Marge: (looking out the window to the front lawn) There's just something about flying a kite at night that's so unwholesome.They look sweet, innocent, even angelic, but there's something not quite right about them. They're too calm, too knowing. They aren't really children any longer, not at heart. Children should be innocent and in need of adult protection. By inverting this, the trope arouses deep-rooted fears. The Creepy Child might not be physically dangerous, but their profound unnaturalness is just as chilling. Creepy children are frequently female, and often Emotionless Girls. They can be, among other things, a Robot Girl, an Oracular Urchin, a changeling, a Waif Prophet, or Evil. As prophets, they emanate otherworldliness; as heroes, they may elicit distrust and contempt from the rest of The Team sans the one female who wants to be surrogate mother, and as villains they remain cute even while the bodies pile up around them. They usually have an Ironic Nursery Tune theme. May be holding a Creepy Doll. A girl who is a Woman in White is usually the Creepy Child. If a Creepy Child is shown drawing, it will usually be a Nightmare Fuel Coloring Book. Compare and contrast Psychopathic Manchild and the usually much more proactive and physically dangerous Enfant Terrible. See also Undead Child and Ambiguous Innocence. Also compare Creepy Cute.
Bart: (turns head to the window. In monotone with lidded eyes and an eerie smile) Hello, mother dear.
Bart: (turns head to the window. In monotone with lidded eyes and an eerie smile) Hello, mother dear.
open/close all folders
- One cellphone commercial played with this trope, featuring loads of Creepy Children (including a pair of white-kneesocks-wearing twin girls sing-songing, "We want a cellphone"). It ended with a message to parents that they shouldn't be scared to buy cellphones for their kids, although if you had kids like that, wouldn't you be wary about giving them what they want?
- The early "Dead Zone" ads for Verizon featured pairs of creepy siblings (two brothers in dress attire and identical twin girls wearing blue dresses).
- An ad for Australian real estate agent L.J. Hooker ended with a creepy girl's gratitude "Thank you, Mr. Hooker". The really scary part was, she probably wasn't meant to be creepy.
- The "Double Life" PlayStation advert, back in the late 90s/early 2000s featured a memorably creepy, world-conquering, Scottish child of indeterminate gender. Check it out, 43 seconds in.
- This TV spot for the 2006 Fantasia Film Festival features a creepy little girl.
- This nerf gun commercial featuring a young Devon Sawa.
- The Cuckoo from the Sandman arc "A Game of You," arch-enemy of the Narnia-like dream-fantasy "Land". Despite her name (and true nature), she mostly appears in the form of a young, pig-tailed, freckled blonde girl — in fact, the childhood form of Barbie, the arc's protagonist.
- Lenore from Lenore the Cute Little Dead Girl.
- Innocence (a.k.a. the Child) is part of a malevolent and extremely powerful living tarot arcanum called The Basanos in the Lucifer comic book. She takes the form of a young, barefoot blonde girl and appears most often as their spokesperson. Her power is the ability to make people "see the world with fresh eyes" - that is, in a harsh light without illusions, delusions, or rose-colored glasses. As an added bonus, this power is exhibited as she walks down a seedy avenue in Amsterdam's Red Light district, causing everyone from hookers to cops to street people to come subtly repulsed at what they're doing.
- 30 Days of Night had a little girl vampire.
- Layla Miller of Marvel Comics' X-Factor. Also an Oracular Urchin. Not anymore, though, since she underwent a Plot-Relevant Age-Up.
- Valeria "Val" Richards, daughter of Reed Richards. She has genius level intelligence at just 2 years old.
- Ariel Chylde in Darkchylde isn't stoic and her voice isn't a harsh monotone. Adults find her creepy because at roughly 12 years old she's smarter than most of them and she reacts to everything with open hostility and condescension.
- Cassie Hack battles the Undead Slasher Movie Serial Killer who Kills People In Dreams variety in Hack/Slash.
- In some incarnations, Batman, particularly after his parents' death. As an adult, he is also sometimes confronted by creepy children who killed their parents.
- And Damian Wayne, who first appears around age eight and attempts to murder the current Robin so he can take his place. A result of being raised by crazy ninjas, and also possibly the combination of Al Ghul and Wayne genes. Living with Bruce helped somewhat, but it's actually Dick Grayson who's really helped him into a solid Heel–Face Turn.
