Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BatmanCanBreatheInSpace

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
altering tense


* In ''Animation/TheReturnOfHanuman'', Hanuman fought against Rahu and Ketu in outer space, with no space equipment whatsoever.

to:

* In ''Animation/TheReturnOfHanuman'', Hanuman fought fights against Rahu and Ketu in outer space, with no space equipment whatsoever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
redirect


* In the ''Animation/PleasantGoatAndBigBigWolf'' film ''Animation/MoonCastleTheSpaceAdventure'', the gang goes to the moon to keep the Gourd King from making it bitter. They do not wear their spacesuits while on the moon, and yet they have no problems breathing there.

to:

* In the ''Animation/PleasantGoatAndBigBigWolf'' film ''Animation/MoonCastleTheSpaceAdventure'', ''[[Animation/PleasantGoatAndBigBigWolfMoonCastleTheSpaceAdventure Moon Castle: The Space Adventure]]'', the gang goes to the moon to keep the Gourd King from making it bitter. They do not wear their spacesuits while on the moon, and yet they have no problems breathing there.

Added: 792

Changed: 28

Removed: 781

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''Literature/{{Kemlo}}'' series by Creator/ReginaldAlecMartin, anyone born in space (i.e. actually in the vacuum of space itself, not merely on board a spaceship or station) can somehow "breathe" in space. Even for a pulpy children's science fiction book series from TheFifties, this strains the reader's credulity to breaking point.

to:

* In the ''Literature/{{Kemlo}}'' series by Creator/ReginaldAlecMartin, anyone born in space (i.e. actually in the vacuum of space itself, not merely on board a spaceship or station) can somehow "breathe" in space. Even for a pulpy children's science fiction book series from TheFifties, The50s, this strains the reader's credulity to breaking point.



* ''Webcomic/{{Shortpacked}}'' is the {{Trope Namer|s}} ("How would he ''know''? Has he ''[[https://shortpacked.com/comic/batman-can-breathe-in-space tried]]''?"). More recent strips show that, while Bruce Wayne can breathe in space, Dick Grayson ''can't''. One ''Bigger Than Cheeses'' comic lampshades this with the title "Breathing in space doesn't help on the Sun" -- the comic itself is about what would really happen in a fight between Batman and Superman. Incidentally, while Batman can breathe in space, Franchise/TheFlash ''[[http://pics.livejournal.com/shortpacked/pic/000y2cyq/ can't]]''... oops!

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Shortpacked}}'' is the {{Trope Namer|s}} ("How would he ''know''? Has he ''[[https://shortpacked.com/comic/batman-can-breathe-in-space tried]]''?"). More recent strips show that, while Bruce Wayne can breathe in space, Dick Grayson ''can't''. One ''Bigger Than Cheeses'' comic lampshades this with the title "Breathing in space doesn't help on the Sun" -- the comic itself is about what would really happen in a fight between Batman and Superman. Incidentally, while Batman can breathe in space, Franchise/TheFlash ComicBook/TheFlash ''[[http://pics.livejournal.com/shortpacked/pic/000y2cyq/ can't]]''... oops!



* In ''WesternAnimation/TheAdventuresOfSamAndMaxFreelancePolice'' episode "Bad Day On The Moon", Sam and Max are able to breathe on the moon (which has no atmosphere) without special equipment, Max shrugs it off by saying "I guess those prissy paranoid astronauts didn't have the spine to try it." Given that the characters reach the moon by ''driving there in a 1960 Desoto convertible'', this is not that surprising.



* In ''WesternAnimation/MiloMurphysLaw'': The Octalians are immune to the vacuum of space as long as they hold their breath and shapeshift; as explained by Loab:
-->'''Loab''' Well, our hull was breached and I was sucked out. You see, we're immune to the vacuum of space as long as we hold our breath and shape shift. Milo was the last one I touched, so I changed into him.



