Creed from Black Cat of course. Train tries to beat it into Creed that he is NOT interested in the sword-wielding Stalker with a Crush. The result? Train ends up unknowingly spread-legged on top of Creed, and only realizes too late that Creed got a hard-on and even orgasmed from it all. Disgust and exasperation are pretty much what describe Train's reaction.
Hisoka from Hunter × Hunter. Killua, too. The latter just less extreme than the previous.
Sebastian (in episode 20, anyway), Grell, and The Undertaker from Black Butler.
A demon casts BDSM themed torture spells on the main cast in Dragon Half. This immobilizes everyone except for Rufa, who can't get enough of it.
In one of the early episodes of Excel♥Saga, after getting a blast of high-voltage current from a soldier, Excel requests "A bit higher, please" with a blush. The torturer thinks his gear is malfunctioning and tries it on the unfortunate fellow next to Excel. Said fellow is promptly incinerated.
Lisa, Kosame, and Fukuyama in Girls Bravo. Naturally that makes things difficult for Yukinari, Kirie, and Koyomi, respectively. For example, in one scene Lisa attempts to molest Yukinari but he shoves her so hard in retaliation that she rolls back and slams against a wall, blood squirting from her head. Lisa's response is...to give a huge Slasher Smile, get Glowing Eyes of Doom, and scream "Geez, Yukinari-sama! You're unexpectedly violent! But that's fine, please be more reckless with me!" She then proceeds to chase him again, perfectly content with her arms outstretched for a hug. In another scene Kirie prepares to do her usual wrestling moves on Fukuyama and Kosame immediately hugs her legs saying "AH! Onee-sama! Please do that move on me as well!" And Fukuyama continues to act like a huge pervert towards the girls despite knowing Kirie will just beat the crap out of him for it. In fact, it seems to make him even more willing to act like a pervert towards the girls.
Zigzagged with Buggy from One Piece. Presumably, torture might work on him, just not using sharp objects, seeing as they don't work on him because of his Bara Bara no Mi Devil Fruit power. As a result, he was easily able to survive his incarceration on the first level of Impel Down, because that's exactly how the prisoners on that level were tortured. (For some reason, none of the guards ever noticed that, and neglected to use seastone restrainers on him.)
France too. After his April Fool's rampage, some of his victims capture him and attempt to humiliate him in retaliation... only to find that he actually enjoys most of their punishment. Until Sweden comes up with a Cool and Unusual Punishment, that is.
Ayeka in Tenchi Muyo! tries electro-torture on Ryoko early on in the OVA's. It doesn't quite work as intended. Her lines translate as something along the lines of "Ahh, I'm coming, I'm coming!" (For the record, that's exactly how Pioneer translated it in the official English dub.)
The supplemental material reveals that Ryoko's body isn't capable of feeling much of anything, especially in terms of pleasurable sensations. Then again, thousands of years of only being able to feel pain might have simply led to her liking it because it was better than feeling nothing at all. However, she reacts VERY differently when exposed to the Master Key immediately after the electric shocks. If she HAD been faking, she'd probably just keep doing so.
One of the ninjas in Ninin Ga Shinobuden discovers a new kink as he's getting spanked during one of Miyabi's rampages.
Slan, the only female member of the Godhand from Berserk, definitely qualifies as this. When Guts fights her at one point in the manga, the only thing that he accomplishes by impaling her and blowing off half her torso is giving her an orgasm.
Kurumu: "You act all innocent, but you, Ruby... are kinky!"
She has also likened tying herself up bondage-style to "wrapping the phone cord around your finger when you're bored", and does it with equal frequency. When the Harem was asked what they were to Tsukune (read: what they want to be to him), her immediate response was "toy" (the official Viz translation uses "plaything" as the answer, but the meaning is preserved).
During the Volume 4 omakes the other girls try on the chain and let Tsukune shock them once. Kurumu and Koko hate it, Mizore is on the fence about it, Yukari likes it, and the very last panel has Moka try. Yukari looks on at Moka's reaction and states "Moka is a "yea" for sure!"
Played with in that same instance. Kurumu notices that Ruby is actually badly weakened by the experience (and not in a good way) but is acting otherwise so the team won't worry about her.
When a doppelganger posing as Tsukune gives Ruby what's intended to be a rib-breaking elbow smash, her response is to hug him with a blush of pleasure and beg him to hit her again.
Kakihara in the Ichi the Killer manga might be the very god of this trope. The whole series actually evolves around him pursuing something so insanely hardcore that even he will get off on it. The film downplays this somewhat, but is still an example of the trope.
As part of his Freak Out, Hell Kaiser Ryo from Yu-Gi-Oh! GX is forced to duel while wearing electrodes that shock him whenever he loses life points. At first, he hates them, but once his turn to The Dark Side is complete, he hardly duels without them.
Also, Yubel, who enjoys pain and insults. The only things that can scare them are being separated from the one they loves forever, and the threat of being erased from existence.
It's more than enjoying the pain and insults. Yubel truly believes for most of third season that extreme agony is the only way to express real love. If you don't hurt the person you claim you love, you don't actually love them.
It's implied in an episode of Michiko to Hatchin that Atsuko would become aroused whenever Michiko would beat her up as a child.
Gauron from Full Metal Panic!. Face it — don't even try to torture or threaten him. He likes it. He's so hardcore to the point where he didn't even seem to mind that much that sharks ate his arms and legs, and he lost an eye, being rendered completely immobile. And apparently, even in that sorry state, he's still in the mood to get off on seeing Sousuke's depressed face.
The same goes for the female scientist that Gauron was strangling, as further explained in the novels. They bothseemed to enjoy it, as Gauron even lampshades it by mocking her, asking her if she actually likes making him angry, and actually wants him to hurt her. He says this with a perfect mixture of "coldness and joy," and she responds by gasping with "pain and ecstasy."
Takuma Fudou from Get Backers shows definite signs of being this. He actually enjoys and savors pain during battles, and is shown to start cutting his own chest up while yelling at Ban to "push him to the limit and make him bleed" when Ban doesn't put up enough of a fight. It's even lampshaded by other characters, who mention the stark difference between Fudou and Ban: Fudou lives for the sadomasochistic, bloody sensation of battle, whereas Ban has no such desire and is a cold professional. On another note, although Fudou seems to have carried a huge grudge for Ban ripping his arm off, it's implied that it's not actually the pain that Fudou hated so much as what was likely Ban's attitude when he did it. Fudou even mentions that he kept his rotting, maggot-infested arm with him, and the sensation he felt were "incredible chills rising up his body."
Hidan in Naruto He pretty much orgasmed when he impaled himself, killing Azuma.
Q & R from Seikon No Qwaser run around begging people to order or punish them sadistically, and when they don't consider the response to be enough for them, they "disqualify" their target in a very violent fashion. Even when they did encounter someone who impaled them on copper poles and shocked them to death with electricity, they regenerated and begged for more.
Aoba admitted to Izaya that he's a masochist who is still looking for a special someone to be his sadist.
Konuma Ryuuko and Haguro Dou of Wolf Guy - Wolfen Crest. So much so that it comes as no surprise when it's revealed that they're dating and that they frequently engage in violent sex and hope to do the same to Inugami whom they both lust after.
Ryuuko, however, starts subverting it later. Unlike Haguro, her love for torture does have some small limits...
Rip Van Winkle in Hellsing. During their battle, Alucard grabs Rip by the throat, slowly sticks her rifle through her chest until it comes out the other side of her body in an act of symbolic rape, and then sinks his fangs into her neck. And (in the OVA) how does Rip react to this? By blushing and letting out a series of orgasmic moans.Not helped by Maaya Sakamoto's voice acting. In the manga, the scene is drawn pretty much exactly like a hentai dojin (and Hirano DID quite a bit of those), down to the ridiculously intense blush on Rip's cheeks when Alucard drinks her blood. And her constant wriggling and gasping under his hands as he slowly inserts the rifle through her torso. And no, the rifle doesn't have a bayonet. Alucard just jammed it in, barrel first.
Tatewaki Kuno of Ranma ˝ frequently expresses his affections for Akane and the pig-tailed haired girl by glomping them despite knowing that they always just respond by beating him up or kicking him to the sky. In fact, since it's them beating him up, he seems to enjoy it.
Happosai is confirmed by canon on this, not just speculation. You can't win with that guy - he enjoys both chikan and the consequences, as long as the beatdown doesn't actually put a stop to his scheme.
Belphegor of Katekyo Hitman Reborn!. During their battle, Gokudera manages to hit him with one of his bombs. Belphegor simply sits up while making somewhat orgasmic noises and muttering excitedly "I was hurt again. It's so thrilling!"
Yandere Kanojo: Manabu's little sister Mayami is a masochist who enjoys getting beaten up by Reina.
While her older sister Panty from Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt is the horniest of the duo, Stocking seems to be more of a masochist at nature, getting off on Electric Torture at one point. May be a hint to her true nature... as a demon (if that was her that came back).
The villain Corset is one of these, especially since he's practically the embodiment of BDSM. When he's being trampled to death by Judgement, he screams in ecstasy and begs for more, though he does panic and beg her to stop when he realizes he's about to die.
