Nightmare Fuel / Harry Potter
aka: Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix

Harry Potter: I'm scared, professor.
Professor Lupin: Well, I'd consider you a fool if you weren't.

Harry Potter... it's just a series of books about a boy going to wizard school, right? Totally kid friendly, right? It's late, but give it a read anyway...

Spoilers abound. You have been warned.

Novels (and films) with their own pages

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
Ladies and Gentlemen: Lord Voldemort. At least until the fourth movie.
  • The first book is mainly safe-for-reading by innocent souls, but there is a horrifying vision at the end, with Voldemort physically inhabiting Quirrell as a parasite - his face protrudes from the back of Quirrell's skull. The video game version is even worse. Here, Quirrell twists his head around so Voldemort is facing Harry directly.
  • Harry's in the library late at night and opens a book. It SCREAMS AT HIM! It's like a disembodied head is trying to escape from the book, wide-mouth yelling the entire time. And, if unintentionally, it serves to foreshadow another situation where Harry encounters another face that's somewhere that isn't supposed to have a face.
  • An auditory example of this trope is the incredibly creepy music that plays in the background of the "restricted section" library sequence. Try listening to that track of the film's score in a dark room...
  • The scene near the beginning in which Dudley falls into the snake's enclosure as Aunt Petunia freaks out and Harry chuckles... but then, Harry notices Uncle Vernon glowering down at him with a nasty Death Glare of utter contempt, and all of a sudden, Harry's face looks stricken, as he imagines how he's going to be punished.
  • Quirrell feeding off the dead unicorn in the forest. When he notices Harry and Draco, he growls and slithers towards Harry and Draco, looking like a cross between a Dementor and Darth Sidious.
  • The three-headed Cerberus acting as the first line of defense for the Philosopher's/Sorceror's Stone is pretty terrifying, even though it's a good-aligned character.
  • Quirrell being burned alive from Harry's touch. His reaction at the flesh on his hand melting was bad enough, but then there is his scream of agony when Harry uses his newfound power on the guy's face. It's also horrifying when Quirrel's face turns to crumbling stone in a nauseating-looking way- and then his entire body begins to turn to stone, he lumbers and shuffles towards Harry like a zombie with his hand outreached, before collapsing onto the ground as a pile of dust. Brrr...
  • There's also the genuine Adult Fear that is the premise of the book: Harry's parents know that the most deadly wizard of their time is hunting their infant. Even though they do everything they can, they can't stay alive to protect him. And instead of being raised in a loving household, he's given to family, who neglects/abuses him. This is justified later in the series as the Dursley family was the only place where he would be 100% safe from Voldemort or his followers, as Petunia was Lily's last living relative. Harry's Childhood may not have been nice at all but at least he wasn't killed and he was pretty much normal, although raised far away from all the fame.

The Tales of Beedle the Bard

  • "The Warlock's Hairy Heart". A wizard decides he's above the weakness of love, and performs some sort of magic to prevent him from ever loving anyone. He tries to woo a woman to be his trophy wife, but she refuses to marry him unless he shows her that he has a heart. During a feast at his castle, he takes her down to the dungeon to show here where he keeps his ACTUAL, STILL BEATING HEART encased in a crystal casket - a heart which, thanks to lack of love is now twisted and hairy beyond recognition. The witch understandably freaks out and begs him to put the heart back in, so he cuts open his chest and puts it back in. The witch then embraces him. Time for a Happy Ending with the wizard saved by The Power of Love, right? Wrong. The warlock's heart is so completely unused to feeling love that it has deteriorated to an animalistic state, driving the wizard to find a true heart. He does this by cutting out the witch's heart and trying to magic out his own. The dinner guest then find him downstairs both hearts in his hands with him licking the witch's heart. In the liner notes, Dumbledore even points out that many wizard parents won't tell it to their children "until they're in an age where they won't have nightmares".

Pottermore stories

  • From the story of the founding of the Ilvermorny school of witchcraft and wizardry.
    " - Chadwick’s dreams had been haunted by the figure of an old witch creeping through the trees towards Ilvermorny. Now he saw his nightmare made true."

Alternative Title(s): Harry Potter And The Philosophers Stone