This happens to Guts in a supremely heinous fashion during the end of the Eclipse when he is forced to watch his lover Casca be brutally raped to the point of insanity by his best friend turned Big Bad Griffith, who has become a demon god named Femto. He tries to reach her by chiseling off his own arm which was trapped in the jaws of a demon, only to be dogpiled by more demons before he can and is forced to watch the rape as a demon claws out his right eye. It's made even more heinous in that Casca was forced to look at Guts in the middle of her rape by Femto when he began to rape her from behind. Not only is Casca being degraded more and worse by the minute, but she has to look at Guts while it happens, and it's heartbreaking to see Casca beg Guts not to look at her during her last sane moments, even though he's just as forced to look on while he's still trying to get to her.
Earlier (but later chronologically), in volume two of the manga, Vargas, the kind but deformed and revenge-driven fugitive, recounts how he was forced to watch as the Count ate his wife and children. This alluded to Guts's own experience with Griffith.
And Guts forced Theresia, the Count's twelve-year-old daughter, to watch as he stabbed the mutilated but still living Count dozens of times. He actually dragged the Count over to her so she'd have a front row seat. This was one of Guts' darker moments.
In Rideback, though it only gets to implying such before he gives in, the main character's brother is forced to give false confession by threatening to rape his sister in front of him.
In Naruto Itachi has twice used his Mind Rape abilities to make Sasuke watch as Itachi murders their entire family over and over and over again.
Seras Victoria from Hellsing has a rather dark and disturbing backstory, which seems to have happened when she was very young. It consists of her father being murdered by burglars, her mother hiding her in a cupboard to protect her, and her mother's subsequent murder by the same burglars. Seras tries to exact revenge by stabbing one of the guys in the eye with a fork; she gets shot for her trouble and one of the perpetrators proceeds to rape her mother's corpse, due to it being "still warm". In full view of little Seras, who lies on the ground bleeding profusely.
Nnoitra orders his subordinate Tesla to beat Ichigo to death and grabs Orihime (who's in love with Ichigo and is the person whom Ichigo has come to rescue) and forces her to watch. He even says "I want you to watch while the guy who came to save you gets torn apart." Thankfully, Kenpachi pulls a Big Damn Heroes moment before Tesla can kill Ichigo.
Similarly, when Ishida and Orihime arrive to the place where Ichigo is fighting Ulquiorra, the latter lampshades the trope when he tells her (paraphrased) to "watch as the person you love the most dies", and then blows a massive hole in Ichigo's chest, killing him.
In Tantei Gakuen Q, while she and Ryu investigate a girl's vanishment in a Boarding School, Megumi is caught and kidnapped by a mysterious masked man. She finds herself Bound and Gagged and is forced to watch as said masked man kills the also kidnapped Student Council President by smashing a bottle in his head. Few later, Ryu and other kids find a video featuring this as well as how the masked man threateningly approaches poor Megu and the scene goes to black, implying he's killed her too. He has not, and Megu is released unharmed but very shaken by what she was forced to see.
In Digimon Tamers, the D-Reaper forces Sakuyamon and Gallantmon to watch Beelzemon fall to his death by sending a Zerg Rush of its Agents at the former and physically restraining the latter. Gallantmon can't break free, and by the time Sakuyamon is done with the Agents Beelzemon's too far away for her to help. Fortunately, he's not too far away for Grani to help.
Averted in Rurouni Kenshin. Because Enishi did not force Kenshin to watch as he "killed" his love interest Kaoru even though he knew what effect it would have on Kenshin, this... set off Aoshi's suspicion that Kaoru was not dead at all. He was right.
In the climax of the 'Saint Beasts' arc in YuYu Hakusho, Suzaku has a giant screen showing the footage of Botan and Keiko being hunted down by his bug-zombies. At first, this serves mostly as a distraction, but as Yusuke increasingly gets the worse end of the fight and things get tighter and tighter for Keiko, it gets closer to torture, culminating in Yusuke on the ground, beaten past moving, while the zombies close in on Keiko. (Botan is not in real danger, as her real form is a spirit the zombies can't touch.)
In Haou Airen, this happens thrice. In two of these times, the person forced to watch is the same:
First, Kaafai is forced to witness how Hakuron rapes his girlfriend Kurumi, whom Kaafai himself has just befriended. This turns out to be VERY plot-important: it inspires the mentallybroken Kaafai to join the police, learn how to handle guns... and to shoot Hakuron dead the next time their paths cross.
Also used when a rival Triad gang kidnaps Kurumi, and their leader has Hakuron watch via video as he strips and molests her.
In Shaman King, Faust VIII has Yoh forcibly restrained by skeletons and forces him to watch as he vivisects Manta.
Happens more than once in Detective Conan, being a mystery series and all. In example, Conan and his friends are given a tablet supposedly coming from Officer Takagi — and when Takagi's girlfriend Sato turns it on, they see it's connected to a camera that shows them a kidnapped Takagi who's Bound and Gagged inside a Death Trap. So either they find and free him soon, or they'll only be able to watch as he dies — either by hanging in a makeshift gallow, by being blown up by a time bomb, or simply by freezing to death. (He's rescued in the nick of time, though.)
In Saint Seiya, it takes place once in a while. The biggest example is Cancer Deathmask using his Psychic Powers not only to restrain a girl named Shunrei and lift her up several meters over a waterfall located at the other side of the world... but to force her prospect boyfriend/adoptive brother Shiryu to watch as he tosses her into the waterfall and to her death. Though this massivelybackfires, via pressing Shiryu's biggest Berserk Button to the core and sending him intoa huge and gloriousUnstoppable Rage. (And it turns out Shunrei survived thanks to Old Master Dohko's efforts.)