- Talia accepted this and started to work on a replacement, eerily telling Damian "He'll be ten years younger than you when he's born" So, taking the above into account, when Damian hits 18, there's going to be trouble (or sooner, since there might be a Plot-Relevant Age-Up for the clone).
- Little Keiko in Usagi Yojimbo. Her only relative was robbed and killed by bandits, and they were about to kill her too when Jei, the book's most stubbornly recurring villain, appeared, declared them to be "evil" and killed them. Keiko almost got the same treatment, but he randomly decided she wasn't evil. She's been traveling with him since then, calling him "uncle", and her ability to remain cheerful through massive bloodbaths is chilling.
- What's also chilling that if this is a result of Jei's evil spirit suppressing her emotional development, the resulting emotional whiplash that is bound to happen if and when that suppression is lifted might likely traumatize her into insanity.
- The X-Wing Series arc "The Warrior Princess" has Plourr flash back to her brother, Harran, when they were both children. Very definitely Royally Screwed Up, he was sociopathic, and the flashback shows him torturing an animal. Then Darth Vader, on a visit, used mental manipulation to transform his hot-blooded sadism into something cold and calculating. When a faction of nobles slaughtered Harran's family and one sister escaped, he tried to stop her so he could watch her die. She killed him and left his body to be eaten by scavengers. That's how she knows that the revolutionary calling himself Harran can't be her brother.
- Fables has recently introduced us to the Literals and the Genres. Among the Genres, Horror is represented by a little blond girl in a pink dress.
- The child incarnation of X-Men foe Apocalypse.
- Gail Simone's run on Wonder Woman had the Crows, five immortal beings disguised as schoolchildren who brew up paranoia and hatred in D.C. both naturally (through the distribution of hate literature and phony terrorist threats) and supernaturally (through a Hate Plague) as revenge against Diana for the death of their father, Ares.
- Grendel has Stacy Palumbo, the adoptive daughter of Hunter Rose, who eventually learns that he murdered her real parents and thus manipulates him into a final confrontation with Argent, in a plan that includes murdering her governess to prevent her from interfering.
- This is what Kiden Nixon thinks about X-23 in NYX. Actually, everyone in the series finds her unnerving.
- Klara Prast of the Runaways, normally a Moe with a powerful Green Thumb, was suddenly transformed into a creepy child after a particularly traumatic accident during the last arc. While in creepy-child mode, she damn near destroyed the Runaways' house by summoning a small forest worth of vines and dispatched an entire squad of heavily-armed men. The latter feat was made even more disturbing by the fact that she had a completely blank expression while doing it.
- Emily the Strange, a 13 year old goth girl with her own vocabulary of swear words, prefers rainy days and night time to daylight, and has an endless list of interests and hobbies that range from the silly to borderline gruesome. And the people she gets along with the best? Her four pet cats.
- In the Neil Gaiman iteration of The Eternals, the childlike Eternal Sprite is reimagined as a Teen Idol who also deliberately depowered the Eternals and wiped their memories, and who is aiding the Deviants in their efforts to awaken the Dreaming Celestial, all because the Celestials made him incapable of physically aging past age 11.
- In Violine, some characters consider Violine is this because of her staring at them intently (she does this to read their minds).
- Rachel Rising, an Urban Fantasy/horror comic, has Zoe, a cute little 10 year old who carries out murders with chilling skill and no shred of remorse. It's hard to say if The Reveal that she's spent almost 50 years as the host of a Fallen Angel/demon that wants to destroy creation and eventually use Zoe to be the mother of his version of the Anti Christ makes her more or less creepy.
- Crossed has a few of these. The first encountered are the Kindergarteners in Volume 1, who are uninfected, but still set traps for people who are passing through the town where they're holed up.
- Any children who become or are born as Crossed are creepy by default, including Patrick in Volume 1 and the (mostly unseen) children of the breeding Crossed in the +100 arc.
- A particularly disturbing possibility gets brought up when discussing rumors about the "Super Crossed", humans who turn but retain some of their humanity due to brain abnormalities (or in one case, being so evil that turning really didn't change much). Apparently, one of them living in Montreal is a child who had autism before C-Day.
- Jordan Borchardt of Revival is as emotionally distant as any of the other revivers but it hits harder since she's a tween girl. Worse, she takes her mother's disappointment at not seeing God during her death too literally and slices off her own eyelids. She is unique among revivers in that her soul has not only been separated, it's destroyed. This allows her to imprison someone else's soul within herself, Horrifying the Horror.
