When you encounter a new type of enemy in cinematic video games, it is often introduced in some sort of context that justifies its existence. After that point however, designers may continue to use that type of enemy in regular rotation even once you've entered places where its presence doesn't make sense, or you may continue to encounter that enemy in quantities far beyond what its origin story would seem to explain.
and Degraded Boss
are often cases of this.
Compare Giant Space Flea from Nowhere
, which is when they come from nowhere with no context from the get-go. This is the enemy equivalent of a Voodoo Shark
, where the explanation doesn't serve to explain how there are so many of them all over the place. Contrast Underground Monkey
for when enemies are recycled, but come in a slight variation for a given environment.
Games that do not attempt to provide fictional justification for their enemy designs are immune to this trope.
- Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon has the Carnivorous Plants that initially show up in the gardening themed Haunted Towers with other plant enemies, and then somehow show up in the final mansion's kitchen in a cupboard (along with the more reasonable Jungle Exhibit).
- Hyrule Warriors has an adventure through several eras in the Zelda universe. The enemies are appropriate to each: Bokoblins in the present and Skyward Sword, Bulblins in the Twilight Princess era, Stalchildren in the Ocarina of Time era. Also, Gorons on death mountain. There are also appropriate bosses: the Twilight Princess era has Argorok, while the Skyward Sword era has The Imprisoned, who was hounding the Sacred grounds at the time. Adventure mode throws this out the window, making you side with any of the enemies while fighting against any other, in any of the settings, and fight any of the bosses, sometimes more than one of the same one which is odd for The Imprisoned especially as The Imprisoned is one singular creature.
- Kingdom Hearts: Any of the Nobody Elite Mooks from Kingdom Hearts II eventually becomes this once their respective Organization XIII leaders are defeated. While it makes sense for them to show up in the final dungeon by themselves (as it is supposed to be their homeworld), they can still show up in the regular worlds for no particular reason, usually in the area you first find them.
- In the first level of Ninja Gaiden on Xbox, Murai sends his own, novice mooks at you in normal mode. From hard mode on, though, the same level makes you fight Black Spider Ninja... which are supposed to be enemies of Murai and have no reason to obey him whatsoever. Similarly, in hard mode you will often fight fiends and Black Spider Ninja altogether, even though these fiends are supposed to fight the Ninja, not help them.
- In Final Fantasy VI, there's the Veldt, which contains every enemy you previously encountered (to allow obtaining their skills in a specific form of Power Copying done by the characer Gau). This includes soldiers, elite soldiers, and enemies said by the story to be already extinct. Some bosses also appear in the Veldt, such as the Senior Behemoth and the White/Holy Dragon.
- The Mole Playing Rough. They first appear in the Lilliput Steps, an underground cave, where they're a decent foe (oh, and the boss there is a giant mole, so there's a mole theme in that cave). However, for same reason, the designers put some specific points (to be exact, in the Dusty Dunes Desert, Summers Beach and the Deep Darkness) around the game where one of them always spawns if you walk around there. Not only are they incredibly weak by that point, but those are places you wouldn't expect to find a mole.
- Another famous example is the Mad Ducks (an enemy encountered back in Winters) behind the store in Saturn Valley. Even stranger is the fact that they are in an area that you can't reach unless you exploit a glitch.
- Mad Ducks also appear in the underground tunnels in Dusty Dunes Desert. They're incredibly weak enemies at that point (to the point that, to be able to provide a bit of challenge, they spawn there in absurdly high numbers), and it also makes one wonder what a duck is doing in a desert cave.
- Talah Rama's cave in Dusty Dunes Desert is for some reason populated by enemies by found back in the Milky Well Cave. Not only are they weak at that point, they'll also run away from you if you've already defeated Trillionage Sprout (which most likely you'll have done by that point).
- The area between Threed and Dusty Dunes Desert will sometimes have New Age Retro Hippies, enemies encountered back in Twoson. They're also on a high ledge, which your party cannot reach. note
- The Dungeon Man is full of these. His first floor contains enemies that were in the Fourside Department Store. The dead ends on his second floor contains enemies from Moonside, an area you can only enter once. His third floor contains a "monster zoo," which invokes this trope.
- Super Robot Wars does this for some Monster of the Week series: Formerly one-off enemies suddenly appear in droves. Can be jarring for series such as GaoGaiGar where the monsters were transformed humans and their looks were based on their personality and their environment.
- Sailor Moon: Another Story uses as Random Encounters monsters that were originally monsters of the week in the show. The monsters in the show were either transformed people or transformed objects, so like in the Super Robot Wars example it doesn't make sense that there would be armies of them.
