When young Clarissa ("Clary") Fray sees three teenagers seemingly commit murder in a nightclub, she is immediately intrigued by them and their strange mannerisms - such as their talk about demons and Downworlders. She later shrugs it off, preferring to live life normally with her overprotective mother Jocelyn and her Geek best friend Simon.That is, until Clary meets Jace again, and she goes home to discover that her apartment's been trashed and her mother's gone missing.When she unknowingly kills the demon that trashed her apartment, Jace brings Clary back to the Institute and she meets the other two teenagers at the nightclub - Isabelle and Alec Lightwood, both beautiful and dangerous. Their tutor Hodge Starkweather explains their world to her - that yes, mythical creatures such as vampires and werewolves do exist, known to them as Downworlders, and that Shadowhunters are a special "breed" of people that act like supernatural detectives, making sure that the Muggles of the world are safe and never find out about the demons that inhabit several dimensions.But things aren't over for Clary just yet. There's a war on the horizon - the Shadowhunters against massive demon forces conjured by the Big Bad of the series, Valentine. But other than that, Clary's personal life is not without its own drama - how will she cure her mother? What about her relationship with Simon, which is slowly getting more and more complicated? And what is she to do about the beautiful and elusive Jace, who seems very attracted to her?This (former) urban fantasy trilogy by Cassandra Clare (otherwise known as CassandraClaire) consists of City of Bones, City of Ashes, and City of Glass. The fourth book, City of Fallen Angels, was released April 2011, and the fifth, City of Lost Souls, was released May 2012. The sixth (and perhaps final) book, City of Heavenly Fire, has yet to be released. Clare has also published a completed prequel trilogy, The Infernal Devices, with these books keeping up the Idiosyncratic Naming by being entitled Clockwork Angel, Clockwork Prince, and Clockwork Princess. A sequel series, The Dark Artifices, set five years after the events of The Mortal Instruments, is also planned.A film version was released August 2013, with Lily Collins and Jamie Campbell Bower having been cast as Clary and Jace.This series has a character sheet. Please put all character-related tropes there.
Provides Examples Of:
Adaptation Induced Plothole: In the book Simon was abducted by vampires because he'd been turned into a rat, and they mistook him for one of them. In the movie, they took him as a hostage because they wanted the Mortal Cup. The movie failed to give us any possible use Vampires could have for the Cup.
Adults Are Useless: Every single higher-up is at a Clave meeting. All of them. While Jace's group of inexperienced youths are pursuing the Mortal Instruments, the maniacal Valentine, and attempting to stop The End of the World as We Know It. Anyone who isn't is either insane with power, revenge, or a spy.
Subverted with Magnus Bane. Physically he looks to be about nineteen, slightly older than the protagonists. But he is actually centuries old and thus technically more of an "adult" than even the oldest Shadowhunters. He is also incredibly useful.
Altum Videtur: Gratuitous Latin is in widespread usage here. Partly justified in that Idris is located in Western Europe and has been around since the Middle Ages, when Latin was still the common language of the educated class in that region. Sometimes abused by Shadowhunters as part of their smug routine. Ominous Latin Chanting is also popular.
Ancestral Weapon: Clary is given her mother's stele in the second book. Subverted since she loses it.
Animorphism: Simon is turned into a rat in the first book, and Magnus can turn into a cat.
Anguished Declaration of Love: Clary gets one from Simon and another from Jace, while Jocelyn gets one from Luke in the third book. Magnus's is more of an Irritated Declaration Of Love, when Alec demands to know why he hasn't called him back, resulting in this exchange:
Magnus: You're an idiot.
Alec: Is that why you didn't call me? Because I'm an idiot?
Magnus: You stupid Nephilim. Why else am I here? Why else would I have spent the past few weeks patching up all your moronic friends everytime they got hurt? And getting you out of every ridiculous situation you found yourself in? Not to mention helping you win a battle against Valentine. And all completely free of charge!
Alec: I hadn't looked at it that way.
Magnus: Of course not. You never looked at it in any way. I'm seven hundred years old, Alexander. I know when something isn't going to work. You won't even admit I exist to your parents.
Magnus also gives one to Alec one book earlier though the love part is only implied
As Long as It Sounds Foreign: Raphael, being Mexican, tends to interject phrases in Spanish when he speaks. In City of Ashes, he tells Clary that Simon "no es muerto," which is incorrect; it should be "no está muerto." It seems like a classic Google Translate error rather than it being intentional.
