|
Narrative
|
From YKTTW
Travis Wells: Removed one of the two entries for Snakes On A Plane. Ununnilium: Thanks! BTW, we usually put new stuff at the bottom of discussion pages. jaimeastorga2000: Doesn't Ender's Game count as a subversion? dirty lies Added a *brief* note on the spectrum of the trope. Specifically, it ranges from justified, plausible plot point, to much more ludicrous (which is often played for laughs.) The model airplane engineer who designed the new airplane in (the original) "Flight of the Phoenix" would indeed have the necessary engineering knowledge to do so- and the character knows it. His comrades are far less sure, and the dissonance becomes a significant plot point. Compare that to the guy in "Snakes on a Plane" who is able to land a BOEING 747 JUMBO-JET because he played an arcade-style PSP GAME- which is clearly as far from a simulator program as you can get, and patently ludicrous. (OF course, this same movie also featured muthafuggin snakes on a muthafuggin plane, so...) My point is, this trope has quite a range of applications to it- from very serious plot point to one-liner jokes (Playstation!) and rather implausible handwaves. Whether or not this warrants a note in the trope description proper, I don't know- it depends on whether or not the first, (justified) use of the trope is at all common enough to warrant it's observation, or if it's entirely outside the description of the trope, and thus subversions. Andy Waltfeld: How'd this wind up becoming a Contributor Page? Also, didn't we have a picture at one point? Mr Death: Edited the Snakes On A Plane example. It would be a Justified Trope if he'd been shown playing a realistic flight simulator, not a PSP game (and as far as I know, there's no Boeing 747 simulator on the PSP). But because they did (sort of) set it up, it's definitely Chekhovs Gun. Caswin: He was playing the PSP on the plane itself, of course... but didn't he mention something else? I know he said he'd logged hours upon hours on something, and I remember watching and thinking, "Alright, this could almost believably work..." Or did I just fabricate a line out of a desire to somehow justify what I was seeing? Fire Walk: Hmmm, I've just seen the Last Starfighter "videogames as space pilot recruitment" plot show up in Batman Beyond, and was wondering if it's worth splitting. Partly because it's explicitly justified, and partly because it has a different role in the story to the normal "Of course I can fly a plane, I've played Flight Sims" things. Is it worth a different trope? |
