Breakout Villain

aka: The Moriarty Effect
Not every hero has an Arch-Enemy... initially. Sometimes, though, a villain will be introduced who ends up being a Breakout Character in his/her own right, and thus a Villain of the Week becomes the villain of the series.

This can be caused by many things, from Writer Revolt, to unbridled fan response to the character, to the writers being blown away by the performance of the actor who shows up to play the role.

Note that this is the accidental creation of an archenemy, not Executive Meddling of "let's make an archenemy for X-character": a Breakout Villain is one who was meant to be a one-shot throw-away that, through fan/author/executive/all-of-the-above response became not only a staple villain, but the villain of the series.

In some cases, the character may never again appear in the original authors' stories, but because of the popularity of the character, subsequent authors or even the fans in general may make their parts bigger and more integral to the mythos in question, via subsequent stories, adaptations, or simply fanon.

Sometimes, these characters become antiheroes in their own right, with all the attendant risks. Most often, though, they retain their wonderful Big Bad status. Can cross over with Hijacked by Ganon if they are turned into a Bigger Bad overseeing a lot of plots seemingly masterminded by different villains.

Compare Ensemble Dark Horse, Spotlight-Stealing Squad. Contrast with Token Motivational Nemesis, a major nemesis who is killed off as soon as the first story arc ends.


    open/close all folders 

    Anime and Manga 
  • Yu-Gi-Oh!: Both Seto Kaiba and the card game, Duel Monsters (Magic and Wizards back then) were originally going to appear only once. Fans got interested, and sent a cavalcade of mail. Kaiba appeared again as the villain of an arc, and played a card game at the end. Fans went crazy. Then the Yu-Gi-Oh Duelist Kingdom Story Arc came out, one thing led to another, and before long, Kaiba was arguably the number-three character after Yugi and Jounouchi, and Duel Monsters was the focus of the series. If you tell someone who hasn't read the manga that Kaiba and Duel Monsters were originally one-offs, you may make their brain spontaneously combust.
  • Neon Genesis Evangelion: Kaworu Nagisa: Few villainous characters have appeared for so short an amount of time (approx. 12 minutes on-screen of the 24-minute episode), yet left such an impression on any one series. Since Kaworu's appearance, and death, in episode 24 of Evangelion, the fan response to his character has been so abnormally outstanding that Kaworu has appeared as a main character in nearly every subsequent incarnation/retelling/sidestory/etc. of the series, including the Evangelion manga series, Angelic Days manga, games, and the Rebuild of Evangelion series.
  • A Certain Magical Index had Accelerator, who with his sheer creepiness, snark, creative use of the power to control vectors touching him and an insane cacklenote  was so popular among the fans that Kazuma Kamachi brought him back, albeit as a self-loathing, brought down to normal crippled Anti-Hero (Grade 4-5). He still is the most amazing character of the whole set.
  • Medaka Box: Similar to Accelerator, Kumagawa Misogi was originally just a Token Motivational Nemesis, meant merely as a cautionary tale about Medaka's past. Before his actual debut, the only Arc Villains included a megalomaniac abnormal, and a ten-year old obsessed with justice. Once he debuted, he secured his position as the heroine's Arch-Enemy and eventually made a Heel-Face Turn.
  • Great Mazinger has Ankoku Daishogun, The Dragon of the story, The Rival, and a Worthy Opponent to Tetsuya Tsurugi, who in the original series, only lasted roughly 3/4 through the whole show. However, he is popular enough that he got two movie adaptation that stars him as the main villain. There is a good chance that someone who never watched the original series did not know that he is actually not the Big Bad.
  • Dragon Ball
    • Freeza, despite being one of many Big Bads in the series, has practically become synonymous with the franchise - likely due to a mix of voice-acting, character design and sheer monstrosity. He has been featured the most as the main villain of the video games, despite appearing at the series' overall halfway point and being much weaker than Cell or Buu. As if to cement this, he's back in the 2015 post-series movie.
    • Freeza's brother Cooler and the Legendary Super Saiyan Broly are Breakout Movie Villains who appear more than once in the DBZ movies and are the first to appear in the video games. Especially Broly, who appears more often in video games than any other movie villain.
  • The Prince of Tennis: Hyotei was originally one of the Seigaku's arrogant rivals. However, their popularity and subsequent development allowed them to be faced a second time in the Nationals. The same treatment happened with Rikkaidai; their popularity meant that they would face Seigaku in the finals.

