Turbulent Priest

http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/tvtropes-turbulent_priest_33.jpg

"Who will rid me of this turbulent priest?"

An Evil Empire, Repressive Dictator, Government Conspiracy or even a Corrupt Corporate Executive has sinister plans. Where will the hero find an ally? In The Church.

A Turbulent Priest is a member of the clergy who will resist the plans of somebody with power. Usually their fight is with a secular authority who threatens the Church or general morality, but struggles against other clergy attempting to subvert what the Church stands for is just as viable a cause.

This trope can be depicted in either a positive or a negative light. If the Turbulent Priest is portrayed as in the right, his opponent is usually interested in money or power, and will quite gladly engage in animal cruelty and other immoral behavior to get it (sometimes said opponent will also attack the church to try and remove any opposition). They could also just be someone who has money or power and thinks this gives them the right to kick anyone in their way, with this often being Truth in Television regarding such situations. If he's in the wrong, the Secular Authority is generally trying to improve society, and the Priest is afraid of change. The Trope Namer (see below) is actually quite neutral by most understandings.

How the Turbulent Priest conducts himself depends on his rank and standing. If he is the equivalent of a Monk or Parish priest, he may offer sympathies to the hero. If the work is set in The Evil Empire or similar, expect him to be part of La Résistance and usually given more freedom than the average citizen, because the Church retains some power and would not like to see its clergy picked on. If the Turbulent Priest is a bishop or other high-ranking member of the Church, expect him to publicly decry the plans, and encourage resistance. If his beef is with one person, sometimes questioning whether his soul is as safe as he thinks is an effective deterrent. Both styles may overlap with a Badass Preacher or a Church Militant.

Named for Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury, who spent most of his tenure arguing with King Henry II over his plans to exercise increased royal control over the Church in England, leading Henry II to utter the quote at the top of the page. There was no real right or wrong side from a modern perspective, as Henry saw clergy abuse the Ecclesiastical Legal system to escape secular punishment, and Becket saw the sovereignty of the Church as being threatened; in summary, both were convinced the other was going to make a power-grab then abuse that power. Interestingly, what Henry actually said about Becket is not exactly known, though several of his knights apparently took the quote as a royal execution order, and murdered the Archbishop at the altar of his own cathedral, getting their king in trouble with the Pope.

Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Anime and Manga 

    Films — Animated 
  • The Archdeacon of the Cathedral in Disney's The Hunchback of Notre Dame interferes with Judge Frollo's more morally questionable acts, such as drowning babies and violating the sanctuary law. Amusingly, the original Frollo from the book was both a more moral person... and archdeacon of Notre Dame. It's like Disney split him in half and made him fight himself.

    Films — Live-Action 
  • Subverted in the movie Black Death. The young monk is the only man who recognizes that most witch-burnings are the result of hysterical superstition, and initially sides with the villagers against the knights. Then he finds out it's a Village With A Dark Secret...
  • The Tower Guardian Dumont in TRON is a Cool Old Guy who maintains the only free I/O Tower on the system, despite Master Control's persecution of User-Believers. He's on the verge of the Despair Event Horizon, but Tron and Yori convince him to help. After he's captured and facing certain de-rez for his actions, he is remarkably sarcastic and defiant, declaring that Master Control "started small, and will end small!"
  • Subverted in the Movie Dracula Untold. The bearded monk is horrified when he finds out Dracula is a vampire, exposes this to his people and extols Dracula to to cure himself or die. Dracula himself is benevolent and using this power to save his people from the Ottoman Turkish Empire. However, the other vampires he creates are bloodthirsty and malicious as the monk feared, and the monk saves Dracula's son from them by repelling them with a crucifix, leading Dracula to realize how dangerous his vampiric subjects are.