* In ''WesternAnimation/MiloMurphysLaw'': The Octalians are immune to the vacuum of space as long as they hold their breath and shapeshift; as explained by Loab:
-->'''Loab''' Well, our hull was breached and I was sucked out. You see, we're immune to the vacuum of space as long as we hold our breath and shape shift. Milo was the last one I touched, so I changed into him.



* In the ''WesternAnimation/SamAndMaxFreelancePolice'' episode "Bad Day On The Moon", Sam and Max are able to breathe on the moon (which has no atmosphere) without special equipment, Max shrugs it off by saying "I guess those prissy paranoid astronauts didn't have the spine to try it." Given that the characters reach the moon by ''driving there in a 1960 Desoto convertible'', this is not that surprising.



* On an early episode of ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBrothers'' Brock Sampson got sucked into the vacuum of space for a good 10 minutes before he was rescued. He survives fine.

to:

* On an early episode of ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBrothers'' ''WesternAnimation/TheVentureBros'' Brock Sampson got sucked into the vacuum of space for a good 10 minutes before he was rescued. He survives fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


SubTrope to TheNeedless, because the character is somehow protected from dangers that would be lethal to human beings, and to ArtisticLicenseSpace, because these outer space inaccuracies are in service of the story. Compare SpaceIsNoisy, where sound is conveyed via vacuum in the same way as sound is conveyed through atmosphere, allowing the characters to talk to one another. Contrast ExplosiveDecompression, where being exposed to a vacuum will quickly make you explode due to the air inside your body trying to expand and fill the void.

to:

SubTrope to TheNeedless, because the character is somehow protected from dangers that would be lethal to human beings, and to ArtisticLicenseSpace, because these outer space inaccuracies are in service of the story. Compare SpaceIsNoisy, where sound is conveyed via vacuum in the same way as sound is conveyed through atmosphere, allowing the characters to talk to one another. Contrast ExplosiveDecompression, where being exposed to a vacuum will quickly make you explode due to the air inside your body trying to expand and fill the void.
void. Sometimes all you need is a SpaceMask.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* Lampshaded and played for laughs in ''[[VideoGame/{{Bleed}} Bleed 2]]'', where two whole levels take place in space. The Heroine Wryn can not, in fact, breathe in space – she can just hold her breath really, really long, through sheer badassery!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Many ''VideoGame/{{Battletech}}'' missions take place on airless moons and martian-style environments. While [=BattleMechs=] ''are'' rated for hard vacuum in-universe (this is one of their major draws), most of the standard-issue vehicles that you can encounter in such missions are not. In addition, cracking open the cockpit of a 'mech does not put the [=MechWarrior=] inside at risk of decompression or atmospheric poisoning.

to:

* Many ''VideoGame/{{Battletech}}'' ''VideoGame/BattleTech2018'' missions take place on airless moons and martian-style environments. While [=BattleMechs=] ''are'' rated for hard vacuum in-universe (this is one of their major draws), most of the standard-issue vehicles that you can encounter in such missions are not. In addition, cracking open the cockpit of a 'mech does not put the [=MechWarrior=] inside at risk of decompression or atmospheric poisoning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content; There IS an explanation for why space is breathable in Treasure Planet, it's just made more explicit in tie-in material


* In ''WesternAnimation/TreasurePlanet'', everyone can breathe in space. No explanation; they just... ''can''. Chalk it up to RuleOfCool, since the whole movie treats space [[SpaceIsAnOcean like an ocean]]. Space is called "The Etherium". And there's all sorts of spaceborne organisms, like {{Space Whale}}s.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/TreasurePlanet'', everyone can breathe in space. No explanation; they just... ''can''. Chalk it up to RuleOfCool, since the whole movie treats space [[SpaceIsAnOcean like an ocean]]. ocean]] (although Space is filled with a substance called "The Etherium".Etherium", [[AllThereInTheManual which apparently allows breathability according to tie-in material]]). And there's all sorts of spaceborne organisms, like {{Space Whale}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Franchise/ThePowerpuffGirls'', the girls frequently end up in space for one reason or another, and have no trouble breathing, talking, shouting, or, in [[WesternAnimation/ThePowerpuffGirlsMovie the movie]], hearing screams and gasps from the Earth while on an asteroid. DependingOnTheWriter: in one episode they did have spacesuits on.

