong enough to start to affect RED Sniper in the other world. And when it plays a third time, everyone affected falls under a suggestion that they have to kill whomever or whatever they were loyal to end the pain. This creates such delightful scenes such as Apple Bloom trying to kill her fellow Crusaders, Spike trying to kill Twilight Sparkle, BLU Sniper trying to kill his teammates, Mayor Mare trying to burn Ponyville down, Luna leading a second coup against Celestia, Mrs. Cake trying to murder her children while begging her husband to stop her...
- "Tick tick, goes the clock..." Doctor Whooves Painful Transformation. Minuette/Riversong, experiencing the the last few minutes of life of every version of herself that died a horrible, agonizing death, ones that she didn't regenerate from, at the same time, on eternal repeat. Demo experiencing every time he died and forgeting each time he survived. Applejack having to live out Pinkie and Twilight bad dreams, both as vitcim and victimizer.
- Slenderman,a Nigh Invulnerable Eldritch Abomination with Mind Rape powers. There is nothing more that needs to be said about him. Team RED was lucky that the RED Medic was able to use The Power of Friendship and Kindness (thourgh Sasha).
- And now, the Slenderman of their world might have taken notice. Fun times
- Chapter 20, Good Lord.
- The revelation that Discord is terrified of Slendermane.
- Celestia being mind-controlled by Slendermane into possibly committing murder.
- Gray Mann's deal with this world's Slenderman.
- Christian Brutal Sniper, the physical embodiment of Sniper's darkest fantasies and self-loathing.
- Nightmare Gardener, made from poor sweet and kind Cheerilee.
- Essentially any time a TF2 Freakshow appears is going to be this... unless it's PAINis Cupcake.
- A recent chapter has Vagineer and Heavydile menacing the RED team alongside Christian Brutal Sniper. To say nothing of the fact that there are now FIVE Nightmares facing off against the citizens of Ponyville...