Played with in Hell Girl. A little girl named Tsugumi Shibata is somehow able to see through Ai Enma's eyes as the Hell Girl meets with her clients, and she uses this ability to help her Intrepid Reporter father Hajime track the clients down and attempt to tell them not to take Ai's deals. As an adult, she still has this skill.
In The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (the movie followup of The Melancholyof Haruhi Suzumiya), Alt!Yuki is forced to watch when [[Yandere Ryoko Asakura stabs Kyon. Ryoko even spins around, waves the knife, and splatters blood on Yuki's face!
Dragon Ball Z: In order to hit Gohan's Berserk Button and see his true power firsthand, Cell spawns seven Cell Jr.'s and then sics them on the other Z Fighters while Gohan watches helplessly, and finally pushes Gohan over the edge when he crushes Android 16's still-living head underfoot right in front of him. At this, Gohan goes Super Saiyan 2 and promptly annihilates the Cell Jr.'s before wiping the floor with Cell.
Black Mask is fond of this technique as a torture tool; he drove Catwoman's sister insane by torturing her husband to death and forcing her to watch and eat the bits he cut off.
In X-Men, Mojo does this to Professor Xavier at one point, using metal wires that force his eyes open while making him grin in Mojo's image.
In the Elseworlds story JLA: The Nail, The Joker uses his newly bestowed energy powers to capture Robin and Batgirl, and then make Batman watch while he rips them apart. Batman gets free (too late) and promptly kills the Joker..
The most painful moment in the "Avengers Under Siege" storyline: Mr. Hyde forces a captive Captain America to watch as he brutally beats the Avengers' elderly butler, Jarvis.
At the end of Superman's "Conduit saga", Conduit sets up television around the deathtrap he stuck Jimmy Olsen in, presumably to invoke this on Superman.
The Young Avengers/Runaways Civil War crossover has one: The Warden kidnaps Billy, Teddy, and Karolina (bringing Xavin's dead body along), and preceeds to perform a vivisection on Teddy, while his boyfriend is forced to watch, able to hear everything except his own voice. This leaves said boyfriend brokenly trying to use his powers to kill The Warden.
Typically a key part of the creation of a new revenant in any given episode in The Crow series. It's especially bad when fans of the first movie read the first comic, and realize just how loose an adaptation it was.
Done to the audience in Alan Moore opus From Hell. An entire issue is spent on the grisly details of one of the killings and subsequent mutilations.
In one New Gods/Superman story, Darkseid forced Mr. Miracle to watch a porno that his wife and Superman did (while brainwashed by Darkseid's rejected underling, Sleez).
In Ultimate X-Men, Magneto punished Pietro for making the Brotherhood a joke by knee-capping Pietro with a shotgun. Wanda's punishment? He made her watch.
Towards the end of an Outsiders arc in which Indigo is revealed to be the latest form of Brainiac, she briefly regains her normal personality long enough to beg Shift to kill her, claiming that once the Brainiac programming reasserts control, she'll be forced to watch as she kills all of her friends.
In Thorgal, Kriss de Valnor takes advantage of Thorgal's amnesia by claiming that he is Shaigan the Merciless, a fellow pirate and her lover. Kriss enslaves Thorgal's wife Aaricia using her and Thorgal's daughter as leverage. Kriss then forces Aaricia to be her personal attendant so that Aaricia has a front row seat as her amnesiac husband makes love to Kriss night after night. It's not enough for Kriss that she finally has Thorgal to herself. No, Kriss has to rub it in Aaricia's face that she's stolen her husband.
In the Fallout: Equestria universe, memory orbs - magical devices which allow unicorns to experience the collected memory within - cannot be exited until the memory has been played completely. No matter how horrific - or embarrassing - the memory is, once you've activated the orb, you're forced to watch (and feel, and smell, and taste) it all.
In a much more direct way, Cognitum forces Blackjack to watch her annihilating several peaceful settlements in order to wriggle some crucial information out of her. Despite a heavy death toll, Blackjack holds back, because she knows that with the information Cognitum will do much worse, but she breaks when her friends and loved ones are targeted next.
In The Chong Sheng Trilogy's third installment, Chiang pulls this by torturing Katara with acupuncture and forcing Zuko to watch. Initially it's to make her tell him about the White Lotus' plans since she just succeeded Pakku as the Grand Master of Water, but evolves into the Kick the Dog variety once it's clear she no longer has the capacity to divulge any information. Bonus points in that Chiang makes it clear what he intends to do to her once she passes out. He doesn't succeed, as Hakoda and others still loyal to Zuko pull a Big Damn Heroes moment out of the proverbial fire.
One Fullmetal Alchemist fanfic involves Envy employing this method on Edward, as he and Sloth engage in some kinky and graphic 'bonding', which proves to be a fairly effective way of squicking out poor Ed, especially since this fic is set in the first anime continuity, where Sloth is actually a resurrected version of Ed's mom Trisha. And to add insult to injury, Envy transforms into his and Ed's father, Hohenheim!
You Obey by Kalash93 contains a very interesting and somewhat meta spin on this trope.
The Galaxy Rangers fic Chrysalis has all four of the Rangers captured by Queen of the Crowns. She gladly sends Niko, Doc, and Shane to her torture chambers. But she puts Zachary in a well-appointed prison and trots him out to a balcony overlooking the chambers.
Queen:You won't pay, Captain, but your subordinates will.
In An Asian's Harem of Asians, Japan sexually enslaves all of the Asian nations (OC's included). The only one that he won't directly violate is his little sister Taiwan, but he still abuses her via stripping her naked alongside the others and forcing her to watch how he either rapes their other siblings or makes them rape each other.
The villain of The Green Hornet fanfic Bad Medicine plans to take revenge on the Green Hornet by kidnapping one of his friends (the OC) and having her tortured to deathwhile videotaping it for him. Fortunately, she's rescued.