to:

* In ''Franchise/ThePowerpuffGirls'', the girls frequently end up in space for one reason or another, and have no trouble breathing, talking, shouting, or, in [[WesternAnimation/ThePowerpuffGirlsMovie the movie]], hearing screams and gasps from the Earth while on an asteroid. DependingOnTheWriter: Although in one episode they did have spacesuits on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Happens in two Object Shows, ''WebAnimation/ObjectOverload'' and ''WebAnimation/ObjectMayhem''. The elimination areas on those 2 places are in space, namely "Prison Planet" and the moon, and none of the eliminated contestants wear equipment in space and yet are perfectly fine. Subverted in ''WebAnimation/InanimateInsanity'', because although the contestants go to space in Episode 2 of Season 2 to save Marshmallow without gear, Mephone4 admits that earlier in the episode, Marshmallow will in fact die in space after an hour if she is not saved.

to:

* Happens in two Object Shows, ''WebAnimation/ObjectOverload'' and ''WebAnimation/ObjectMayhem''. The elimination areas on those 2 places are in space, namely "Prison Planet" and the moon, and none of the eliminated contestants wear equipment in space and yet are perfectly fine. Subverted in ''WebAnimation/InanimateInsanity'', because although the contestants go to space in Episode 2 of Season 2 to save Marshmallow without gear, Mephone4 Mephone 4 admits that earlier in the episode, Marshmallow will in fact die in space after an hour if she is not saved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Happens in two Object Shows, ''WebAnimation/ObjectOverload'' and ''WebAnimation/ObjectMayhem''. The elimination areas on those 2 places are in space, namely "Prison Planet" and the moon, and none of the eliminated contestants wear equipment in space and yet are perfectly fine. Subverted in ''WebAnimation/InanimateInsanity'', because although the contestants go to space in Episode 2 of Season 2 to save Marshmallow without gear, MePhone4 admits that earlier in the episode, Marshmallow will in fact die in space after an hour if she is not saved.

to:

* Happens in two Object Shows, ''WebAnimation/ObjectOverload'' and ''WebAnimation/ObjectMayhem''. The elimination areas on those 2 places are in space, namely "Prison Planet" and the moon, and none of the eliminated contestants wear equipment in space and yet are perfectly fine. Subverted in ''WebAnimation/InanimateInsanity'', because although the contestants go to space in Episode 2 of Season 2 to save Marshmallow without gear, MePhone4 Mephone4 admits that earlier in the episode, Marshmallow will in fact die in space after an hour if she is not saved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Happens in two Object Shows, ''WebAnimation/ObjectOverload'' and ''WebAnimation/ObjectMayhem''. The elimination areas on those 2 places are in space, namely "Prison Planet" and the moon, and none of the eliminated contestants wear equipment in space and yet are perfectly fine. Subverted in ''WebAnimation/InanimateInsanity'', because although the contestants go to space in Episode 2 of Season 2 to save Marshmallow without gear, MePhone4 admits that earlier in the episode, Marshmallow will in fact die in space after an hour if she is not saved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There are 2 moon maps in ''VideoGame/PlantsVsZombiesGardenWarfare'' 2, and there's no sort of sustaining tech for either the Plants or Zombies.

to:

* There are 2 moon maps in ''VideoGame/PlantsVsZombiesGardenWarfare'' 2, and there's no sort of sustaining tech for either the Plants or Zombies. While the lack of air wouldn’t be a problem for the Zombies, both they and the Plants ought to freeze to death on these maps, but for whatever reason, they don’t.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''ComicBook/SamAndMaxFreelancePolice'' episode, "Bad Day On The Moon", the eponymous duo blast off to the moon (via thousands and thousands of match heads stuffed into the [=DeSoto=]'s tailpipe) with only a set of penny-conscious moon gear (paper bags with plastic eye holes to put over their heads) to protect them from the lack of atmosphere on the moon. But, despite Sam's preparedness (he brought a spare bag in case he ran out of air), it turns out that they can breathe easily on the moon, as Max exemplifies by taking his bag off to dig some moon dust out of his eye. Explained thusly:

to:

