Troperville
Editing Help
Tools
Toys
|
alt title(s): Bechdels Rule; Bechdel Test
There aren't a lot of franchises with more than one, if any, interesting and complex female characters.
The Bechdel Test or the Bechdel-Wallace Test is a sort of litmus test for female presence in movies and TV. In order to pass, the film or show must meet the following criteria:
- it includes at least two women,
- who have at least one conversation with each other
- about something other than a man or men.
Now, by limiting yourself to shows/movies that pass the test, you'd be cutting out a lot of otherwise-worthy entertainment; indeed, a fair number of top-notch works have legitimate reasons for including no women (e.g. ones set in a men's prison or on a military submarine or with no conversations at all or with only one character). You may even be cutting out a lot of works that have a feminist tone. But that's the point: too little fiction created today, particularly in TV and movies, has independent female characters. Things have improved since the test was first formulated (the strip in which it was originally suggested was written in 1985), but Hollywood still needs to be prodded to put in someone other than The Chick.
It's obviously easier for a TV series, especially one with an Ensemble Cast, to follow this rule than a film, because there's far more time for the conversation to occur in. For example, Stargate Atlantis is not an especially feminist show, but one episode features two female characters discussing a (female) alien that's attacking them, and in the fourth season the presence of a female commander, a female doctor, and a female warrior meant for a lot of conversation about something other than dudes. To compensate for this, Bechdel's Rule-inspired analyses of television often look episode-by-episode, or compare the series' compliance with Bechdel's Rule with its compliance with a "reverse Bechdel rule" with the roles of men and women swapped.
Named for Alison Bechdel, creator of the comic strip Dykes To Watch Out For, who made it famous with this strip . It's also called the Mo Movie Measure, after Mo, the main character of DTWOF, but Mo wasn't yet a character when the strip appeared; it's from the early days of the strip before it moved to a serial format with recurring characters. The strip itself notes a film need not be essentially feminist to pass the test, as the last film the character saw was Alien (with two women discussing the xenomorph).
Contrast The Smurfette Principle — Works that follow The Smurfette Principle include a female character strictly for demographic appeal with no real consideration for what attracts the female demographic; works that pass the Bechdel Test have regular characters that just happen to be female and are not flat. In many ways, this makes them more feminist than works that try to be feminist. Instead of the existence of "interesting and complex female characters" being hyped and celebrated like a rare phenomenon, it's not treated as the least bit unusual. However, this doesn't necessarily mark them as independant characters. In Female Success Is Family, we can see that even a well rounded female character with her own goals is most often only relevant to the story by her relationship to a man.
Works that score high on the Bechdel Test:
open/close all folders
General
Anime and Manga
- Subverted and
played straight pretty much cheatin' in Azumanga Daioh. While the girls often talk about humorous, non-romance oriented topics, they also spend a great deal of time discussing boys other women.
- Lucky Star. It helps when a) there are only two men in the cast, and b) one of the first conversations is a 6 minute dialogue about how to eat different foods.
- Higurashi No Naku Koro Ni
- Sailor Moon
- Fullmetal Alchemist: what with Action Girls galore, Izumi Curtis and the fact that The Chick is actually a likeable and interesting character even while being completely feminine and not having any signs of Action Girl-ness (manga-only), FMA is arguable one of the most feminist mangas around.
- Helps that the manga is done by a woman.
- Black Lagoon, while simultaneously managing to preserve the dignity of the male sex, as does...
- Bleach, Rukia and Orihime are both female main characters, and neither are stereotyped flat female characters. There is an even interesting variation that, despite Rukia being viewed as more masculine by the fans, she's also more likely to wear dresses (and loves bunnies!) than Orihime, who is the sweet, bubbly girl in comparison (she wears skirts in most of the color spreads, but opts for a track suit during the Soul Society arc, and wears hakama pants for Hueco Mundo). About 1/3 of the rest of the huge cast are also female.
- Gunsmith Cats
- Neon Genesis Evangelion
- Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha. As Erica Friedman, the ever snarky Yuricon founder, mentioned in her blog
after her encounter with the over-enthusiastic shippers of the fandom, all of the mostly female cast look married to their careers more than anything else.
- Slayers
- Card Captor Sakura
- Claymore With the tremendous amount of action girls and alot of time spend fighting it's pretty difficult to find two adult males engaged in a conversation. And if there is, it's usually the town elder discussing the situation and the need to call for a Claymore with his advisor which technically counts as being a conversation about females.
