troperville
tools
toys
5th Feb: Echo Chamber Season 1 blooper reel on Youtube here
SubpagesMain
|
In movies and TV, the primary method for showing that something has become the news item of the moment is to have somebody flick through the channels on TV and find that every single channel is covering the same story simultaneously. To make things more convenient, sometimes every time they switch channels they find a new aspect of the story being covered, so that this random succession of sound bites adds up to a fairly cohesive television article.
For example, Bob the jewel thief watches the news triumphantly:
Reporter: "Russian Police are baffled after the mysterious disappearance of the Hungarian crown jewels."
Bob switches channels.
New reporter: "The jewels, on loan to the State Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, were supposedly protected by a five-million-ruble security system."
Bob switches again.
Yet another reporter: "However, at nine o'clock this morning, museum curator Dmitri Chukraj was alarmed to discover that the entire display had somehow been replaced with some Reese's Pieces and a rubber chicken."
And so forth. It's sometimes parodied by having him turn to a channel that normally wouldn't have the news - a Japanese news channel, or MTV - and yet it's still talking about it. Expect a news-phobic Apathetic Citizen to stop flipping immediately if they do manage to find anything else on.
Makes varying degrees of sense; when the story is about, say, a nuclear threat on the White House, you'd expect nothing less. But when it's something like a chimp loose on the freeway, it starts to get dubious. And even if it is important, flipping through channels never gives repeat information, even though it's highly unlikely that each broadcast started at the exact same time and covered all the points in the exact same order. Plus eventually you have to get to some shopping channel or college/school billboard or public access channel which would never break their format (or even have the ability) to report anything at all. Nevermind the fact that the various news channels are watching each other's broadcasts, and therefore information on breaking developments doesn't stay exclusive for long.
This trope has for all intents and purposes replaced the Spinning Paper montage, which in movies of the thirties, forties and fifties was used to this effect by having the story appear as the front page of every major newspaper.
See also Coincidental Broadcast, Worst News Judgment Ever, or Your Television Hates You for the non-news version. The basic idea is Truth in Television.
Examples
Anime and Manga
- Justified in Black Cat, after the Big Bad kills more or less every major world leader in one day. No one is talking about anything else, obviously.
- The third part of Jojo's Bizarre Adventure has an interesting variant that combines this trope with Coincidental Broadcast. Joseph's stand gives him a clairvoyant ability when used in conjunction with certain objects: when he uses this on a television, the channel begins flipping rapidly, and the resultant melding of words from different speakers ends up spelling out a new message that gives the information he wants.
Comic Books
- While not an exact montage, in Watchmen, Ozymandias sees the effect of a disaster by watching multiple news channels simultaneously and getting the message that has been sent.
- Same thing in Kingdom Come, with Superman watching multiple reports of the Kansas disaster in the Fortress of Solitude.
Film
Literature
- In Ben Elton's book Popcorn, a set of serial killers reveal to their hostages that their situation is on every channel on TV. Except for one channel showing The Simpsons, which is seamlessly dropped in.
Live-Action TV
- This happens frequently on the new Doctor Who series. During episodes where aliens or creatures attempt to invade Earth, fictional news broadcasts (usually BBC News) will be shown explaining the situation and worldwide reaction to the event. In the episode "Army of Ghosts", the Doctor is shown at one point flipping through TV channels, which are all devoted in some way to the regular appearances of the ghosts — not just on the news, but on talk shows, T-shirts, and even Eastenders. Similarly, in "Aliens of London", the crashed spaceship is the hot topic on all news channels, and also Blue Peter (which is showing kids how to make a model of it). This happened as recently as the episode "The Sontaran Strategem".
- Subverted in the episode "The Sound of Drums", where Mr Saxon flicks through various channels reporting on the upcoming First Contact, before finally settling down to watch The Teletubbies.
- Played for laughs in Saturday Night Live, in a skit where Bill Clinton, in bed with Hillary, tries desperately to find a news channel that is not discussing his sex scandal. No hope for him though, as even the weather report manages to weasel it in.
- Used in the pilot of Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip where every news channel is covering the show's producer's outburst on live TV about the crappy state of today's television landscape. It actually uses this to mock the quick formation of memes as every single reporter independently latches onto an analogy to the famous "I'm mad as hell" scene from Network.