    Comic Books 
  • Black Adam: Captain Marvel was such a happy, fun, feel-good-superhero series at first... then Black Adam came along. Originally intended as a one-shot baddy back in the 40's, Black Adam has come back in force several years before the Crisis on Infinite Earths, to become the most powerful villain/antihero of not only Captain Marvel mythos, but also one of the most powerful villains in The DCU. In recent years, he's proven to be more popular than the hero he was created to oppose. It is all the more interesting in that Captain Marvel already had a designated "primary villain" in the form of Dr. Sivana, who debuted alongside him in Whiz Comics #2, bedeviling the Big Red Cheese with a whole deck of Villain cards throughout The Golden Age of Comic Books.
  • Most successful Batman villains are Breakout Villains.
    • The Joker: Believe it or not, the villain of villains, the Clown Prince of Crime, the one crazy bad guy who can make Satan pee in his pants just by laughing, was not originally intended to be the Batman villain, let alone the most well-known villain in comic history. According to the other wiki: "He was slated to be killed in his second appearance, but editor Whitney Ellsworth suggested that the character be spared. A hastily drawn panel, demonstrating that the Joker was still alive, was subsequently added to the comic."
    • Harley Quinn's initial role was to do little more than help smooth out a punchline with a Joker character coming out of a cake, but eventually went on to be a comparable villain in much of the DCAU (and the comics) to even the Joker.
    • The Riddler was featured in a whopping two stories in his debut year (1948) before being promptly forgotten for nearly twenty years. After being brought back into the comics (just in time for the 60s show), he climbed his way up to the highest tier of the Bat-Rogues almost overnight.
    • Scarecrow was featured in only two stories as well, neither of them memorable in the least. Then came a certain issue of The Brave and the Bold comic book that gave him his fear gas... and the rest is history.
    • For decades, Mr. Freeze was a joke villain from the 60s in the same league as Calendar Man and Killer Moth. Then the Batman: The Animated Series episode "Heart of Ice" aired, and he instantly became an A-list villain and one of the most haunting and tragic characters in Batman's rogue gallery.
    • In the third Two-Face story, Batman persuaded him to turn himself in and submit to any needed psychotherapy and surgery by loading a coin to land on its edge, and he did it and got better. They brought back another version and then had him revert.
  • Superman
    • Lex Luthor started out as a minor if powerful villain, with only two comic appearances in the first year he was created. Superman's original arch-nemesis was intended to be the now largely forgotten Ultrahumanite.
    • Though not a character, Kryptonite was first introduced in the radio series. This Achilles' Heel became a defining element of the Superman mythos. (Something called "K-Metal", which amounted to the same thing as Kryptonite, figured in a comic book script well before the radio show, but the script was never published because Lois Lane found out Superman's identity.)
  • If you were to watch any modern incarnation of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, you would think arch-ninja The Shredder is the end-all-be-all of Turtles baddies. Originally, though? He died in the very first issue of the original comic, and was later brought back for a handful of issues—as a clone—only to be killed off again soon after, never to return.
  • The Iron Major became a popular recurring villain for Sgt. Rock, despite dying in his first appearance.
  • Doctor Doom is this to the Fantastic Four; appearing in their fifth issue, he took over their second annual, getting a Death by Origin Story background for him and his parents, and has since then had his own book, own team-up series, and antagonized most of the Marvel verse by power hoarding MacGuffins and being The Chessmaster Magnificent Bastard with Powered Armor. Lampshaded in Doom's third appearance. Stan Lee and Jack Kirby spend some time discussing how good of a villain Doom wound up unexpectedly being and lament killing him off so fast. Doom promptly storms in, very much alive, and berates them for doing the same.
  • The Angel gang in Judge Dredd were introduced as villains of the arc, and one by one were killed by Dredd as the "Judge Child" saga progressed. However, fan response was so positive that Mean was brought Back from the Dead, in one of the exceedingly few occasions that Tharg's rule against resurrections has been ignored. Mean has since become one of the iconic characters of the series.
  • In the Disney Ducks Comic Universe, Flintheart Glomgold started out as The Rival to Scrooge for the title of Richest Duck in the World. Flintheart only appeared in three stories by his creator Carl Barks, but by his third appearance, he had ascended to Scrooge's Evil Counterpart and was one of the few villains to demonstrate murderous intent against Scrooge and his nephews. The Second Richest Duck in the World was mostly forgotten for the next twenty years, until Don Rosa reintroduced him in "Son of the Sun". Comics, the cartoon series DuckTales, and video games have since portrayed Flintheart as a step above Scrooge's usual villains to the point of being his Arch-Enemy. Another breakout villain for Scrooge would be John D. Rockerduck. He was originally a one-shot character created by Carl Barks, but for some reason Italian duck artists made him a recurring character decades later.
  • The Green Goblin was originally a fairly average Spider-Man villain, with possibly the only thing which made him stand out being the fact that his identity wasn't revealed and he kept escaping. Then he found out Spider-Man's identity…. then he killed Gwen Stacy… He's also an unusual case in that he was dead for quite a long time by comic book standards, but after he was brought back he tends to have some hand in almost every major plot against Spider-Man.
    • Joe Straczynski's run has Morlun- he was an antagonist only in the first JMS story, but was the only one to be brought back, usually as a part of a big event, as his mere presence shows things are getting serious.
    • Venom. While he wasn't intended to be just another regular villain (he was made debut in a double-sized 300th issue), neither Marvel nor its creator foresaw him becoming the most popular Spider-Man villain and being promoted to one of the "big three" along with the Green Goblin and Doc Ock. Its creator even had plans to kill him off, but his popularity prevented this.
    • As a result of this, Venom's creator created Carnage in order to kill him off in his place. Once again his plans were foiled when his debut issues quickly sold out despite lack of marketing and the character went on to become extremely popular, rivaling even Venom's fame and causing a 14-issue crossover centered on him to follow.
  • Bullseye for Daredevil. DD had a fairly extensive Rogues' Gallery, but it was considered a pretty poor one. Then Bullseye, the assassin who never misses debuted in issue #131, 12 years after DD himself appeared, and the great rivalry was on.
  • Early in his professional career, comic book writer/artist Jim Starlin was offered to write an issue of Iron Man. Starlin didn't think his career would last very long, so he took the chance to introduce a couple of new characters for his one-off issue. One of those characters was the issue's villain, Thanos. Starlin would go on to write many more comic books, and Thanos would become one of the Biggest Bads in the Marvel Universe.
  • Mortadelo y Filemón: Ibáñez made appear the rival organization ABUELA only once, as a one-time Villain of the Week in "El plano de Alí Gu-sa-no". This didn't stop other writers to use it as the arch-enemy of the organization TIA.
  • Played with with two Captain Atom villains. Major Force was never more than a secondary or even tertiary adversary for Captain Atom, but he later became a fairly major Green Lantern villain, particularly for Kyle Rayner. Wade Eiling, by contrast, was always intended to be the central antagonist for Captain Atom, but has since broken out to become a major villain for the entire DCU. He has also broken out to be a major antagonist for the whole Justice League in Justice League Unlimited, and now seems slated to become a major recurring antagonist for The Flash (2014).