The CSI: Crime Scene Investigation fanfic Face The Music has Grissom totured by Reggie Shelling and Ruben Denaglio. Grissom escapes, but near the end of the fic, he's recaptured after Shelling, who escaped the first time, uses Sara as bait. Shelling starts in on Sara, then Grissom convinces Shelling to focus on him so he'll stop hurting Sara, meaning they're both forced to watch at various points.
In "What if Snape Died", Voldemort didn't know the prophecy, but that just delayed (for a few years) the moment Harry Potter would become the Boy-Who-Lived. Some of his Death Eaters forced James to watch as he tried to kill Harry. Since Lily did sacrifice herself after all, the Killing Curse came back at him like in the book series.
Subverted in Red vs Blue: Revenge of the Robots. Unless Sarge gives O'malley what he wants, he'll be forced to watch Wyoming not kill Grif. Which, considering how much Sarge hates Grif, is an unbearable torture.
A horrifying version happens in the Lost Girl fic Faeral. Dyson has, for complicated but well-explained reasons, gone psychotic and previously tried to rape Lauren. When Bo is talking to him later, he is confused as to why she is angry over it. He then concludes that as a Succubus, she wants to watch him rape Lauren. Bo damn near kills him on the spot. He later breaks out of his cell, hell-bent on raping Lauren in front of Bo. Bo finally snaps, and gives him a No-Holds-Barred Beatdown to make him stop.
In Naruto: the Secret Songs of the NinjaKakashi and Naruto get captured by an old enemy of Kakashi who is out for revenge. He specifically invokes this trope by torturing Naruto in front of Kakashi, explaining that he's studied Kakashi for years and knows that hurting his comrades will make him suffer far more than anything you can do to him. Defied by Naruto when he tells the torturer to Bring It and tells Kakashi not to give in, no matter what.
In The Man Called Flintstone, the Green Goose tortures Barney Rubble on the rack to make Fred Flintstone talk. Subverted when Fred doesn't crack and tell the Green Goose what he wants to know, but ignores Barney's suffering.
In Wreck-It Ralph, during the climax, the Cy-Bug King Candy/Turbo tries to force Ralph to watch as Vanellope is about to be eaten by the other Cy-Bugs. This only prompts Ralph to attempt his big Heroic Sacrifice. A few minutes later, the Turbo side can only watch as he is drawn towards destruction.
In The LEGO Movie, Lord Business would prefer to let Emmet and the Master Builders have a front row seat to the destruction of Bricksburg (Emmet's home city) to really torture them before the Think Tank self-destructs. He imprisons the latter in his Think Tank and ties the former to the self-destruct mechanism's battery. Emmet, being the one forced, is closest to the computer screen where the apocalypse is effectively taking place.
In The Incredibles, Syndrome does a variation of this to Mr. Incredible; he's made to listen to a radio transmission from his wife and children as their plane is being targeted by missiles. Worst of all, Syndrome didn't know it was Bob's family, but thought they were his back-up. The reveal that there were children on board didn't stop Syndrome in the slightest.
Law Abiding Citizen: Clyde removes the eyelids of the man who killed his wife and daughter and puts a giant mirror above the operating table he's been strapped to, forcing him to watch as he is tortured and dismembered.
In Marv's short of Sin City, his friend and parole officer Lucille was kidnapped by the cannibal Kevin, who then ate her hand. When Marv finds her, the poor woman breaks down and cries "he made me watch!"
Mal does this to the Operative in Serenity - torture in this case being watching a heartbroken Alliance researcher tell and show of the atrocity on Miranda - the Alliance's greatest crime - right before the speaker is attacked, raped, and ultimately eaten by Reavers. The feed goes on. It also tortures him in a different way. It destroys his entire view that the Alliance is truly making the universe a better place, which is the reason he was doing horrible things for them.
The killer does this to his first victim in Die Watching, setting a TV monitor next to the chair she is tied to so that she can watch him kill her.
RoboCop 2: Hob turns away as Cain mercilessly butchers a traitor to his cause. Cain forces the maybe-15-years-old-tops Hob to watch anyway.
In The Final, the outcasts chain their victims to the floor and set up a torture chair in the front of the room, torturing and mutilating them one by one as their friends watch.
In For a Few Dollars More, El Indio, the Big Bad, in one of his first Kick the Dog moments of the movie, forces a guy who took money to place him behind bars to watch as the family that he started with that money (his wife and his little boy) are taken outside and shot to death, while also making him listen to the pocket watch that Indio always carries.
Invoked in The Green Hornet. "He took my favorite toy, and he ripped the head off. Right in front of me."
Bryan Mills threatens to invoke this in Taken when confronting a corrupt French agent about the whereabouts of his kidnapped daughter. After the agent attempts to intimidate him into dropping the case, Bryan shoots the agent's wife in the arm, assures him that he only winged her, and orders him to help, or "the last thing you'll see before I make your children orphans is the bullet I put between her eyes." The agent complies.
In the sequel, the tables are turned and it's Bryan who is told that he'll have to watch his ex-wife die when her throat is partially slit and she's suspended upside down to bleed out.
In Underworld Rise Of The Lycans, after Sonja is tried and found guilty of high treason mainly due to her being impregnated by her lover, the werewolf Lucian, with a child who would be half vampire, half werewolf, her punishment consisted of having her chained to a pillar and Lucian chained to the floor face-to-face, where she was forced to watch Lucian get whipped. Then, it all gets worse when Lucian was then forced to watch her get burned to death by exposure to the sun.
A rather chilling example in Strange Days: a rapist blindfolds his victim, then hooks her up to the memory-recording device he's using at that moment... forcing her to experience her own rape and subsequent murder as though she were in his body. So not only is it happening to her, she's forced to get off on it the way he is.