Kou of Monochrome Factor. In the anime adaptation, he's implied to have a bit of a bondage fetish, present for no other reason than to creep Aya out after she beats him up and he begs for more.
In the first chapter of Hekikai No Aion, Minato warns Tatsuya about not messing around with Seine because he thinks she is a masochist that likes being bullied.
Hilariously "enforced" by Seine to keep Tatsuya out of her neck.
Yuki's father in Mirai Nikki once begged Minene to keep kicking him.
Minako Aino in Sailor Moon. When someone looks in your Dream Mirror you usually faint from the horrible pain, when Hawk's Eye and Tiger's Eye looked into hers she got horny. She's the type who craves attention. She'd actually been chasing both of their disguised forms in that episode of Super S. Earlier, in one episode of S, she got jealous because her fellow Senshi had been targeted for their Heart Crystals and starts going out of her way to draw an attack on herself. It actually works, but here's the funny part. Normally, the process makes the victim faint almost instantly. Minako held out for several minutes, crying out that she had been worthy of an attack and taking the crystal with her a considerable distance before finally fainting deep in a parking garage.
During Liang Qi's final episode in Canaan, Liang Qi, rapidly losing her grip on sanity (not that she's ever been sane to begin with) is so desperate for any kind of contact with her "nee-sama" Alphard that after the latter slices her leg with her knife during their big fight, Liang Qi begs her to hurt her more.
Kyouhei Kannazuki is such a masochist that he often screws up on purpose to get punished by his superiors. The only punishments that actually scare him are the threats of being castrated or killed.
Origami Tobiichi doesn't care what humiliating things are asked of her, as long as her crush Shido Itsuka is the one asking. At one point, she even acts like a dog and uses Shido's belt as a leash on herself.
Aria of Seitokai Yakuindomo has many kinks, including masochist ones. She has been seen to be happy with wearing a chastity belt all the time, and masturbated with enema at least once.
In Mangaka-san to Assistant-san to, Sena tries to punish Aito for not paying her but she only ends up awakening his inner masochist because her lashes aren't strong enough to cause him serious pain.
In an episode of Inugami-san to Nekoyama-san, Sarutobi threatens to put a gag over Inugami's mouth if she mentions her name again. All this does is make Inugami blush and drool with anticipation.
In general, it's a Running Gag (no pun intended) that Inugami seems to enjoy being insulted, humiliated, or compared to a dog, just so long as it's by a pretty girl.
In Sabagebu!, Urara falls in love with Momoka after she realizes that she enjoys getting beaten up by her.
In Bleach after Charlotte Chuhlhourne is zombified by Mayuri he is completely immune to the trigger which causes his comrades to feel immense pain. Not that the trigger doesn't work, he just is completely unfazed.
In Big Finish Doctor Who, the Eighth Doctor often pretends to be Too Kinky to Torture. It never really works, and there are plenty of audios in which he sarcastically begs for more torture just to screw with his captors, only to be broken soon after and start begging for them to stop.
In an issue of X-Men, at one point during a battle between Iceman and the White Queen, Iceman binds his foe to the wall with ice shackles. Far from being intimidated, the White Queen mentions that she used to pay good money for just such an experience. Taken captive in Generation X...same words.
There's a reference in Watchmen to Captain Carnage, a masochist who threw himself in front of masked heroes in an attempt to get beat up. This backfired when Rorschach threw him down an elevator shaft.
In Villains United, Luthor's Society captures the Secret Six and they are tortured. Unfortunately, one of the Six is Parademon, an inhabitant of Apokalips, who has dealt with worse daily since childhood, and seems to enjoy the process.
Parademon: Thank you, Granny! May I have another?
Another Secret Six example (They're an odd bunch) Manhunter is whaling on Ragdoll with her sharp steel gauntlets. His response?
Ragdoll: No, don't stop! I've almost finished!
And the Penguin in both Secret Six and Birds of Prey turns out to be this. He doesn't care when Bane slaps him around and instead asks if one of the female team members could beat him up instead as then he would enjoy it more. And he gets a crush on Dove in Birds of Prey after she knocks him out
In the comic series Marshal Law, all the superhumans were created with a process that deadens their ability to feel pain. The Marshal himself wears razorwire wrapped around his arm as part of his costume. Many other "heroes" also mutilate themselves. When the Marshal is tortured, he thanks the torturer for letting him feel again, if for only a moment. Then he feeds the torturer to cannibals. A very dark World Half Empty.
Batman's Joker doesn't seem to have a problem with pain, though he laughs at everything so take that as you will. At least once he was seen tied to a chair and beaten up by a so-called sadist. After a while, he pointed out how utterly ineffective the man was at torture by pointing out, quite correctly, that due to the man's lack of imagination, the face, the only part he had really focused on hitting, had mostly desensitized, and that since he had been focusing so intently in the area without specialized tools (which would be the case if the point of it all was deformity) led the Joker to conclude the man had no real gameplan beyond merely dishing out as many punches as he could, making him a complete bore.
In Salvation Run it's revealed that he's in CONSTANT pain ever since the night he was bathed in the chemicals that made him the Joker, and he's just gotten used to it and gotten to like it.
This is jokingly mentioned when Green Arrow handcuffs her in the Injustice comic. Harley states that she finds being bound enjoyable, since it reminds her of the kinky games she used to play with the Joker.
In one comic, Harley ties up a cabdriver and duct-tapes the man's mouth shut. When the guy cries out, Harley tells him to shut up and states that surely this isn't the first time he's ever been bound and gagged by a pretty woman.
MAD features a Batman Begins parody where Bats starts beating up a bad guy. The reaction?
"Wait a minute. I'm getting smacked around and intimidated by a weirdo wearing a rubber bodysuit... Then what the hell do I need these hookers for? Usually, I have to pay them $500 a night for that same service!"
This is a common theme with Etrigan. Being a demon, he is a natural masochist. Not only does he enjoy pain, it makes him physically stronger and more powerful.
A Far Side strip features a pair of demons forcing the damned to toil in a mine. One guy is cheerily pushing a wheelbarrow while whistling. One demon says to another, "You know, I just don't think we're reaching that guy."
A cartoon by Gahan Wilson showed a man on the rack... cracking up the torturers by telling jokes. "... But, seriously...." Of course, it might've been that he was making them laugh too hard to actually inflict any pain on him....
A nameless alien in Nemesis the Warlock is in the hands of an inexperienced torturer, while his supervisor comes along. The alien sympathetically agrees with the criticism the supervisor gives, and while the torturer is soon busy receiving an earful from the supervisor, the alien says it'll torture itself if they won't do it.
In an issue of Daredevil the title hero leaves the Crippler Bound and Gagged after defeating him. When Silver Sable rips the duct tape off of Crippler's mouth, the villain cries out in pain and then asks her to do it again.
In the comic adaptation of Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere, Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar are just as unkillable as they are in the book and TV series, but they also display shades of this trope. In the comic, Mr. Vandemar charges into a fireball with his tongue hanging out, as though he were lapping up the flames; Mr. Croup, meanwhile, seems to derive almost-orgasmic pleasure from devouring a rare vase, blood pouring from his mouth as he swallows the glass shards.
In Croup's case this is possibly more pleasure taken in destroying something of great value which is also ancient and beautiful, but masochism certainly wouldn't be at odds with his characterization.
In one comic, The Creeper is tortured to test his pain threshold. Though he obviously feels pain, he only laughs, telling that he can't help it as the torture tickles before passing out. Any less amount of pain and he just speaks his usual nonsense, meaning that torture for any other reason, would most likely be fairly useless.
Safe to say that any psychological torture he would only find even more funny.
During the Treasures Of Britain arc of Sláine, Sir Lancelot has taken refuge in a monastery after the death of King Arthur. Slaine conceals himself, while Slaine's rival and his troops arrive to torture the information out of Lancelot regarding the whereabouts of the story's MacGuffin. Unfortunately for them, they find that he wishes to be tortured as penance for having an affair with Guinevere and even offers them his own equipment to do so.
In Peter Milligan's reboot of Shade, the Changing Man, version 3 of Shade is driven mad by his previous death and afterlife. When he finds out he's about to be tortured, he expresses enthusiasm for the idea, as long as it's being done by an expert.
With his regenerative powers combined with insanity, torture is completely ineffective for Deadpool.
The reason torture doesn't work all that well on Deadpool is because he was tortured past the Sanity Event Horizon as part of Weapon X. Killebrew, the doctor in charge of Wade's "treatment", can still cause him to break out in PTSD, but everyone else is a rank amateur.
In an issue of Dark X-Men, Norman Osborn tries to control Aurora from Alpha Flight by fitting her with a tiara that electrocutes her every time she disobeys him. She eventually escapes by developing a Split Personality, one who is masochistic enough to enjoy the pain long enough to remove the tiara.
Umbridge: I believe you are inappropriately dressed for your detention today.
Harveste *cough* Harry *cough*: Am I? Did I need my own manacles? Should I go get them?
The dark red writing glowed wetly for a second before disappearing and slicing itself into the back of the abomination's hand. He gasped.
"Oh, Professor, this is a Blood Quill! I haven't used one in years!"
Voldemort has Harveste in the graveyard at the end of year four: "Crucio!"