- Suzumiya Haruhi No Yuutsu
- Chrono Crusade, partially thanks to three out of the four characters in the nakama being female (as well as Chrono and Rosette's boss, and three of the villain "sinners"). Somewhat weakened when you realize that the nakama is almost Chrono's Unwanted Harem, though.
- Noir, Madlax, and El Cazador De La Bruja by Bee Train. With the majority of the cast being consistently female, all three are about conspiracies and hard-boiled action (except, perhaps, the third one). And Christian existentialism.
- Princess Tutu has Ahiru and Rue talking about and vying for Mytho, but also commenting on each other's ballet skills, forming an odd comradery and Ahiru trying to help Rue with her issues. Then there are the talks/therapy sessions Ahiru has with the various females possessed by heart-shards and her talks with Edel.
- Would Dokkoida fit this as well? Haven't seen much of it so far, but it seems like it might fit...
- Cowboy Bebop
- Dennou Coil has the mostly female cast primarily involved in discovering the secrets behind the city-wide Augmented Reality system, and thus passes the Bechdel Test in pretty much every episode — even in the character arc of the primary male character.
- Ashita no Ousama (Tomorrow's King) focuses on a female would-be playwright, with the lead having numerous conversations with female friends and colleagues about her progress as a play-wright. Also a regular internal monologue directed toward her dead grandmother.
- A number of Hayao Miyazaki films pass (possibly all, even), such as Kiki's Delivery Service, Spirited Away and My Neighbor Totoro. Not surprising given the large number of female characters given focus in his films, and the comparative lack of focus on romance.
- Death Note fails this test to an insane level. It's quite possible that there isn't even a moment, in either the manga or anime, where two females interact with each other AT ALL. The series could be toeing the border of sexism if it wasn't handled so well.
- There are moments where Sachiko (the mother), Sayu (the sister), and Misa (the girlfriend) interact. However, consider that all these characters are almost solely defined by their relationship to the hero...
Comic Books
Films
- Aliens
- Bound
- Fried Green Tomatoes
- Ginger Snaps
- Thelma And Louise
- Kill Bill
- For all its other faults, Death Proof also scores high: the second group of four women talk at length about their jobs, funny accident stories, self-defense and gun ownership, the film Vanishing Point. Sex and relationships work their way into the conversation as well, but they're clearly just another part of the women's lives instead of their all-consuming focus.
- Fargo, by the Coen Brothers. Although it must be pointed out that, in spite of a strong Pregnant Badass lead character, the movie only technically passes the test - because, when Marge is interviewing the two hookers about her suspects, they are talking about men - only not in that sense. The hookers are simply describing what the two suspects look like, and actually seem more interested in getting sidetracked into talking about every other topic under the sun.
- Legally Blonde — The protagonist's character arc is all about finding a purpose beyond a love interest, in fact.
- Happy-Go-Lucky: It has lots and lots of those, but for starters: Near the beginning of the movie we have the main protagonist Poppy and her sister AND her long-time female flatmate Zoe AND two other long-time female friends groggily talking about all sorts of things after a night at the local discotheque. We also have alot of scenes between Poppy and Zoe, Poppy and her female teacher colleagues and Poppy and either of her sisters which pass the Bechdel Test.
- Surprisingly, the 2007 version of St. Trinian's. While some of the older students are dressed in skimpy clothes, it's not overt and the schoolgirls' main focus was getting enough money to keep the school open. While there was some teasing and mocking of the new girl, she's quickly accepted by everyone in the school.
- Whip It
- Oddly, Bring It On. The main characters don't talk much about dating, as it's all about the controversy. They're also all portrayed as smart, and the lead female is taking advanced chemistry.
- Mean Girls does well, as while romance is discussed the movie is really about the vicious politics of "girl world".
- The fact that they discuss romance sometimes is okay. Even if it's the main plot, as long as the female characters are shown to have other interests/concerns which they discuss with other women, it passes. Mean Girls passes particularly well because it demonstrates the perils of prioritizing romance over bigger things (in Cady's case, her math grades).
- Mad Money
- The Descent.
- Zombieland
- Juno.
- Pirates Of The Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl technically just scrapes through; Elizabeth and Anamaria exchange two sentences of dialogue about the ship chase.
- The Devil Wears Prada. They talk about fashion a lot. They also talk about their careers and then there's the Hannibal Lecture and the Not So Different moment.
Literature
- Animorphs
- The Assassins Of Tamurin
- The Chronicles Of Narnia
- The Faerie Queene — Una with Caelia, Artemis with Aphrodite, Britomart with Radigund (if talking about how you're going to kill each other counts); the female leads Britomart and Amoret mostly only talk about their love interests, but they make up for it with plenty of Les Yay.