Clare has stated when asked by a fan "What kind of a name is Clary?" that she was named after a friend, who's full name is Clarissa, much like the Clary in the books. The only real similarities seem to be red hair(though Cassie also states that she imagined Clary's a much darker shade) and the first four letters of their names.
Beethoven Was an Alien Spy: In the film, Johann Sebastian Bach is stated to have been a Shadowhunter and his music was designed to harm demons.
Battle Couple: When Alec and Magnus go into the final battle as partners
Also Luke and Clary's Mother.
Also Maryse and Robert Lightwood, though not explicitly given screen time as such.
The Beautiful Elite: All the Nephilim are somehow good-looking (with the possible exception of Hodge and The REAL Sebastian Verlac). The vampires, too.
Beta Couple: Alec and Magnus; Luke and Jocelyn. Simon and Isabelle at the end of the third book and during the fourth.
Big Applesauce: The first two books, as well as the fourth. The third book is set in Idris, but the trope is still in play, as the representatives of the faeries, vampires, warlocks and werewolves that come to Idris (which is located between France and Germany) are all from New York City. The prequel trilogy is set in Victorian London.
Big Brother Instinct: Alec takes his job as the oldest Lightwood sibling very seriously. Jace too, despite not being their real brother.
Black and Grey Morality: The story kind of trips over this. Valentine is supposedly evil because he hates all Downworlders and wants to kill them all, but when you see how the Shadowhunters treat mundanes and Downworlders, you start to wonder how they got to be the designated heroes.
Blue-Collar Warlock: Magnus Bane, who lives in a warehouse loft and generally behaves like a New York hipster. This is apparently not unusual for warlocks in general. One is even shown to work in a hospital as a nurse.
Brainwashed: Jonathan does this to Jace in City of Lost Souls.
Break the Haughty: Gets a glorious example in City Of Ashes, when the Inquisitor learns that her plan to trade Jace to Valentine for the Sword and Cup won't work. It causes her to freak out and have a short BSOD before Maryse snaps her out of it.
Brother-Sister Incest: In City of Bones a fortune teller tells Jace that he will "Love the wrong person". He falls in love with Clary, who turns out to be his sister.
Subverted. They end up not related. Jace is the son of his supposed Father's second second-in-command. And Clary ends up with Jace, though only after meeting and kissing a boy she finds out is her REAL brother. Oops.
In City Of Lost SoulsSebastian/Jonathan is shown to actually want Clary, backing her up against a wall and forcefully kissing her, while going on about how they can be evil and rule the world together.
But Not Too Foreign: Every character of a different ethnicity who appears in the series always turns out to be biracial, (usually half Caucasian). Magnus is half Dutch half Indonesian, Aline is half Japanese half Caucasian, Maia is half black and half Caucasian.
For the entire duration of Jocelyn's kidnapping and subsequent coma, Clary is completely devoted to bringing her back. When Jocelyn finally is cured and returned, the very first thing Clary does is tear into her for depriving Clary of her Sight and not preparing her for the Shadowhunters' world.
Can Not Tell A Lie: The fairies. This should not be mistaken to mean that they are always honest.
Captain Obvious Reveal: The series is rather infamous for these, due to its very frequent use of Foreshadowing. The most hated examples were that Valentine was Clary's father and Clary and Jace weren't siblings.
Casting Gag: In the film, all of the Shadow Hunters have British accents. Clary who is the daughter of one is also the daughter a Brit
Celestial Paragons and Archangels: Raziel, who created the Shadowhunters. Also, Michael, Gabriel and many others are mentioned but do not appear. Raziel explicitly states that God exists, but what degree of direct interest He takes in earthly affairs is ambiguous.
Chekhov's Gun: In the first book, Madame Dorothea's tarot cards: the Ace of Cups was the Mortal Cup.
Also, the lake that Clary and Luke fall into during City of Glass turns out to be the Mortal Glass.
Chekhov's Skill: Clary's ability to draw - this helps her create Runes of her own.
Code of Honour: The Shadowhunters' Law, which provides a moral framework for what they do, but which is often very restrictive. Both the heroes and villains have a distinct tendency to try to circumvent it, even while accepting it in principle.