It was unbearable, excruciating, maddening. It felt like he was being roasted, like hot pokers were pressing into his eyes, his mouth, his ears, every inch of his skin, followed by knives being tapped into the very marrow of his bones then twisted, twisted, twisted until he was like Karkaroff's hand or Draco's green peas. He felt like foot-long splinters were being driven under his nails, and he couldn't move, couldn't breathe because he was screaming, screaming so loud, louder than anyone had done under Wednesday, under Grandmama, and there was just pain, pain, pain everywhere…
Lord Voldemort laughed cruelly as he lifted the curse from Harry's panting, shaking body, and his Death Eaters laughed with him, too scared to do anything else.
"How does it feel, little boy?" Tom hissed threateningly. "How does your first taste of real pain feel?"
"Oh." Harry took a deep shuddering breath, then another one. That pain… had opened his eyes to what was really happening now. "Now I understand why Mother loves red-hot pokers so much."
"My Mother – oh -" Harry shuddered as another spasming ripple danced along his nerves. "-I've never really understood until now – ah- it was glorious. Absolutely divine. Do it again."
In Reparations, Harry is a healer. At one point, one of his colleagues talks about a patient who kept trying to get out of bed, so in the end she had to conjure ropes and tie him up. Apparently, he liked it.
In the Tenchi Muyo fanfic ''The Devil and Miss Mihoshi'', Mihoshi proves that not only is she too kinky to torture (breaking the devil's best torturer into a shell of his former self), she's too kinky/dumb to damn. The devil himself can't break her, and is forced to release her to avoid her relentless cheerfulness and bumbling from ruining hell.
In the Katekyo Hitman Reborn!Slash Fic "Homecoming" Chapter 4 Tsuna is about to be molested by Mukuro and hits him. This doesn't deter Mukuro in the slightest but he is stopped when guards arrive on the scene.
A variant happens in the Azula Trilogy, as Iroh isn't too kinky but too awesome: the attempt ended in the torturer wannabe escaping because his attempts had ended either in miserable failures or Iroh torturing him.
Subverted in Constant Temptation which makes it very clear that torture is very different from harmless safe, sane, and consensual S&M games. Though Light's experience with taking pain helps him get through the ordeal.
One Justice League fanfiction plays with this in the form of an Illusion MasterOC. His reaction to torture severely freaks out his torturer. But he later admits to his partner that he actually used his sensory manipulation powers to simply convince his body that pain was pleasurable.
In Off The Record when captured and tortured by S.H.I.E.L.D. agents Loki begins giving them tips.
A non-torturous variant occurs in the lemon fic White Christmas. In order to snap Molly out the succubus-induced lust haze she's in, Harry slaps her lightly on the arm. It doesn't work.
Later, Tai Lung tries a nerve strike on Po, a move that previously paralysed all of the Furious Five... only to have Po giggle as it only tickled him. This one is justified by his Kevlard.The attempt at acupuncture earlier in the movie failed because it was hard to find his nerves under his "fur".
Films — Live Action
Morticia (and pretty much The Addams Family in general) reacts quite favorably to pain and torture. When interrogated in the first movie, she compliments the turncoat lawyer stretching her on the rack with "You've done this before!"
Not to mention when Gomez is freeing her:
Gomez: Leather straps, red hot pokers...
Morticia: Later, my dearest...
In certain incarnations, they even merrily torture or attempt to murder each other for amusement, never mind the insinuations about Gomez and Morticia's sex lives.
Morticia: Don't torture yourself, Gomez... that's my job.
James Bond in the 2006 version of Casino Royale makes a show of enjoying being smacked by a knotted rope in a rather delicate place by Le Chiffre, which convinces Le Chiffre that he's never going to break. Luckily for Bond, Le Chiffre doesn't last long enough to up the ante.
Bond: *shouts in pain* NO! NO! TO THE RIGHT! TO THE RIGHT! TO THE RIGHT!
It does sort of explain why he never has to worry about having little James Bonds running around though (besides the ladies all dying).
Notably, during that scene he also has that line about how Le Chiffre would be known for being the man who died scratching Bond's balls.
Repeated in Skyfall when Silva's molestation fails to disturb Bond.
Xenia Onatopp in GoldenEye seems to enjoy getting beaten up almost as much as killing people. Her fight scenes with Bond indicate that she wasn't going to stop fighting simply out of pain.
Up until he burns her ass on a hot radiator. . . guess she was only into SOME types of pain, which is rather Truth in Television.
Monty Python and the Holy Grail features the renowned Black Knight who persists on continuing to fight when every single one of his limbs has been cut off by King Arthur, insisting they were only 'flesh wounds' and even called Arthur a fleeing coward when he was limbless body on the ground.
Muppet Treasure Island has Clueless Morgan and company trying to torture Gonzo for information. They put Gonzo on the rack... of course, this is a Muppet whose idea of fun is getting keelhauled, so the only thing they succeed at doing is making his arms and legs ten feet long.
Gonzo: I might even have a future in the NBA!
The DVD commentary put it best in its simplicity: "They picked the wrong guy."
Used and ultimately subverted in the Street Fighter live-action movie. When Honda is being tortured by one of Bison's mooks, it seems like a straight use of the trope, since it looks like he's enjoying it and has a peaceful smile on his face. The subversion kicks in after the guard leaves, when his ally Balrog cringes at the damage done to him and Honda, clearly in pain, explains, "I'm Sumo, brother. My body can be in one place, my mind another."
The Joker in The Dark Knight laughs maniacally whenever someone attacks him, especially Batman, since it only drives him closer to "breaking his rule." The Joker rubs the futility of it all in Batman's face, saying, "You have nothing! Nothing to threaten me with! Nothing to do with all your strength!" It's also lampshaded by the cop he later takes hostage, who says, "I know you're going to enjoy this. I'll just have to enjoy it even more."
Probably a more straight example, when Batman is interrogating the Joker and slams his head into the table, the Joker tells Batman that starting with the head makes the victim fuzzy, so they can't feel the next hit. . . and responds only with "See?" when Batman then punches his hand arguably hard enough to shatter it completely.
Vampire in Brooklyn: "Interesting. I've been stabbed, and I've been hanged, and I've been burned. Even broken on the rack once, but I've never been shot before. Kind of itches a little!" And then to demonstrate the fact he puts his finger inside the hole and wiggles it a bit.
In Wasabi's first scenes, Hubert is tasked with interrogating a transvestite of this ilk. After a violent punch that makes him spit teeth, he compliments his captor: "You really know how to talk to women."
Arthur Denton of Little Shop of Horrors (played by Bill Murray, based on a similar character in the 1960 movie played by Jack Nicholson) is a masochist, who goes to Dr. Orin Scrivello, D.D.S in search of some really intense pain. Scrivello is a sadist who delights in tormenting his patients, so Denton's enjoyment of the process really ruins his day.
Arthur: I think I need a root canal. I definitely need a long... slow... root canal!
Lou in Fight Club tries to intimidate Tyler Durden by beating him up. Tyler gets really into it, inviting Lou to join the club, and laughing maniacally as Lou pounds his face in.
In Videodrome, jaded psychotherapist Nikki Brand has Max Renn thrust a hatpin through her earlobes during sex, idly burns herself on the breast with a cigarette during a relaxing moment, and eventually runs off to Pittsburgh to audition for a reality show in which people are savagely tortured for the amusement of the television audience.
Gene Wilder pretends to be this way in Stir Crazy when the warden is trying to force him to join the prison rodeo.
In Top Secret!, Nick Rivers realizes that his being late to school was All Just a Dream and he is very relieved to find out that he is in reality ONLY being whipped by two henchmen.
Klytus states Princess Aura is this in the 1980 movie Flash Gordon. From what we see of the torture, though, he is most likely lying.
Prince Barin: You tortured Aura! Klytus: An interesting girl. I think she found it rather enjoyable.
In The A-Team, Murdoch is placed into an army psychiatric hospital after his arrest. When given electroshock therapy with no anaesthesia, he responds pseudo-orgsamically - "Oh, yeahhh. That's the stuff."
In Under Siege 2 Dark Territory, our damsel in distress tries to threaten the main goon with mace. This proves to be ineffective after he corrects her that it's actually pepper spray, and then proceeds to spray some into his mouth to "clear the sinuses".
Neal Stephenson's The Diamond Age involves someone who reacts to a seemingly horrific form of torture (direct pain-nerve stimulation) as if being tickled because he's got nanobots installed in his body to counteract it. His torturers simply decide to do things the old fashioned way.
Duke Ah! That is my IRON MAIDEN. Well may you tremble, for -
Nanny Ogg Can I have a go in it?
Duke Your pleas fall on deaf - Wait, what?
Duke And after that, we shall use FIRE!
Nanny Ogg Fine by me, it's bloody freezing in here! I mean, seriously, how much would it have cost to install some heating?
One of the Dragon Lance Prequels, some minotaurs attempt to torture Sturm Brightblade and Tasselhoff Burrfoot. Sturm, being a Solamnic Knight, stoically endures everything with nary a change of expression. Tasselhoff, on the other hand, helpfully makes suggestions to his torturer. Being a Kender, he's incapable of feeling fear, and his bones are difficult to break — and heal quickly. Thus, the worst thing the minotaurs can do is to BORE him by trying the same form of torture for more than ten minutes, which is why he starts making suggestions. In the end, the torturer might have come away from the session feeling worse than his victim — if nothing else, he probably got a nasty headache.
