[[quoteright:239:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/VjWP2_8701.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:239: [-Her dream would end, and reality would show itself. However, it had not yet ended. Indeed, the girl's dream had come to an end, but that of La Pucelle would start from then.-] [[note]]Background, clockwise from bottom left: Red Rider (Achilles), Black Lancer ([[UsefulNotes/VladTheImpaler Vlad III]]), Red Berserker (Spartacus), and Black Rider (Astolfo). Foreground: Ruler ( [[UsefulNotes/JoanOfArc Jeanne d'Arc]]).[[/note]] ]]
->''In the name of Jeanne d'Arc, I command thee, fourteen Servants.''

''Fate/Apocrypha'' is a LightNovel written by Yuichiro Higashide and illustrated by Konoe Ototsugu set in the ''[[VisualNovel/FateStayNight Fate/stay night]]'' universe. It was originally conceived as a joint-project MMORPG by Type-Moon, with the help of several other authors and artists like Creator/GenUrobuchi, but was eventually cancelled when a suitable development partner could not be found[[note]]at least until it eventually evolved into the mobile game ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder''[[/note]]. The concept was later revived as a five-part LightNovel, with two previews published in the ''Type-Moon Ace'' magazine. The full first novel was released at Comiket on 29 December 2012. The second novel was released on the 15th of August, 2013, the third on December 29, 2013, the fourth on May 30, 2014, and the fifth and final volume was released on December 30, 2014.


In an AlternateTimeline, the Third Holy Grail War is forever changed when the [[TheAlliance Yggdmillennia faction]] steals the Grail from Fuyuki City and rebuilds it in Trifas, Transylvania. Many years later, the Holy Grail War begins again, but this Holy Grail War is fundamentally different than the previous ones, namely there are now fourteen Servants summoned by the Grail on two teams: Red, consisting of the Magus Association, the Church, and other mages hired by the Magus Association, and Black, consisting of mages of the Yggdmillennia faction, with seven Servants each. In addition to the two sides, the war is now also being presided over by a Servant, [[UsefulNotes/JoanOfArc Jeanne d'Arc]], a Ruler-class Servant whose primary job is to make sure the two factions don't adversely cause problems to the {{Muggle}} world. Despite it appearing to be a normal Grail War, behind the scenes forces threaten to overturn the Grail War, and throw the world into chaos.

An anime adaptation by Creator/A1Pictures was announced December 31, 2016. It premiered on July 1 2017, has been licenced for exclusive streaming on Creator/{{Netflix}}, and will run for 25 episodes. The first half of the series premiered [[http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-07-03/fate-apocrypha-anime-to-premiere-on-netflix-on-november-7/.118399 on Netflix worldwide on November 7, 2017.]]

----
!!''Fate/Apocrypha'' provides examples of:
* TheAlliance: Yggdmillennia is actually a collection of new, dying, and weak magus clans taken in under one banner, with the middle name indicating which clan that member originally descended from. Even their crest isn't unified.
* AllMythsAreTrue: Mostly played straight, although there are a few deviations. For example, Vlad III was most certainly not an actual vampire during his lifetime, though the prevalent association with them has given him access to a Noble Phantasm that lets him ''become'' one... though [[BerserkButton he '''really''' loathes it]].
* AllThereInTheManual: A lot of the information about the Servants originally came from the Fate/Complete Material IV guidebook rather than the actual novel. Fate/Apocrypha Material further expands on them and also explains what happened to the surviving Masters after the last book.
* AlternateTimeline: In this story, after the Holy Grail was stolen from Fuyuki following the third Holy Grail War by the Yggdmillennia and it no longer was held there, but in Transylvania. So the events of ''LightNovel/FateZero'' and ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight'' never occurred as they should have. However, InSpiteOfANail, Waver is Lord El-Melloi II.