    Literature 
  • Having at the core of its plot a schism between a Corrupt Path of Inspiration and the nation it tried (and failed) to destroy, there is a number of such characters in the Safehold series, such as Charis Archbishop Maikel Staynair and members of the reformist movement within the Church of God Awaiting known as the Circle.
  • Friar Tuck in the Robin Hood legendarium.
  • A Song of Ice and Fire features the "Sparrows", pious knights and peasants who become increasingly angered at the unmitigated atrocities (and general immorality and corruption) occurring across Westeros, eventually leading them to force the installation of one of their number as the new High Septon, who starts out as rather openly condemnatory of the leadership of the realm. Cersei Lannister attempts to placate them by authorizing the restoration of the Church Militant.
    • King Baelor the Blessed from the backstory proves an interesting case. He was an utter pacifist who walked barefoot across the continent to make peace with his elder brother's enemies, and constantly gave away the kingdom's treasury to the poor, but it was only through the political savvy of his machiavellian uncle Viserys that the nobility were kept from rebelling. In The World of Ice & Fire, it is suggested Baelor might have been assassinated because he got in his head that all infidels must be converted, which would have led to a humongous civil war against the Northmen and Ironborn, who practise different faiths from the rest of Westeros. That said, even Baelor backed away from reviving the Faith Militant, so yes even the Befuddled One had more political sense than Cersei.
    • The Red Priests of Rhillor are generally The Fundamentalist advocating extreme solutions and combining faith with sex-positive attitudes and magic. Tyrion sees a Red Priest rally a crowd of slaves in Volantis advocating for the end of slavery and heralding Daenerys as an abolitionist saviour. Tyrion is scared of the religious frenzy this evokes in the crowd leading him to remark:
    Tyrion: Give me priests who are fat and corrupt and cynical, the sort who like to sit on soft satin cushions, nibble sweetmeats, and diddle little boys. It's the ones who believe in gods who make the trouble.
  • Several examples in Mercedes Lackey's Bardic Voices and Valdemar novels.
  • Rosemary Sutcliff got a lot of mileage out of religious conflicts. Fanatical druids stir up anti-Roman revolts in The Eagle of the Ninth and Frontier Wolf; monks bicker with King Arthur in Sword at Sunset; Augustine of Canterbury rocks up to convert the dubious Anglo-Saxon kings in Dawn Wind; zealous Puritans ally with Parliament against King Charles in The Rider of the White Horse and Simon; and Presbyterian Scottish Covenanter priests reject the rule of English kings in We Lived in Drumfyvie and Bonnie Dundee.
  • Philip in The Pillars of the Earth is one. One of his great life goals is to prove that faith and virtue is a more powerful force than violence and wickedness. In the end, he does.
  • In the third Dune book, Children of Dune, a man known only as "The Preacher" pops up on Arrakis condemning the religion of Muad'Dib that the Fremen have set up. Notably, he isn't condemning Muad'Dib himself, but rather the overbearing, controlling religion that has come about since Muad'Dib's death, and many suspect that he's trying to return the Fremen to their previous way of life. The Preacher is Paul-Muad'Dib himself, returning in disguise after everyone believed him dead. He never liked the religion that sprung up around him when he took control of Arrakis, and after some reflection in the desert has committed himself to tearing it down.
  • A villainous example in The Dinosaur Lords with father Tavaros, the Papal Legate (army chaplain) sent to look after spiritual health of Correction Army. In fact, he has a doctrinal feud with this army's commander, and constantly tries to undermine him. He also encourages the more rebellious elements of the army to Rape, Pillage, and Burn, and propagates the "let the gods sort them out" mentality.

    Live Action TV 
  • Jake in All The Small Things introduces sweeping reforms in his church in order to make it relevant to the local community. Needless to say, the traditionalists in the choir and on the parish council aren't happy.
  • One episode of Blackadder I has the title character, the younger son of the king, made Archbishop of Canterbury after his father had the previous one assassinated for being turbulent. Blackadder spends the whole episode trying not to be this trope, even trying to talk a dying nobleman out of leaving all his money to the church. The king celebrates the fact that, unlike Henry II, he will never have to ask "Who will rid me of this turbulent priest?" Unfortunately, a pair of drunken knights overhear part of the conversation and think it means they should go kill the new archbishop.
  • The first and third High Septon as depicted in the TV adaptation of the A Song of Ice and Fire books; Game of Thrones. However, details were changed about the High Sparrow and his order from the book counterparts into a take that against religious fundamentalists.