Combat Stilettos: Isabelle wears heels constantly and fights in them when she needs to. She has even been known to use them as weapons, slashing and impaling targets with her kicks.
Comically Missingthe Point: More than once during the Anguished Declaration of Love as seen above, where Alec Lightwood seems more concerned with the fact that Magnus didn't return his calls and lied about his age than the fact the city is under attack and Magnus is explaining all the pain Alec's closeted-ness and his love is causing him. Leading us to this little gem where they BOTH end up missing the point of their conversation:
"You told me you were three hundred! You're seven hundred years old?"
"Well, eight hundred, but I don't look it."
Coming-Out Story: Alec is outed quite spectacularly towards the end of the third book.
Luke gets Simon a pamphlet called 'How To Come Out to Your Parents' when he becomes a vampire and tells him to adapt it to suit the situation. Neither Simon nor Clary is amused.
Dating What Daddy Hates: All over the place. Isabelle dates anybody but other Shadowhunters. Alec winds up in a gay relationship with a warlock. Jocelyn isn't wild about her daughter dating the boy that Valentine raised. Jocelyn and Luke's relationship has caused them no end of grief over the years. Valentine forced Stephan Herondale to divorce Amatis simply because she was Luke's sister. Aline and Helen's lesbian relationship is controversial for Shadowhunters. Somewhat invoked and somewhat subverted when Maia and Simon date: A werewolf and a vampire dating is controversial but their mutual surrogate father figure, Luke, doesn't care and thinks highly of both of them. Worth noting that while these relationships are all said to be taboo, actual opposition or fallout is very low-key if it's seen at all.
Dawson Casting: The film adaptation is very guilty of this, casting actors in their mid-to-late-twenties as the teenage main characters. Most notorious is 27-year-old Kevin Zegers as 18-year-old Alec. That said, the producer has revealed that although they won't be specifying anyone's exact age in the movie, the characters are supposed to be somewhat older than their book counterparts.
Evil Counterpart Race: The Dark Shadowhunters that Jonathan Morgenstern creates using the Infernal Cup and Lilith's blood. They are stronger and faster than regular Shadowhunters, but cannot use their Runes or angelically aligned weapons. Whether they will develop demonic equivalents remains to be seen.
Evil Plan: Driving the plot in every book. In the first three it is Valentine's. In the fourth it is Lilith's and the fifth and sixth center on Sebastian's.
In Uinverse Brother Zachariah is a quite obvious expy of Brother Jeremiah, although he's shown to be a bit more human. With good reason.
Extra-Strength Masquerade: The Shadow World is generally invisible to Mundanes. Many Downworlders strut around fairly openly, relying on humanity's natural Weirdness Censor to cause people to not see them for what they really are. The Shadowhunters, being almost human, put a modest amount of magical effort into rendering themselves unnoticeable in everyday society. Also, their countryapparently doesn't exist.
The Fair Folk: Fairies are rarely trustworthy. Although they cannot lie, they are masters of evasion. They also have a definite sadistic streak and will ally with good or evil depending on where they think their interests are best served.
Fantastic Racism: Nobody gives mundanes any respect. One of the more blatant examples was when Simon takes down the Greater Demon in City of Bones. An Amazon.com review notes that the Shadowhunters react in a manner that "suggests Simon's mundane status was a crippling retardation he managed to overcome; apparently mundanes are incapable of dexterity, motor skills, or strategy?" Who was making weapons before the Nephilim were created, again?
Not just mundanes, but Shadowhunters in general tend to look down on Downworlders too, and the vampires and werewolves are constantly at each others necks, and the Faeries are equal-opportunity misanthropes.
The elitism of the Shadowhunters is often Lampshaded by outsiders, notably Clary and Simon, as well as Downworlders.
Fantasy Kitchen Sink: Warlocks, werewolves, vampires, faeries, demons, angels, and Nephilim are the main fantasy creatures; however, many others are mentioned in passing. In fact, in City of Bones Jace tells Clary that "all the stories are true."
Except for mummies. No one believes in mummies.
Foreshadowing: The Lightwoods have a history of marital troubles. Isabelle is noted as wishing she had her parents' blue eyes instead of her own dark ones. Blue eyes are a recessive genetic trait, it's impossible for two blue-eyed parents to have a child that's not blue-eyed.