** In addition, there have been numerous Holy Grail Wars fought all over the world since the theft of the original grail, which is presumably how Waver managed to achieve the title of Lord El-Melloi II as in ''LightNovel/FateZero''. The main difference is that the Romania Leyline is better than most, allowing the summoning of fourteen Servants rather than ''less than'' seven (a number of these supplementary Grail Wars apparently don't even boast a normal complement) and is capable of reaching the Root.
** And the original summon catalysts for the usual ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight'' and ''LightNovel/FateZero'' Servants have been lost since, once the information of the war spread, they were stolen and passed around until no one knew where they were. The Servants of ''Apocrypha'' can seem a little "second-string" because that's the ''point'' - they're easier to summon with broad catalysts (like Mordred) or are a bit obscure and all their relics haven't been plundered yet.
* AnimationBump: Used in some of the fight scenes, but is most evident (and sadly, also rather [[BrokenBase contested]]) in episode 22.
* AnyoneCanDie: There is little doubt that a lot of Servants will die, now that there are 15 of them in total. (And probably some of the Masters will kick the bucket too).
** [[spoiler: As of the third volume: Black Saber, Black Lancer, Black Berserker, Black Caster and Red Berserker have all fallen, and on the Masters' side of things, Roche, Darnic and Celenike. There is a slight chance for Black Berserker to respawn through Blasted Tree's secondary effect. In addition, although Siegfried had been KilledOffForReal, the Homunculus can take on his form for three minutes each time a Command Seal is used.]]
* ArtifactOfDoom: The Holy Grail, naturally. [[spoiler: [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] later on as it was revealed that the Einzberns in the 3rd Holy Grail War of this timeline [[ForWantOfANail summoned Shirou Kotomine instead]] of [[TheCorruption Angra Mainyu]].]]
* ArtisticLicense: Abused to the highest degree with the Servant designs, but most obviously, Jack the Ripper is a young, skimpily-dressed teenage girl.
* AscendedMeme: In the anime Siegfried and [[spoiler:Sieg]] tend to say [[ApologisesALot "sumanai"]] often. Siegfried earned a reputation in ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'' as ''Sumanai-kun" because of how often he said it and how he doesn't really have the best stats.
* BadassCape: Siegfried, Shirou Kotomine, Astolfo and Karna. Darnic may also count.
* BadassFamily: The Yggdmillenia, although they aren't actually related by blood, except for Fiore and Caules.
* BadassInANiceSuit: The Yggdmillenia are all dressed in Renaissance-ish white military uniforms.
* BathtubScene: Jeanne gets one in Episode 19.
* BigBad: Shirou Kotomine is the main villain of this series.
* BlackAndGrayMorality: Neither Shirou Kotomine nor Darnic Yggdmillenia seem particularly moral. [[spoiler:Their intentions are a completely different story, however - Shirou wants to rid humanity of all evil and suffering, while Darnic's wish is the far more selfish magus goal of simply reaching the Akashic Records, albeit with the benefit of guaranteeing the prosperity of the Yggmillenia clan.]]
* BloodKnight: A lot of heroes happen to enjoy fighting, which is partly why they are so good at it. Of note are the two NighInvulnerable Servants, Rider of Red and Saber of Black, who get excited when fighting someone who can injure them due to being bored of never being in danger.
* {{Bowdlerise}}: In the anime, Mordred turns a thumbs up into a thumbs down instead of [[FlippingTheBird flipping off]] [[spoiler:Adam]].
* TheCameo: Waver Velvet of ''LightNovel/FateZero'' makes a brief appearance.
** Saint Martha of ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'' appears in Chapter 5 of the manga during an explanation of the Ruler class. She does have Ruler class version in the game, but here she appears in her Rider costume. (Just as well--her Ruler costume is a bikini.) Arjuna also makes a brief appearance in this chapter as Karna compares Siegfried to him.