In The Avengers, Loki threatens to have Clint, who's under Loki's control, ambiguously rape, torture, and finally kill Natasha, and then release him from the mind control to allow him to see what he did before killing him. A bit of variation, however, as it's Natasha who he is threatening.
Red Eye: Inverted. When Rippner faces Lisa in their final confrontation, Rippner tells Lisa that he is going to make her father watch what he's going to do to her (instead of the hero/heroine watching a loved one get harmed). Whatever he was planning on doing, it is averted in the end.
In Soldier, the Super Soldier squad is forced to watch a pack of dogs attacking a wild boar as children during their training.
Big Bad's thing in Opera is forcing the main character to watch him brutally kill people. He does this by placing needles under her eyes, making her unable to blink.
The Quick and the Dead. As a child, Lady was forced to watch Herod hang her father, who asks the Big Bad not to let her watch. Instead, Herod says he'll let her father go if she's able to Shoot the Rope. Unused to the heavy revolver, she accidentally puts a bullet in her father's head.
Spaceballs parodies this; the bad guys' plan to have the King give the air-shield combination is to force him to watch them give his daughter back...her old nose!
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest: After Bootstrap Bill betrays him by helping Will escape the Flying Dutchman, Davy Jones makes him watch as he summons the Kraken to destroy the ship that Will is currently on. Though Bootstrap is initially unaware of it, Will gets out alive.
Done, quite notoriously, to Tony in Scarface. After being captured in a drug deal gone bad, Tony is forced to watch as Angel is messily dismembered with a chainsaw. He's rescued just before facing the same fate.
Spawn: After Clown's plan is foiled in the climax, he prepares to rape Wanda in front of a beaten Spawn and forces him to watch. Cogliostro intervenes to prevent this, prompting Clown to retreat to Hell.
In "The Quillan Games", Bobby is forced to watch as Mr. Pop, Quillan's last hope, is incinerated by BLOK, thus making Quillan the second territory lost to Saint Dane.
Alex Rider is tied down and forced to watch as Razim kills Jack in Scorpia Rising.
In a indirect example, Captain Red Wegener from a Coast Guard ship investigating the rape and murder of a family aboard a ship in the Tom Clancy book Clear and Present Danger realizes that the suspects they have for the crime forced the owner of the ship to watch as they raped his wife and daughter before they killed him.
Labyrinths of Echo by Max Frei. In one of sequels, the hero happened to witness things too overwhelmingly weird, even for a Cosmic Plaything like him. He closes his eyes, but oops — he's still forced to see it all. Eyelids do nothing.
King Jacob of The Tennis Shoes Adventures tries to get Garth to reveal the location of a treasure by forcing him to watch as Garth's niece, Melody, is killed. Too bad he doesn't know. (While Garth has a Heroic BSOD, Mel gets better.)
Dexter's "yodeling potato," having your limbs removed and your tongue cut out. In front of a mirror. Starting at the fingers/hands/feet and working up slowly. Additionally, the eyelids and lips are removed.
The Stephen King short story "Quitters, Inc." (published in the collection Night Shift) about the ultimate anti-smoking program (adapted into a segment of the film Cat's Eye). Three little words: "the rabbit room."
In the Star Wars Expanded Universe novel Darth Bane: Path of Destruction, Bane kills a man's two sons and forces him to watch. Justified in that Bane then used the father's anguish to fuel his dark side powers.
In the book of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, things play out differently from the film. The witch does this because she can't physically harm Dorothy thanks to the protective charms of the slippers and the North Witch's protection spell. Didn't stop the Witch with a Capital B from trying to get Dorothy's cooperation by torturing the Lion, threatening Toto, and leaving Nick (the Tin Man) and Scarecrow as ruined heaps at the bottom of a nearby ravine. Baum had his moments...
In Neverwhere, in order to get information out of Door, the bad guys decide that instead of torturing her, they'll torture Richard instead while she watches.
In the fifteenth Dresden Files book Skin Game, Nicodemus organizes a gambit around this and the fact that Karrin is a Violently Protective Girlfriend to Harry. He surrenders to her when she wields the Sword of Faith, but not before ordering the Genowska to kill Harry. The Genowska slowly starts crushing Harry's skull, while Karrin is helpless to stop it. In a rage, she strikes at Nicodemus with the Sword, breaking her word and unmaking the Sword.Nicodemus is a real bastard.
He does it again, later in the same book. He has Charity captured, and intends to burn down her house with her children inside before killing her.
In Warrior Cats, Tigerstar, after taking control of ShadowClan and RiverClan, organizes an attack on WindClan. Once the Curb-Stomp Battle was over, he rounded up all the prisoners and forced them to watch as he brutally killed a young apprentice, as a "warning" as to what would happen if any of them tried to defy him again.
In the Power of Three series, Ashfur tries to burn Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf alive and force their adoptive mother to watch as "vengeance" for her choosing another mate instead of him two years ago. Her quick thinking gets them out of it, but at the cost of her adopted kits' love.
In The Sword-Edged Blonde, this is part of Eddie's Back Story: when he was sixteen, he and his girlfriend were attacked by bandits, who held him down and made him watch as they raped and killed her. Even worse, it was kind of his fault the bandits attacked them in the first place.
Turned sideways in Neil Gaiman's The Problem of Susan, where Susan is eaten first, but her (conscious) severed head is left behind so she can watch further horrors unfold regarding her siblings and what Aslan and the White Witch do.
In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Bellatrix Lestrange, unable to torture Harry because he's carrying a delicate MacGuffin of the Death Eaters, tells her colleagues to torture his love interest and local Cute Witch Ginny Weasley in front of him instead. She later tortures Harry's good friend Neville Longbottom in front of Harry as well, but is interrupted a moment before he gives in.