- His Dark Materials
- Little Women
- Perry Rhodan: Capable women and relationships exist, but if anything, it's the men who discuss relationships - and not in the "conquest" sense. Might be done deliberately to avert The Smurfette Principle.
- Watership Down: For all the (justified) complaints about how rabbit society as depicted in the first novel is more patriarchal than rabbit society in Real Life, as well as females being valued as nothing more than breeding stock, Hyzenthlay and her friends do meet the three terms of the Bechdel Test.
- Quite a few of the Discworld novels, but most especially the Witches and Tiffany Aching series.
- Later books about the watch do well too.
- Monstrous Regiment as well. Discworld passes the test best when the women are allowed to be flawed and funny, and that's Monstrous Regiment all over.
- A Little Princess
- The Secret Garden
- The Wonderful Wizard Of Oz, and the Oz books in general. It helps that the protagonist is female and so are most of the powerful supernatural entities in the setting.
- Harry Potter
- Pride And Prejudice is only Fair For Its Day but a bit of a snarky inversion for its day, as is a lot of Jane Austen's work. Yes, all the lead heroines like Jane and Elizabeth have to talk about is marriage and men... but they also show that life for women shouldn't be like that, what with Jane and Mr. Bennett advising Lizzie not to marry without love and respect for her partner, and Elinor from Sense And Sensibility advising Marianne not to act like the world has ended because her lover abandoned her. Since society did not quite agree that it was acceptable for women to have anything besides pleasing men on their minds, however, Austen's feminism comes not from using this trope but from demonstrating the need for it in Real Life.
- The Dresden Files
- Also, the Codex Alera by the same author. Yes, the women do talk about men- but they talk about a lot of other things too, including but not limited to warfare, politics, and preventing The End Of The World As We Know It (or causing it, if the Vord Queen really counts as a "woman" or not).
- Young Wizards. Not hard, since three of the main characters are female.
- Honor Harrington: while Queen Elizabeth, Honor, Emily, Michelle Henke, and co. spend a lot of time talking about men, it usually consists of how to remove them from power. Or, y'know, kill them.
- Northanger Abbey probably scores the highest among Jane Austen's work, given how often Catherine and Eleanor talk about books and art. In fact, this is used to emphasize how different their friendship is from the shallow "friendship" Catherine has with Isabella, who talks about nothing but men.
- Anything by Tamora Pierce. Understandable, seeing as she is dedicated to subverting the Smurfette Principle.
- The Wheel Of Time features a good many (strong) female protagonists that interact a lot with each other and easily passes the test. Actually, if you start counting the "main" characters, there are actually more females than males! ....On a less positive note tough, three of those female characters end up being the Hero's Love Interests ( Yes. He "loves" them all, and they love him so much they are willing to share.) Also, the said strong female characters tend to become very harebrained whenever they think about their Love Interest, if not becoming only a flat, boring shell of the character they were after getting married... Still, it is a commendable attempt at depicting females in fantasy.
- Your Mileage May Vary. Jordan's portrayal of women is widely seen as one-dimensional and demeaning, although their sheer numbers do allow them to pass the Bechdel test.
- Kate Daniels best friend Andrea Nash works with her at the Order of Merciful Aid; their conversations are usually about monsters, guns, and fantasy politics. As well, Kate sort of inherits an orphaned teenager, Julie. Kate talks to her about life, death, family and self-worth, among other topics, and their conversations about Julie's teenaged love interest are more about a mentor telling a young woman what she needs to know about the world and the people in it.
- The Women Of The Otherworld series has five (so far) female narrators who are all friends with each other; rarely, if ever, do they discuss their significant others. They're usually too busy fighting monsters, but they do make a point of staying in touch and maintaining their friendships over the course of the series.
- The Princess Diaries, although a lot of the conversation between the girls is about boys, passes pretty easily since the series is about a girl with several female friends.
Live Action TV
- Buffy The Vampire Slayer
- Angel
- Firefly, given that River is pretty crazy (you would be, too), and doesn't seem to have any romantic feelings, and Zoe is married and focused on work, it's not too hard.
- None of Firefly's female characters are single-handedly focused on romance. Kaylee loves her job as Serenity's mechanic, and for Inara, the reason that the obvious mutual affection between her and Mal is never consummated is because she prioritizes her job as a Companion above it. The reason "Our Mrs. Reynolds" is funny because Saffron's submissiveness sticks out in an otherwise very feminist universe ...until we find out it was all an act to allow her to take control of the ship.
- Dollhouse: Actives are iffy, but Adelle and Claire never discussed romance onscreen.
- In a nutshell: Pretty much everything by Joss Whedon.