- In the The Legend of Zelda Fanfiction Free as the Wind (On the Recommendation page), Toon Link, of all Links, suddenly switches between Creepy Child and Cheerful Child on many occasions, which almost never fails to shock the other characters around him (including two other Links.) Him switching back into Cheerful Child-mode can sometime be really relieving, since his Creepy Child-persona's knowingness is very unsettling at times.
"Everybody's going to die. Just not now."
- Child of the Storm has Diana, whose empathic abilities make her uncomfortably knowing, which along with her purposefully calm demeanour, frequently creeps people out, until they get to know her at least.
- Harry himself, being thirteen, can occasionally come off as this. His demeanour during his apology/warning to the Ravenclaw Quidditch team following their collective discharge from St. Mungos (he'd put them there via creative flying and use of bludgers because of their bullying of Luna Lovegood) is considered by the team to be a) unsettling, b) slightly inhuman. He's also known to have intuitively mastered wandless fire magic, occasionally literally Playing with Fire, be a powerful psychic, have intermittent Super Strength and have a strange 'double voice', which he can use at will and is intimidating enough that it shuts up the Weasley Twins without so much as a smart remark. Being followed around by the wolves of Odin and, occasionally, his ravens, only exacerbates this. And then there's the frequent comparisons to Magneto, the warnings that he could just as easily go from a hero to becoming something horrific. Notably, he's aware of all of these and their effect. Except for Freki and Geri, who he treats like giant pet dogs, and the ravens, who he likes, they freak him out just as much as they do everyone else. That said, he isn't shy of using them and his growing reputation to his advantage.
- Sleepless contains several examples. The first installment has Diamond Tiara a nine-year-old serial killer with insomnia, and a couple of residents of mental clinic for foals in Trottingham. The third story in the series, Manehattan Blues adds White Dove who doesn't hesitate to burn a warehouse with her classmate inside. Children of Equestria gives us also Diamond Tiara's hallucinations of Silver Spoon and Curtain Call.
- In Chapter 22 of a Naruto Fanfic, Naruto: Altered History, when Naruto meets Kyuubi.
"Oh fuck," Naruto muttered, a chill sweeping through. He knew now, beyond any doubt, that he was in for it, only the most evil of demons pretended to be little girls. It was a fact of nature, the more innocent looking the little girl, the more evil the demon. This girl was the picture of innocence, which meant Naruto now faced a majorly gruesome end.
- In a relatively popular Percy Jackson and the Olympians fanfiction known as Whispers in the Dark, the main character Taylor definitely qualifies. She's 4, and she knows more curse words than the average 10-year-old. Let that sink in for a minute.
- A chapter of Toy Hammer gives us Emma, a creepy kid who appears and disappears out of nowhere, and gives the main character nosebleeds.
- Though she's not so creepy any more because she's actually one of the Emperor of Mankind's reincarnations.
- In the Firefly fanfic Forward, we have Inducer One-One-Nine, who becomes a retroactively creepy child when we discover it's Katie.
- Fiona from Kira Is Justice is this, complete with bold dialogue.
- In Cori Falls's fanfiction Where Angels Dare to Tread, baby!James was supposed to come as Wise Beyond His Six Months, but looks like this instead. Seriously, which baby deliberately cries in his christening and then looks all "I did it to screw my parents's plans for me!"?
- So very many Super!Harry Harry Potter fanfics, a result of trying to get him off to a good fixit start while following the books' timeline. Often due to time travel, but also to various weird upbringings and instances of becoming a Child Prodigy. Both lampshaded and not.
- "Escape From Never Never Land", a Harry Potter fic, has a sort of subversion. On the surface she's a creepy child. But really she's really 14, trapped in the body of a child by magic which makes it worse....
- Cream is seen as one in Always Having Juice, having a difficult time discerning the real from the imaginary due to her special power, and being diagnosed as mentally ill before being adopted by Vector.
- Both Gabrielle and Chaos in the Tamers Forever Series, especially the first one.
- It Sucks to Be Weegie! has Lucas. It says something when quoting lyrics from Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street isn't out of character for him.
- The daughter of Harry Potter and the Winter Queen in The Denarian Knight. When they first meet roughly a year after her conception (at which point she's seven or eight due to the differing passage of time in the faery realm) she says "Hello father" in the most deadpan voice ever and his response is "Okay, that's not creepy at all."
