War is not for winning. It is for surviving.
"That's how you get deathless, volchitsa. Walk the same tale over and over, until you wear a groove in the world, until even if you vanished, the tale would keep turning, keep playing, like a phonograph, and you'd have to get up again, even with a bullet through your eye, to play your part and say your lines."
is a 2011 historical fantasy novel by American speculative fiction author Catherynne M. Valente
. The novel retells the Russian folk tale
of "Marya Morevna and the Death of Koschei the Deathless," set against the backdrop of the Russian Revolution and the rise of the Communist Party.
Young Marya Morevna, daughter of twelve mothers, watches as three birds turn into men and come to wed her sisters, and wonders when one will come for her. As she grows from girlhood to womanhood in St. Petersburg
, her eldest sister marries in Tsarist Russia
, while the other marriages describe the passage of years into the revolution
. But Marya is claimed by someone greater: Koschei the Deathless, Tsar of Life, a menacing figure locked in eternal battle with death. Marya must learn to navigate the treacherous borders between life and death as war comes for her, for life, and for all of Russia.
Deathless provides examples of the following tropes:
- Aloof Dark-Haired Girl: By around the middle point Marya is definitely this; she has grown into The Stoic during her time in Buyan. Her long, black hair is frequently emphasized.
- Action Girl: Marya as she is an officer in Koschei's army. Later grows into a Lady of War when she becomes tsaritsa. This is keeping in line with the original tale, in which Marya Morevna is a warrior-princess.
- All Just a Dream: Marya's time in Yaichka. She wanted both Koschei and Ivan and this was the only way she could really have the traits of both men in one person.
- Anti-Villain: Koschei the Deathless, a well-known villain of Russian fairy tales, is instead portrayed more sympathetically.
- Badass Boast: "I am Marya Morevna, daughter of twelve mothers, and I will not be denied."
- Lebedeva has a stream of these in the same vein, based around the art of makeup.
- Big Fancy House: Marya's family home, at least initially. Because it's so big it's made into a dwelling for twelve families under the communist regime, hence Marya's twelve mothers.
- Marya's eldest sister Olga lives in a massive, magical country estate after her bird-marriage.
- Bi the Way: Marya has an off-screen affair with a rusalka.
- Bittersweet Ending: Everyone is dead in the end, but death is no worse than life, and there are hints that a reconciliation between Marya and Koschei is in the works, as at the very end of the book Marya is trying to return to Koschei, on what will probably be more equal terms this time.
- Blue and Orange Morality: The struggle between Koschei and Viy and the values of the citizens of their kingdoms are incomprehensible to humans, just as human values are incomprehensible to them.
- Break the Cutie: Marya is slowly broken over a period of years, beginning in her childhood when she witnesses birds transform into men who marry her sisters and take them away. No one believes her, forcing her to keep this a secret. By the time Koschei comes for her, between the magic she has witnessed and the way her home life and Russia degrade over those years, she is already in trouble. Things only get worse for her when she marries Koschei.
- Brother-Sister Incest: Koschei and Baba Yaga were apparently an item once upon a time. Yaga claims that when you're immortal it doesn't count as a bad thing.
- Broken Bird: Marya, by the time Ivan enters her life. She has forgotten a good deal of her human emotion.
- Byronic Hero: Koschei again, as he is more dark and troubled than outright evil.
- Crazy Jealous Guy: Koschei, although he's better at taking it in stride than most examples.
- Dark Is Not Evil: Viy is the Tsar of Death, but Death is no worse than Life.
- Dead Person Conversation: Marya has such conversations with Svetlana with Lebedeva.
- Defecting for Love: Marya abandons Koschei and his war when she falls in love with Ivan. All the Yelenas and Vasilisas did the same.
- Despair Event Horizon: The Siege of Leningrad.
- Devoted to You: This is Koschei's curse. He is hopelessly in love with Marya, though he can't express it in a way she appreciates.
- Earn Your Happy Ending: Maybe. The happiness of the ending is debatable, though the characters fought very hard for it. Literally.
- Forever War: Between Life and Death. The war is going badly, but then, the war is always going badly.
- Four Is Death: Marya is the fourth daughter in her family, and the daughter who ends up marrying Koschei and bringing about his death.
- Funny Foreigner: This is the view the people of Buyan have of Marya and her ignorance of their ways.
- Grey and Gray Morality: Koschei and Viy are constantly opposed to each other. Neither is good, but neither is evil, either.
- Genre Savvy: The people of Buyan, but especially Baba Yaga. Koschei has married so many young women in the past that everyone knows what to expect. His former wives are even called Yelenas like they are some sort of breed with its own characteristics. Of course, things go very differently with Marya.
- Koshchei freaks out when Ivan shows up, because people named Ivan have a history of getting the better of people like him.
- Loners Are Freaks: Marya, from the very beginning. She realizes she is something of a freak when she reveals her beliefs about marrying birds to her classmates, and she remains fairly isolated when she becomes queen in Buyan because she is human.
- Love Martyr: I think allowing oneself to be tied up in one's wife's basement while she has a life with her lover in the house above and uses you for sex and submission for years on end counts as pretty damned martyred, wouldn't you agree, Koschei?
- One Steve Limit: Played straight with Marya, as there is only one Marya Morevna, but averted with all the Yelenas. Baba Yaga says Koschei has a weakness for Yelenas. And Vasilisas.
- Rule of Three: In keeping with the book's fairy tale roots, this pops up frequently. The three birds that court Marya's three sisters, the three tasks she has to perform for Baba Yaga and the three friends who help her with them, the three gifts Marya's sisters give her, etcetera.
- Scenery Gorn: Everything in the Country of Life is alive. Everything. The buildings are made out of skin, the fountains spurt blood instead of water, hair grows from rooftops... When Marya brings Ivan to Buyan, he is rightly horrified.
- Shout-Out: Marya and her sisters have the same/similar names as Tsar Nicholas II's daughters: Olga, Tatiana, Maria, and Anastasia. The only difference is Marya is the youngest of her own family and Anastasia is instead Anna.
- Shown Their Work: Valente shows extensive knowledge of this period of Russian history and of Russian folklore. Her husband and his Russian family exposed her to the culture, stories, and history, and helped with issues of language.
- Tall, Dark and Handsome: Much is made of Koschei's beautiful appearance.
- Truth in Television: Much of the depiction of the Siege of Leningrad, up to and including cannibalism.
- Utopia: Yaichka is a fairly straightforward example; it's an idealized Russia where nobody goes hungry and all the factions during the Revolution reside in relative harmony. Justified as Alkonost deliberately constructed it that way.
- Vain Sorceress: Madame Lebedeva plays with this trope, being both vain and a sorceress. As she clearly explains, however, her preening is not mere vanity, it is an exercise of her will, and therefore an act of magic.
- War Is Hell: War permeates the novel, and it is never depicted as being in anyway righteous or glorious. Ultimately, everyone suffers for it. The characters even lampshade this by talking about how the war is going badly, but then, the war is always going badly.
- What the Hell, Hero?: Ivan is horrified by the sort of life Marya leads in Buyan, and he says so.
- Your Cheating Heart: Marya is in love with both Koschei and Ivan.
- Although it only becomes actual cheating (Koschei knows about Marya's affairs and doesn't mind) when she leaves for the mortal world with Ivan, and later locks a pining Koschei up in her basement without telling Ivan about it.