* In the ''ComicBook/SamAndMaxFreelancePolice'' episode, story "Bad Day On The Moon", the eponymous duo blast off to the moon (via thousands and thousands of match heads stuffed into the [=DeSoto=]'s tailpipe) with only a set of penny-conscious moon gear (paper bags with plastic eye holes to put over their heads) to protect them from the lack of atmosphere on the moon. But, despite Sam's preparedness (he brought a spare bag in case he ran out of air), it turns out that they can breathe easily on the moon, as Max exemplifies by taking his bag off to dig some moon dust out of his eye. Explained thusly:



* Pre-crisis Characters/{{Superman|TheCharacter}} could hold his breath indefinitely in space. After the ''ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths'' reboot he needed an oxygen mask until Mongul Jr taught him a method of holding his breath.
* If you're a comic book character simply ignoring physics is a valid option: in ''Trinity'', Despero leaps out of his armada flagship to fight ComicBook/GreenLantern in space, when his lackey objects saying he has no spacesuit on, Despero merely shouts "Air is for cowards! Do it!" and he actually survives perfectly fine.
* In ''ComicBook/XMen: X-Cutioner's Song'', there's one scene where Cyclops and Jean Grey escape one of Stryfe's fortresses and attempt to get away by ''crawling across the moon''. Not only do they survive that brief point of time before they ''pass out''. That's also counting the fact that there's also probably enough gravity that Jean can take a misstep and promptly faceplant onto the moon's surface and get a bloody nose.

to:

* ''ComicBook/{{Superman}}'': Pre-crisis Characters/{{Superman|TheCharacter}} could hold his breath indefinitely in space. After the ''ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths'' reboot reboot, he needed an [[SpaceMask oxygen mask mask]] until Mongul Jr Jr. taught him a method of holding his breath.
* If you're a comic book character simply ignoring physics is a valid option: in ''Trinity'', ''ComicBook/Trinity2008'', Despero leaps out of his armada flagship to fight ComicBook/GreenLantern in space, when space. When his lackey objects objects, saying that he has no spacesuit on, Despero merely shouts "Air is for cowards! Do it!" it!", and he actually survives perfectly fine.
* In ''ComicBook/XMen: X-Cutioner's Song'', ComicBook/XCutionersSong'', there's one scene where Cyclops and Jean Grey escape one of Stryfe's fortresses and attempt to get away by ''crawling across the moon''. Not only do they survive that brief point of time before they ''pass out''. That's also counting the fact that there's also probably enough gravity that Jean can take a misstep and promptly faceplant onto the moon's surface and get a bloody nose.

Added: 222

Removed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A Grand Day Out is a short film.


* ''WesternAnimation/AGrandDayOut'': WesternAnimation/WallaceAndGromit can breathe just fine on the moon. They don't exhibit weightlessness in outer space either, with only a ball Wallace kicks into the air being affected.



* ''WesternAnimation/WallaceAndGromit'' can breathe just fine on the moon in ''WesternAnimation/AGrandDayOut''. They don't exhibit weightlessness in outer space either, with only a ball Wallace kicks into the air being affected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyXIV'' ''Endwalker'' has Mare Lamentorum - a section of the moon. No character, including yours, has any problems breathing and talking without any sort of specialized, or even magical, equipment, and gravity seems to function exactly the same as it does on the planet despite obviously lacking an atmosphere. [[spoiler:Considering the Moon is actually an artificial spacecraft disguised as a satellite, and one of the reasons it was created was to act as an ark for humans to evacuate the planet, this is likely justified.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


*** This could also be explained by the fact that Peter Quill at that moment still possessed his Celestial Powers, albeit he still didn't know it.