In City of Bones, Simon makes a joke about Jewish Vampires. That's exactly what he ends up becoming
Forgotten Phlebotinum: The Alliance Rune. After City of Glass it's never used again, even when Shadowhunters and Downworlders are going into battle right next to each other.
Functional Magic: Primarily Inherent Gift, as one of the defining attributes of being "human" is the inability to use magic and thus free access to magic is generally limited to Downworlders and Shadowhunters. Warlocks (who are half-demon) are the primary practitioners of magic, although the Shadowhunters have their Runes and the fairies possess strange powers.
Fur Against Fang: The vampires and werewolves do not get on well; this is because the two demon species which originally infected humans, giving rise to the vampires and werewolves, were rivaling species who hated one another.
Genre Savvy: In City of Ashes, newly turned vampire Simon Lewis says the following line after Valentine's ship blows up.
Simon: Never believe the bad guy is dead until you see a body. That just leads to unhappiness and surprise ambushes.
Geometric Magic: Angelic Runes are a crucial part of the story, and the most potent weapon in the Shadowhunters' arsenal.
Gratuitous Greek: Interestingly averted despite the regular use of Gratuitous Latin and the fact that Shadowhunters are usually educated in both Classical languages. While it is mentioned that some texts, such as the Book of White, are written in Greek, nobody seems to drop any Greek phrases, even though they often do so with Latin.
Half-Human Hybrid: Warlocks are the progeny of couplings between humans and demons. They are themselves generally infertile.
Happily Adopted: Jace, by the Lightwoods. Clary Lampshades this when Jace is angsting about his lack of a last name and she points out that he's always been Jace Lightwood.
Heterosexual Life-Partners: Jace Wayland and Alec Lightwood. Alec's sexuality and initial attraction to Jace notwithstanding, the two share a "parabatai" bond which is explicitly stated as being a permanent bond of partnership even stronger than that of brothers.
The Hunter: The Shadowhunters protect humanity from supernatural creatures. Subverted somewhat in that the Shadowhunters are themselves supernatural in nature.
Idiot Ball: At the end of City Of Glass, Clary decides to wish Jace back to life. Which is great except she seems to have forgotten about all the other shadowhunters that died. Real considerate there Clary.
Though considering what happens it causes Jonathan to come back to life and create an anti-nephilium group, this might not be a bad thing
Arguably, Simon's little incident with the vampires in City of Ashes counts.
Idiosyncratic Episode Naming: All of the books in the series are called "City of X". The titular City of Bones is the Silent City, while the titular City of Glass is Alicante.
Interspecies Romance: Played straight with Magnus and Alec. No punintended. Every warlock is the offspring of a human and a demon (though Word of God says that most of these cases are rape, not romance), in City of Ashes Isabelle is dating a faerie knight. The fey themselves are the offspring of demons and angels. Jocelyn and Luke and Isabelle and Simon, as of City of Lost Souls, are in the same vein as Tonks and Lupin, with their lycanthropy and vampirism respectively being more like diseases than a genetic trait, though there are born werewolves in-universe. The Blackthorn family is said to have some fey blood as well.
Love Triangle: Clary falls for Jace. Long time best friend Simon has always loved Clary, but Clary doesn't find out until later. Alec has a crush on Jace, who doesn't realize it for quite a while. Simon has a crush on Isabelle, Alec's sister. She loathes him when they first meet but he grows on her. By the end of the first book, Jace has fallen for Clary as well. Oops. Later, Maia is introduced. She likes Simon, and he likes her back. But we can't let anything in this story be simple. Sorry Simon.. By now, Magnus Bane has been introduced. Guess who ends up with him? In City of Glass, yet another player is introduced, Sebastian. Clary has a short fling with him. Oops again. Only it turns out that Jace and Clary aren't actually related. But in Sebastian aka Jonathan's case, it's for real. And he knew it. And this is to say nothing of Jocelyn's love history, which is simpler (Lucian / Valentine), or other side love interests like Isabelle's fling with Meliorn or Maia's ex Jordan. As of the fifth book,Clary/Jace is on with difficulties, Alec/Magnus is off, Jocelyn/Lucian is on, and Maia/Jordan is on.
MacGuffin: The titular Mortal Instruments: A cup, a sword, and a mirror
Magical Society: The Shadowhunters most definitely, complete with their own magically-concealed country located on the border of France and Germany. The Fair Folk likewise count for much the same reasons. Vampires and werewolves are a less organized variation, being organized into local clans and packs respectively, and they live within mundane cities. The warlocks are an aversion, being mostly free agents bound primarily by individual relationships.