- Quetzalcoatl in the Horseshoes and Hand Grenades story, A Month of Sundays who wants to find 'best friends' and think that the best thing about them is that they share...blood. To amp up the creepiness, he's a Serpent in a contract with Ankh and his human form is a child version of Ankh. The creepiness gets toned down after Jun gives him a Tastes Like Friendship moment and he becomes a shy, scared boy with abandonment issues.
- Taya in Diaries of a Madman, whose lack of understanding of certain social conventions can make her come across as very creepy at times.
- Ongetsu, Kurosaki Karin's zanpakuto spirit in Phases of the Moon and all its sequels and spin-offs, is this combined with Bratty Half-Pint and Creepy Doll. It doesn't help that he manifests as a Sinister Scythe that happens to be Anti-Magic. The doll is a stuffed black rabbit that Karin owned before her mother died, and represents her inner weakness and repressed emotions.
- From Gensokyo 20XX, Reimu seems to be developing shades of this. Aside from the mental illness, she is very unnerving for anyone who doesn't understand how sweet she can be but is unusually and very fatalistic for a child, along with easily and quickly accepting cruelty, along with giving it when she sees fit to. What's more to this is that a group of kitsune wanted to kill her for reasons unsaid and people tend direct their hostility to her.
- The Gravity Falls Transcendence AU Fan Verse is full of this trope, played in multiple different ways. Dipper gets this reaction from others (and sometimes from himself) because he's been turned into a demon, Mabel and later her children because they hang out with demon!Dipper. Then there are the assorted children trying to make deals with Dipper (some of which manage to creep him out).
- [spoiler:Bill's] reincarnations. Toby, a sweetheart with some...interesting personality quirks such as calling pain "funny feelings", is a good example of one. This is often subverted though.
- Tom in Tom Riddle's Schooldays. Other characters find him charming and friendly, but the way he calmly considers murder…
- Tom, Bellatrix and Hermione in Fall Back Nineteen Forty. Tom in particular does things that would nauseate many adults, and doesn't see anything wrong with them.
- Thousand Shinji: Shinji, Asuka and Rei can look like three traumatized but average fourteen-year-old kids... because they're hiding that they're borderline psychopaths. Rei's apartment is a trash-filled shrine to rot and decay, Shinji manipulates people for shits and giggles, Asuka is a murderous vigilante, and any of them is perfectly willing to kill whoever gets in their way.
Films – Animation
- Coraline: The Ghost Children. Especially the one with her mouth frozen open in an expression of perpetual horror. Depending on your point of view, the other Wybie could qualify in the beginning. There's just something creepy about his constant smile.
- Lilo from Lilo & Stitch. She says things like "My friends need to be punished" in a monotone while placing spoons decorated as her Hula Halau-mates from a previous scene in a pickle jar and watching them, all while sitting next to a book titled "Practical Voodoo". She gets better, this being a Disney movie. Completely justified, considering that the movie takes place shortly after her parents are killed in a car crash and this is her way of coping with the loss.
- ParaNorman plays with this trope quite a bit. It's deconstructed throughout the film, peaking at adults willing to kill children because they're terrified of them. But then it's reconstructed.
- Sid in Toy Story.
- Trolls: There's a wall-eyed child Troll. For one thing, he likes watching his parents as they're sleeping.
- The video to Portishead's "All Mine" features an extremely unnerving little girl lipsyncing the song.
- Alice Cooper's song "Years Ago" is supposedly narrated by Steven, a lost child who only does monotone. the song is set to a species of Creepy Circus Music.
- Turn around, Briiight eyes!
- The music video to Avenged Sevenfold's "Nightmare" has a little blonde girl covered in blood and smiling while tossing a ball around which is also covered in blood.
- The video to The Prodigy's "Omen" features a creepy little girl playing a Xylophone to bookend the piece.
- The video to the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' Y Control features a small army of them. And they're armed.
- The little girl in the video for Skrillex's "First of the Year"  looks super-creepy but less scary than the usual because it's implied that she only lures child molesters into the abandoned car park to be killed by a demon she controls
- The album cover for They Might Be Giants' John Henry... You try looking at a girl staring blankly with a pickaxe in her hands and not have the jibblies...
- The music video by OOMPH! - "Augen Auf" features a birthday party where the Adults are innocent, but the Children are the ones with more devious intent.
- All of the children in the Vocaloid song "Circle You, Circle You". It comes off as more sad than anything when you realize that they are living in an Orphanage of Fear and have been horrifically experimented on in order for some Mad Scientists to (successfully) discover the secret to immortality. Said scientists would force the children to play the Japanese children's game "Kagome, Kagome" and then cut off a limb whenever they lost. The children play this game with wayward visitors even after the scientists are long dead, making the song a good case of horror all the same.