- Subverted in the Rainbow Shell quest in Chrono Trigger. It seems really strange to be fighting Naga-ettes and Gnashers, enemies that appeared in the 600 A.D. Cathedral at the very beginning of the game. That is until you fight the boss, Yakra XIII, who is the descendant of the boss of the Cathedral.
- There's also the enemies on the way to the Rainbow Shell. The area is filled with stronger palate-swapped versions of enemies you fought in the prehistoric era. Like above, this is justified by the area, Giant's Claw, actually being the millions years old ruins of the prehistoric Tyrano Lair.
- In Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, Goombas, as per the norm, are the earliest and weakest enemies in the game. Yet for some reason, they reappear in Riverside Station, a late-game dungeon. This is purely a game play instance, as their isn't really any reason in the story for them not to be around.
- Can happen in Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate. Each area has their own monsters, and variants made to fit other areas, and otherwise the areas they appear in fit their habitat. Later in the game however, almost every enemy can appear on the tropical Deserted Island though free hunting at night, even if it doesn't make sense. One example would be Brachydios, a volcanic monster who typically avoids water since it dilutes its blast slime walking around near the beach, which makes it easy to get rid of Blastblight by rolling around in water, something that normally can't be done in the areas you normally fight him in.
Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game
- A lesser-known example is the electricity-shooting skeletons in Niel Manke's Half-Life mod They Hunger. The first one is encountered in a laboratory where it is brought to life by being electrocuted, which does much to explain why it attacks by zapping you with bolts of lightning. But then you continue to encounter electric skeletons for the rest of the game, all over the place, even though it's impossible to think that every instance of this enemy could have been created in the same way.
- In Half-Life 2, Headcrabs appear at first mostly in places where the Combine have specifically used them as a biological weapon, and they're usually accompanied by the remains of their artillery shell cages. After the Ravenholm level however, they become more-or-less just Goddamned Bats ready to pop out of any vaguely abandoned area.
- When you add up all the bodies, the extensive bloodstains, the skeletons, the zombies and the Lost Souls you fight in Doom 3, they seem to outnumber the human population in an area quite a bit.
- Averted in Metro 2033. Librarians remain in the Lenin Library, Demons are exclusive to open spaces, Nosalises don't leave the tunnels, Watchmen are only seen on the surface, Lurkers are always seen near their burrows, and Dark Ones aren't encountered as normal gameplay enemies at all. Last Light mixes things up a bit, giving us Watchmen in the tunnels and Nosalises on the surface, but there's a good reason for each: the Watchmen only enter the tunnels in an area where the ceiling is breached, and the Nosalises inhabit a railway bridge that's connected to the Metro and is a largely enclosed space not unlike the tunnels.
- Some Killing Floor maps evoke this, notably Suburbia, which takes place in a small American town thousands of miles from the Horzine labs. Since the specimens aren't plague-type zombies and have no way of infecting others, this means that hundreds of them somehow crossed the Atlantic Ocean. This becomes even more confusing when the Patriarch appears, since it essentially means that all of the specimens somehow crossed the ocean.
- In Borderlands, mutant bandits came about when they were exposed to the Vault Key (or where it was found) in Headstone Mine (Sledge's base). They soon end up everywhere.
- World of Warcraft: Rockflayers are creatures natives of Draenor, but somehow, they can also be found in Deepholme, the Elemental Plane of another world.
- In a bizarre reversal of this trope, they can't be found on past/alternate timeline Draenor players can visit, only on the present day/main timeline world of Outland. The game even pokes fun at this discrepancy with a Garrison Mission to Rockflayer Island. All your followers find is a rock.
- While not location-specific, something similar to this arises in Star Wars: The Old Republic as an element of Gameplay and Story Segregation. In several situations, your character can make peace or even ally with the leaders of a previously hostile group, only for the mooks belonging to that group to continue attacking you on sight.
- Viruses in the entire Super Mario Bros. series. In their first appearance they appear as enemies in Dr. Mario, which makes sense. In Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga, they appear in an abandoned university laboratory, which makes sense. In Mario & Luigi: Dream Team? They appear EVERYWHERE. Deserts, the beach, caves, in town, on an icy mountain... And in groups of 16 at a time to boot (now granted, viruses are technically omnipresent in nature, but still...).
- Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels randomly places enemies from the original game in unlikely locations like Bloopers (squid-like monsters) on the ground and earth mooks underwater. Later games avert this.
- The infamous Metools from the Mega Man (Classic) games. In the original Mega Man game the little hard hat guys appeared only on Guts Man's stage, which had the look of a quarry/construction site. (Guts Man himself appears to wear a hard hat) however they have since appeared in every Mega Man game on multiple levels, in massive numbers, and even throughout most sequel series, to the point that they are the most common enemy encountered. That said, there are a handful of variants who conform to the theme of a boss's stage.