Changed: 265

Removed: 404

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed repeated entry.


%%* '''Unsure''' The ''ComicBook/FantasticFour'' just use helmets-- their [[MySuitIsAlsoSuper uniforms]] double as spacesuits (except ComicBook/TheThing, his skin is tougher than any spacesuit) -- the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_activity_suit Space Activity Suit]] was still several years away from invention when the FF started this practice.

to:

%%* '''Unsure''' The ''ComicBook/FantasticFour'' just use helmets-- their [[MySuitIsAlsoSuper uniforms]] double as spacesuits (except ComicBook/TheThing, Characters/TheThing, his skin is tougher than any spacesuit) -- the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_activity_suit Space Activity Suit]] was still several years away from invention when the FF started this practice.



* Pre-crisis ''ComicBook/{{Superman}}'' could hold his breath indefinitely in space. After the ''ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths'' reboot he needed an oxygen mask until Mongul Jr taught him a method of holding his breath.

to:

* Pre-crisis ''ComicBook/{{Superman}}'' Characters/{{Superman|TheCharacter}} could hold his breath indefinitely in space. After the ''ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths'' reboot he needed an oxygen mask until Mongul Jr taught him a method of holding his breath.



* In ''WesternAnimation/TheAdventuresOfJimmyNeutronBoyGenius'', the characters are capable of breathing in outer space without helmets or spacesuits. At one point, this is lampshaded by Sheen, who asks Jimmy how it's even ''possible'' for them to survive in space without said equipments (other than them being in a [[RuleOfFunny cartoon). Unfortunately, Carl's annoying singing drowns out all of Jimmy's explanations.
* During the [[GrandFinale Grand Finale]] of ''WesternAnimation/{{Amphibia}}'', [[spoiler: the [[FinalBattle Final Battle]] occurs [[AstralFinale in space]] with the girls using their [[SuperMode Calamity Forms]] to fight against [[BigBad The Core]] in order to prevent it from [[ColonyDrop crashing into Amphibia]], however, the girls aren't able to stop it, and when all hope seems lost, Anne decides to pull a [[HeroicSacrifice Heroic Sacrifice]] by taking all the powers of the [[MacGuffin Calamity Gems]] by herself to destroy The Core, this removes Marcy and Sasha's powers, but for some reason they are both able to still breathe in space before being sent back to the planet. Sprig then flies up to space with [[RobotBuddy Frobo's]] help to try to convince Anne to don't sacrifice herself, and he is also able to talk and breathe normally.]]

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/TheAdventuresOfJimmyNeutronBoyGenius'', the characters are capable of breathing in outer space without helmets or spacesuits. At one point, this is lampshaded by Sheen, who asks Jimmy how it's even ''possible'' for them to survive in space without said equipments (other than them being in a [[RuleOfFunny cartoon). cartoon]]). Unfortunately, [[TheUnreveal Carl's annoying singing singing]] [[TrollingCreator drowns out all of Jimmy's explanations.
explanations]]. When interviewed about this the animators said that they decided that spacesuits would interfere with the expressions of the characters, so that InSpaceEveryoneCanSeeYourFace.
* During the [[GrandFinale Grand Finale]] of ''WesternAnimation/{{Amphibia}}'', [[spoiler: the [[FinalBattle Final Battle]] occurs [[AstralFinale in space]] with the girls using their [[SuperMode Calamity Forms]] to fight against [[BigBad The Core]] in order to prevent it from [[ColonyDrop crashing into Amphibia]], however, the girls aren't able to stop it, and when all hope seems lost, Anne decides to pull a [[HeroicSacrifice Heroic Sacrifice]] by taking all the powers of the [[MacGuffin Calamity Gems]] by herself to destroy The Core, this removes Marcy and Sasha's powers, but for some reason they are both able to still breathe in space before being sent back to the planet. Sprig then flies up to space with [[RobotBuddy Frobo's]] help to try to convince Anne to don't sacrifice herself, and he is also able to talk and breathe normally.]]normally]].