- "Kids With Guns" from Gorillaz' Demon Days.
- The girl on the album cover of Beautiful Freak by Eels.
- Wednesday Addams from The Addams Family, who's seen relaxing in the graveyard.
- The Magnus Archives: Agnes in "Burned Out". She stays that way into adulthood.
- The Wyatt Family used creepy children, most notably wearing sheep masks and brown cloaks, and having the children sing Christian hymns in a evil manner in several of their feuds, most notably with John Cena, Daniel Bryan and their girlfriends The Bella Twins. In several matches, children under the Wyatt Family's control have interfered in their matches against Cena and Bryan.
- In the radio adaptation of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Mr. Jekyll and Utterson are terrified at the expression of wrath in the young Henry's face, noting that the first time it happened was when he was two years old.
- The Old World of Darkness game Wraith: The Oblivion has "Striplings", a title given to Spectres (evil ghosts of Oblivion) who died before the age of ten and have corpuses (ghost bodies) resembling children. They exist among all of the Spectral castes (including at least one Malfean, the God-Kings of Oblivion) and form a society unto themselves. Other Spectres (even Malfeans) find them to be completely ungovernable and "creepy".
- The short-lived Immortal RPG featured the Peri, youngsters rescued from the Children's Crusade and made into immortals whose talent is to transform their bodies into weapons. The game's soundtrack had a bit with the sound of someone being stabbed, followed by a childish voice saying, "G'night!" and giggling. Worth noting is that Immortal has been revived as a free RPG, available here, although the Creepy Children described have been retconned into being just part of the Peri as of the current edition; many of the others are still Creepy Children, though, just from different origins.
- The card game Lunch Money features monochrome pictures of a young girl with nursery rhymes and other sayings having vaguely to do with the cards' intended effects. The artwork is fairly surreal, but becomes truly creepy when one considers that the cards represent the character's actions in a brutal street fight (i.e. Punches, Kicks, hitting a guy with a chain, etc.).
- In the French game In Nomine Satanis / Magna Veritas (the English version isn't a straight adaptation, more a remake) children of a demon and a human can be either normal kids, demons, or official creepy children. I love the illustration on that chapter in the rulebook.
- Voice of Demnogonis in Mutant Chronicles. Looks like a child, but in fact feeds on Life Energy.
- The predilections of the Deathlord known as the Dowager in Exalted...well...we'll let Things One Is Not Allowed To Do In Exalted spell it out.
Not all Abyssals are creepy little girls.
1. Except when the focus of the game is on the Dowager, that is.
2. Even then she Exalts creepy little boys too.
- In The Dreadful Secrets of Candlewick Manor, an expansion for the RPG Monsters and Other Childish Things, the players are creepy orphans with a mysterious past and terrible powers.
- Younger Fetch Children in Changeling: The Lost (the better of the two results of a Fetch successfully conceiving a baby) are explicitly mentioned as being slightly autistic, which gets really spooky when they start asking about a Changeling's Mien and open gates to the Hedge by being in the general area. They get better, though, and what's more, they're inherent weapons against the True Fae. Thus, if you see a Fetch Child, keep him alive, and breathe a sigh of relief that he wasn't a Fetch Spawn.
- Malifaux being Malifaux, this pops up several times. The main contenders are from the Neverborn: Candy is the Woe of Innocence Lost, who takes the form of a small girl with pigtails and a basket of (poisoned) sweets; Baby Kade is a wild eyed baby with a knife and a penchant for killer teddies. There are also more sympathetic examples, The Stolen are Lost Boys-style pre-teen boys lured into The Breach and used ruthlessly as meat shields or sources of power.
- At the Universal's Halloween Horror Nights event, one of their mascot characters, Cindy Caine, is the most famous example. Creepy children doing creepy things is a recurring haunted house and scarezone theme. However, due to the events' mature focus and casting requirements, the children are often portrayed by small/younger looking adults and usually wear masks or makeup.
- Ilya from Fate/stay night. Even when she's calling the hero 'Oniichan'. Especially when she's calling the hero 'Oniichan'.
- Higurashi: When They Cry:
- Higurashi provides the example of Rika Furude, the little miko girl who usually serves as a Deliberately Cute Child but knows way too much about what has happened and what will happen, and who also possesses a rather disturbing fixation with torture and mutilation. However, this later revealed to be because she's Really 700 Years Old in mentality and often on the receiving end of the aforementioned torture and mutilation due to a "Groundhog Day" Loop that only she and Hanyuu are aware of.