- Mega Man X has the Dig Labour/Degraver, miner mavericks who attack with pick-axes and wear hard-hats. It makes perfect sense for them to appear in the stage of Armored Armadillo who runs a mining operation, but not in Flame Mammoth's stage, which is primarily a disposal site. It also has the abovementioned Metool from the Classic series, who appears in the same situations as the Degraver, and more, making it even more of an example of this trope.
- Spyro: Year of the Dragon has the octopus enemies you found in Seashell Shore showing up later in Crystal Islands, a place where every other Mook is made of crystal.
- In most strategy games, upgrading a unit will cause all units of that type to instantly improve. In Age of Empires, outposts not visited in thousands of in-game years can suddenly replace their clubs with swords and their loincloths for suits of plate armour.
- Warcraft III: In one mission, Malfurion and Tyrande discover spiders that have grown to gigantic size when they came into contact with demonic corruption. However, there are many more giant spiders in the world, both in this game and in WoW, spiders that have never met any demons.
- Several of the Northrend stages feature blue dragons. But the backstory establishes that Deathwing killed all of the blue dragons, with the Aspect Malygos being the only one left. However, The War of the Ancients trilogy has the red dragon Krasus preserving a few blue dragon eggs after traveling back in time to the era they were originally wiped out in, providing a retroactive explanation for anyone who needs one.
- In Brütal Legend, it's possible to miss two Side Quests available during the campaign against General Lionwhyte and his glamed-up army. Since these quests assume you're still fighting him, coming back to complete them has you fighting Hair Metal units past a point in the story that they've all been wiped out.
- Dead Rising famously gives you the Zombie Genocider achievement for killing a number of zombies equal to the entire population of Wilamette. Even accounting for out-of-town visitors and the infection spreading, it seems rather unlikely that that many zombies would wind up in the mall. And they still keep coming.
- Silent Hill 2
- Pyramid Head is explicitly made from part of James' damaged psyche. Doesn't stop him from showing up in later games that have absolutely nothing to do with James.
- The Abstract Daddy is sprung from Angela's psyche. When it reappears as a Degraded Boss, Angela is nowhere to be found.
- The babies in Dead Space. You first encounter them in a prosthetics lab with babies growing in tubes all over the walls. Nice and creepy. But even though this lab is only a single room with maybe 50 baby tubes total, from that point on zombie babies are ubiquitous all over the ship and you fight at least a hundred of them in the game.
- Used as an actual plot point in Kid Icarus: Uprising, where enemies of various factions get copied in later chapters to fight alongside one another, despite them originally being hostile to each other.
Pit: So the Chaos Kin is copying Aurum enemies that are copies of the Forces of Nature.
Viridi: It makes you think, doesn't it?
Pit: No, not really. It's just weird.
Wide Open Sandbox
- Husks in Mass Effect 2 can fall into this, especially when you start wondering how many people there had to be on this single scientific expedition in order for there to be so many husks.
- Fallout 3 has Super Mutants, which appear far more numerous than their origins would suggest. Likewise, Raiders often seem to outnumber townspeople and wastelanders. Enclave Soldiers can also be encountered before they officially enter the plot, and after their bases are wiped out in Broken Steel. Aliens sometimes respawn on Mothership Zeta if you return, even though you cleared out the ship.
- In Fallout: New Vegas, Fiends and Powder Gangers continue to randomly spawn after you have killed their leaders and exterminated their strongholds. And even if you've killed Caesar, Vulpes, and the rest of his fort, and driven the Legion from their strongholds on the west side of the Colorado, leaving only the Legate's camp on the opposite end of Hoover Dam, Legionary Assassins keep spawning throughout the Wasteland every few days.
- In Fallout 4, Brotherhood of Steel Vertibirds still occasionally appear after you have destroyed the Prydwen airship.
- This applies to a lot of the gangs in the Grand Theft Auto series. The story missions could have you killing hundreds of their members, murdering all of their bosses and destroying all of their businesses, but they'll still be walking around the map ready to come after you if you cross their paths. The exceptions to this are the Ballas and Vegos in San Andreas, who will stop spawning if you take over all of their territories, and the Purple Nines in III (Though a glitch about that will prevent them from spawning in future games if you don't take the right precautions).
- In Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin the Nest Of Evil has both unique enemies and enemies that appeared elsewhere in the game. They're not exactly out of place however. This trope comes into play with one of the final rooms, which contains two of The Creature, which is also known as Frankenstein's Monster. Earlier on he's a boss with an introductory cutscene of his body getting activated in a mad scientist's laboratory, now he's a Dual Boss In Mook Clothing with no explanation of what he's doing there and how there could possibly be two of him.