In the Saga of the Exiles, there is a character named Felice Landry. In one scene Culluket the Interrogator picks her out of a group of prisoners to torture for information. Worst choice he could have made. Not only does she get off on his treatment she actually becomes a superpowered badass and enables her comrades to escape using the powers he has inadvertently set free within her. She later spends quite a bit of effort looking for him to return the "favor."
In the Star Wars Expanded Universe, Han Solo is tortured a number of times. His response is usually along the lines of "Is that all you've got? I was tortured by Darth Vader."
In a threat of torture for two, Leia followed up with "So was I. That was before we met."
Meanwhile, the Yuuzhan Vong love pain and torture. Their idea of a lazy Saturday afternoon involves spending time in an organic device called the Embrace of Pain.
As a result, a young woman shaped by the Vong to be like them gets lines like these: "I'm half Yuuzhan Vong inside. The only thing pain would cause me is a religious experience." and "I know something about pain you don't. Pain drowns other people. I just swim in it."
The split personality was actually anticipated and planned for. (The next step was to change the torture regime in order to encourage discord between the personalities and confuse the issue of who should be in charge when.) Mark only escapes because (1) they underestimate him and (2) they underestimate his initial mental fragility.
They don't know that Ser Galen tortured him worse when he was a teen.
Mark: You see me, Baron. But I see you, too.
Averted, ironically, in the Kushiel's Dart trilogy. The heroine literally experiences pain as pleasure, but when a captor begins skinning her alive, the sensation is so intense as to be torturous anyway. In the third book when she's trapped in the harem of a mad dictator, she doesn't exactly enjoy being done in the ass with a spiked iron rod either, and privately admits that this is about where she hits her limit.
Just to clarify: she enjoys pain, rather than experiencing it as pleasure. (And that's all pain, including emotional pain and unfulfilled desires, though the effect is strongest with physical pain.) So torture still hurts her.
In The Book of the New Sun, Severian the Torturer, who has been raised in the arts of professional torture, both mocks the ineptitude of his tormentor and offers professional tips. The casual manner in which he retells the experience makes it a Crowning Moment Of Awesome.
When the Doctor is psychically tortured in the Expanded Universe novel Return of the Living Dad by reliving painful memories, the pain he's experienced turns out to be more than the psychic torturing him can cope with. So instead, the torturer takes his most pleasurable memory (a nice cup of tea) and increases the sensation a million times, at which point he breaks.
Semirhage does this intentionally in The Wheel of Time. Apparently nobody trains their operatives to resist intense pleasure, so it works better than pain in some cases.
A couple of the Eighth Doctor Adventures novels feature this as regards to the Doctor's companion and the TARDIS's resident Lovable Sex Maniac Fitz. Subverted in one, in which he is hit with a whip and learns he doesn't get the appeal at all. In another (Mad Dogs And Englishmen), he, the Doctor, and fellow companion Anji are stripped and collared by space poodles. Anji hates it, the Doctor is wholly indifferent, and Fitz...
"Fitz," Anji hissed. "Are you telling me you really don't mind trotting around starkers in a collar and lead?' He grinned. "Are you kidding?"
Referenced in Ghost Ship when the Fourth Doctor converses with his Temporary Love Interest about her favourite poets:
'Oh please,' she said, scowling. 'Come the revolution, he'd be the first one I'd have lined up against the wall, given a last cigarette and then, you know, horsewhipped to death.'
'He would probably have quite enjoyed that, you know?' I noted, speaking from a keen personal knowledge of the man.
Implied in the Short Trips and Sidesteps story "A Town Called Eternity", when the Fifth Doctor survives being hanged thanks to his respiratory bypass system. He notes in his internal monologue that hanging was not a means of execution on Gallifrey, but a 'risky hobby for seedy Cardinals with regenerations to spare'.
In John Ringo's A Deeper Blue, a drug lord kidnaps Mike's manager/mistress/etc (It Makes Sense in Context), Anastasia, and tortures her for information. She's a hardcore submissive and enjoys it. Very, very much. It helps that the torturer in question is an ignoramus who fails to tell the difference between sounds made in response to pain and sounds made in response to orgasm.
In one of the Dune sequels by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson, a group are trying to reawaken the memories of a ghola of the Baron Harkonnen, which is usually accomplished by pushing someone to breaking point with some great trauma. However, he proves Too Kinky to Torture and the only thing that eventually works is sensory deprivation.
Played dead straight in Anita Blake. The villain Gabriel's dream was to be slowly killed by Anita. Nathaniel, a protagonist, was also quite the masochist. As well as Narcissus, who was more of a grey character.
Gabriel actually wanted to rape, kill and eat Anita, while she was armed and doing her best to kill him. He was very masochistic, not suicidal. And he's never actually tortured. Also, Nathaniel has limits, but Raina and Gabriel broke him, so that he was incapable of saying "no". He is shown badly hurt and clearly not enjoying it in "Narcissus in Chains" (pinned to the wall by multiple blades) and mentions that he was enjoying prostituting himself until he was gutted in "Burnt Offerings", but not during or after.
Subverted with Tomasso in Guy Gavriel Kay's Tigana. He is known throughout the land for being an open homosexual and masochist, but he is nearly driven to tears before the real torture even starts, when the guards are allowed to "play with him". It doesn't help that he was deliberately exaggerating the more outrageous aspects of his lifestyle in order to make people underestimate him, so the masochism, for instance, may have been a complete and utter fiction on his part.
The Pilfered Princess: Sarah annoys her torturer by orgasming during a torture session, and spends the entire story begging Inferno to "rape" her. Because, frankly, the Dark Lord's ogres, trolls and other assorted underlings just aren't that good at the whole sex thing.
In the Wheel of Time, the Aiel are very, very resistant to torture. Perrin only manages to break his Shaido prisoner in the ninth book by chopping off one of his hands and threatening to chop off his other hand and his feet and leave him like that. When Egwene finally masters the Aiel technique she starts laughing her head off while being beaten, much to her captor's startlement. Semirhage, as the best torturer in the history of existence, doesn't eventually get broken through torture but by the humiliation of being spanked by a woman less than a seventh of her age.
Also, when Semirhage is captured, even though Rand doesn't allow Cadsuane to torture her, the Aes Sedai decides that physical pain will never work anyways; it's what Semirhage is expecting and probably looking forward to. Instead, she decides that humiliation is a much better tactic.
In The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Arthur Dent and Ford Prefect are captured early on by the Vogons. The Vogon captain proceeds to read his poetry, the third worst in the universe, but Arthur bluffs his way out of it, claiming he actually enjoyed the poem. However, he was lying; the television show displays him in the same pain as Ford, while the film simply shows him confused but certainly uncomfortable. He and Ford start an improvised literary analysis, but the captain is not convinced and dumps the two out an airlock. Fortunately, they are rescued.
Ford Prefect is implied to have a version of this related to the Janx Spirit drinking game, where the eventual loser is forced to perform a forfeit, "which was usually obscenely biological". It then states that Ford Prefect usually played to lose.
In Clive Barker 's Hellraiser mythos, this is how the Cenobites initially came to be: they spent such a long time being tortured in Hell that eventually they found that they actually enjoyed the sensations. The natural extension then was to reshape their bodies and inflict this exquisite pain upon others.
In the original short story the Cenobites, or Order of the Gash, have nothing to do with Hell and everything to do with sensation. Meaning they inflict their tortures and deformities on themselves for novelty's sake.
In the Italian fantasy novel Balthis the Adventuress there's an entire underground subrace that lives by this trope: they sleep in hard stone beds, eat and drink awful-tasting things daily and often flail and beat each other up as a form of greetings. When we get to see on of their on kind "tortured", we see her sit on comfortable pillows, with no chains or restrains and with delicious food and excellent wine. And she complains a lot for it.
In Robert Rankin's The Book of Ultimate Truths, a group of monks seem to have a fascination with paintings of martyrdom - naked, buffed martyrdom. Captured by the Big Bad, the Abbot, bound, gagged, and naked apart from a gossamer posing pouch, seems to be having a wonderful time.
The Charonese from John Varley's novel The Golden Globe have turned pain into a religion. When "Sparky" Valentine tells Isambard Comfort that his sister died in pain, he replies 'Good'. Isambard eventually gets his just desserts when his pain nerves are permanently destroyed by our hero.
In H. L. Oldie's "Messiah Clears the Disk", Judge Bao, a senior judiciary officer, is accused of treason, jailed, and whipped. First thing he tells to his interrogators? He points out that the investigation is being conducted with gross violations of the Torture Canon, then lectures them on the exact sequence and timing of various pain-inflicting techniques that the accused must be subjected to. The chief interrogator makes sure the protocolist takes notes.
In Little Star, Max Hansen develops a masochistic complex after being wounded by Theres. When "The Wolves of Skansen" ultimately torture him to death, he has an orgasm.
True Blood: Maryann's reaction to being bitten by Bill. "Yes! Ravage me! Ravage me!" Plus she probably knew that her blood was toxic to Bill, since she is a supernatural being.
Maryann again in the Season 2 finale, when being impaled by a bull.