Magitek: The flying motorcycles the vampires ride, which are powered by "demon energies".
Magic Versus Science: The extensive wards that conceal and protect Idris also appear to interfere with technology. Hence the Shadowhunters do not use things like automobiles to get around within the country, even though those that live elsewhere are quite familiar with them. Witchlight is used to provide things like illumination that would normally be powered by electricity in other countries. Elaborate mechanical devices, possibly related to phonographs, are used to play music. There is no cellular coverage or internet access naturally. It is also noted that Runes interfere with the proper ignition of gunpowder, which is why Shadowhunters do not make use of firearms.
Naginatas Are Feminine: In City of Ashes Isabelle walks in with her trademark whip and a naginata. When Alec asks if the naginata is for him, she tells him to get his own weapon, promptly giving it to their mother.
Not Good With Rejection: Really, it gets to the point where should-be True Companions are abandoning each other to vampires and demons for slights like "I can't believe you like her/him more than me!" and "It wasn't my fault!" Kind of sends the underlying message that this is all teens are capable of.
Official Couple Ordeal Syndrome: To put it mildly. All the more notable considering that Jace and Clary have only known each other for months in-universe. Alec and Magnus seem to have gotten ensnared in this as well.
Old Shame: You know, it might be easier for Cassandra Clare to erase all memories of that NC-17 Ron/GinnyIncest Fic if she didn't go and give her published series the exact same name.
And boy, does it ever show on the Amazon reviews.
It would likewise have been easier for her to ditch the whole plagiarism debacle attached to the Draco Trilogy if she'd either used her real name or else gone with a different pseudonym. She's one of the few writers who had a pre-built Hatedom and Fan Wank before she even got published.
But she also had a built-in fandom and she got her book deal because of her fandom fame, so it's a bit of a double-edged sword. The fact that so many characters are Expys from her best-known work, not to mention the copy/paste of scenes from the same into this series, would make it a little hard for her to get away with pretending to be someone else anyway.
Power Glows: The seraph blades, the angels and Magnus' hands all do this.
Power Trio: Jace, Alec and Isabelle start out the series as this. However, the group dynamic changes when Clary and Simon come along, and still further when Jace and Clary become an Official Couple, as do Alec and Magnus Bane resulting in a more complex set of relationships.
In City of Glass, Max is also seen reading Angel Sanctuary, a manga about a reincarnated angel who is in a romantic relationship with his sister. It has a case of Does This Remind You of Anything as well as bringing to question why a nine year old with fairly strict parents would be reading it. But then again, his parents have quite a lot of marital issues. So his reading choices likely passed largely unnoticed. Besides, they probably thought that that something called Angel Sanctuary would be clean and proper.
Happens often with animanga, given that Simon is characterized as a typical Geek. At one point Clary asks him if he wants to spend the evening with her watching Trigun.
Shut Up, Hannibal!: In the third book, Valentine avoids this by using a magic rune to keep a character quiet so he can monologue without interruption. The character eventually gives a rebuttal by writing in the dirt.
Spell Book: The Gray Book is dedicated to the Angelic Runes used by Shadowhunters, and the Book of White with spells affecting life and death among other things. Shadowhunters and Warlocks are prone to collecting spell books, the former to keep them under lock and key, the latter in order to use them.
Straight Gay: Alec. Generally the only way gays could be without being expelled from the Clave. Interestingly, homosexuality is not in fact prohibited by the Law. Shadowhunters just tend to look down on it, possibly as a reflection of their slightly archaic culture.
Summoning Ritual: The Mortal Instruments are required to summon the angel Raziel, a ritual that can only be done once every millennium. Once they have all three, Raziel will come to them and will grant any single wish the summoner wants. Or rather, he won't smite them the moment he appears and might consider granting that single wish. Well...
Supernatural Elite: The Shadowhunters tend to see themselves as this and act accordingly. The Downworlders are not especially happy about it, but lack the necessary unity to do much about it.
Sword of Plot Advancement: Much of the action in the first three novels involves locating and recovering the titular Mortal Instruments, one of which is literally a sword, "Maellartach". Some other items, like the Book of the White, are also the subject of quests. Then in City of Lost Souls it is again literally a sword, in this case "Glorious", the sword of the Archangel Michael.