    Films — Animated 
  • Sleeping Beauty: Maleficent was, in the original story, not that important to the actual story and only appears a few times. The Disney adaptation has made it so that now Maleficent is widely considered to be among the coolest villains Disney has ever produced, and indisputably one of the most formidable, and has become one of the go to main villains for Disney whenever they do a serious crossover, such as in Kingdom Hearts and Fantasmic! She also got her own movie.
  • Hercules: Hades, despite having no redeeming qualities whatsoever (and being in one of the least well regarded Disney films), James Woods' spirited portrayal of him made Hades one of the most iconic and popular Disney villains.

    Films — Live-Action 
  • Star Wars:
    • Boba Fett. Boba Fett's presence in the movies was… minimal, at best. But oooooh, has he become a staple of the Star Wars Expanded Universe. Much contention has been made over his survival after being ingested by the Sarlacc (Lucas says he died; Dark Horse Comics along with most fans say he survived), but his popularity cannot be debated. Boba Fett is, to most fans, as integral to the plot as any other characters- in some respects, much more important and likable to the series as a whole. Lucas' opinion later shifted to "Sure Why Not," and he actually considered adding in a scene of him surviving in the 2006 DVD of Return of the Jedi. Tellingly, Boba has a bigger role as a little boy in Attack of the Clones than he did as an adult in the original trilogy.
    • Darth Vader counts as well. Because he's become such an iconic character, it's easy to forget that he actually had a relatively minor role in the original 1977 film: he only had 9 minutes of screen time, he didn't have his famous theme music, he and Luke's father were clearly meant to be different people, and he spent most of the film as an enforcer for the real chief antagonist, Grand Moff Tarkin. It wasn't until The Empire Strikes Back dropped a certain revelation about Luke's parentage that he became the trilogy's main villain, with Luke's battle with him (and his eventual redemption) becoming a crux of the series.
  • Agent Smith from The Matrix was originally supposed to be a Starter Villain, but due to his popularity with fans he was brought back and incorporated in the storyline of the next two films as the main antagonist.
  • Pinhead of the Hellraiser series was originally just one of the group of monsters in the original Hellraiser. He was even killed off in Hellbound: Hellraiser II. But Doug Bradley's portrayal of him made him very popular with the fans, and Pinhead today is the de facto villain of the series, and its mascot.
  • Jason Voorhees in the original Friday the 13th (1980) was just a dead Red Herring to his mother, the real killer of the film. Then, it was decided to bring him back in the sequel. By the end of the eighties, Jason had become a pop culture icon.
  • Khan from Star Trek started out as just another Villain of the Week for Kirk to defeat. He got to return in The Wrath of Khan as one of the series' most notable villains. He even got to show up in Star Trek Into Darkness as one of the main villains.
  • Though the first three John Carter of Mars novels form a loose trilogy, they don't really have a single Big Bad- the closest thing would be the Holy Therns, but they don't show up until the second book, and their leader Matai Shang doesn't put in a personal appearance until the third. For the film adaptation, both the Therns in general and Matai Shang in particular are Arc Welded into the first novel's basic plot, with the intention of making him the unquestionable Big Bad of the potential franchise.
  • Three Finger from the Wrong Turn series, the only character to appear in all five films. In the original, he and his brothers had about the same amount of screentime, and Saw Tooth appeared to be the leader of the group.
  • In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Loki played by Tom Hiddleston has exploded in popularity as the villain in both Thor and The Avengers, becoming probably the most popular character in the universe after Tony Stark.
  • The Godzilla films first had King Ghidorah in this role. Originally brought for a movie to give Godzilla and Rodan a villain to work together against, his popularity led to him becoming Toho's most used monster aside from Godzilla himself, even appearing as villain to Mothra. The second one was Mechagodzilla. Originally just done using the idea of a robotic Evil Knockoff to Godzilla Toho had done with King Kong, Mechagodzilla providing a much more serious threat than anything Godzilla had fought in years led to it becoming his most popular and iconic enemy aside from King Ghidorah, and since then every new Godzilla film series has included a version of it.
  • The Tremor family from Smokin' Aces were all killed off in the first movie, but they proved so popular that the second film became a prequel just so they could show up again.
  • Jaws, the famed henchman with the steel teeth from James Bond. He was originally supposed to die at the end of The Spy Who Loved Me, but Richard Kiel's acting made him so likable that they changed the ending so that he survived when it turned out that the test audiences loved him. He returned in Moonraker, becoming one of the rare villains to appear in multiple Bond films, and would have returned in For Your Eyes Only too had the producers not ultimately decided to go for a more realistic Bond film. He has since become one of the most iconic villains in the franchise, appearing in multiple video games and even the James Bond Jr. cartoon, always as an Implacable Man that Bond must defeat through creative means.