- All the members of that club are creepy at times, but the only other one in the right age category is Satoko, whose crazy moments tend to inspire more sympathy than fear.
- The sister series to Higurashi, Umineko: When They Cry, features Maria, the protagonist's nine year old cousin who has a creepy fixation with the occult and a tendency to start laughing whenever someone's murdered. She's much worse in the anime than in the original sound novels thanks to Flanderization. However, despite her strange behaviour she isn't actually evil, just very socially maladjusted, and her obsession with the occult is a way for her to cope with being bullied and her mother's abusive treatment.
- Inubushi Keiko, the mentally unstable serial killer from Remember11.
- Yuni also has his moments.
- fault milestone one has the original Rune, who gets pleasure, or something similar to pleasure as she's incapable of feeling emotion, from stabbing Marcos with a tree branch and mutilating small animals.
- The unnamed girl in the notorious Quicktime animation Play With Me goes beyond merely creepy and right into nightmarish.
- The kids from the Nickelodeon Clickamajigs game Black Licorice. In the game you're supposed to give them candy but you CAN'T give them black licorice because it causes them to transform into horrible grotesque monsters.
- Vendetta from Making Fiends is an elementary school kid who isolates herself from the rest of the class and makes fiends to sic on anyone who makes her mad...which is everyone. Her name should give you a clue. She also speaks in a weird, gravelly voice that has what is likely a Bulgarian accent.
- Little Joel from Lawn Justice seems innocent at first, but (he's actually responsible for all the destruction in the series). Mommy's little hero.
- Kari from Mari Kari Mari's undead twin sister who murders anyone who makes her upset.
- Mari is unnaturally cheerful, not letting the mysterious horrible deaths of everyone who's even slightly mean to her or the general hatred and contempt seemingly everyone holds for her ever get her down.
- Scary Go Round had a story arc based around such a character, known simply as "The Child", who is a harbinger of change and cause of discord. It turns out that The Child is being raised by someone who looks like Michael Jackson, turning it into a "Funny Aneurysm" Moment that meant the end of the comic had to be rewritten.
- Pandora is introduced in this form in El Goonish Shive. She's notably somewhat an aversion since her form changes to fit her mood, so she only looks like a child when she's being playful and mischevious. She's a lot creepier when she's pissed.
- Gunnerkrigg Court:
- Zimmy is introduced as an over-the-top creep: she's verbally combative towards the protagonists, her science fair entry is "an abomination" the reader never gets to see, she seems to have no visible eyes, and a body-snatching demon is afraid of her. This gets thrown on its head in a later chapter, when the revelation that she's been Blessed with Suck turns her into a sympathetic character who abuses people so they'll avoid her, for their own safety. Which gets flipped on its head again, with the revelation of how Zimmy treats her best friend and why.
- The main character, Antimony Carver, is an interesting example. The audience sees her when she's alone with her best friends, and thus sees that she's pretty well-adjusted for someone with such an unusual childhood (and the missing parents). Eventually, however, it's revealed that most of her classmates see her as a creep — because all they see of Annie is her impassive public facade and the fact that she never socializes with anyone besides Kat.
- Annie's father, Anthony, comes across much like Annie (in Flash Back): a normal guy to his best friend Donny, an emotionless robot-boy to everybody else. Apparently Annie looks like her mother and acts like her father. Must be torture for poor Eglamore.
- Jack, when he's under Demonic Possession.
- Chelsie Warner of Concession appears to be a cuddly anthropomorphic lamb-girl in a pink dress. On her first appearance, she stabs Artie Crowley in the eye with a crayon. Shortly thereafter, she has sex with him when he's too delirious to realise what he's doing. When he wakes up, he is horrified not only because of what he's done, but because "Chelsie is actually a boy." It's recently been revealed that Chelsie's hypersexual behaviour is related to a form of childhood bipolar disorder. She became significantly less creepy with proper medication and hormone treatment, after being adopted by the local (quite definitely non-paedophile) preacher. The Where Are They Now epilogue shows her in her late teens, fully transitioned, apparently recovered from her unfortunate past, and calling Father Tim "Dad".
- Charby from Charby the Vampirate is a perfect example of this.
- Mye, Hex, Tony, Claire and a large number of other characters qualify too.
