Main Tropes Index

Troperville

Editing Help

Tools

Toys

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

Custom Search

Describe Squall here. Good luck.

A rather combative, pessmistically optimistic yet curious troper who loves Chess, holds extremely politically-incorrect social views, is fascinated by The Unexplained, seeks out Crowning Moments of Awesome wherever he can find them, and tries to identify, wherever possible, potential ontological fallacies contained in mainstream pop-culture fiction, in the name of separating that which is worthy from that which is not. Toward that end, has anyone ever considered:

  • How did Older Biff Tannen get back to Normal 2015 in Back to the Future, Part II after he had given himself The Almanac and created the Alternate Universe in which he would have then arrived on the return trip? This affects the entire story, as Doc learns who caused the disaster only through finding the broken top of the cane that Biff broke only after impossibly arriving back in the normal world.
  • That when the crazy old guy in Gods Debris says,
    Every generation of humans believed it had all the answers it needed, except for a few mysteries they assumed would be solved at any moment. And they all believed their ancestors were simplistic and deluded. What are the odds that you are the first generation of humans who will understand reality?
    ...he himself is assuming that, just because given people in a previous, potentially ancient generation might have indeed gotten things 100% right (well...99...98?...) in their perception of reality, the vast majority of their peers would've accepted it? Or rather, here are two counter-suppositions for you
    1. Given the majority of humanity's truly epic history of genocidal intolerance of anything they both couldn't keep under constant control but could successfully kill, wouldn't the odds favor the slaughter, rather than flourishing, of anything that truly transcended their limited thinking?
    2. Are the odds against finally getting it right any greater than the odds against every previous generation being right about their ancestors being wrong?
  • In Terminator 2: Judgment Day, when T-1000 arrives at the Dyson residence, how are those papers still burning in the garbage can? Paper burns pretty quickly (as directly observable IN the scene, incidentally), and enough time has passed for the machine to hear the break-in report given over the police scanner that directly leads it to the Cyberdyne headquarters.
  • In Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, when Spock brilliantly deduces the existence of a vessel that can fire while cloaked, why do he and the rest of the crew automatically assume it is of Klingon origin, when the Romulans, who later on in the very same movie (let alone the overall Trek universe) are proven to be quite against any such détente between their rivals, not only also possess cloak technology, but were in fact its originators among the Alpha Quadrant powers?