Clary is raised by her mother Jocelyn, and thinks of her mother's devoted, if platonic, boyfriend Luke who is really a Shadowhunter named Lucian Graymark that was turned into a werewolf as her stepfather. He later gets a Relationship Upgrade with Jocelyn. She believes her biological father was a soldier killed in action, but he is really the Big Bad Valentine Morgenstern.
Jace is supposedly the son of Michael Wayland. But then it turns out that Michael was murdered and the man who supposedly fathered him was really Valentine Morgenstern, leading to a Brother-Sister Incest problem with Clary. It later turns out that his actual biological father was Valentine's right-hand man Stephen Herondale. Needless to say, Jace goes through a great many surname changes, although he often uses Lightwood after his adoptive parents and siblings.
Valentine did in fact have an actual son with Jocelyn, Jonathan, whom he raised in secret. Jonathan disguises himself as Sebastian Verlac, a cousin of the prominent Penhallow family. Later he magically coerces Jace into regarding him as a brother. Jonathan also has a Brother-Sister Incest vibe with Clary.
Teens Are Short: It is called out repeatedly that the main characters whose biological parents are still running around look very much like their parents, only shorter.
To Be Lawful or Good: A common quandary for Shadowhunters. The Clave is often rather clueless, even about the actions and motives of its own members. As a result the heroes must often struggle with deciding whether to follow the Law, or do what is necessary and/or right.
Too Dumb to Live: Simon. Breaking into a hotel of murderous vampires that have expressed that they wouldn't mind having an excuse to turn you into hamburger meat isn't such a good idea. Especially if you go alone. And do it at night. Sure the vampire blood was summoning him back to Raphael, and he would have given in and sought them out sooner or later, but if he had only asked Luke, he would have known to wait a few more days, and the blood would have gone out of his system, as well as the compulsion it had on him to return to Raphael.
Trilogy Creep: First, there was the original trilogy (City of Bones, City of Ashes, and City of Glass). Then, it was announced that Clare was writing a steampunk prequel trilogy set in Victorian London (The Clockwork Angel, The Clockwork Prince, and The Clockwork Princess). Then, a fourth book centered around the Simon character of the first trilogy was revealed to be in the works (City of Fallen Angels). Then Clare decided to add two more books to the Mortal Instruments story (City of Lost Souls and City of Heavenly Fire) while also stating that this new trilogy of TMI books would no longer focus solely on Simon but rather on the entire cast. This series of somewhat obscure YA fantasy books literally tripled in size.
It has far more than tripled now. In addition to the Mortal Instruments and the Infernal Devices, there are three new trilogies in the works; The Dark Artifices, TLH and TWP (the latter two currently only being known by their acronyms). Note that all of these (Infernal Devices included) are separate series within the same universe, and each trilogy (not including the double-trilogy of the Mortal Instruments) is written so that it can be read on its own.
The Verse: Clare is also publishing a prequel series. The first book was recently released.
As of 2013, there are The Mortal Instruments, The Infernal Devices, The Dark Artifices (first book to be released soon), and then the secretive TLH (a sequel to TID) and the even more secretive TWP (of which nothing but the initialism is known), all taking place in the Shadowhunter world.
The Shadowhunters received their special abilities from drinking the blood of the angel Raziel given to them in the Mortal Cup. New Shadowhunters can also be created this way, although the process is risky. Jonathan Morgenstern arranged the creation of the Infernal Cup, tainted by the blood of Lilith, which can turn humans and Shadowhunters into Dark Shadowhunters.
Consumption of angel or demon blood generally, even in dried form, can result in changes to a person or their offspring. Valentine, Jocelyn, Clary, Jace and especially Jonathan were all altered to some extent in this way due to Valentine's experimentation with the blood.
Vampires and werewolves are the descendants of two different species of demons. They can transmit their condition to humans, and even Shadowhunters, via bite.
Weirdness Censor: A standard attribute of mundanes. They simply do not possess the necessary perception to notice most supernatural phenomena, and supernatural beings can evade detection with little or no effort.
"Well Done, Son" Guy: Jace spent most of his life being this - until he found out who his father really was. And even then....
Well-Intentioned Extremist: Valentine. Unfortunately, his plan to reform the Clave to protect against demonic threats involves raising a massive demon army and slaughtering them all.