** Flatt Escardos of ''Literature/FateStrangeFake'' makes an appearance in the first episode of the anime adaptation.
** Arturia, [[Videogame/FateGrandOrder Merlin, Lancelot, Tristan, Gawain, Bedivere and even Agravain]] all appear briefly during Mordred's flashback in episode 6 of the anime adaptation. For a non-character cameo, Arturia's lance Rhongomyniad appears for the first time with its ''FGO'' appearance, whereas in previous showings of the scene it was a simple lance. Morgan le Fay (Mordred's mother and Arturia's sister) also makes her first animated appearance in the same episode.
** Fionn Mac Cumhaill of ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'' appears in episode 9 of the anime, appearing as Darnic's servant during his flashback to the Third Holy Grail War. Zouken Matou of ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight'' also appears in the same flashback, bleeding out and dying as he futilely reaches out to the zeppelins taking the Greater Grail away.
** [[VisualNovel/FateStayNight Medea]] (specifically, her "Lily" version from ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'') and Artemis appear in episode 18 as part of Atalanta's flashback to her past. [[LightNovel/FateZero Gilles de Rais]] in his "Saber" form also appears in episode 18 as part of a brief flashback to Jeanne's past.
** [[spoiler:Justeaze Lizrich von Einzbern]] appears before Shirou in episode 20, dressed in full Dress of Heaven regalia.
** Statues of Hektor and Penthesilea as they appeared in ''VideoGame/FateGrandOrder'' appeared during the activation of Achilles Cosmos Noble Phantasm, both of them being heroes with heavy links with Achilles' legend.
* CliffHanger: Volume 1 ends during the battle between Red Saber (Mordred) and [[spoiler:the Homunculus]], where we see Mordred's wind-up, but not her actually dealing the final blow. [[spoiler:Of course, when we rejoin the battle in volume 2, it turns out he survived]].
* CrazyPrepared: The Yggdmillenia, although Darnic Prestone in particular really counts. Rather [[JustifiedTrope justified]], considering that he's been preparing ever since the Third Holy Grail War. That's 70 years worth of preparation, folks.
** [[spoiler: Despite all that planning, "Shirou Kotomine" manages to outsmart and murder Darnic by the end of the second volume. It helps that Shirou had been around for almost as long as Darnic, and was probably even more prepared than him.]]
* CurbStompBattle:
** [[spoiler:By the end of the second volume and beginning of the third, the Red Faction is in an overwhelmingly favorable position: The Black Faction had lost their two strongest Servants (Siegfried and Vlad III) as well as their Berserker (Frankenstein), while their Caster (Avicebron) betrays them to the Red Faction. They only have three Servants left, although Black Assassin (Jack the Ripper) had essentially defected after being attacked by Fiore Yggdmillenia. In contrast, the Red Faction has lost their Berserker (Spartacus) in battle and their Saber (Mordred) betrayed them, but all of their other Servants are in perfect condition and they even have a bonus Ruler Servant (In the form of Amakusa Shirou) on their side. This means the Red Faction sits at seven Servants total while the Black only has effectively ''two'' to count on. Luckily, the Black Faction gets reinforcements with Mordred, Ruler (Jeanne) and Sieg (who can use Siegfried's power for a limited time) joining them to stop Amakusa Shirou]].
** Rider of Red wipes the floor with Berserker of Black during their brief encounter, since she can't hurt him and he horribly outclasses her in combat ability. Saber of Black fares better in that he's skilled enough to clash with Rider of Red evenly, but due to the nature of their [[NighInvulnerable Noble Phantasms]], [[MutualDisadvantage neither one can really hurt the other]].
** Kairi Sisigou and Saber of Red vs. half a dozen of Caster of Black's golems and several homunculi soldiers. Master and Servant tear them apart (quite literally in Saber's case) and walk away with no injuries to their name.
** Later, Mordred wipes the floor with Astolfo and Frankenstein, making the latter use her last resort attack.
* DramaPreservingHandicap:
** Caster of Red can OneHitKO anyone who's parameters are lower than his, which would a lot more useful if his parameters weren't abysmal.