In The Saga of Darren Shan, also known as the Cirque Du Freak series, the second-to-last book gives us this between Steve and Darren. "I dare you to do this." Different in that Steve is essentially doing it For the Evulz at this point, and if Darren also does it, it'd keep Steve from actually realizing and becoming truly evil, and if Darren doesn't, Stevewould go absolutely batshit crazy. Ultimately it's Steve killing Darren's godson and son-of-best-friend Shancus, that is Steve's crossing the Moral Event Horizon and he dares Darren to do it as well. And Darren almost does kill the kid he's holding, Steve's son Darius. What keeps him from doing it? Steve telling his boy to tell Darren his mom's name. His mom's name? Annie Shan, Darren's sister. Woah.
In the Rizzoli & Isles novel The Apprentice, the cops are investigating the murder of a wealthy doctor and the disappearance of his wife. When they find the husband's body tied to a chair propped up in the middle of the bedroom, the cops are horrified to realize that the killer forced the helpless man to watch as he raped and murdered his wife before slashing his throat.
According to Herodotus one Median prince was actually forced to eat his son by his king. Later he supposedly ended up commanding a large part of the same monarchs army at a critical battle with Cyrus The Great. Figure out what happened next.
In The Sword of Truth series it is mentioned that part of the Mord-Sith training involves them being forced to watch their mothers tortured to death. The protagonist is threatened in the first book that if he won't help the Big Bad, he'll be forced to see his love tortured for a very long time (not killed - the Big Bad wanted a heir from her). In another book, knowing that Zedd and Adie won't give in to torture, the Big Bad assures their cooperation by threatening to torture children in front of them instead. A few more examples are present throughout the series.
In Mistborn, an Inquisitor mentions casually to Vin that when he tortured her brother, he died before spilling the secret they were after. Thus, this time, he was going to use a different tactic: torturing her friend Sazed instead. (He doesn't get the chance.)
This turns out to be behind the plot of The Carpet makers by Andreas Eschbach: the previous Emperor puts a defeated rival king on life support and forces him to watch how all life on his home planet gets killed off, to be replaced by carpets.
In the beginning of Shogun by James Clavell, the Japanese are surprised to learn that the main character John "Anjin-san" Blackwell (who is the leader of a group of shipwrecked European sailors) isn't vulnerable to personal humiliation, and even more surprised to learn that he is vulnerable to this trope. Abuse and mistreat him all you want, and he won't break; but touch one of his companions instead...
In A Song of Ice and Fire, Tyrion reveals that he'd been forced to watch his beloved new wife Tysha gang raped. And then forced to participate himself. When he was thirteen. And the whole thing was orchestrated by his father. (With his older brother Jaime also in it.)
Theon Greyjoy is also forced to watch and participate as Ramsay rapes and abuses Jeyne Poole. It's implied that this doesn't happen just once either.
In Dune: House Harkonnen, a teenaged Guerney Halleck is forced to watch as his sister, who has just spent a year as a Sex Slave for Harkonnen soldiers, is brutally gang-raped before Rabban finally strangles her.
Adventure Hunters: This is how Marcus secures Regina's cooperation chaining her to a wall so she has to watch him tortue Golon.
In Chaos Walking's second book, The Ask and the Answer, Mayor-turned- President Prentiss tortures Viola while a horrified Todd watches on behind a soundproof one-way mirror. Todd breaks first and gives Prentiss information about the upcoming invasion by the Answer.
In MockingjayPeeta reveals that he was forced to watch the execution-by-torture of Darius and Lavinia.
The Hunger Games themselves are a nation-wide version of this for the districts. Each one is made to watch, on television, as two of their adolescent citizens engage in a weeks-long fight to the death with 22 other kids, and only one survives. Katniss sums up their message herself:
"Look how we take your children and sacrifice them and there's nothing you can do."
In "Catching Fire" Katniss is forced to watch Cinna being severely beaten and dragged away to his implied execution.
In Coda, Ell makes Anthem watch Alpha and Omega track.
Inverted and Subverted in an episode of Workaholics-high on acid, Alice is convinced a man has information on how to find a poaching fellow salesman, Psycho D. She threatens to melt her face with a clothes iron in front of the man's children if the man doesn't start talking. She then puts it to her face, screaming-only to realize it wasn't on.
In another episode, the guys come to rely on Jillian after she saves them from a tough guy in the opening of the episode. At the end, she defends them from a man by threatening to beat his ass in front of his "ugly, funky-butt children."
In American Horror Story: Coven, Delphine is sent is sent to a personal hell where she is forced to watch her daughters be tortured over and over again in torture devices she herself devised .
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: In season five, Glory, while confronting Buffy in her own home, invokes this when she openly threatens to kill Buffy's loved ones and friends and make Buffy watch her do so if she doesn't turn over the Key.
Glory: I'll kill [your sister]. I'll kill your mom, I'll kill your friends ... and I'll make you watch when I do.
Angel season 2 has a particularly brutal example. Just as Angel has finally saved Darla and convinced her to live out the remainder of her life as a human, Wolfram & Hart comes in with Drusilla; Lindsey McDonald himself tasers Angel and makes him watch as Drusilla turns Darla into a vampire again. This pushes Angel into He Who Fights Monsters territory for a good few episodes.
Battlestar Galactica has an unplanned bonus to Boomer impersonating identical humanoid robot Athena. Helo, Athena's husband, comes into the bathroom where Boomer has just Bound and Gagged Athena in a bathroom stall, and mentions that since "she" is going on a mission they should take the opportunity to say an intimate goodbye. Of course, Athena chooses that moment to become drowsily awake enough to watch.
Doctor Who has many examples. One is found in Genesis of the Daleks. The Doctor has to tell Davros how every Dalek war was lost or Sarah Jane and Harry will be tortured.