  • Professor James Moriarty, created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to be a one-time opponent of Sherlock Holmes, and to bring about Holmes' demise. In fact, Moriarty was only given more than a passing mention three times in Doyle's work- the story where he appeared, and apparently killed Holmes; and the following story, which brought Holmes Back from the Dead, and in this it's only Moriarty's men; a third story, written much later but set earlier, uses him as a brief Diabolus Ex Machina. Every author, director, fan, etc. afterwards, though, has made Moriarty the villain of Sherlock Holmes, lifting him to the point of mythical status among literary characters; to the modern viewer, it's inconceivable to have an original Holmes movie or television series with original Holmes mysteries without having Moriarty as the central, most important villain.
    • He is now so integral to the mythos that a subplot of the first episode of Sherlock, revolving around the mysterious and vaguely threatening figure who tries to get Watson to spy on Holmes, only works because the audience expects this to be Moriarty and thus be surprised when it turns out to be Mycroft Holmes. A later episode of the same series reveals that all Sherlock's cases so far were connected to Moriarty's schemes.
    • Another "villain" to become central to the Holmes Universe (i.e. original canon and adaptations), despite her one appearance, is Irene Adler, who is the only woman to ever outwit Holmes. In Doyle's stories, he does make a few fleeting mentions of her as the only person whom Holmes never beat- though hardly as many as one might be led to expect by adaptations
    • Fanon has retconned both Moriarty and Irene into the Holmes mythos. There is now a timeline of cases where Holmes clashed with Moriarty's organization, and it's a popular theme in homages and pastiches that Sherlock and Irene had a tryst during Holmes's absence after Reichenbach.
    • Colonel Sebastian Moran, Moriarty's right-hand man. The story that brought about Holmes's resurrection established that he was there when Holmes killed Moriarty, even spontaneously attempting to finish the job, then proceeds to become a Breakout Villain himself. One of the few characters that gets mentioned in several stories, despite only appearing in one, to the point where he's sometimes Watson's full blown Evil Counterpart.
    • Elementary does us two for one. Holmes' season one character arc and backstory was hinged on Irene Adler, and how he spiralled into drugs after she was killed by Moriarty. They became two very important ghost characters for most of the season, until the finale, when it's revealed that they are one and the same. Moriarty forged Irene's persona to distract Holmes, then bring about his downfall because he foiled her plans.
  • King Arthur: Mordred. In the early mentions of King Arthur in Welsh mythology, Arthur was slain by Medraut, later to be known as Mordred. However, Medraut's importance in the mythos as a whole was almost non-existent, save for that he killed King Arthur. Other villains had come and gone, and it seemed that Mordred was intended to just be another, though the only one who finally got lucky (although Arthur slew him in the same action, so his luck is debatable). Ask anyone in modern times, however, who is the villain of the story of King Arthur, and the answer you will get is "Mordred" almost all the time (though Morgan Le Fay is another name that also comes up quite frequently, and is, coincidentally, another example of this trope). Mordred has become so integrated into the mythos of Arthur that it is unheard of to not include him in any story involving Camelot.
    • Modern depictions of Mordred usually bump him up to being King Arthur's son with Morgan, which has a number of neat effects. First of all, it ups his status from being a random evil knight into Luke, You Are My Father. Second, it gives him an actual motivation- he wants to be recognized as the rightful heir but Arthur refuses. Third, it makes Arthur the architect of his own demise, directly. Fourth, it ties him in with Morgan Le Fay, the other popular Moriarty of the series, so everything's wrapped up in a neat little package.
      • This is The Theme Park Version by way of the One Steve Limit. Originally, Mordred's mother was Morgan's sister Morgause, which ends up giving him a supporting cast in the form of his (half-)brothers at court- Gawaine, Gareth, Gaheris, and Agravaine. In Malory, at least, they're a bit of a Five-Man Band. The earliest mention of Mordred is a reference to "The Battle of Camlann" where "Arthur and Medraut died". From the context (or lack of same), it's not even clear that they were on opposite sides!
    • The Welsh Triads include Mordred in a list of heroes. The first unambiguous mention of Villain!Mordred is in Geoffrey of Monmouth's Historia Regum Britanniae (1100s). From there, Mordred got steadily more villainous: in Geoffrey he only speaks twice, in the Alliterative Morte Arthure (early 1300s) he's an angsty Worthy Opponent, in the Stanzaic Morte (late 1300s) he's distinctly worse, and by Malory's Morte d'Arthur (1470s) he's all the way into For the Evulz. As Malory's is the only version most non-medievalists have read, that's the characterization that held.
    • In the end, calling Mordred a "breakout villain" is strange, to say the least. You go back far enough, and he isn't even a villain, but ever since Geoffrey brought him in his function has been constant: he kills Arthur. And, interestingly, that's all he does in most versions. He spends the entirety of Malory hanging around the background, getting constantly mentioned but never doing anything. A byproduct of the fact that there are no "tales of Sir Mordred" since all he ever did was stab his uncle and/or father in the back and try to force Guinevere into marriage.
      • Post Malory, however, there are some works that try to make Mordred into a full on Big Bad for the whole of King Arthur's story.
      • As stated before, Morgan La Fey is another example. She goes from healer who preserves Arthur's immortality, to minor level evil witch, to full blown Big Bad in a great many modern takes on King Arthur.
  • The Lord of the Rings: Sauron originated as a relatively minor villain from the earliest version of the legend of Beren and Lúthien, and the proto-Sauron was a giant cat. The character subsequently morphed into the Evil Sorcerer Thu, and from there into the demonic being known from The Lord of the Rings. In the process, he got promoted from one-shot villain to the God of Evil's Dragon to the Dragon Ascendant and Big Bad of the most well-known part of the mythology and the second most significant villain in the Middle-earth Verse.
  • The Wonderful Wizard of Oz: The Wicked Witch of the West, thanks to the popularity of the classic film, has become the most recognizable of Oz's villains and the Big Bad of most adaptations of the Oz series (i.e. the 1980s cartoon). In the original novels she only appeared in one chapter in the middle of the first book, during which she was Killed Off for Real; the closest thing the Oz books have to a Big Bad is actually the Nome King, who appeared in several books to cause trouble for the land of Oz. In particular, it's the 1939 film version everyone remembers. This is noteworthy because that adaptation actually changed the character quite a bit -The book Witch wasn't green, didn't ride a broomstick, and was not the Wicked Witch of the East's sister (though they were allied). But the success of the film has caused those traits to be adopted by many subsequent adaptations, even ones that are ostensibly based on the books.
  • Alice in Wonderland:
    • The Queen of Hearts only appeared in the last third of the first Alice book and wasn't really as much a villain as she was a temperamental yet comic battleaxe, whose executions were never really carried out. However, Alice spinoffs like American McGee's Alice, The Looking-Glass Wars and the 2010 Tim Burton film have made her the main villain, transforming her into an evil dictator who rules Wonderland with an iron fist and Alice's greatest nemesis. Oddly adaptations will also often combine the distinct, if thematically similar, Queen of Hearts and Red Queen characters into one when doing this.
    • Likewise, The Jabberwock, who only appeared in a poem in Through the Looking Glass where he was quickly killed, has become a significant villain in things like the aforementioned American McGee's Alice and Burton film, as well as a television adaptation in which it stalks Alice throughout.
  • Guy of Gisbourne originally appeared only once in the Robin Hood legend as a bounty hunter who gave Robin an extremely tough fight but was ultimately defeated and killed. He has overtime been elevated to The Dragon or even Big Bad status in retellings.
  • Conan the Barbarian: Thoth-Amon makes only a passing appearance in a few stories, but both comic adaptations make him Conan's Arch-Enemy.
  • Artemis Fowl: Opal Koboi was originally just part of a Big Bad Duumvirate with Briar Cudgeon (an antagonist, but not really the main villain of the first book) in the second book. Then she returned in the fourth book, killing Holly Short's superior.. And was revealed to be the Big Bad of the sixth and eighth book.
  • Slappy of the Goosebumps series was a minor character in the original "Night Of The Living Dummy". He wasn't even the actual villain of the book. Despite that, he was brought back for a sequel book, and took off as the series standout villain from there.
  • Faction Paradox from the Eighth Doctor Adventures first appeared in "Alien Bodies", in which they were just one of the villains. They become the closest things to the Big Bad for much of the series and eventually got a spin-off, though set in an alternate continuity.
  • Graham MacNeill originally created Acting Captain Honsou as a one-off villain for Storm of Iron whose only real notable factor was being the most interesting of the recurring bad-guy viewpoints and the only one to survive to the end, after the other major Iron Warriors viewpoints were killed messily. Then he needed an Iron Warriors villain for Dead Sky, Black Sun and Honsou popped up. Since then, Honsou and his vendetta against Uriel Ventris have produced enough material for a second appearance as a major villain in the Ultramarines books plus a full Iron Warriors omnibus, and the introduction to said omnibus has MacNeill admit that Honsou has taken on a life of his own and is likely to be back for more at a later date.