- Fraggle Rock
- Stargate Atlantis, as noted above.
- Star Trek Voyager passes this one with flying colors almost every episode, but Star Trek The Next Generation fails surprisingly. Yes, two strong female leads, but they are usually discussing their respective love interests.
- A magazine article dated 1998 (the height of Star Trek Deep Space Nine and Star Trek Voyager era popularity) talked extensively about Dax, Kira, Seven, Torres and Janeway between the two series and its depiction of women compared to the earlier series. When interviewing Rick Berman, he made mention that people seem to have easily forgotten Tasha Yar, a female Chief of Security who grew up in a colony that became a violent gangland. The actress left when she felt she was being underused, and it was just bad luck that the remaining women on the Enterprise were the more passive caretakers.
- Star Trek Enterprise also passes. While T'Pol was one half of the Official Couple, she rarely discussed her relationship with anyone except Trip. Most conversations she had with Hoshi were business-related.
- The reimagined Battlestar Galactica was known to fail the reverse Bechdel test, in which there were episodes where two men (the Adamas junior and senior) only talked about women (usually Starbuck and Roslin). While two female Ace Pilots settled a grudge in the main story.
- The Middleman. Lacey and Wendy. Art crawl!
- Power Rangers scores shockingly high for a series aimed at prepubescent boys. Then again, aside from a few seasons it's an aggressively No Hugging No Kissing franchise.
- Stargate Universe
- The West Wing scores a pass despite a less-than-progressive female-male ratio in the West Wing Staff (which does, of course, mirror Real Life). CJ's bitching out of Mandy in regards to an opposition memo is the prime example that comes up from Season One.
- Torchwood. At least season's one and two. Despite only having two main female cast (albeit out of 5 characters), their relatively infrequent discussions about men as usually outweighed by their job-related discussions. Then again, sometimes in Torchwood the men have more discussions about other men... does that count as failing the reverse Bechdel Test?
- Xena Warrior Princess
- Gilmore Girls
- Scrubs lampshades this in the episode where Elliot asks Carla if they would have been friends if they hadn't dated JD/Turk respectively. She answers that no, they wouldn't have.
- Castle
- Doctor Who. The females hardly ever talk about men, being far more concerned about the Monster Of The Week. The old series was especially remarkable in it's time for having many female characters and hardly any romance.
- Friends
- The remake of Cupid lampshaded this in an episode, with a female character agreeing to go running with the female lead as long as they didn't talk about men. They immediately break their promise.
- CSI
- 30 Rock
- On Fringe, Olivia Dunham talks to other women—Astrid, Nina, suspects' families—about men quite a lot, but it's generally in terms of catching them (criminals) or keeping them from doing something stupid (Walter). She also has talks with her sister and niece about plenty of everyday stuff. The only "romance" conversations she has center on Rachel's abusive ex-husband.
- Law and Order: SVU, the Designated Doctor has the same relationship with Olivia as she has with the other detectives.
- Chuck is an interesting case — while female lead Sarah and her supervisor General Beckman are often discussing Chuck in some way, it's more as a national security asset than specifically as a love interest.
- Bones passes the test most weeks — while all the characters discuss their love lives a fair amount, Brennan, Angela, & Cam (and sometimes Daisy) tend to discuss the evidence for the case they're working on. Additionally, they'll discuss their own personal issues without reference to men.
- Better Off Ted beautifully passes the test. On the surface, it would seem like Veronica and Linda would be mostly talking to each other about the complicated relationships they each hold with Ted, but they've brought it up, got it out of their system, and moved on. Now, they're throwing bagels into air-ducts!
- The Golden Girls Not that they don't still talk plenty about their love lives though.
- How I Met Your Mother has Robin and Lily... although their non-man-based interaction isn't that substantial.
- Freaks And Geeks is perhaps the best example of how passing The Bechdel Test should not be as much of an accomplishment as it is. Look at how predominantly male the main cast is, but yet how many of the conversations between Lindsay and Kim, or Lindsay and Millie, etc. have nothing to do with boyfriends or romance. (In fact, most of the romance conversations on the show involve at least one guy.) It really makes one wonder how it is that rom-coms with mostly-female casts find the measure so elusive.
Theater
- Wicked
- Into The Woods
- Chicago
- The Sound Of Music- due to Maria's discussions with the Mother Superior (with the exception of the last one which is all about how she's in love with Georg), the other nuns singing "How Do You Solve a Problem Like Maria?" the first time, the conversations between the female VonTrapp kids and most of theirs with Maria.
- Fiddler On The Roof just barely passes (the conversation between Golde and Yente at the end about Yente's plans to move to Jerusalem is what does it).