In the New Series, the Master also does this to the Doctor, forcing him to watch Earth literally get decimated while helpless to stop him. Why? For the Evulz, of course! Most villains find that this is the most effective way to break the Doctor. In Season 1, the Doctor was forced to reveal who he really was when Rose was getting tortured in front of him. In Season 4 Davros once again tried to break the Doctor first by making him watch the Tardis (with Donna in it) get destroyed and then was seconds close to forcing the Doctor watch as the Daleks destroyed reality itself with a reality bomb.
Torchwood: Jack Harkness describes being subjected to this in his past: "I went to war when I was a boy. I was with my best friend. We got caught crossing the border over enemy lines. They tortured him, not me, because he was weaker. They made me watch him die. And they let me go." Icing on the cake: Jack convinced his friend to go to war. It would have been an adventure, he claimed
In Firefly the crew stumbles upon a derelict ship plundered by vicious space cannibals called Reavers. All the passengers on the ship but one man were brutally tortured and murdered. As it turns out, the Reavers deliberately left him alive and made him watch as they did their work on the others, traumatizing the man so badly that the only way he could cope was by becoming a Reaver himself.
In "True Night", the UnSub's backstory was that a street gang forced him to watch as they murdered (and implied gang-rape) his pregnant girlfriend, whom he'd just proposed to. No wonder he snapped.
It was part of Karl "The Fox" Arnold's modus operandi: he targeted dysfunctional families and forced the father to watch as he killed the other members before finally killing him.
Tim Curry's character in the two-parter "Our Darkest Hour"/"The Longest Night" would always leave behind a witness after raping, beating and killing their loved ones. It turned out that his mother, a prostitute, used to make him watch while she worked. It's implied she also offered him up to her clients.
In "Revelations", the UnSub (Tobias Hankel) watches his potential victims through their webcams, then records and posts their murders online. He also kidnaps Reid and forces him to choose one of the victims to be murdered. When Reid instead chooses one to save, Tobias goes and kills a different one (and their spouse), leaving Reid tied up and forced to watch it happen on the laptop in front of him. Cue Reid's guilt. The next time we see him, he's staring catatonic. Garcia also had to watch all of the videos repeatedly, unable to track Tobias. Later in the same episode, when the team's efforts to track him down make him angry, Hankel punishes them by switching the video camera back on and making them watch while he beats Reid nearly to death.
In "100", The Reaper (using a stolen cell phone) forces Hotch to listen to his wife being shot dead. The entire team hears it, too. It does notendwell for the Reaper.
The same thing happened to the team when Prentiss was being beat up by a cult that had her and Reid. She used the fact that the team was listening to get a message to them.
The episode "Proof" when the UnSub kidnapped and tortured his niece, burning her hands off with acid. In the final scene of the episode, her father as some sort of self-punishment for not noticing that his brother was seriously screwed up, forced himself to watch the video of his daughter being tortured.
In the episode "Children of the Dark" the two UnSubs would force the kids to watch as the first UnSub beat the parents to death. Then the second UnSub would inject them with poison.
The entire point of the MTVGame ShowTrashed. Don't get enough questions right, and you get to see your prized possessions go up in smoke (sometimes literally).
The "Bonus Round" on Distraction: Get a question wrong, watch your brand new car get vandalized or one of your prizes get destroyed.
A Sunset Beach storyline involved an evil twin imprisoning his good brother... and forcing him to watch through a two-way mirror as he made love to the man's fiancee.
A third Ozian example. In Tin Man, Cain was locked in a Steampunk stasis chamber for eight years while a holographic recording of his family's torture was set on repeat playback.
The Space Cases first season finale contained a textbook exmaple, where Warlord Shank demands information about the Crysta from Harlan after some of the gang have been captured and tied up. When Shank brings out his Agony Beam, Harlan, of course, defiantly tells him that torture won't make him talk. Shank calmly asks, "Who said anything about torturing you?" before turning it in the direction of the unconscious Catalina. Good thing he also didn't say anything about giving him truthful information.
Sylar does this in Volume 4 of ''Heroes; he tortures one of the soldiers sent to kidnap him, then immobilizes him while torturing two innocent bystanders. Well, one innocent bystander and one villain wannabe, but he didn't know that yet...
On 24, Jack Bauer orders Qurac soldiers to kill a terrorist's son on a webcam feed in order to break him. It was staged.
Jack threatens to do something similar to the villain of Season 3:
Jack: When your daughter is infected, I'm going to make you watch her die.
In Kurosagi, Kurosaki is unable to stop his father from murdering his sister and mother before coming for him as well.
In the TV movie Echo, Jack Wagner's twin brother character moves into his brother's life after abducting him and makes love to his fiancee, having it broadcast to his brother through a live camera so he can sit helplessly and watch.
Recurring bastard Kolya on Stargate Atlantis pulled one of these on the entire city of Atlantis when he forced nearly every member of the command team to watch his torture of Lt. Colonel John Sheppard via live-telefeed.
In the penultimate episode of Breaking Bad, Jesse, who was captured and made to make his trademark blue meth for Jack and Todd, gets caught trying to escape their compound. Jack retaliates by forcing Jesse to watch his girlfriend Andrea get executed at her front porch by Todd and then threatening to do the same to her son Brock if he tries to escape again.
In Power Rangers Super Megaforce, after Vrak has defeated the Rangers for a second time (the first time showing them Cruel Mercy), he tells them that he will leave them alive so they are forced to watch his drills destroy the planet.