    Live-Action TV 
  • In Law & Order: Criminal Intent we have Nicole Wallace, AKA That Evil Aussie Chick. Now, this being a crime show, she doesn't get that many appearances, but if you can outwit Goren...
  • Doctor Who: The Daleks: Despite challenging the TARDIS for the title of the most iconic element of Doctor Who, they were created in defiance of co-creator Sydney Newman's insistence on writing a non-traditional Science Fiction series which would avoid Bug-Eyed Monsters. This explains why they died at the end of their first story with no hint given that they might possibly return. Now these motorized pepper-pots have had more than twenty appearances and posed a threat to the Doctor exceeded only by other Time Lords and similarly Sufficiently Advanced Aliens.
    • In turn, Davros, the creator of the Daleks, made such an impression in "Genesis of the Daleks," that all the remaining Dalek stories in the original series are basically Davros ones to some degree with the Daleks largely reduced to his flunkies and rivals. This is arguably a case of this trope not working in his favor as using Davros so much turned him into a huge Base Breaker from overexposure.
      • A lesser but still relevant example: The Autons. They appeared twice, in 1970 and 1971, but are still remembered as one of the Doctor's iconic villains. When the series was revived in 2005, Russell T Davies and co. were deliberating what classic Doctor Who-monster would be used in the first new episode to relaunch the series. The Autons were given that honor.
    • The new series has the Weeping Angels, whose first appearance didn't even have them fighting the Doctor directly, but after subsequent appearances they're on their way to joining the show's showcase of most iconic monsters.
    • Another lesser version is the Zygons, who only made one appearance in the Classic Series. Despite this they are among the most popular Doctor Who monsters and ended up being the main villains for most of the 50th anniversary special.
  • LOST
    • Benjamin Linus, or rather actor Michael Emerson, was originally scheduled for a three episode stint in Season 2. His performance won the producers' everlasting affection and it was expanded to the rest of the season, and then into a regular in Season 3. If this isn't reason enough to include him, in Season 4 one of his fake aliases happens to be Moriarty.
    • Dean Moriarty, though, making this an On the Road reference, as well as a nod to Sherlock Holmes. (The character from On The Road was named as a reference to the Holmes villain, it still works as a reference to both.)
  • Sigfried from Get Smart was originally meant to be a one-time villain, but then popped up again a few times, and is now considered the main villain of the series, even appearing (well, In Name Only) in the 2008 feature film adaptation.
  • Cavil on Battlestar Galactica. In his original appearance, he actually seemed to be one of the nicer Cylons. Turns out he was lying about not supporting the genocide and was its main instigator. Then it turns out that one of the Cavils introduced was a nice Cylon not supporting the genocide, and the other Cavils introduced was the mastermind. Alas, The Plan...
  • Scorpius from Farscape was supposed to be a one-shot first-season villain but the performance was so effective that he returned and quickly usurped the then-Big Bad.
  • Buffy the Vampire Slayer
  • Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Although Gul Dukat appeared in the pilot episode, he was never intended to be a recurring character...but Marc Alaimo just played him so well.
  • Knight Rider: K.A.R.R. was originally a one-episode villain. He was introduced as K.I.T.T.'s Evil Counterpart and ultimately destroyed at the end of the episode. He was brought back in a second episode, "K.I.T.T. vs. K.A.R.R.", due to his popularity. Despite only appearing in two episodes, he's widely remembered as the heroes' Arch-Enemy and plays a prominent role in both the video game and the recent reboot of the series.
  • Murdoc the Master of Disguise assassin on MacGyver. Originally a one-episode villain, his use of creative schemes and deathtraps made him a good foil for master-of-improvisation MacGyver himself, so they kept bringing him back about once a season (due to his Never Found the Body and Staying Alive tendencies), and he's now remembered as MacGyver's Arch-Enemy.
  • Sylar on Heroes was originally planned to be the series' Starter Villain, who would be Killed Off for Real at the end of the first season. However, due to the character's popularity with fans, he was made into a main character and "The Face of Evil" for the series, to the point that every following Big Bad ends up getting Hijacked By Sylar in their season's finale.
  • In Sliders, the Kromaggs (an evil Alternate Universe version of humanity that had evolved differently) eventually become this. Unfortunately it also marks the point where they become the Malignant Plot Tumor, since the show's original Walking the Earth appeal had to be down toned to make place for more action scenes.
  • Barabas, the Demon of Fear, was a Monster of the Week villain who appeared in the 13th episode of Charmed. He proved popular enough that the writers ended up bringing him back several times (about once every other season). He never became a seasonal Big Bad, but is probably the show's most frequently-occurring nemesis right behind the actual Big Bads.
  • Smallville: Lionel Luthor, Lex's Corrupt Corporate Executive Abusive Dad was originally meant to appear in only a few episodes of Season 1 as a way of making Lex's Freudian Excuse seem more poignant. John Glover's performance was excellent, however, and the fandom embraced the Magnificent You-Know-What as a Love to Hate character of the first degree. Lionel was written into Season 2 as a major antagonist and Recurring Character, and became the Big Bad of Season 3. In the process he gained new dimensions to his character and his own Freudian Excuse becoming an Even Evil Has Standards Archnemesis Dad who was himself the product of Abusive Parents. He was later possessed by Jor-El and made a Heel-Face Turn, becoming a dark Mentor figure to Clark. Killed Off for Real in Season 7 by Lex, Glover and Lionel returned to the show in Season 10 as Earth-2 Lionel, an Eviler Twin of our Lionel, who was The Heavy for most of the last part of the show. In some ways Lionel, and not Lex as was originally intended, became Smallville's defining villain.