* The kids in ''WesternAnimation/JimmyNeutronBoyGenius'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheAdventuresOfJimmyNeutronBoyGenius'' pull this off. There is an explanation, but [[TheUnReveal Carl's singing]] [[TrollingCreator drowns it out]]. When interviewed about this the animators said that they decided that spacesuits would interfere with the expressions of the characters, so that InSpaceEveryoneCanSeeYourFace.



* Used frequently in ''WesternAnimation/SuperFriends''.While usually only Superman went into space without any breathing equipment, the other Super-Friends were able to survive with just fishbowl helmets. Oh, and [[SpaceIsNoisy Space was Noisy]].

to:

* Used frequently in ''WesternAnimation/SuperFriends''. While usually only Superman went into space without any breathing equipment, the other Super-Friends were able to survive with just fishbowl helmets. Oh, and [[SpaceIsNoisy Space was Noisy]].

Added: 289

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For the most part, ''Series/{{Farscape}}'' manages to avoid this trope, the exception being in the mini-arc "Look At The Princess", where John Crichton manages to hold his breath long enough to float from one craft to another. Even though the air pressure will rupture your lungs, that's why you ''don't'' hold your breath in a vacuum, though that's the least of that scene's problems with science . . .

to:

* For the most part, ''Series/{{Farscape}}'' manages to avoid this trope, the exception being in the mini-arc "Look At The Princess", where John Crichton manages to hold his breath long enough to float from one craft to another. Even though the air pressure will rupture your lungs, that's why you ''don't'' hold your breath in a vacuum, though that's the least of that scene's problems with science . . .science...


Added DiffLines:

* ''WebAnimation/ASDFMovie'': Desmond the Moon Bear. He's not native to the moon, even asking how he got there in the first appearance, yet talks and breathes with no issue. He's dead in his second appearance, but WordOfGod is he was killed by some unseen creature rather than lack of air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the sci-fi series ''Akiko'', this is handwaved hilariously when the eponymous character takes her first trip into space in a roofless shuttle--there's ''plenty'' of air in space!

to:

* In the sci-fi series ''Akiko'', ''Literature/{{Akiko}}'', this is handwaved hilariously when the eponymous character takes her first trip into space in a roofless shuttle--there's ''plenty'' of air in space!



%%* '''Unsure - probably a subversion''' Barrington Baley's The Garments of Caean some of heroes (like Alexei Verednyev and his girlfriend Lana Armasova) just live in space. They know they can. [[spoiler:They are colonists who wear their advanced spacesuits/miniships their whole live. Their cyborg opponents also can do that but don't need suits and looks mostly human. He thought that members of research expeditions are cyborgs because of how they look and because they tried to extract him from the suit.]]

to:

%%* '''Unsure - probably a subversion''' Barrington Baley's The Garments of Caean Literature/TheGarmentsOfCaean some of heroes (like Alexei Verednyev and his girlfriend Lana Armasova) just live in space. They know they can. [[spoiler:They are colonists who wear their advanced spacesuits/miniships their whole live. Their cyborg opponents also can do that but don't need suits and looks mostly human. He thought that members of research expeditions are cyborgs because of how they look and because they tried to extract him from the suit.]]



* In the ''Kemlo'' series by Creator/ReginaldAlecMartin, anyone born in space (i.e. actually in the vacuum of space itself, not merely on board a spaceship or station) can somehow "breathe" in space. Even for a pulpy children’s science fiction book series from TheFifties, this strains the reader's credulity to breaking point.

to:

* In the ''Kemlo'' ''Literature/{{Kemlo}}'' series by Creator/ReginaldAlecMartin, anyone born in space (i.e. actually in the vacuum of space itself, not merely on board a spaceship or station) can somehow "breathe" in space. Even for a pulpy children’s science fiction book series from TheFifties, this strains the reader's credulity to breaking point.

Top