In BIONICLE, Karzahni's Mask of Power has the effect of trapping the target in a vision where they're usually unable to move, and witness horrible alternate futures. In one instance, he made Jaller see what would have happened if he had frozen in place instead of saving his friend Takua, thus allowing the villain Makuta to win. In this alternate future, the terrorized islanders would have risen up against Makuta's rule, only to be brutally killed one by one by his henchmen. This also counts as Mind Rape, as it leaves the victim too shaken to try to escape Karzahni's realm.
A common trope used during the Attitude Ere, particularly in the feud pitting "Stone Cold" Steve Austin and Vince McMahon. One example is Austin showing — via the Titan Tron — that he had earlier poured tons of concrete in McMahon's new Chevrolet Corvette!!!! Another time, as Austin and The Rock were trading verbal jabs, Austin revealed, via video footage, that he had dropped a steel beam on top of the Rock's brand new Lincoln Continental!
But bad-guy wrestlers forcing their face opponents to watch beatings and other wicked actions has dated back long before. Two examples come to mind:
In 1988, to help set up the first-ever SummerSlam main event (Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage against Ted DiBiase and André the Giant), Savage (with Miss Elizabeth in tow) delivered a promo throwing out an open challenge, to which Andre came out and taunted the "Macho Man." Savage accepted, only to have DiBiase sneak in and attack the champion, after which Andre and DiBiase double-teamed the champion; the trope-fitter here was Elizabeth being restrained by Virgil, forced to watch a brutal-for-the-time attack.
In 1991, Jake Roberts vs. Earthquake was set up in memorable style: Roberts was scheduled to take on Earthquake, who eventually got the better of "the Snake" and tied him in the ring ropes. Manager Jimmy Hart threw the snake bag (containing Roberts' snake, Damien) into the ring as 'Quake told Roberts, "You are going to see me ... (pause for dramatic effect) ... squash that snake!" Roberts was crying and trying to break free, but could only watch as Earthquake repeatedly performed his "Earthquake splash" to (Kayfabe) crush the snake to death.note In reality, the snake bag contained pantyhose filled with raw ground beef, and an electric motor to simulate Damien "moving around" inside the bag. Roberts was disconsolate as he finally broke free of the ropes ... but by that time, 'Quake was being led from the ring. Commentators McMahon, Roddy Piper and Savage remarked that it reminded some of the cruel childhood memory of being forced to watch a bully kill a beloved pet.
Colt Cabana tried to force Christopher Daniels to watch CM Punk's murder of Allison Danger, which he was to perform in retaliation for Daniels attacking CM Punk's girlfriend and Second City Saint manager Lucy. Danger was spared when it was revealed BJ Whitmer was the one who attacked Lucy.
Religion and Mythology
In The Bible, a priest named Pash-Hur throws Jeremiah into jail for the night because of his prophesying about Judah's sins and the upcoming invasion by Babylon. The next morning Jeremiah declares that God has changed Pash-Hur's name to Magor-Missaviv, "terror all around," because he will watch all his friends die in the attack before being dragged off to Babylon for the rest of his life.
Knights of the Old Republic: Admiral Saul Karath eventually manages to capture the heroes and starts grilling the Player Character for information. He already expects that his Cold-Blooded Torture isn't going to work very well if he simply uses the painful electrocution on the PC themselves. However, he has both your potential love interests in similar torture chambers...
While he doesn't get to see how it happened, Cormag from Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones is forced by Valter to have a long and good look at his murdered brother Glen's mangled corpse. What Valter didn't say, though, was that he was the one who killed Glen.
One of the bad endings of Hijikata's route in Hakuōki has Kazama threatening to hurt Chizuru in front of Hijikata because, he declares, he's heard that humans suffer more watching someone they care about get hurt, and he wants Hijikata to suffer. When Hijikata responds by throwing down his sword in surrender, Kazama tortures him to death in front of Chizuru with the specific intention of teaching her not to defy him.
In Final Fantasy XIII, Orphan forces Fang to watch him torture Vanille in order to get her to transform into Ragnarok and kill him. Fang ends up transforming into an incomplete Ragnarok but turns back into a human before she can kill Orphan. Then Orphan proceeds to torture Fang while Vanille watches. Who knows what would've happened if Lightning and co didn't pull a Big Damn Hero moment.
One was at the very end of Xenosaga3, Wilhelm tortures Shion to try and get KOS-MOS to activate Zarathustra. It doesn't work of course because KOS-MOS decides she simply wants to be herself instead of someone else so she destroys the key to Zarathustra, making it spiral out of control. Woops. Everything gets better though.
A major driving force in Luca's rage-filled insanity in Suikoden II is that he was forced to watch his mother be gang-raped for an entire week by Jowston Alliance rebels when he was a child. And when he finds out the kidnapping and gang-rape was all orchestrated by the mayor of Muse and leader of the Jowston Alliance Council, Darrel, he resolved to wiped the City-State off the map and murder all its inhabitants.
Ultima V: Warriors of Destiny was one of the first to use this trope. If you are captured by Lord Blackthorn, you are asked one of the mantras to the Shrines of Virtue. If you refuse, Lord Blackthorn will drag a companion under a swinging blade and ask "are you sure you don't want to tell me?" If you continue to refuse, your companion will die and will never return.
At one point in Kingdom Hearts II, Donald and Goofy are captured by a bunch of Heartless while Sora is unconscious. When he comes to, he encounters a "Heartless Commander", who then tortures the two with electricity after Sora makes a snarky comment on his status. Sora instantly surrenders to save his friends, and all three of them are thrown in prison.
The scene is recreated in the manga adaptation, but Sora is the one who gets tortured, while his friends watch in complete horror.
Sonic Lost World: Eggman invokes this while ranting at the Deadly Six for their rebellion, vowing to "destroy everything they love and make them watch." Later happens to Sonic, who can do nothing but watch helplessly over the Miles Electric as the planet-draining machine sucks the life out of Knuckles and Amy.