- The Cyantian Chronicles: Quinn and Collin.
- Collin is a telepath who can walk through walls. He's experienced fear from come people due to this fact.
- Quinn is also a telepath. She can also walk through walls, teleport through another dimension that only she can reach. Quinn also has "Oulies" as friends, who are beings who are trapped between life and death in a realm that only Quinn can see. Quinn's invisible friends are real. And to top it all off, Quinn has been known to surprise/creep out Collin and the other members of her family.
- Erfworld: Parson Gotti suspects that Wanda was one of these. Before he learns that Erfworld has no children.
- In Sire, Susan causes Anna to appear to be one of these, hijacking her body, sitting quietly on her bed, and pulling all the hair out of its head, slowly counting each one off. Her parents promptly send the innocent Anna off for help.
- Shelly's conscience from Wapsi Square looks like one and she knows it.
- Memoria: "Harriet, I've never been afraid of a little girl before."
- In Underling, Lazarus, despite his horns and the company he has kept thus far, meets up with a truly creepy girl.
- In Sinfest, the agents of the secret sisterhood.
- Mua, the antagonist, from Kiss Wood. She's enslaved a huge amount of the population and she wants Sul to become another. Her introduction involves her showing one of the slave camps to Sul, watching a slave trip and a guard killing him (believing he's no longer able to work and therefore useless); she laughs at the sight and says there's an opening place for him.
- Aradia from Homestuck is probably the most "classic" example of this trope in the comic, but most of the trolls can fall under it due to some rather Troubling Un Childlike Behavior. Caliborn is also pretty disturbing.
- Disbelief the Shadow Child from Roommates is a barefoot creepy little boy wearing white (and having Ninja Prop Living Shadows). When he was introduced he basically KOd the cast with "I don't believe in you!"... when he returned he gleefully offered to do the same with their enemies. He is an Anthropomorphic Personification right out of the Time Abyss so he quite possibly invokes and exploits the trope intetionally.
- There are a few examples in Book Of Lies, but The Girl in the Tower takes the cake.
- Posey in The Sanity Circus is a Scarecrow who embodies pediaphobia - fear of dolls -, and so always has a creepy, flawless, eternally-young appearance. Even though she's an Eldritch Abomination and can consume people's souls with a smile.
- Ben Drowned: Ben thinks you shouldn't have put him here...
- Defection: The roaming Fey, often seen outside school gates handing out lollipops to passing children.
- SCP Foundation
- SCP-053 is a seemingly normal three-year-old girl. But there's a reason she's detained by the SCP Foundation. Something about her is deeply unsettling to adults and older children. Unsettling to the point that it induces violent rages, usually directed at her. Then, the moment they inflict any harm upon her, they die almost instantly and she regenerates rapidly from any injury they managed to inflict. Omnicidal Maniac SCP-682 seems to like her, though — and, as the label suggests, he holds a murderous hatred for all other living things.
- SCP-899 is a spatial phenomenon that kidnaps regular children and turns them into this. And they will kill you.
- All child SCP items are this trope. Strangely though very few of them are an outright Enfant Terrible, even 239, a Keter-class, isn't really evil, just naive and easily tricked into believing something is true/real and considering how her powers work.
- Katy Towell's Web Animation/Childrinrskary IS this trope. One of the reasons she drew the art and made the animations was because she thought children were creepy.
- A staple in Red Rover, in which the protagonist has to save the children of The Royce Institute For Exceptional Children - the ones still living. All of the children in question are peculiar in some manner, and deeply disturbed and/or disturbing.
- There Will Be Brawl: Ness and Lucas. And How!
- Survival of the Fittest v2 has Brandon Cuthbert, a 12 year old genius who skipped a few grades and is in highschool. Before getting sent to the island, he had a fascination with dissecting woodland creatures. And while on the island, he killed at least 3 different characters, including slicing one open after suffocating him to unconsciousness with an X-Box controller. It also happens in quite a few backstories for some characters.
- ASDF Movie. "I like trains."
- The Fear Mythos gives us the Cold Boy, who sits around, singing nursery rhymes. He'll cut you off from those you love, or he could just freeze you to death. Yet he never seems evil. Just creepy. Then there's the Unnamed Child, an Uncanny Valley child whose victims break away from their family and friends to pursue it after it leaves them.
- This little darling. Even if you don't read her (or should that be their?) backstory.
- MistBunny of Dark Dream Chronicle is a cute little girl who has tea parties and everything. She also just so happens to work for a certain tall, faceless gentleman. KarmA has stated that she really creeps him out.