    Lionel, and Glover's portrayal of him, resonated so well that he was written into the comics as Lex Luthor's canonical (and deceased) father. While Lex had obviously always had a (deceased by the time of the "present day") father, this character had never had a consistent name or physical appearance and usually had no importance. But ever since Smallville, Lex's father is explicitly named "Lionel Luthor" and flashback scenes have depicted him as looking very similar to actor John Glover. A zombiefied, Black Lantern version of Lionel even showed up for revenge against Lex in Blackest Night.
  • Emilia Fox as Morgause from Merlin was only supposed to be around for a couple of episodes, but ended up being so integral to the episodes she featured in that the writers kept her around for longer.
  • Klaus from The Vampire Diaries quickly became this despite the fact his influence was originally not going stretch far into season 3, much less into season 4. However his character as well as the other Originals (Elijah gets a special mention as someone who was going to die within one episode), became very popular in addition to the writers just loving writing for them. Klaus is so popular he may in fact get his own spin off.
  • On Batman The Riddler quickly came to be one of the Dynamic Duo's most popular adversaries, likely because of Frank Gorshin's amazing performance as the character.
  • On Stargate SG-1, Ba'al is obviously intended to be a villain of the week, but Cliff Simon's performance became a fan-favorite, particularly in later appearances where his character becomes Dangerously Genre Savvy.
  • On iCarly, Neville was originally going to be a one-shot villain, but he had since become a recurring villain out and the gang's Arch-Enemy. Dan Schneider even called him The Joker to Carly's Batman.
  • On Alias, Mr. Sark was originally just a gofer for the Season 1 Big Bad, The Man. He was such a hit with the fans that he became The Dragon in Season 2, then became the Dragon Ascendant to share the Big Bad role in Season 3, went back to being the Dragon in Season 5, and, in fact, eventually managed to be the only recurring villain on the show to make it all the way through the finale alive and free.
  • Dr. Miguelito Loveless debuted in the third episode of The Wild Wild West and ended up getting captured. But he made such a memorable impression (and his actor, Michael Dunn was good friends with lead Robert Conrad in Real Life) that he'd turn up again and again (his second episode would be the only other time he'd get captured) to become Jim West's undisputed archenemy.
  • Supernatural: Crowley was originally just a minor character aiding the Winchesters against Lucifer in what Eric Kripke intended to be the final season. After it continued beyond that, he was popular enough to come back and he's since become the show's most recurring and recognizable antagonist, eventually being promoted from recurring character to main cast in Season 10.
  • Raina from Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. was originally intended to be a minor villain, but the writers and fans found the character so entertaining that she was given a greatly expanded role in the plot.

    Tabletop Games 
  • Magic: The Gathering:
    • When Yawgmoth and the other Phyrexians first appeared, they were barely a footnote in the flavor of the Antiquities expansion; eventually, they morphed into the centerpiece of Magic's Rogues Gallery. After Yawgmoth's defeat, the Phyrexians made a comeback in the Scars of Mirridon block.
    • Nicol Bolas was one of the five elder dragons in Legends. Due to his card having a more powerful and unique mechanic than the others, he was reprinted 12 years later in Time Spiral and was one of many characters from the past to appear in its novels. While most of the old planeswalkers were either killed off or depowered in those novels, Bolas remained as a planeswalker. He appears again in the Alara block, and has since taken over the position of Big Bad from the Phyrexians.
  • Asmodeus of Dungeons & Dragons started out as a brief mention in 1st Edition as the ruler of Hell. Then 3rd put the spotlight on him in the Book of Vile Darkness, and he became one of its most popular villains as the game's Satanic Archetype. Recognizing his popularity, some of the last books of 3.5 featured Asmodeus heavily and let him get one over on the entire pantheon twice. When the game upgraded to 4th Edition, he jumped up from an archdevil to the God of Evil... and just to solidify it, Pathfinder featured their own version of Asmodeus as the God of Evil.