Video Games
- The Phoenix Wright series. While there is a considerable amount of female interaction throughout the series, the most notable example would probably be the interactions between Mia Fey and Dahlia Hawthorne, since they take on the roles of heroine and villain of that particular case.
- Halo. Cortana when talking to Keyes in 2 and 3, Foehammer in 1, and different people in the books mostly are on non-John related stuff. Even then, she only has a slight inherited (from her creator, who's cloned brain that had all of her memories and intelligence in it) attraction to John.
- Halo Wars also gets mention, as Serina and Professor Anders are normally a bit busy dealing with the Covenant.
- In the books, the Spartans NEVER talk about guys, as they have no sex drive due to the UNSC augmentations. It's a side effect.
- Halsey and Kelly never talk about this in Ghost of Onyx, either. This is due to one being a Spartan, the other a 60 year old woman (However, that's about middle age by then) and the fact they have bigger problems. Again, Spartans have no sex drive.
- Batman Arkham Asylum. When Harley runs into Ivy, Ivy just begs Harley to let her out of her cell.
- Certain Sonic games, like Sonic Heroes, Sonic Rush and Sonic Chronicles.
- All Fallout games. Yes, all of them.
- All Elder Scrolls games, too.
- Mass Effect also scores high on this, particularly if you play a female Commander Shepard (as you don't overhear many conversations that don't involve you).
- This seems a trend for Bioware - Dragon Age, their latest game, also scores high.
- Saints Row 2 can also score high if you make a female character. In fact, the female version uses the same script, so she comes off as lesbian, or at least bi.
- Mercenaries also passes this, with flying colors (assuming you pick female player character, Jen).
- Alyx Vance may be Freeman's obvious love interest, but she's fully fleshed and a plausible product of her environment, growing up in a commune of scientists post-cataclysm as a hands-on engineering mechanic with survival skills and a geeky streak. Dr. Mossman, the other female main character, may not match her Bad Ass quotient, but she's at least as capable in a crisis as any of her scientist peers.
- Final Fantasy X-2, probably the girliest Final Fantasy game to date.
- Final Fantasy XIII, not surprising as it shares director with X-2.
- Persona 3. Yukari and Mitsuru's friendship and professional relationship are one of the major aspects of the game (at one point, they nearly come to blows over the true purpose of SEES as a combat and investigation unit, and they help each other through major personal crises,) as is Fuuka's relationship with Natsuki.
- The earlier Atelier Series games score very high on this, as the protagonists are all female and typically goal-oriented; the first game, Atelier Marie, didn't even have "romance options". Sadly, those games have yet to make it over to the US, even after years of waiting; the later installments which have come over struggle a lot harder with this. Atelier Annie, the most recent release in the series, however, manages to once again pass with flying colors.
- The World Ends With You barely does it with Shiki and Rhyme. Just barely...
Webcomics
Web Animation
- Teen Girl Squad - Yes, they're aren't as well developed as some examples, like say, Coraline. Yes, it was purely due to laughs. However, they did filled out the rules rather well regardless.
Western Animation
- Avatar The Last Airbender
- Alice In Wonderland
- Batman The Animated Series
- Captain Planet And The Planeteers
- Codename Kids Next Door
- The Powerpuff Girls
- Sat AM Sonic The Hedgehog
- Walt Disney's Sleeping Beauty: Scary thought, considering the title character is extremely passive and hardly does anything except sing songs, fall in love, and cry about her arranged marriage. But forget about the princess for a second and look at who gets the most plot time: it's the three good fairies and Maleficent, all females.
- Teen Titans
- Where On Earth Is Carmen Sandiego? — The premise of the show is "Kid Heroes chase The Sandiego around the world with help from a Magical Computer." Starring an Action Girl versus a famous female Villain Protagonist is never treated as anything odd or revolutionary. That is the feminism judged by the Bechdel Test.
- She Ra Princess Of Power
- Jem. Most impressively, She-ra and this were released in 1985, around the time when the rule was first noticed due to the small amount of popular media that could pass it.
- The Incredibles
- The Princess And The Frog — Tiana is the first Disney Princess since Aurora to get significant interaction with other female characters like Charlotte, her mother, and Mama Odie.
- All the Barbie movies.
- Coraline
- WITCH
- Rugrats
- The Simpsons
- Daria
- The Secret Of NIMH
- Mulan - okay, while it's more focused on the title character's battle, she did have some talk from her grandmother and mother before she ran away to war.
- Lilo And Stitch
- Phineas And Ferb
- Ruby Gloom
|
|