- Inverted in the British comedy Broken News, which is based on someone supposedly flipping between 24-hour news channels, all of which are showing different stories, and the amusement comes from the start of one story feeding into a different one as the channel is changed.
Newspaper Comics
Video Games
- In Starcraft II, this is the method Matt Horner uses to bring Jim Raynor up to speed on the Zerg invasion. Of course, when you have an event like this where billions of people are being killed, it ought to be on every station. The flipping itself is justified in at least one case, where a sudden explosion kills the news crew and cuts off the signal.
Western Animation
- Was sent up in The Simpsons episode "Radioactive Man", where the channel breaks occur every syllable: "Ev"-"er"-"y"-"one"-"is"-"tal"-"king"-"a"-"bout"-"Ra"-"di"-"o"-"act"-"ive"-"man"-"y'all."
- Used also in "Homer Bad Man" where, inexplicably, Homer allegedly touching a babysitter's butt is national news on every channel and Movie Of The Week fodder.
- Yeah, you know things are bad when even Channel Ocho is having a field day at your expense.
- Except that one channel that never talks about anything past the 1980's.
- A common variation is for a character who is trying not to think about some topic be reminded of it in some way by everything on TV. In one Sponge Bob Square Pants episode, Squidward is annoyed by Spongebob and Patrick's fascination with playing in an empty box. When he turns on the TV, everything is somehow related to boxes.
- Including a Boxing Match which consists of Two Boxes fighting.
- A version of this was seen on The Weekenders, where Tish, angry that her friends have started using her name as a slang word, flips through the channels and discovers that every channel has some reference to "Tishing". (An advertiser is heard to say "It's Tishtastic!")
Real Life
- Subverted in real life where, if a story's important, it won't be covered in the news.
- Unless it's on the level of the 1991 Gulf War, the attacks of September 11th, 2001, the transit bombings in London, England on July 7th, 2005, or the OJ Simpson trial in which case try finding a channel that isn't covering it, and for hours on end at that.
- So much so that parents were warned not to let their children watch TV on the afternoon of September 11th, 2001 because of how widespread the coverage was. To be fair, this was back when the major networks used to actually have children's programming blocks on weekday afternoons (and of course, much of PBS's normal daytime programming is comprised of the likes of Sesame Street and Barney & Friends)
- The same goes for a Presidential address (shown live) in the US.
- There are plenty of less-than-important stories that get wall-to-wall coverage as well. In fact, less-than-important stories seem to get more wall-to-wall coverage than important ones.
- This came with the rise of round-the-clock news coverage. They have hours of news to fill, so they tend to repeat themselves quite a bit. Shows with sensationalist leanings, such as Nancy Grace, are even worse; that women can get a solid six month's worth of shows out of one news event.
- Supposedly, the Bill Clinton/Monica Lewinsky scandal literally took up about 1.5 times as much screen time as every other news story combined when it was the big story.
- Michael Jackson's death has become a "too true" example of a single story dominating several stations at once.
- The Michael Jackson coverage took up almost a month of round the clock coverage, even ignoring major global events like the revolts in Iran and a coup in Latin America.
- For a less recent example of the above, see Princess Di.
- At least in the United States, there will always be some channels which wouldn't change their programming even at The End of the World as We Know It. The Cartoon Network is going to show their cartoons, the Food Channel is going to be baking a cake, and Sesame Street is going to sing a song about sharing.
- 2 out of 3. After the attacks of September 11th, 2001, the Food Network broadcast a memorial graphic and nothing else.
- The attacks didn't alter the Street, but a storyline was aired about a fire at the Fix-It Shop a year after. (Arthur had a similar storyline.)
- A lot of networks (especially networks that broadcast nothing but pre-recorded shows) were operated completely automatically back then. The only person on site might have been a lone security guard. It never occurred to the owners that there could be a national emergency serious enough to affect broadcasting but not serious enough for broadcasting not to matter. Nowadays most networks have at least one operator on duty in Master Control whenever they're on air for this exact reason.
- Also, a lot of the kids' networks deliberately didn't change their schedules, so that kids would have something safe to watch.
|
|