The bar is set even higher in Season 3. At the end of Episode 3, Bill and Lorena have a very violent sexual encounter, where Bill (pissed off beyond belief) twists Lorena's head 180 degrees. Lorena's response?
"William, I so love you."
Sam Puckett of iCarly is implied to be this. In, iDate a Bad Boy, she describes being tased as "not so bad; it's actually kind of a rush" with a rather wistful look on her face. In iHatch Chicks, Carly bites one of Sam's hands for making a joke about fried chicken; Sam then implores her to bite the other one.
Jade from Victorious is also implied to be this. In one episode, she got disappointed because something wasn't painful, and in another, she said "this is causing me pain, and not the good kind."
Episode villain Namtar in Farscape could re-wire his nerve responses from pain to pleasure, turning a pinned arm near breaking into an intensely pleasurable experience. When Aeryn gives an experimental twist, his response is "Harder!"
Stark has spent so much time in Scorpius' Aurora Chair, he now appears to enjoy the process of having the memories ripped out of his brain and shown on screen, to the point of screaming "Again, Scorpy! Frell me again!"
And, in turn, when Scorpius is being tortured by the Scarran War Minister Ahkna, in between bursts of flesh-searing heat to the face, he waggles his tongue at her and remarks "I've been searching my whole life for a female like you."
From CBS' Mom: after a brief but intense affair that ended up hurting her, Bonnie realizes that Chef Rudy would probably take pleasure in any physical pain she might inflict so she decides to take her anger out on his incredibly expensive wine collection instead. It still ends up arousing the both of them.
An unintentional example occurred in House (Although Dr. House might have gotten a thrill out of it.) They put a teen with severe burns into a hyperbaric chamber (which would hurt like hell.) Apparently, he's in so much pain, his brain confuses pain with pleasure, and he orgasms.
There's a running gag in The Mighty Boosh where any time Bob Fossil, or anyone played by the actor, will respond to being tortured/raped/brutally murdered with "Ooh, ah! A little to the left!"
Once in Just Shoot Me!, Jack put electric buzzers on Nina and Elliot's chairs as punishment for making too many jokes at his expense. Nina enjoys the charge, and asks for "two short ones followed by a long, sustained one."
Several years before Farscape, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine featured the enigmatic character of Cardassian tailor Elim Garak, a former spy, secret operative and assassin of the Cardassian Obsidian Order. In episode 22 of Season 2 ("The Wire") Dr. Bashir discovers that Garak has an implant in his brain that is wired to stimulate the pleasure centers of his brain to produce large amounts of endorphins whenever Garak suffers strong physical pain. Originally, it was meant to "protect" Garak against physical torture. During his exile among Bajorans (who hate Cardassians), humans and other aliens, Garak built a device that allowed him to remotely control the implant and turn it on or off whenever he wanted. At first, Garak had merely planned on using the implant from time to time, whenever the stress and depression of eking out an existence as a humble tailor on a space station among hostile aliens became too much for him. But one day, as he admits to Dr. Bashir, he turned the implant on and never turned it off; he became addicted to the high endorphin levels.
Mirror Universe counterpart of Kira, 'The Intendant' seems to like the idea of torture. When she's captured by the Rebels, she advises Mirror!Julian to turn up the setting on his 'little toy' (a pain-inducing Phlebotinum).
The torture of Gaius Baltar in the episode "A Measure of Salvation" (Season 3, Ep 07) of Battlestar Galactica is a subversion. While Cylon Number Three / D'Anna is torturing Baltar with pain inducers and psycho talk, Baltar tries to project himself to a beach to avoid the pain. There Head-Six appears to him and coaxes him into having sex, with her which results in a rather explicit reaction from Baltar. Naturally, D'Anna is really weirded out. Seriously, if the guy you are torturing and who only a moment ago was writhing in agony suddenly starts writhing in arousal and yelling "I love you!" and "Don't stop!" over and over doesn't make you think he's gone completely bonkers, lost his marbles, or gone nuts, then you're probably unflappable. Also, he's a keeper.
From the same series, Leoben Conoy, the crazy Cylon Number Two. He actually fell in love with Starbuck while she was torturing him.
The last episode of the first season of Burn Notice has Sam captured and continually beaten for information by heroin dealers. He begins by complimenting their technique in beating him, subverts Torture Always Works by giving one false confession after another, and basically constantly mocks his captors and actually encourages them to kill him (this is both to psyche them out and because he doesn't want his friends to be killed trying to rescue him).
Buster/Kim: Torture me all you want, Demonica, I'll never crack! Demonica/Jenny: Oh, but you will. Malicia/Megan: By the time we're through with you, you'll be begging to tell us everything you know. Demonica/Jenny: You'll be our puppet. Malicia/Megan: Our slave. Buster/Kim:(enthusiastically) Great! You're doing great! (Tom Paris [playing the hero Captain Proton] bursts into the room waving a raygun) Proton/Paris: You're done for, Demonica! Malicia/Megan: Malicia! She's Demonica. Proton/Paris: Whatever. You two are going to jail for a very long time. Buster/Kim:I've goteverything under control, Proton! Shouldn't you begetting back to Headquarters?
Carla: Woody, you don't know what you're getting yourself into. I mean, those guys at Gary's are vicious. They could strip you naked, paint you red, and put you on a subway. Woody: They wouldn't do that. Carla: They did it to me. But I got the best of them. Norm: How's that? Carla: (chortling) I loved it.
The bots sometimes show strange tastes. In Gamera Vs. Guiron, character Tom is threatened with a spanking. Tom Servo talks back at the screen, "I'm Tom. Spank me!"
In The Movie, Tom ends up plugging a hole in the ship with his body, exposing his lower anatomy to the vacuum of space. His reaction is "I'm experiencing a sensation altogether new to me. and frankly...I love it!"
The contestant in Pod #9 on Solitary 3.0 exhibited such behavior during the metal clips treatment. All the other contestants screamed in agony as they attached 40 hard metal clips around their body. Unbeknownst to them, contestant #9 acted nonchalant about the whole thing and even seemed enthusiastic about furthering the "torture". Later, when another contestant got to punish someone of their choosing with a second 10 clip treatment she chose #9, unaware of his preference for the "torture". #9 proceeded and mocked the treatment by feigning pain then laughing about it.
In a third-season episode of La Femme Nikita, "Threshold of Pain", the terrorist Simon Crachek is captured by Section. The Torture Twins, a mousy-looking man and his equally mousy-looking woman both sporting large orange plastic briefcases, are brought in to interrogate him. Up to this point of the season, Madeline always sent them in to crack the more difficult prisoners, whereupon they'd emerge wordlessly a scene later, leaving the prisoner quivering and shaking and ready to spill his guts. In this episode, the Twins emerge after a session with Crachek, look at Madeline and shake their heads. Meanwhile, strapped to his chair in the interrogation room, Crachek has a big smile on his face.
Drusilla falls into this category as a result of the torture and madness inflicted on her by Angelus. It seems likely that some of it is inherent to being a Buffyverse vampire but not to the degree found in this insane seer. As seen in the Angel comics when she is sent to Hell with the rest of L.A., but she sees it as her family's pleasant old home.
Spike: "I'm gonna tie her down and torture her until she loves me again!"
And Drusilla's response when Angel says she isn't alone because she has him and Darla:
Drusilla: Not in the least. You won't even hurt me just a little bit.
Also, Zachary Kralik, a one-shot villain from season three, thorougly enjoyed being burned by a cross in his... nether regions.
Torchwood: No matter what punishment someone gives him, Captain John Hart manages to turn it into a fetish:
Gwen: ON YOUR KNEES!!! Captain John: Honestly, it's always sex, sex, sex with you people.
A Saturday Night Live Dickens parody had the young protagonist on board Her Majesty's ship "The Raging Queen", where discipline was rigidly enforced and enthusiastically accepted.
Was that Miles Copperthwaite? In which all the sailors are "manly men"?
The Jackass crew. They certainly enjoy hurting each other, especially Knoxville.
On Chuck, Jeff is quite the weirdo. Tie him to a tree, inject him with sodium pentothal, he just thinks it's a party.
In Supernatural, many characters display this over the course of the show in response to torture, although it's usually just meant to piss off the torturer as they're still in agony when it's actually applied. One of the few who doesn't even display any physical signs of discomfort is the Alpha Vampire when he's captured and interrogated (read: getting electrocuted). This trope is also Crowley's reason for changing Hell from physical torture to an eternal waiting line.
Alpa Vampire: [bored] Oww. Please Stop. That hurts.
Community, milder than most examples here, but the Dean misinterprets Jeff's threats to step on him as some kind of pleasure to enjoy.
Larrin in Stargate Atlantis once experiences the terror of being fed on by a Wraith, a process which is known to be extremely painful and causes rapid aging in the subject. Sheppard forces the alien to return the lifeforce it took from her, after which a once again young Larrin remarks with a confused grin that "it felt kinda good".
In fact, this is how Wraith worshippers are trained by their masters: the worshipper is fed upon until he or she is on the brink of death then the Wraith gives it all back. Rinse and repeat over and over again until the subject swears loyalty.
In Sons of Anarchy there is an episode where Tig is captured by a crew of bounty hunters. He insults one of them to provoke a beating, and seems to enjoy it.
