Literature: My Sister's Keeper
My Sister's Keeper
is a 2003 novel by Jodi Picoult
. Anna Fitzgerald has gone through countless surgeries, transfusions and shots by the age of thirteen. Is she sick? No. She's doing it for her older sister Kate, who has suffered from severe leukemia since the age of three. Anna was born to be a perfect match for Kate. Kate now needs a kidney and Anna decides she's had enough. So she sues her parents for medical emancipation. This book has a high Tear Jerker
warning, and is the 7th most challenged book in schools and libraries for 2009
. Made into a movie
starring Abigail Breslin
as Anna and Sofia Vassilieva as Kate in June 2009.
This book contains examples of:
- Abusive Parents: Sara is the emotional abuse type, though she isn't doing it because she hates Anna; rather, it's because her single-minded devotion to Kate blinds her to the needs of her other children. When Anna was five, Kate needed bone marrow from her so Sara had doctors restrain Anna while they extracted the bone marrow. Whenever Anna questions her, Sara always blackmails her saying "why won't you help your sister?" One of Kate's messages to Anna in the movie is "I'm sorry I let them hurt you", make of that what you will.
- The Alcoholic: Brian after Anna's death, although he gets better.
- Billy Needs An Organ
- Bittersweet Ending: The film version. Sick of watching her parents torture Anna just to keep her alive, Kate helps Anna win her lawsuit and lets herself die. Kate may be gone, but she dies at peace with herself, knowing Anna can finally live.
- The book version. Anna wins the lawsuit. On her way to the hospital to see Kate she is in a car accident that leaves her brain dead. Alexander decides her kidney should be donated to Kate which saves Kate's life. So Sara gets what she wanted - Kate gets to live - but it comes at the cost of her younger daughter's life, and there are no guarantees Kate will stay in remission.
- Book Ends: The film starts with Anna going to a lawyer then jumps back in time then moves forward again to end just after the court case.
- Composite Character: Aunt Kelly in the movie is a combination of Sara's sister and Julia in the book.
- Compressed Adaptation: The movie takes out entire plotlines (such as Jesse's pyromania) and characters.
- Diabolus Ex Machina: Ohhhhhhhhh yeah.
- Debate and Switch:Due to the Shocking Swerve, the moral dilemma is averted.
- Death by Adaptation: Kate in the movie takes the place of Anna.
- Designer Babies: Anna is probably a more realistic example of this trope.
- Downer Ending: The book ends with Anna dying in a car crash and her organs being harvested for Kate, while Sara gets her way yet again. The film changed this into a Bittersweet Ending/ Earn Your Happy Ending.
- Expository Hairstyle Change: In the present Sara's hair is long and straight. When it shows Kate, Anna and Jesse as children it is longer and curly. In the ending scenes it is cut short.
- Gender Flip: The judge presiding over Anna's case is male in the book, but played by Joan Cusack in the movie.
- Hair Reboot: Sara shaves her head to show support for Kate though the movie keeps changing timelines so two scenes later her hair is back to its original length.
- Heel-Face Turn: Campbell.
- The Hero Dies: Anna herself in the novel, while Kate dies in the movie.
- High School Sweethearts: Campbell and Julia.
- Ill Girl: Kate
- It's All About Me: Like many of Picoult's fictional mothers, Sara has this trait. For most of the book, she believes that Anna has filed the lawsuit to annoy her. She's genuinely surprised when Kate reveals how she actually feels, and her first thought when she is confronted with her daughter's fate — Anna's brain-dead, organ-harvested body is not "my poor baby" but "what do you call a parent who's lost a child?
- Knight Templar Parent: Sara, who both creates and blights Anna's life in order to save Kate, while dismissing anyone who isn't of any use in the pursuit of that goal. Including her own son.
- Littlest Cancer Patient
- Middle Child Syndrome: Inverted; Kate is the middle child of the family, and gets all of the attention because of her cancer.
- Never Trust a Trailer: The movie trailers looked to be a dramedy of accepting a sibling having possibly terminal cancer. Then the shock comes with the book synopsis.
- Parental Favoritism: There are countless examples. The mother, Sara, mainly cares about Kate and Kate only. She only cares about Anna because she can help Kate. Here are the more depressing examples.
- While pregnant with Anna, she hadn't even thought of a name, she was more happy with the thought that the baby would help Kate. It is only until the book progresses that Sara does learn to love the real Anna more.
- Kate needs more lymphocytes from Anna. The appointment falls during her friend's birthday party and Anna is allowed to stay for half of the party. As Sara is taking Anna to the car, she asks why she had to leave. Sara is so angry because "[her] sister is more important than cake and ice cream", that she tells Anna to stop acting like a five year old. Anna was five at the time.
- The oldest son Jesse is neglected after it is found out he is not a genetic match for Kate. Sara finds it hard to feel sorry when he, a 6 year old, gets his blood tested to see if he is a match for Kate. As a result he becomes a chain smoker and a Pyro Maniac.
- Another example with Jesse: at one point Sara is too depressed over Kate to take Jesse to shop for new cleats like she'd promised, and tells him they won't be going. Jesse gets upset and points out that she isn't even doing anything, and Sara screams at him until he runs upstairs upset. When Sara later goes up to apologize to him, she discovers that Jesse has used a fork to pull out his braces, and he says to her, "Now you never have to take me anywhere."
- Pyro Maniac: Jesse.
- Running Gag: Campbell never giving anyone a straight answer once they ask what his service dog is for, since he's not blind. But he is epileptic.
- Scholarship Student: Julia at the Wheeler School where she and Campbell met.
- Shoot the Shaggy Dog: In the original novel, at least. Anna's battle for medical emancipation is proven pointless when she dies in a car accident and both her kidneys are harvested for her older sister.
- Spared by the Adaptation: Anna herself in the movie lives, while Kate dies instead.
- Thanatos Gambit: The film has Kate arrange one of these because she wants to die and doesn't want Anna to suffer anymore.
- Third Line, Some Waiting: Campbell (Anna's lawyer) and Julia's relationship. Julia is removed in the movie.
- Title Drop: When Julia turns up at the Fitzgeralds' and asks Jesse where Anna is, he replies "Am I my sister's keeper?"
- The Unfavorite: Jesse, and to a lesser extent, Anna. See Parental Favoritism above.
- Useless Bystander Parent: Brian. While not happy with Anna's Walking Transplant status, he pretty much lets Sara get her way all the time, resulting in this trope.
- We Named the Monkey Jack: Campbell's dog, Judge.
- Walking Transplant: Anna