  • Super Mario Bros.:
    • Bowser. Before Super Mario Bros. 1, the portly plumber tangled with a lot of nasty foes. Donkey Kong, Foreman Spike, and random unorganized critters (though some did look similar to Koopas). But once Super Mario Bros. hit the scene, it was Mario's defining moment, and from that day forth, the Koopa troop and its fearless leader would be his most prominent nemesis. This seems even more dramatic in America, where Bowser was in fact absent for a game before making a triumphant reappearance in Super Mario Bros. 3. In this case it was the unforeseen popularity of the game that caused Bowser to become a Breakout Villain.
    • Wario. The Super Mario Land games felt like Gaiden Games to the main franchise, and then part 2 featured this fellow, and the next one starred him, and he turned Anti-Hero. Since then he's been a mainstay of the Mario franchise.
  • In the original PlayStation version of Resident Evil, Albert Wesker was just a standard horror movie stock character (the obligatory traitor who gets eaten by the monster in the end, Paul Rieser's character from Aliens). However, following his return in Resident Evil: Code: Veronica, he managed to pretty quickly be built up to be the Big Bad of the entire series over the course of the following decade up until his last appearance in Resident Evil 5.
  • Revolver Ocelot in the original Metal Gear Solid was notable for being the sole surviving member of the renegade FOX-HOUND unit by the end of the story and a mole under the service of Solidus Snake, although there was not much to suggest that he was anything other than a double agent. Each subsequent entry in the series would reveal more about Ocelot's past and motives, having him shift from one allegiance to the next and outliving the main antagonist of each game until becoming the main antagonist himself in Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots.
  • Warcraft: Sargeras started out as little more than a footnote in the lore, as a Sealed Evil in a Can demon lord whose powers Gul'dan tried to harness. The revelations of his origins as a fallen Titan and creator of the Burning Legion elevated him to Bigger Bad of the entire franchise.
    • Also the Old Gods (a race of Eldritch Abominations), originally a tangential source of the mythos based on the Cthulhu Mythos, they were used to add some creepy side stories used in the expanded World of Warcraft storyline, and also used as Disc One Final Boss for the original version of the game (pre-expansion), the Old Gods consistantly appear as the ultimate source of all evil, to the point it has a become a Running Gag to blame things on them
      • Sargeras, founder of the Burning Legion? Went mad fighting the Old Gods. Weird primal deities worshipped by troll witch doctors? Totally Old Gods. Elementals Lords? Servants of the Old Gods. The Lich King? His necromantic powers all derive from the Old Gods. Deathwing? Pawn of the Old Gods. War of the ancients? Masterminded by the Old Gods. Creepy fairy circles in Tyrisfal? Probably the Old Gods. Negative emotions buried beneath the earth by an Ancient Emperor that come to life? Actually remnants of dead Old Gods
      • Flesh races supplanting the rock and metal older races? Blame the Curse of Flesh inflicted on the old races by Yogg-Saron.
  • Wilhelm "Deathshead" Strauss/Strasse of the SS Paranormal Division returns as the eventual Big Bad in Wolfenstein (2009), mainly due to his status as being the sole surviving Nazi of any prominence in Return to Castle Wolfenstein besides Himmler. He's even more prominent in Wolfenstein: The New Order, being the primary source of the Nazis' mechs and other super science.
  • Bishop Ladja of Dragon Quest V. In the original SNES game, while he did have some presence in the plot, he was ultimately a minor villain who showed only a mild evil and dies less then halfway through the game. The DS remake propels him into this, giving him a unique appearance, replacing King Korol with him as The Dragon, giving him much more screentime.
  • SHODAN was so much of a standout villain in the first System Shock, that she was brought back for the second, where she became one of the most legendary villains in gaming history.
  • Vergil, Dante's Aloof Elder Twin, from Devil May Cry. In his first appearance, he was simply a Brainwashed and Crazy servant of the game's Big Bad known as Nelo Angelo, although he made a good impression by serving as a challenging Mirror Boss several times over. Then, he reappeared in DMC3 (a prequel chronicling some of Dante's backstory and early demon-hunting days), giving players a glimpse of his more complex character quirks and motivations, revamping him into an even more challenging opponent that stands in Dante's way, and giving him a somewhat pitiable send-off of sorts. Needless to say, this not only made Vergil the most recurring boss in the series (with a total of 6-7 battles), but cemented him as the most recognizable villain as well. As such, Vergil joined the lineup of Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3 alongside Dante and Trish (herself something of a Breakout Character), much to the delight of DMC fans.
  • Ridley, from Metroid was originally just The Dragon (literally) in the original NES game. Nowadays he's Samus' Arch-Enemy due to his involvement in her past when he murdered her parents and his refusal to stay dead. His consistently awesome boss fights might also have something to do with it.
  • The Materials in the Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha As Portable games were originally one-dimensional Darkness of the Book of Darkness-based Evil Twin copies of the three Aces, and were unceremoniously destroyed by the end of the first game, The Battle of Aces. Except it turns out that the fans liked the Materials, so they were revived in the sequel, The Gears of Destiny, and had the game revolve around them, expanding their personalities, backstories, and importance. Oh, and they also got an official manga with them in the starring role. And they return in another Alternate Continuity as the main foreign rivals team of the Card Game-focused Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha INNOCENT. Not bad for Licensed Game Spin-Off villains who were supposed to just show up and get killed on their first appearance.
  • Sonic the Hedgehog: Similar to Ridley, Metal Sonic was originally just The Dragon to Dr. Eggman, appearing only as a boss in Sonic CD. Eventually, his popularity skyrocketed to the point where he was made the Big Bad of Sonic Heroes. He's generally considered the second most prominent villain after Eggman himself.
  • Kingdom Hearts
    • Both Axel and Xigbar have had their roles expanded since their debut game thanks to their popularity. The difference is Axel undergoes a Heel-Face Turn and becomes an anti hero, then later a straight hero with his own Keyblade, no less. Xigbar turns out to be the main Dragon for Xehanort and as of 3D shares Big Bad status with him as one of his 13 vessels.
    • To a lesser extent, Chernabog was so well received (being an awesome boss to fight, and having his own theme from Fantasia, Night on Bald Mountain, playing in the background) that he came back as a boss fight for Riku in Dream Drop Distance. His appearance is very close to a Heartless, and he has the privilege to be one of the only enemies in the KHverse to not have a entry in Jiminy's Journal, which only reinforces his aura and mystery.
  • From the Silent Hill series, Pyramid Head from the second game left such an impression on everyone that he's often seen as the series' mascot, of sorts. Despite the original nature of his character, he appeared in a somewhat different form in Silent Hill: Homecoming, and appeared in both of the film adaptations of the games.