    Tabletop Games 
  • Necromunda has the Arch Zealot of the Redemption, a completely batshit insane Imperial priest who goes around with his band of fanatics setting fire to heretics. He's so extreme higher-ups in the Redemptionists have put a bounty on his head.
    • The Warhammer 40K short story The Last Church, set before the Great Crusade, features Uriah, the priest who looks after the last church on Terra. He spends the story debating the need for religion with a mysterious stranger who turns out to be the God Emperor of Mankind in disguise. Then he proceeds to call out the Emperor in front of a crowd of Thunder Warriors (prototype Space Marines) and walks back into his burning church to die in the flames.
    • During the Age of Apostasy, the corrupt head of the Ecclesiarchy (and Administratum, and Munitorum) Goge Vandire ruled with an iron fist until he was opposed by a firebrand preacher known as Sebastian Thor. Thor whipped his followers into a frenzy and started a rebellion, which Vandire sent a fleet to crush. The entire battlefleet was obliterated by a Warp storm that was taken to be a sign from the God-Emperor himself, and a full-blown civil war resulted.
    • Implied to be the case with the pre-Fall Eldar, who tried to convince their kin to abandon their debauched ways. Unfortunately, the others disregarded them, resulting in the birth of Slaanesh, the loss of their homeworld and the death of about 90% of their race.

    Video Games 
  • Turbulent Priests tend to pop up a lot in Random Events in Paradox Interactive games, such as Crusader Kings and Europa Universalis. Revolts and / or stability drops tend to follow in their wake, leading to much frustrating head-clutching.
    • In Crusader Kings II, Catholic bishops are Turbulent as long as they like the Pope more than their secular liege. This, by paying taxes to the Pope and withholding levies from their liege.
  • If the respect of the Religion Faction in Tropico 4 drops too low, they'll begin preaching against El Presidente's rule, lowering the opinion of everyone who visits a church (i.e. everybody). In general, priests are troublesome when they get unhappy, because it causes a lot of unrest to spill over if they're executed.
  • In [PROTOTYPE 2] Father Guerra is a close ally of protagonist James Heller through the first part of the game.
  • Mass Effect plays with this in the form of two minor NPC's, a Hanar evangelist and a Turian C-Sec officer. It's a netural situation of Grey and Grey Morality, as the evangelist is preaching in the Presidium, where all preaching is forbidden was a form of religious neutrality, but the C-sec officer is trying to move him along out of bigotry against the Hanar and/or their religion (as he only refers to the evangelist using a racial slur and the religion's he's espousing as "nonsense"). Siding with either, depending on how it's done, can get either Paragon points, Renegade points, both or none.

    Western Animation 
  • One of the Fire Temple's Fire Sages in Avatar: The Last Airbender helps the Gaang gain access to the inner chamber in "The Summer Solstice".
    • As a member of the Order of the White Lotus, Jeong Jeong is this, as is their leader Iroh.