In a later episode he says something to the effect of "I don't know if this is good or not but I'm totally hard right now" while Tara is busy picking a bullet out of his buttcheek.
Blackadder II: when Blackadder is captured by the dastardly Spanish, he is taken to the second degree by gloating Inquisitors and shown the implements of torture. In his usual yawningly disdainful way, he corrects their poor English and suggests better Spanish terms for the devices. He also spot-translates a leering Spanish guard's threats conerning the pain that will soon be inflicted on him.
vampire Elena has turned off her emotions and Stefan and Damon are trying to find a way to elicit an emotional response from her that will 'flip the switch' back to normal. They finally resort to torturing her by exposing her to sunlight without her protective ring. Her skin starts to burn but she just uses this as an opportunity to mock the brothers again. Finally, she manages to get out of her bonds and stands fully in the sunlight. She is on fire and in agonizing pain but she is having way too much fun messing with the Salvatores to stop.
In Continuum, Kiera is roughing up Garza. Garza considers this "foreplay".
In Criminal Minds, serial killer Frank Breitkopf's modus operandi involved kidnapping a victim, injecting them with just enough ketamine to paralyze them, and then open up their bodies so he could remove all of their organs one by one. Breitkopf would get off on the look of fear on his victims' faces, encouraging his assault. However, he falls in love with one woman because, when she was incapacitated by Breitkopf, instead of being afraid of what was going to happen to her, she enjoyed it, thus subverting his plan, so he let her go so that he could pursue a relationship with her.
On Person of Interest Shaw says she "kind of enjoys this sort of thing" when Root threatens to torture her with a hot iron.
A particularly dark version in the Doctor Who story "The Deadly Assassin", in which the Doctor reacts to Agony Beam torture with boredom, heavily implying he's been through it a lot in the past.
A variant appears in the Defiance episode "Slouching Toward Bethlehem." Nolan and Yewll interrogate a Votan spy, who also happens to be the BDSM specialist at the local brothel. The flaw in torturing him for information becomes obvious; the combination of him being Irathient and dealing in pain for a living means that his threshold for physical pain is through the roof. It's not that he enjoys it, per se; he can simply take it without breaking, and eventually his captors resort to a Mind Probe instead.
The music video for "Happiness In Slavery" by Nine Inch Nails. A man walks into a room, gets naked, lies down... and then a machine rips off his penis and grinds him into meat. And he enjoys it.
Sparky from Metallica, who enjoys his electric chair too much.
Sparky: "My eyeballs feel hot!"
Done with Pepe Le Pew in Bugs Bunny's Birthday Ball, who doesn't let getting sprayed in the face deter him from pursuing Honey Bunny.
WWE's Mankind used to be an example of this, back when he first started, with the announcers going on and on about his seeming affinity for pain. It was then subverted, during a Worked Shootinterview by Jim Ross...
Mankind: You know what you tell the people, week in and week out? You say, "Look at Mankind! I don't even know if he feels pain... or maybe, maybe he likes pain!"... What is it about pain that I love?... Is it when I can't get up when my little boy says, "Daddy, I wanna play ball!" and I can't do it? Is that where the fun starts? Is it where a doctor injects a 12-inch needle into the discs of my spine so I can wrestle one more day? Whoopee! Let the party begin!... All you've done to people is mislead them, and let them believe that I'm having the time of my goddamn life when I'm in pain!
Raven, during his WCW days, invoked this a few times. One of the most memorable being during his first grudge match against Chris Benoit; when caught in the Crippler Crossface (Benoit's Finishing Move), he started laughing.
Exalted has a fighting style called Laughing Wounds, pioneered by the Lover Clad in the Raiment of Tears, who may very well be the physical incarnation of this trope. To give you an idea of what it's like, one of the first Charms one can learn in the style allows you to turn wound penalties into attack bonuses. And yes, whips and chains count as form weapons, and a BDSM sense of fashion is included.
In the Forgotten Realms setting exists the goddess Loviatar, The Maiden of Pain. Similarly to the Dark Mistress from Dungeon Keeper as mentioned below, her worshipers absolutely adore pain, both inflicting it and experiencing it—in a battle too. This goes double for Loviatar herself, who will actually wade into a pitched battle solely to get injured and experience the sensations.
Pathfinder gives us the god Zon-Kuthon. Estranged brother of the Goddess of Love, he presides over darkness, suffering and sado-masochism. He is depicted in styles reminiscent of the Cenobites, having flayed and pierced his flesh countless times. His priesthood's creed is 'Experience Without Limits', and one of their most holy ceremonies involves stripping one of their number of limbs, eyes, ears, tongue, and lips (and often eating them in the process), leaving a head and torso which are kept alive to be violated and tortured ever after. They call this 'The Joymaking', and the victims are high ranking priests. They don't just volunteer, they demand it be done to them.
In Deep 7's Red Dwarf Roleplaying game (yes, it exists), humans get extra dice to their fortitude because of this trope. They're crazy enough to enjoy things like Yanni concerts and five-alarm curries.
This is why the Inquisition in Warhammer 40,000 hate having to deal with Chaos cultists from the Slaanesh faction. At least one Inquisitor found a sensory deprivation tank the best option. Makes sense.
Most Slaaneshi cultists tend to be too kinky to care even about that. Whatever you do to them, if they win, they get the high of winning. If they lose, they get a new experience to savor. In fact, in a Ciaphas Cain novel at least one of the Slaaneshi cultist got off of being killed, and the others were fighting each other to get hacked to pieces, which lead to a great deal of Squick from Cain when he realised that they were actually getting sexual pleasure from being slaughtered.
One example of this is towards the end of the novel Fulgrim where one of Ferrus Mannus' bodyguards is about to crush a fallen Emperor's Children legionnaire, the legion that fell to Slaanesh, who took a full hit from a flamethrower and pauses when he sees the look on the Marine's face isn't pain from having his entire body burned with futuristic napalm but ecstatic pleasure. This pause doesn't end well for said bodyguard.
Easiest way to deal with Chaos followers would be a Pariah — particularly a Culexus Assassin. Just force them to stay in its presence, perhaps have the Pariah rape them... you know, because Pariahs are utterly horrific to regular people, and even more so to those touched by the Warp.
A Culexus doesn't have to do anything in order to rape someone.
Dark Eldar get bonus points by actually getting physically rejuvenated by torture. One book tells of some Space Marines failing miserably to extract information from a Dark Eldar captive through conventional torture methods because the captive got off on it. However, the Dark Eldar had a breakdown when one of them had the idea to lock him in an empty room with nothing to do.
Naturally, the same problem exists for Witch Hunters in Warhammer. One enterprising Hunter figured out a way around this, by numbing the cultist's entire body before proceeding, torturing him by not letting him feel it.
One particularly awe-inspiring example is Giles Corey in The Crucible, who gets accused of witchcraft during the Salem trials but refuses to confess. Authorities torture him by slowly crushing him under heavy weights, but he never confesses and only asks for more weight. He does this until he dies—not out of masochism but out of sheer stoicism. By the way, Giles Corey was a real guy, and this really happened to him during the Salem witch trials.
There's also the Dark Mistress from the Dungeon Keeper series — where all other minions are sent to the torture-chamber to punish them for not working hard enough, thus scaring their colleagues into working harder — or for captured enemies, who can be turned to the dark side or into vengeful ghosts by the ordeal... the Dark Mistress is sent there to raise her morale. Actually, she tends to go there of her own accord, which can be troublesome if you've got many of them, since they wind up taking up slots you could use for your enemies.
Have you ever wondered who is running those torture chambers? The name implies that she is sadistic and would probably prefer to do the work herself — in fact, if you have a victim in it and put one of these ladies in, they sometimes begin to work on the victims which increases the speed of the torture.
Also implied to apply to the Keeper himself, as shown by the phrase given should you end up with 10 Mistresses: "You have an excess of Mistresses. There's a word for Keepers like you."
A mild example is Calisto Yew of Ace Attorney. When Franziska von Karma threatens her with her trademark whip (actually a riding crop in this case), Yew says it "kind of sounds like fun". Of course there's still some situational squick. This is a flashback case. Franziska is thirteen.
Mao from Disgaea 3. Upon discovering that his butler has been experimenting on him while he was unconscious, he decides to march on over to him and demand video of it for his own viewing pleasure.
Subverted by SIE from Alpha Protocol. She clearly gets some enjoyment from her own pain (if you attack her, she'll send you an email about how she enjoys pressing her bullet wounds) but when she is captured by Bravko, she can clearly be heard crying out and nearly sobbing.
City of Villains' Silver Mantis, second in command to Black Scorpion, thrives on this trope. Almost every boss has dialogue as you damage them further, from 3/4ths to half to 1/4th health, and upon defeat. The average Silver Mantis dialogue sounds more like she's engaged in other activities. At least one defeat dialogue has her congratulating your character on really knowing how to treat a girl, with an addition to call her later. This after you, depending on powerset, may have inflicted anything from blunt trauma to 3rd degree burns to direct psychic assault on her mind... To being cut with steel claws by a shiny-black clad Catwoman look-alike.