  • In The Order of the Stick, Nale was the only member of the Linear Guild originally slated to escape from the first battle with the heroes. However, fans really liked Thog, so the Giant decided to spare him and, while he was at it, Sabine as well, developing her and Nale's relationship into a case of Unholy Matrimony.
    • Similarly, Redcloak was originally going to be killed off fairly early on (his name was even envisioned as a pun on Red Shirt). Instead, he ended up surviving and being fleshed out, becoming one of the most complex characters in the story.
    • This trope is a key facet in Tarquin's Xanatos Gambit involving Elan. It's his contingency in case his Evil Empire plot is toppled. The legend of the hero who defeats him will serve to spread his own legend and inspire generations of new Evil Overlords to follow in his footsteps. As he puts it, "If I win, I get to be a king. If I lose, I get to be a LEGEND!"

    Western Animation 
  • Harley Quinn, everyone's favorite Hench Wench from Batman: The Animated Series. She was originally invented as a one-shot female henchmen to leap out of Commissioner Gordon's cake (the censors allowed The Joker to do it instead), and an overwhelming fan response turned her into a recurring villain and a Canon Immigrant into the comics. She even went on to be one of the few villains to Out-Batman Gambit Batman himself and come this close to actually killing him.
  • Kim Possible
    • Shego was originally "just a henchman" to Dr. Drakken, but later developed into a competent but unambitious villain who entertained herself (and the audience) with her incessant verbal jabs at Drakken and Kim. Drakken's own standing has curiously enough has also benefited from her popularity: even though he gets out-shined by his own assistant on the popularity polls it was thanks to this dynamic that he became the second most important villain in the series.
    • Monkey Fist was originally just a crazed monkey themed villain who happened to be one of the few villains Ron Stoppable could actually face. Over time, as Mystical Monkey Power became more prominent, so did Monkey Fist (effectively becoming Ron's Arch-Enemy).
  • In the original Mirage Comics version of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, the Shredder was actually a fairly lackluster Starter Villain who managed to get himself Killed Off for Real at the end of the very first issue. In later issues a colony of sentient worms would take up the mantle of The Shredder (it's a long story), but even they only appeared in a few issues and played a rather minor role in the comics plotline. However, the 1980's cartoon adaptation made him the Big Bad, and he's been the Turtles' Arch-Enemy in every future adaptation of the series ever since. In Turtles Forever Mirage Shredder shows up for about 10 seconds before he's knocked off a building by the 1980's Turtles.
  • On Gargoyles the Archmage was originally only supposed to be a Villain Of The Week, but creator Greg Weisman liked David Warner's voice acting so much he decided to bring him back, making him the villain of the three-part "Avalon" arc through a Stable Time Loop and a couple Artifacts of Doom.
  • Mad Stan from Batman Beyond was originally a one-shot joke villain thrown in to make Terry miss his date with Dana. The fans loved him, and he eventually became a regular member of the Rogues Gallery.
  • Negaduck from Darkwing Duck. After the Negaduck I episode, Tad Stones (the Show Runner) said he liked Negaduck and wanted him brought back for more episodes; this resulted in Negaduck II, who the fandom embraced as perhaps not just the most popular villain but the most popular character on the show, period. When the revival comic book came around, the writer has said that he intended to have a F.O.W.L. story for the second arc and a Negaduck story for the third arc, but sheer fan demand made him swap the order.
  • In The Powerpuff Girls, The Rowdyruff Boys were originally one-shot evil spear counterparts of the titular heroines that got Killed Off for Real at the end of the episode. Fan popularity ensured that they were brought back several times.
  • Plankton of Spongebob Squarepants, while initially a recurring villain, was placed alongside many other antagonists or jerks the cast faced. As seasons passed, he got more and more spotlight episodes, and stared in several Villain Episodes.
  • The Dreamstone, while Sgt Blob and his minions Frizz and Nug were always the consistant villains, they were merely mooks to the real Big Bad Zordrak initially, with the story designed with Rufus as the intended main character initially. Within a short duration of episodes, both the heroes and Zordrak were Demoted to Extra with Blob's men usually acting as Villain Protagonists. In later seasons Urpgor also gets larger roles and sometimes eclipsed even the other Urpney squad in screentime.
  • Chase Young of Xiaolin Showdown was originally a one-shot character- an Arch-Enemy to Master Monk Guan, himself originally a one-shot character. By the next season, he'd become the closest thing to a Big Bad for the whole show and remained that way for the rest of it.
  • Charmcaster from Ben10 initially was introduced merely as a niece and sidekick for Gwen's Arch-Enemy Hex. In the end, Hex only got a few more appearances where he gradually became less and less important over the course of the franchise, while Charmcaster had several additional appearances, Character Development and became more of an Arch-Enemy to Gwen than he ever was.
  • Tirek from the first of the My Little Pony Tv Specials was only a one-shot villain who got killed off in his premiere, but he became the most popular villain in the G1 continuity for being a surprisingly vile piece of work. Fast forward a few decades to My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic and his new incarnation became a Satanic Archetype and the antagonist for the fourth season's finale.

Alternative Title(s):

The Moriarty Effect, Moriarty Effect