    Real Life 
  • Thomas Becket, as described above.
  • The potential, and actual involvement, of major religious organizations in political matters is one of the main reasons that radical political movements make an effort to curb religious institutions, religious people and/or religion itself on taking power.
    • During The French Revolution, the Catholic Church was the largest landowner in France and in order to reform the economy, the newly formed National Assembly voted to sell Church property (a move supported by soon-to-be-former Bishop, Talleyrand) and most controversially promulgated a Civic Constitution of the Clergy that made the French Catholic Church subservient to the national government, and priests and bishops into government servants. This was seen by French catholics as invasive and threatening to their religion, was denounced by the Pope and directly led to a Civil War in the Vendee.
    • Ironically the same Catholics greatly resented some of the Constitutional Clergy who fell out of favour with the rise of Napoleon Bonaparte (who managed to win a Concordat with the Church to heal religious disputes). From their perspectives, the likes of Abbe Gregoire, a civic clergyman, who advocated abolitionism, clampdown of anti-semitism and also advocated for the preservation of Church monuments and relics during the Revolution, fell into disfavour. Gregoire, a devout Catholic and firm revolutionary, strongly opposed Napoleon's plan to roll-back the Church reform with the Concordat and to the end of his life, even during the Restoration refused to abjure his oath to the discredited Civic Constitution.
    • During Red October, the Russian Orthodox Church was widely despised for its support of the deeply unpopular Tsar, its nasty anti-semitism and opposition of any reforms and revolutions. So naturally, the Bolsheviks felt compelled to suppress the Orthodox Church by promoting state atheism and also supporting minority religions such as Russian Muslims, Jews and Old Believers. This policy ended when Stalin, a centrist made an effort to restore some of the privileges of the battered Orthodox Church, albeit within limits. He especially tapped into this sentiment during World War II, despite being an atheist on a personal level. He also reversed Lenin's policies towards religious minorities.
  • Pope John Paul II actively encouraged the Solidarity movement in Poland, which resisted Communism. Some people credit the man with being a major part in Communism's non-violent downfall.
    • And he was far from being the only one. Father Jerzy Popieluszko was an activist preacher involved in the Solidarity movement, and murdered by the secret police.
      • A fairly large number of Catholic religious officials in Catholic parts of the Soviet bloc (as well as the Russian Empire) were actively involved in activities against the regime. One, Cardinal Slipyj of Ukraine, provided the model for the fictitious Cardinal Lakota in the novel Shoes of the Fishermen.
  • Jaime Cardinal Sin, the Archbishop of Manila, was one of the main figures in the revolution that brought Philippine dictator Marcos down.
  • Two examples from the Catholic Church: One, Cardinal Paulo Evaristo Arns helped save the torture records in the Brazilian dictatorship and store them abroad for later use (as evidence against the torturers, hopefully, but, at the very least, as a registry of that dark period), besides providing aid and abode for those that resisted said dictatorship. He actually managed to copy all or most of the records in a measly 24 hours as well by using the structure of the Church (and against the wishes of its conservative side, which meant he had to do it subtly), making it a Crowning Moment of Awesome. Two, some bishops of the "Sul-1" branch of the Church tried to interfere in the Brazilian presidential elections in 2010, using abortion (changes to abortion laws weren't really being discussed) as an excuse to attack a candidate, ignoring the rules the Church itself set regarding interference in politics in the process. It got bad enough that the Pope became known to some people as the losing candidate's most effective campaign volunteer.
  • Marco Arana in Peru interacting on the behalf of natives against mining companies and other such forces. He even founded a political party! However, this involvement in politics got him expelled from the church. Other priests have also gotten involved but not to the same extent.
  • A minority of priests, Catholic and Protestant, were this to the Nazis. Many preached against the party's actions from the pulpit, while others hid those bound for the camps in their orphanages and abbeys. Several of these priests were caught by the Nazi's and either killed or imprisoned.
    • Catholic cardinals von Preysing and von Galen and Protestant minister Bonhoeffer were determined enemies of the Nazi regime and, as such, were loathed by Hitler who said, "the foulest of carrion are those who come clothed in the cloak of humility and the foulest of these Count Presying! What a beast!". Coming from Hitler, it is a huge compliment to the moral fortitude of these men.