Batman: Arkham Origins: During the climax of the "Cold, Cold Heart" DLC, Ferris Boyle, after freezing Batman and incapacitating Mr. Freeze, dismisses Freeze's pleas to restart the cryogenic machine and save Nora, stating that he'll keep Freeze alive just long enough to watch her die before he kills him. Fortunately, Batman breaks free from the ice and subdues Boyle before that happens.
This happened to The Blonde Marvel when she didn't want to pay for Madame de Sade's broken window.
Parodied in Aoi House when Elle finds out two heterosexual men have joined their club. As they really can't lose two more members without getting closed by the university, she is determined to fix the minor problem with Alex and Sandy.
The Greatest Gift has a disturbing example with Astra/Venus. Her father forced her to watch her Evil Twin Jupiter/Fake Venus strangle their mother to death. Did we mention they were fillies when this happened?
Any time Susan overpowers Anna in Sire she is forced to helplessly watch her "Sister" pilot the body that they share and commit impassioned crimes. This has included confirmed kills so far. One of which was their beloved uncle.
This is how Marie feels in Pyrrhic, having been forced to watch Joshua Mercy Kill Chase.
Megabyte: The boy doesn't need to see this. Enzo: Can't I at least say good-bye? Megabyte: Well... ... ... no.
The premise behind Robot Chicken, the show opens as a dead chicken is brought back to life, then watches a bank of monitors with his head locked in place and eyes forced open. One of the monitors is blank as the show begins and zooms in upon it, supposedly this is what the chicken is going to be forced to see, and we will see it. As of Season 5, the tables have turned and the chicken has put the scientist in the same situation.
Slade: If you join me, if you swear to serve me, if you never speak to your friends again, I will allow them to live. But if you disobey even the smallest request ... I will annihilate them, Robin. And I'll make you watch.
Living Laser: New York is gonna burn. And I'm gonna make you watch.
In an American Dad! episode Roger goes on a campaign to ruin the life of a man named Sidney who Roger believes stole from him. This vendetta includes destroying Sidney's garden and raping his favorite sycamore tree. Later, Roger sends Sidney a letter that says, "Your sycamore had saplings. I made them watch."
In an episode where Stan puts his mind in the body of a horse, he (in the horse body) keeps getting poked in the face by a little kid despite Roger warning him not to. To the kid's shock, horse-Stan threatens to go to the child's house and kick his mother to death while he watched.
Freakazoid! had a mild version of this played for laughs. The villain, Gutierrez, wants a code that will give him super powers. When the hero and his mentor refuse to give it to him (the hero doesn't even know the code), he reveals he has the hero's family captured as well. The method of torture used on the family? The best of Marty Ingles.
"What kind of sadistic creature are you!?!"
In the SpongeBob SquarePants episode Krab Borg, SpongeBob and Squidward think Mr. Krabs is a robot who can talk to electronics. They tie him up and force him to watch them interrogate his expensive appliances. Most of them end up destroyed, making the money-grubbing crab scream and cry.
All in vain, as Spongebob realized the whole thing was all in his i.ma..gi...na....tionn — oh look, there's Halley's Comet! (runs away).
Comically inverted in Batman: The Brave and the Bold's Lighter and SofterAnimated Adaptation of Emperor Joker: after Bat-Mite becomes powerless by accidentally giving all his powers to the Joker and making him a Reality Warpinggod, the new Clown Emperor would use his newfangled cosmic powers to kill the Dark Knight and then bring him back from the dead. To make matters worse, he attempts to make Batman go insane. Despite Harley Quinn's pleas to spare the lives of Batman and Bat-Mite, the Joker complies of sparing Bat-Mite by turning him into a Jester!Harley version of him, then forcing him and Harley to watch (along with the newly-created Joker-Mite) while the Clown Emperor forces the Dark Knight through a comedic, torturous Death Montage in an attempt to make him go insane! Poor, powerless Bat-Mite... or is that Harley-Bat-Mite?
In The Simpsons, after Mr. Burns accidentally walks into a tree, he orders its acorns killed while the tree watches.
The Clock Orange scene mentioned above is parodied when Mr. Burn uses a similar device to force Santa's Little Helper to watch scenes of terrible violence in an attempt to make him a vicious attack dog.
One episode of Avatar: The Last Airbender has an Earth Kingdom general try to force Aang into the Avatar State by making him watch as he slowly bends Katara underground, presumably to suffocate. It works.
In the Rocko's Modern Life episode "To Heck and Back," Heffer is confronted with his gluttony in Heck, and forced to watch Rocko dying inside his guts (after Rocko fell in while trying to retrieve a chicken bone that had gotten caught in Heffer's throat.)
In the final episode of Justice League Unlimited, Darkseid tells Superman that this is his plan. He talks about how he is going to destroy the planet and kill everyone on it, and only after Superman has seen it, will he kill him.
A Family Guy episode has Peter doing the really old cartoon gag where the steam coming off a freshly baked pie forms beckoning fingers and tries to go up Peter's nose, which is supposed to draw Peter into eating the pie. When Peter refuses, the steam somehow starts ripping off Peter's clothes so it can rape him. We then see the steam is also holding Quagmire's eyes open, forcing him to watch.
In Buzz Lightyear of Star Command: Zurg manages to capture Booster, XR, and Mira and gloats about the tortures they are in store for. He's especially proud of Mira's, saying she can ghost right out of cell. Doing so however causes alarms to go, breaking her concentration, leaving her in her cell. The torture is that she has to watch her teammates be tortured, powerless to stop it. Except it's a kid's show. So XR finds being stretched enjoyable (it gets out the kinks); and while Booster's cell is supposed to turn his strength against him and throw him around the room, he sees it as a Bounce House and great fun. So Mira just smirks at him.