You can have three guesses who's going to win. The first two don't count.
In any martial arts fight, there is only a finite amount of ninjutsu available to each side in a given encounter. As a result, one Ninja is a deadly threat, but an army of them are cannon fodder.
A specific form of Plot Armor
, this trope is very common due to the numerous storytelling
considerations fueling it. Drama thrives on conflict
, and having the few put up a fight against the many is basically a free conflict coupon that's automatically viable during any few vs. many confrontation. Why have the superhero team curb stomp
the villain if you can make him powerful enough to force them into Teeth-Clenched Teamwork
? Why have the dozens of Mooks
club The Hero
unconscious three seconds into an encounter if you can let him take down seven or eight of them before he collapses, to show how much of a Bad Ass
he is? That would be letting some perfectly good dramatic tension
go to waste.
As the number disparity grows larger, another factor comes into play—there's strength in numbers, but also anonymity
, which in fiction is a crippling weakness
. Characterization is a precious, rare resource that is difficult to set up, which means most characters are not going to get any
. Since characters often travel in homogeneous packs in terms of characterization depth
, the larger a group is, the less characterization its members probably have.
In other words, if Team Meager is up against Team Gargantuan, we probably know something about Team Meager and at least care how well they're going to do in this fight—maybe we even outright sympathize with them and root for them to win. Team Gargantuan, on the other hand, is likely a faceless
blob of Mooks
or Red Shirts
that we don't care about on any personal level
. Letting Team Gargantuan steamroll over Team Meager in this scenario would be anticlimactic
letting Team Gargantuan do that means playing this trope straight almost by definition.
Hence, you end up with the few gaining an almost-automatic boost to their capabilities when pitted against the many. Extra points if, when presented with their multiple adversaries, one character notes
that "We barely were able to handle one, how on earth are we going to handle this many?" right before successfully doing just that.
This can, of course, apply to Elite Mooks
other than ninjas. Vampires are particularly susceptible to Conservation Of Ninjutsu, as are werewolves, alien monsters, Special Forces commandos
and Super-Powered Robot Meter Maids
There are a few conceivable ways in which this trope can be Justified
- The most obvious one is adhering to Magic A Is Magic A—if you consistently portray someone as powerful enough to take on a large number of people by their own and put an explicit limit on what they can and can't do, the Willing Suspension of Disbelief will not suffer nearly as much. How to establish the superiority of small numbers in concrete terms is another issue.
- Another is to introduce some superior technology or art, available to the small group but not the larger group, that evens the odds (think the armies of Saladin vs. an M1 Abrams Tank). If stealth specialists are forced to fight head-on heavy hitters who excel exactly at this job—which is usually the case with the "ninja" form of the trope—it's a bad strategy, and heavy losses are expectable, too.
- One more plausible scenario for this trope is if a smaller group of people is simply better coordinated than an larger group of opponents, and tries to stack the odds in their favour, however they can—cutting off paths for reinforcements, luring enemies into ambushes or traps, or disrupting their communications. This relies heavily on the element of surprise, as well as considerable planning and ability to adapt to situations on the fly, and would be considerably more effective if the group had some of the previously-mentioned advantages. In any case, if the element of surprise is lost or if the plan starts to fall apart, you can expect things to get very bad.
Despite all of those possible justifications, this trope is generally a result of the Theory of Narrative Causality
more than anything else—fights are won one way or the other because the plot says they should and not because of any relevant In-Universe
factors. In Real Life
, there is strength in numbers more often than not; large groups of fighters have probably been trained
to fight as a group and take advantage of their superior numbers if they ever manage to corner a single foe, and in some creations of mother nature this is a natural-born instinct (as a pack of wolves would be happy to demonstrate on any unfortunate prey). Quality over Quantity has lost a great many more fights in reality than it has in fiction.
See also Too Many Cooks Spoil the Soup
, Strong as They Need to Be
, Fixed Relative Strength
and The Worf Effect
. Compare Conservation of Competence
and Kill One, Others Get Stronger
. This trope is a reason the Zerg Rush
may fail. Beware, however, in case Reality Ensues
, and this trope doesn't
apply. If the system doesn't
use this, The Minion Master
will capitalize on it, as will the Wolfpack Boss
. Contrast Elite Army
("in the that one Ninja
is a deadly threat", while an army of them are almost invincible
.) and One-Man Army
(for characters who are strong enough to take on large numbers of enemies). An aversion may result in a Bolivian Army Ending
Also known as The Law of Inverse Ninja Strength
: Threat Per Mook = O(1/N)
where N = number of Ninjas (or other "Elite Adversaries"), that is, the threat per mook tends to decrease fast enough so total ninjutsu cannot grow, assuming arithmetic additivity of threat
Subtrope of both Quantity vs. Quality
and Quality Over Quantity
NOTE: This obviously does not apply when the hero had some superior advantage against a big group (like, say, a gun or magic powers) and then lost it and had to go hand-to-hand for the last few guys. Let's not get carried away.