Silver Mantis is more disturbing to those who have actually read her backstory. She grew up with an addiction. To having pieces of metal surgically grafted into her skin.Without anesthetic. If you look closely at her costume, you'll notice that it has a metallic sheen, and that it includes small metal spikes coming out of her exposed skin.
Hanch from Drakengard 2 does this too. Over the course of the boss fight against her and her pact-beast, the things she says (and the noises she makes) imply that she's actually rather enjoying getting the crap beaten out of her.
Shadow Hearts: Covenant has this when the party is thrown in jail on St. Marguerite Island and held at the mercy of dominatrix foe Veronica. The player has to choose which character will be tortured by her from a list of each character's responses to the idea of being tortured, most of which are defiant or fearful, but one of which is ecstatic as the prospect. Since they're not lined up in the same order as the cast onscreen, you can only find out who said what by choosing each option, after which you learn that the one excited about it is not Yuri, as you might think, but Gepetto.
Ōkami : "The Labyrinth of Torment is for the enjoyment of everyone on Oni Island, so don't make a mess of it while playing."
In the PS2 / Xbox release of The Bard's Tale, as the eponymous Bard makes his way to battle Fnarf, the guy that follows him there disables magic electrical forcefields by jumping into them and geting electrocuted. However, he claims to enjoy (and even anticipate) it, to which the Bard amusedly remarks "And they call me a deviant!"
In The Suffering: Ties That Bind the boss battle with The Creeper ends with the monstrous spirit being stabbed to death by his own cojoined whores. As their knife-like tongues rip into his stomach, he screams, "Yes! That's it! Faster! Harder! Deeeeeeper..."
Gray Fox of Metal Gear Solid blatantly enjoys being attacked. "That's good, Snake... hurt me more!" A milder example is MGS3's The Pain (doesn't blatantly claim to enjoy pain), and he's ambiguous. Could just be that as his beekeeping hobby probably involves insects attacking him, pain barely hurts ...or you could interpret it that he covers himself with them because he enjoys pain.
Homer Pieron from Valkyria Chronicles enjoys getting hurt, which is emphasized with a potential that boosts his stats when his health is reduced to less than half. To top it off, the animation for activation has him practically orgasm.
Edy's DLC has him encourage Edy to keep hitting him, causing her to remark "So pretty, so broken."
Doviculus of Brütal Legend if FAR too kinky to hurt. When fighting him, his normal combat banter is "More pain" and other such comments. Also, some of his attacks inflict pain on him, such as using his heart as a guitar pick and stabbing himself with a huge spear as a double team attack.
In Six Days A Sacrifice, you can threaten an acolyte with torture unless he gives you information. He points out that, as a worshipper of what's basically the God of Pain, he's already done far more horrific things to himself than the characters can even conceive of.
In one of the Team Fortress 2 promotional videos, Meet the Sandvich, you are treated to the inside of a refrigerator where the titular Sandvich resides. After the Heavy grabs the Sandvich, you hear the sounds of the Heavy attacking and the Scout begging for mercy while the Soldier insults the Heavy on his sloppy work. Which is then subverted seconds after. Then again, it could just be the Soldier trying to be Drill Sergeant Nasty.
Soldier: You call that breaking my spine? You RED-team ladies couldn't break a spine if-*snap* AAAAGGGHH, MY SPIIIINE!
In Guilty Gear Xrd, when Faust uses his Ass Shove super, most characters are shown in a severe state of shock and/or pain. That is, except for I-No, who has a massive smile on her face when hit by it.
In a similar light, in BlazBlue: Chrono Phantasma, Relius' Astral Heat has several characters in compromising positions. But while the commentary for various characters is along the lines of disgust, Azrael basically asks him "That all you have?"
In Bang's gag reel, Azrael makes several comments about how lame the various tortures happen to be - he compares the cold of round 2 disfavorably to Kokonoe's freezer, and even asks in round 5 to "amp up the juice" when everyone is being electrocuted. He even makes a snappy comment when being digested by Arakune!Ironically, his inability to register that kind of pain winds up getting him killed along with Bang, Amane and Ragna.
Subverted in Dragon Age: Origins by Zevran's dream - he may joke about being tied up, but the cold blooded torture he suffered at the hands of the other Crows is clearly not something he enjoyed.
Albedo from Xenosaga. When he has his arm blasted off by Jr., he simply laughs.
In the English version, this trait is instead called Contrary, and the effect is lost.
In the game inFAMOUS the Big Bad of the story Kessler tells the protagonist Cole that in order to survive through torture and pain in general is that you have to enjoy the beating, even come to LOVE the pain. This is over the phone as Kessler had just gotten through torturing Sasha another villain in the story, despite Cole's indifference to Sasha as a person, as a result of her psychological torture on him and her sexual advances on him that he was blatantly uninterested in, he finds Kessler to be disgusting for torturing her.
The Rabbids in Rabbids Go Home, but replace "kinky" with "dumb." They enjoyVideo Game Cruelty Potential, and happily enjoy getting smacked in the face, having their features pulled at or exploded, and getting knocked around like pinballs.
The Sims Medieval has an Interrogation Chair, a chair Sims can tie other Sims up in to extract information either by "Persuasion," which requires interactions the Sim will like, or "Interrogation," which requires interactions the Sim will not like. Some Sims you can interrogate will actually like being doused with water, and liking a Chinchilla Attack is not unheard of. Almost, but not quite, this trope, since the interaction still affects their Will and can lead to the interrogating Sim getting the information.
The Black Witch in Immortal Souls is easily powerful enough to do whatever she wants, yet she'll willingly go along with being tortured, ordered around, and beat up if it suits her whims, and even claims to enjoy the pain. Lampshaded by a couple of the main characters when they can't figure out why she's cheerfully camping out as a prisoner of the Templars and submitting to their experiments when their control chip doesn't actually work on her.
Can be used to the player's advantage in Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers. When talking to some of the less... 'friendly' demons in a battle, they will sometimes ask the player character to scream for them, or even state their intent to 'bully' the party (most likely with a hard-hitting spell). Being too eager to scream, or answering 'I want more!' to being bullied, will often make a demon flat-out leave the battle in disgust.
In A Witchs Tale, Liddell sees a torture room early on and admires it.
Undead warlock Richard from Looking for Group. He was only trying to be helpful to the torturer when he pointed out there was room by his calf to insert another knife. In fact, when he was taken back to the dungeon he asked if he could have another go. He seemed to mistake the torture chamber for a spa. Oh, and he started singing during his torture sessions. Which rather unnerved the Legion soldiers. Though he did complain about the waterboarding.
After the death of Pompey in Something Positive, he appears in one of the 'Old Familiar Faces' arcs, complaining to the demon in hell that he doesn't get the worms eating his flesh or lake of fire torment.
Pompey: I was just re-reading this travel brochure, and I must say I'm filled with disgust at the false promises.
Demon: That's not a travel brochure. That's a Bible, and really I wanna know how you keep finding them down here.
Yuuko: This murder is becoming less of a random act of revenge and more like a public service.
In Flipside, protagonist Maytag has learned to accept pain rather than fight it, allowing her to be virtually impervious to torture and even mutilation. One scene has her smiling gently as her arm is being eaten, much to the dismay of the person doing the eating.
In GastroPhobia, Klepto is either telling the truth or using this strategy to avoid being tortured at all:
Phobia: You know, some people whip their slaves for less than that. Klepto: Phobia, it has been my goal to be whipped by an Amazon since I was thirteen.
Fanfic example: Yocchi ends up getting this turned around on herself in this Anime Addventure episode, however. And yes, it is another example of this trope.
Ranma: You call this torture? My mom would call it foreplay....
Girly (here) features a torture chamber designed as a mock-up of hell, but when Winter and Otra arrive, there are only two prisoners. One of them is an immortal who loves being eviscerated. The other is a veterinarian who, while she has not shown any masochistic tendencies in this comic, is an Expy of an earlier character who has appeared in some less reputable comics.
Played completely straight however when Sylvester and Adam eventually do try to torture him, which ends up being far moretorturousfor them. He eventually DOES give them the information they want though, as thanks for how much pleasure they gave him.
Gloog: I really did enjoy that wonderful burning pleasure you gave me.
Played with in thisOrder of the Stick strip, the Lantern Archons assume this when the Monster in the Darkness wants them to attack him with their rays of light, when really he just doesn't like the dark.
The grey aliens in the Sluggy Freelance story "Oceans Unmoving" are a bit weird like this, none more so than Murdock, who even likes to watch Dr. Viennason's DVDs. When he's put in futuristic manacles that cover his hands entirely, he wants to wear them permanently after he's been freed from imprisonment.
A version that's oddly light on both kinkiness and torture - in Grrl Power, Sydney speaks dismissively to the waitress at a spicy-food-oriented restaurant, prompting the workers there to dose her food with "The Unmaker." To the astonishment of all involved, she ''loves'' it.
Yuki shows shades of this in the beginning with her "emergency handcuffs". Later, Didi comes home unexpectedly and mistakes Yuki for a burglar. As Didi's tying her up on the bed, Yuki yells out, "Harder! I can slip out of these easily!" She even asks Gary for some clothespins!
There are a million worse things you could be doing to me other then just setting my foot on fire. No no no, get the one with the hooked end on it, there you go. Sharess you're terrible at this, no wonder you didn't make it into the Order of Salvation.