- In LISDEAD He appears to be one
- Violetta. At times, she can fall into this, but she's harmless, and what mostly gets to people (namely Sunflower) is that she is of Transylvanian decent (her ancestors can be traced back to ancient Transylvania) and looks similar to an archetypal vampire, coupled with the fact that Toki adopted her from an orphanage in said region. Aside from some strange interests and the looks, she is a fairly normal kid.
- Parodied in this fake advertisement for a casting company specializing in kids like this.
- Tim from Marble Hornets when he was a kid. He would habitually go into bouts of panic and terror while he was being confined to the mental hospital, claiming that something was watching him even though his doctors could see nothing. He ran away from the hospital on multiple occasions in order to hide from it, ending up at Rosswood Park or in the maintenance tunnel from Entry #60. When the doctors locked him in his room after these escapes, he would scream and claw at the walls until he had to be sedated with his medication. In Entry #65, he appears to relapse briefly into this state.
- Parodied by CollegeHumor in "Horror Movie Daycare", which unites many of the creepy, satanic, possessed, ghost, and alien children of horror movies in the same daycare.
- Buzzfeed's "The Creepiest Things A Child Has Ever Said To A Parent".
- In Bum Reviews, Chester A. Bum about a child actress Dakota Fanning: "I ALWAYS KNEW THAT SHE WAS A VAMPIRE! SHE ACTED LIKE SHE WAS THIRTY YEARS OLD WHEN SHE WAS FIVE!"
- Cameron in The Babysitter. He speaks seldomly, won't respond to the babysitter or his mother, watches the same YouTube video over and over again, and has a nasty habit of showing up behind people. Additionally, when he somehow summons the host of the show and his giant teddy bear sidekick, both dripping blood and sporting Slasher Smile s, he has no reaction; in fact, he seems happy, even after his babysitter is killed before his eyes and it is implied his mother is next.
- Welcome to Night Vale has several, although people don't view all of them as creepy.
- The City Council sends messages to Cecil through various mute, empty-eyed children. Cecil complains that he's never sure what to do with them once they've delivered the message by whatever means they're using this time, and asks if anyone wants one, before noticing he's disappeared.
- When two boy scouts are going to receive the highest rank, Eternal Scout, hordes of creepy pale children appear and watch people silently. As the ceremony gets underway they attack and try to drag people away to whatever place they came from. Speaking of which, the boy scout ranks also include Blood Pact Scout, Dark Scout and Fear Scout, and include badges like Invisibility and Advanced Siege-Breaking Tactics.
- Tamika Flynn is 12, and emerges from the Nightvale Summer Reading Program with a book well above a 12 year old's reading level and the severed head of the Head Librarian - thus saving the children from whatever ghastly fate was in store for them at the hands of the librarians. She proceeds to read at a very high level while forming the children of the town into a resistance movement against Strexcrop while wearing the hand of a librarian around her neck to prove that she has already overcome the most fearsome of foes, and Cecil is completely on her side.
- From Killerbunnies, we have Visceraline, who this also an Enfant Terrible. Going by her profile, she is a child with a fairly sadistic disposition and sees other people as "dollies" (Read: Toys for her do as she will) and is speculated to have had something to do with her parents' disappearance.
- While she is creepy, Jeanne is an unclear case in that we don't know if she is actually a child.
- Twig has Sylvester, who's creepy in the sense that he enjoys picking out the psychological weaknesses of the adults around him and taking a sledgehammer to them, and Helen, who's creepy in that she doesn't actually have emotional reactions and is just faking them all the time with the skill of a Master Actor.
- Parodied in the Funny or Die sketch Scary Girl, which stars Chloe Moretz as a child actress called Enid Krysinski who, no matter what the role, always plays a Stringy-Haired Ghost Girl because that's what she's actually like. Her mother seems to find it adorable.
Enid's Mom: Enid's always been very theatrical.Enid: [creepy whisper] I've been in almost EVERY...school play.
[Cut to video of Enid's school production of Peter Pan]Peter Pan: Clap if you want Tinker Bell back. [sporadic clapping from audience] Tinker Bell...wherever you are...
[Enid as Tinker Bell pops up behind him, apparently out of the ground. Screams from the audience.]
- No Name Given, but the abused son in The Nostalgia Critic takes after his parents, burying Hyper alive, groping a Barbie doll and having fun at animal cruelty.