Meet John. An Indian who never met his parents because he was raised by a white couple. He takes revenge.
In this work, we see examples of:
- Alternate Universe - Tends to be of the kind in the ending to Neon Genesis Evangelion, a fantasy created by the protagonist.
- Ambiguous Syntax - The title, Indian Killer, could be someone who kills Indians or an Indian who is a killer.
- Anachronism Stew - Who the hell said Native American in The Seventies?
- Animal Motifs - the owl
- Ascend to a Higher Plane of Existence - It's implied Father Duncan does this.
- Blatant Lies - There's a whole chapter late in the book consisting of Truck spouting one after the other.
- Blind Seer - One of the homeless Indians.
- Darker and Edgier - Compare this to any other Sherman Alexie work.
- Did We Just Have Tea with Cthulhu? - John and Marie are quite friendly.
- Expy - Reggie's father might be based on real-life South Dakota politician Bill Janklow, who is infamous in Indian country.
- Five-Man Band - A homeless Indian says the Indian Killer has Crazy Horse's magic, Wovoka's vision, Chief Joseph's smarts, and Geronimo's heart. Considering that John's 6'6", John himself could be considered The Big Guy.
- Foe Yay - Wilson becomes quite enamored with John.
- Four Is Death - You can make a fun drinking game out of the number of times four is mentioned.
- "Funny Aneurysm" Moment - A somewhat hidden one. There are 420 pages, which may be the standard Arc Number, if it was deliberate at all, but after Columbine made April 20 famous for other reasons...
- Gainax Ending - "Had the Ghost Dance worked, you'd be dust." And of course the novel itself has one. To understand, John dies, but the killer, who until now has been implied to be John, is still on the loose. The easiest solution is that Reggie was the actual killer.
- Gary Stu - Wilson shows us how it's done. Ethnic background the writer wishes to be, check. The Last of His Kind, check. Chick Magnet, check. Magical, check.
- Go Mad from the Revelation - John concludes Father Duncan did this.
- A God Am I - Played for laughs.
- Good People Have Good Sex - After he finds out that his girlfriend hates Indians, Reggie has angry sex with her for a week, for the sole purpose of the cosmic irony of her bearing an Indian child.
- Conversely, John, upon finding a white man watching Asian porn, is disgusted by it.
- He Who Fights Monsters - Where to begin? Marie assumes David is hitting on her out of some ethnic fetishism and is therefore a racist...because he's white. John wants to kill a white man as revenge for all the Indians who were killed. Mather thinks he's fighting racism, while being racist in his own way. Reggie wants revenge on his abusive father by killing white men. Aaron wants to avenge his brother by killing Indians.
- Karmic Death - The people who killed David killed him over casino money, and then are killed over an illegal poker game.
- Leitmotif - An odd example of a literary one, John's leitmotif is the sound of sandals walking on sand.
- Man in White - One took John away from his family in his fantasies.
- Mark of Shame - Near the end.
- Mr. Seahorse - John thought he was pregnant once.
- Mood Whiplash - Alexie calls the book "a feel-good novel about interracial murder".
- Moral Event Horizon - John abducting a boy; the boy eventually becomes his Morality Pet.
- A Nazi by Any Other Name - Truck starts talking about eugenics near the end of the book. He goes farther than Jensen's recommendation to pay people $100 for every IQ point below 100 in exchange for voluntary sterilization toward forced sterilization.
- Occidental Otaku - Done American-style. (Called "Twinkie" or "wannabe" colloquially.) Many, many well-intentioned white characters have a fascination with Indians.
- Proud Warrior Race - When it's discussed as to what tribes drink which sodas, a Coeur d'Alene corrects the lecturer and says they just drink blood.
- Psycho Rangers - Though neither Reggie's gang nor Aaron's is really "good", they both commit hate crimes against the other ethnic group, they're both in groups of three, and they both ultimately have one guy say What Have I Become? and tell the police.
- Soapbox Sadie - Marie
- Sociopathic Hero - The killer at times. Many of his targets are people presented as scum, often racist. And not just racist against Indians; one watches Asian porn.
- Start of Darkness - The first few chapters are dedicated to this.
- Take That - Much of the book is such, but especially the Native American literature class. Truck Schultz is also a Take That to conservative talk show hosts, especially since Truck only says such things for ratings.
- Those Two Guys - Paul and Paul Too
- Villain Protagonist
- Where Da White Women At?
- Women Are Wiser - Boo assumes Marie couldn't be the killer because she's a woman.