Karin-dou 4koma: A furious Seren hangs Kinka from the ceiling in apparent rope bondage off-panel for a perceived wrong. When she realizes her mistake and returns to release her, she finds a very happy Kinka saying that she could get used to this as a reward.
Mars: [after being bitten by a snake] "Ow! Oh, God... it felt good! Don't worry, Serena, I'm used to putting worse things in my body."
And in a far less subtle example, the moment where she demands some rough sex from the villain attacking her.
Sailor Venus as well
Malachite: "I'm going to hit you with a beam now, that is supposed to knock you out, so I can molest you, take the crystal, and then molest you."
Lita: "No way!"
Mina: "Me first!"
Dr. What in AH.com: The Series (and arguably Landshark as well). The only person who ever managed to successfully torture information out of What was one of his Alternate Universe counterparts, and that was by tantalising him by holding lesbian porn just out of reach.
The titular Salad Fingers appears to have masochistic tendencies.
A non-sexual variant occurs in Survival of the Fittest v4, where Rein Bumgarner is well-known for enjoying pain, enjoying the adrenaline rush that it gives him. As a result, he actually attempts dangerous stunts partly for this reason.
Ask That Guy loves getting tortured by his boss, whether he does things right or not. There could also be another example after the Sage episode, while he clearly didn't enjoy it while it was happening, the next episode is basically nothing but sex jokes and orgasm-faces.
Well, if Spooning With Spoony is any indication, Sage is also this. Note: he was rather nonchalant about being roofied and raped by Spoony. Twice.note once in Spooning With Spoony 2, and once in the third Donation Drive, which started with Spooning With Spoony 3
Sage: Same time next year? [kisses Spoony on the cheek]
Hilariously deconstructed in Reflets d'Acide, where the villain Mortis uses the Priest of PainSacher-Masoc as his Mole amongst the other priest of Maender-Alkor, convincing him to work for him by promising him to torture him as a reward. Similarly, when the priests find out about his betrayal and attempt to interrogate him, they quickly realize torture won't work on him and are Genre Savvy enough to promise him they will hit him if he confess. And it works.
In Ultra Fast Pony, Rarity enjoys pain. Threats of violence don't work on her, because anything her opponents can think of is something she already does for fun.
Applejack: You take that back or I'll cut ya! Rarity:[defiantly] Oh, yeah, will you? [hopefully] Will you? ... You can if you want...
Futurama: When Fry first awakes in the 31st century, he's put through a machine called the Probulator that almost leaves him in tears. Bender later undergoes the same treatment and says, "That Probulator sure knows how to treat a man."
Of course, seeing as how Bender and the Probulator are both machines, it was probably a little more consensual than when Fry was on it.
In Bender's Game, Leela is forced to wear an electric shock collar to discourage her tendency to violence. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on your point of view), she comes to associate the electric shocks with the pleasure of beating people up, and starts to enjoy being shocked.
In Total Drama Island when one of the challenges the campers face is to withstand ten seconds of torture, Izzy gets the challenge of being electrocuted by electric eels. She enjoys it. "Again!"
She then gives herself a poison-ivy face-wrap.
In the same episode, Lindsey thanks them for putting hot, gooey marshmellows on her face than ripping them off, though only because it was the best lip wax she's ever had.
In the episode I Triple Dog Dare You, Owen becomes this. The entire episode was a long game of truth or dare (without the truth part), and until Gwen and Owen team up, Owen gladly undertakes each and every dare thrown at him. The highlights include chewing Harold's saved and chewed gum, giving a bear a purple nurple, and eating dog food.
One episode of Family Guy contained a flashback of the Griffin family being tortured by the Dungeon Master. Peter was being whipped, but casually made fun of the torturer.
Peter: Um, oh I'm sorry were you just whipping me or did I just get bit by a mosquito? (Dungeon Master whips Peter again) Say Lois, if you happen to see the Dungeon Master could you tell him his grandmother was just trying to work me over?
Let's not forget the cow that enjoyed being milked and branded.
Or when Stewie found Lois hitting him stimulating.
Stewie: Come on, discipline me! Make me wear panties, rub dirt in my eye, violate me with a wine bottle- my God, I really do have problems, don't I?
Or Lois's interest in BDSM and how in one scene Peter shoots her and she excitedly demands that he "Stick your finger in there and twist it!" or when Peter started kicking everything after seeing Road House, Lois asked him not to kick her, unless it was her nipple.
Slave-driver: [whips him] What's you name?
Tobi: Tobi with an "I." With an accent over the "I," and a little line over the "O" so you know it's a long vowel sound and not a short one. And sometimes I like to dot the "I" with a little smiley face or a heart or something. Something to brighten the reader's day.
Slave-driver: [whips him] I asked you what your name was.
Tobi: Honey, you keep that up it's whatever you want it to be.
In South Park, when the boys approach Mel Gibson demanding their money back after seeing The Passion Of The Christ, Gibson proves to be this. The problem is, the boys have absolutely no intention of torturing him. Nevertheless, he oils and chains himself up whilst insisting that torture will do them no good (especially if they torture him in just the right place). The boys are, needless to say, utterly freaked out by this.
Captain Hero from Drawn Together, being a profoundly perverted parody of a superhero gets off on most anything, from being smashed by a lead model of the Eiffel Tower, to having his intestines removed from his body. Given the show he's in, this is pretty much expected.
An episode of Moral Orel has the title character misinterpreting the preacher's sermon about renouncing worldly pleasures as getting rid of everything that feels good; unfortunately, what makes Orel feel best of all is his relationship with the Lord. He tries to counteract this by subjecting himself to 24/7 torture, but ends up... well, looking forward to his father's next discussion "in the study."
The 1953 Pepe Le Pew cartoon Wild Over You. Click here and scroll down to the third cartoon of the first post for a description (or watch here).
One episode of Jimmy Two-Shoes had Heloise trying to give Beezy the rack. His only response is "Ah, that feels good." Another episode had him getting shocked by an electric helmet, only to clap "Again! Again!" Yet another episode has him constantly punching a Hollywood Voodoo doll of himself, saying "Neat!" every time.
Another episode had Lucius hiring Jimmy as a product tester, specifically because he knew anything that could break him would be Misery Inc. material. Sure enough, he enjoys all the products, even when Beezy suffers.
Archer has Cheryl, who's got a serious kinky side:
Pam: Well, what's the poem gonna be when Cyril snaps and horribly murders you?
Cheryl: ...I dunno. "World's Gushiest Orgasm?"
She also gets off on deliberately provoking people into attacking her. At one point she provokes Lana into tackling her and beating her senseless, and has an orgasm in the process. Later, when she gets slapped by Archer, her only response is to smile, and then angrily call him a "Tease!" when he walks away.
Something like this is implied with Coach Buzzcut when he tells Butt-Head to "kick him in the jimmy". Butt-Head does so, prompting Buzzcut to turn red and demand he do it harder. When Butt-Head complies the second time, Buzzcut's response is a heated "EEEEEEEEEEEEEYES!"
In King of the Hill, a pornographer makes a perverted website about Peggy's feet. Her husband, Hank, finds out about it, meets the pornographer, and gives one of his signature lines: "I'm gonna kick your ass!" The pornographer sticks his rear out and says something like, "Ooh, good! Let me get it on camera!" Hank decides against doing what he had threatened, as he usually ends up doing when he makes that threat.
Interesting variation here. It's not for him, it's just that he takes his job seriously, and is clearly a pragmatic businessman.
Johnny Bravo in the original short when a girl zaps him with a stun gun at the Aron City Zoo, although (like the series that would later follow) it just may be that he actually doesn't have a clue (and thus is actually that stupid)...
Rocko's Modern Life: In one episode Rocko is in the yard, practicing his jackhammering, only he can't see very well, so he's land the jack hammer on Spunky. Heffer dives taking Spunky out of harm's way at the last second, but Rocko lands the jackhammer on Heffer's back-side instead. Rocko apologizes for running him over, but Heffer says that he "kind of likes it" while biting the grass and looking extremely pleased.
Somewhat in Green Lantern: The Animated Series. Razer's captors try to Mind Rape him into submitting by showing him his worst memories over and over again. He enjoys it, because he gets to see his dead wife again, if only for a moment.
In Dragons: Riders of Berk Ruffnut and Tuffnut take this above and beyond. They constantly abuse each other and clearly enjoy the pain. Also, whenever someone jokes about a plan involving one of them getting seriously injured or even sacrificed, the usual response is that they're happily to oblige.
Fishlegs: In the past, I know Thor's enjoyed a sacrifice or two.
Ruffnut: Let's sacrifice Tuffnut!
Tuffnut: (ponders for a second) Okay. What time should I be there? There better be fire involved.
On Adventure Time,Jake is sick of Finnusing him as a battle suit and seriously hurting him, so he does the same to Finn to get him to admit that it sucks. Unfortunately, even non-conventional forms of torture (getting Finn to read a boring book, embarrass himself in front of his girlfriend's family, etc.) prove ineffective, until the end when Finn is begging Jake to actually go through with his plan of making him jump in a volcano. Having his burns treated by Clown Nurses? Too much for Finn. Worth It for Jake.