    • Fortunately von Preysling was protected from Nazi retaliation by his high position. Unfortunately his cathedral administrator, confidant and fellow Turbulent Priest Bernard Lichtenberg, was not. Lichtenberg served at St. Hedwig's Cathedral from 1932, and was under the watch of the Gestapo by 1933, for his courageous support of prisoners and Jews. He became a confidante of Bishop von Preysing from 1935. He ran Preysing's aid unit, the Hilfswerke beim Bischöflichen Ordinariat Berlin, which secretly gave assistance to those who were being persecuted by the regime. From 1938, Lichtenberg conducted prayers for the Jews and other inmates of the concentration camps, including "my fellow priests there". For preaching against Nazi propaganda and writing a letter of protest concerning Nazi euthanasia, he was arrested in 1941, sentenced to two years penal servitude, and died en route to Dachau Concentration Camp in 1943.
    • While some have believed that Hitler was Christian, his personal views were complex. He was Raised Catholic, but by the time he was an adult he had a highly syncretized set of personal beliefs. He concluded a Concordat with the Vatican (overseen by Monsignor Pacelli, the future Pope Pius XII) and several Protestant and Catholic priests advocated voting for Nazism over the Social Democrats, but this did not mean he supported Christianity or saw Nazi Culture as Christian. He considered Christian concerns with compassion and charity a significant weakness. Hitler also believed the core values of Nazism – like nationalism, obedience and loyalty to the state – were contradicted by religious teachings. Still the Church was sufficiently powerful that Hitler never made any great campaign to curb or persecute Christians until 1936 onwards, one such instance being that 15,000 Jehovah's Witness were detained in concentration camps where a quarter of them died.
  • Girolamo Savonarola, the 15th-century Florentine preacher, political reformer, and self-proclaimed prophet. He was charismatic enough to have won converts like Sandro Botticelli who willingly burned his own paintings during the Bonfire of the Vanities. It ended however in overall failure because, as Niccolò Machiavelli said, Savonarola was a charismatic but an unarmed prophet and he had no army to enforce his theocracy before his defeat.
  • Son Jong-nam was a North Korean defector and Christian missionary, who died in a Pyongyang prison after being arrested in 2006. In January 1998, Son defected from the tyrannical regime, took his wife and daughter and fled North Korea, joining his brother in Yanji, Yanbian Korean Autonomous Region in northeast China's Jilin province. A South Korean missionary, who lived in the region on the pretext of involvement in the lumber business, sheltered them for some time after their arrival. However, Son's wife died of leukaemia seven months later. Son, distraught, began to grow closer to the missionary, leading to his eventual conversion to Christianity; he then aided the missionaries in converting other North Korea defectors in China. He was arrested by Chinese police and deported back to North Korea in January 2001, where his brother says he suffered electrical shocks and beatings with clubs, causing a limp in his leg and the loss of 32 kilograms (71 lb) of body weight. Son returned to North Korea with Bibles and cassette tapes in an effort to proselytize people in his home country. However, in January 2006, police found the Bibles at his home in Hoeryong and arrested him again. According to his brother, the charges were illegal border crossing, meeting with enemies of the state, and disseminating anti-state literature.
  • Oscar Romero, a Catholic archbishop in El Salvador during the Salvadoran Civil War. He spoke out against the persecution of priests and human rights abuses carried out by the Salvadoran government and was consequently assassinated by a member of a state-sponsored death squad. Currently being considered for sainthood in the Catholic Church, though his cause for canonization has been taking a while.
  • Cardinal Vicente Enrique y Tarancón was despised by the most immovilist elements of the Franco dictatorship to the point of being greeted with the cry ¡Tarancón al Paredón! ("Gun down Tarancón!") at Carrero Blanco's funeral. It should be noted that after Vatican II the Franco dictatorship was a bigger Catholic hardliner than the Vatican itself.
  • In medieval China, a wandering monk named Zhu Yuanzhang put an end to 100 years of Mongol rule in China by himself and seized the throne as the Hongwu Emperor, first of the Ming Dynasty. Since he had been born in a dirt-poor farming family, his is also one of the most epic Rags to Royalty stories ever.
  • Fr. Alexis Toth, a saint in the American Orthodox Church, to the American Catholic Church. Originally an Eastern Catholic priest ministering to Ukrainian immigrants in Minnesota, he was enraged by the way his flock was treated as second class Catholics for following Greek rather than Roman rite. He not only quit Catholicism to join the Orthodox Church, he led many thousands of Eastern European immigrants to follow him as well.
  • The TropeMakers were probably the Biblical prophets, who prophesied against the corruption of the people, the priests, and above all, the kings of Israel and Judah. For example; Moses' opposition of the Pharaoh in the Book of Exodus.
  • Many leaders of the Civil Rights Movement in the U.S. starting in the 1950s were religious leaders, with the most famous examples being Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X. Many leaders in the continuing effort to correct racial injustices in American society today are also religious leaders.
  • Priests following the Liberation Theology loudly protested against Central and South American dictators and some paid for this with their lives.


http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TurbulentPriest