** Karna rivals Gilgamesh for the title of strongest Servant period, but his absurd mana consumption can kill his master instantly if he uses his full capabilities.
* EnemyMine: Jeanne enforces a temporary ceasefire between the Black and Red Factions so that they'll work together to stop [[spoiler:Dracula from acquiring the Greater Grail]].
* {{Expy}}:
** As with most of the franchise, ''Fate/Apocrypha'' features a Saber that references Arturia. In this case, Mordred, Arturia's son [[spoiler:(actually daughter)]] makes an appearance as one of the Sabers. Jeanne d'Arc, who Arturia was [[JeanneDarchetype compared to]] in both ''Fate/stay night'' and ''Fate/Zero'', is also present.
** One of the Masters is called Shirou, has white hair and somewhat tan skin, and wears a red shroud similar to that of ''stay night'' Archer's. [[spoiler:This one is, of course, a ''massive'' RedHerring.]]
* FlashForward: The novel begins with a battle between Red Saber (Mordred) and Black Saber (Siegfried), something that has yet to actually happen by the end of the book. [[spoiler: It later turns out that the Homunculus was the one fighting Mordred, and that the real Siegfried had died by that point.]]
* ForWantOfANail: The event that separates this universe from the ''VisualNovel/FateStayNight'' universe is [[spoiler: the Einzberns summoning a Ruler Servant instead of Avenger in the Third Holy Grail War.]]
* {{Foreshadowing}}: In the prologue scene, Siegfried and Mordred are battling each other, with Mordred taunting Siegfried for being a "[[spoiler:fake]]". This is because later on, it is revealed that [[spoiler:the Siegfried she is fighting is not the real one, but a homunculus that has copied his appearance and abilities to a limited extent.]]
** If you look closely, [[spoiler:Sieg's [[https://img00.deviantart.net/d8cd/i/2017/223/7/c/fate_apocrypha_seig_command_seal_by_aki_artist-dbjr9ov.jpg command seals]] are shaped in the form of a dragon reflecting his power from Siegfried. Later on, he himself transforms into Fafnir in order to carry the Greater Grail to the Far Side of the World.]]
* FourIsDeath: In Episode 4 of the anime [[spoiler:Siegfried makes his HeroicSacrifice to save Homunculus' life]].
* FunctionalMagic: The novel makes use of the traditional Franchise/{{Nasuverse}}-style magic rules.
* GenderFlip: As per the ''Fate'' series' tradition, some of the Servants are gender swapped versions of mythological and historical figures. In this case we have FrankensteinsMonster and Mordred, Arturia's "son", with UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper being a borderline case since even now the real Jack the Ripper's gender is occasionally called into question. Astolfo, on the other hand, ''isn't'' gender-flipped [[DudeLooksLikeALady despite what you might think]].
* HalfwayPlotSwitch: At first, the story seems set for a great struggle between Yggdmillenia and the Magus Association. [[spoiler:By the end of Volume 2 and essentially confirmed in Volume 3, the true struggle is in fact between the Servants who have sided with either of the two Ruler-class Servants, Jeanne d'Arc and Shirou Kotomine, with Sieg as its focus]].
* HowWeGotHere: Episode 1 opens with a grand battle between the Red and Black faction before rewinding to before most of the Servants were even summoned. The story doesn't get back to the opening point until the end of episode 10/early episode 11.
* ImprobableWeaponUser:
** Jeanne's main weapon is her standard, which she justifies by noting it's tipped with a spear point, so why not?
** Kairi uses human fingers as bullets and hearts filled with teeth as grenades. [[NotMakingThisUpDisclaimer We're not kidding]].
* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Let's see... we have 14 Masters, 15 Servants, several named characters at the Magus Association, and the Homunculus that the Yggdmillenia keeps. This is all only within the first book, mind you, and become a major problem on characters development later. [[spoiler: Getting the number of characters down to a manageable number is a likely out-of-universe reason for Shirou Kotomine's plot to brainwash the other Red masters into handing over their Servants.]]
* LogicalWeakness: As Archer of Black lampshades, no matter the measures a Servant takes, it's pretty much impossible to hide your true identity from someone who knew you in life, especially [[spoiler:your teacher]].
* MundaneUtility: In addition to all his amazing talents, Black Caster can also make the equivalent of a magical television from the flame of a brazier, from which the Black Team observes Kairi and Mordred's fight with one of their patrols.
* NighInvulnerable: All over the place, really. To list the three most major cases:
** First, we have Siegfried, who [[BloodBath bathed in the blood of a dragon]], and is completely invulnerable to any attack that isn't of at least A-Rank power. The only way to get around this is to aim for the [[FatalFlaw small leaf-shaped mark on his back.]]
** Next, we have Achilles, who cannot be harmed by any Servant that doesn't possess a Divine attribute or [[ForgedByTheGods Divine Constructs]], unless they attack his [[AchillesHeel heel]] [[spoiler:which ''only'' deactivates the Noble Phantasm in question]]. [[StoryBreakerPower This is extremely broken,]] as there is no guarantee that a Servant with a Divine attribute will be summoned in the Holy Grail War unless through a specific catalyst. Luckily for the Black Faction, they have Chiron within their ranks (and if they didn't, there is basically nothing the Black Faction can do to stop Achilles from wiping all of their Servants out, attacking his heel notwithstanding).
** Then, we have Karna, who possesses an [[ArmorOfInvincibility invincible armor]] that even gods would have difficulty in destroying. It reduces any damage (physical or conceptual) to a tenth of its original value. In addition, in the original myth, it granted [[CompleteImmortality complete immortality]] to Karna, although it is unknown if this feature is carried over into the Fate/Apocrypha continuity. If it does, Karna is StoryBreakerPower incarnate. And considering that the armor was best known for granting immortality, the odds are in Karna's favour. The only saving grace is that [[AwesomeButImpractical in order to use his ultimate god-killing spear, Karna must permanently sacrifice the armor]].
* ObviousBeta: Looking over the various half-finished and hilariously broken Servants listed, it's clear that this was a project that was abandoned halfway through development. The Light Novel has taken some steps to remove this by replacing or altering characters or skills.
* OhCrap: Archer of Black and Fiore have a subdued one when they realize that they can't remember anything about their encounter with Assassin of Black due to one of their skills, meaning that, aside from knowing that their True Name is Jack the Ripper, they know absolutely nothing about them.
* OneHitKill:
** Black Assassin's Maria the Ripper is capable of this, [[AwesomeButImpractical although only under some rather specific circumstances.]] First, the target must be female. Second, the skill must be activated during night time. Third, there needs to be a dense enough mist covering the vicinity, although she has a secondary Noble Phantasm that can assist with this aspect.
** Red Caster is also capable of this through First Folio, [[CoolButInefficient although it only works against opponents that are weaker than him.]] Considering that his stats are rather abysmal compared to other Servants, it is unlikely that this would work against any of the Servants from the Black Faction.
** Red Lancer possesses an Anti-God Phantasm that will most certainly kill any Servant that becomes a target of it. However, [[TooAwesomeToUse it can only be used once]], and he must permanently sacrifice his armour of invincibility in order to activate it.
* OurHomunculiAreDifferent:
** The Black Faction has a noteworthy amount of Homunculi in their ranks. They serve as a [[LivingBattery mana source]] for the Servants, and also act as sentries alongside the Golems made by Black Caster.
** Red Saber (Mordred) herself is a Homunculus, albeit a rather special one that's more like a [[DesignerBaby Designer Baby.]] [[spoiler: She was noticeably unnerved when she first saw some of the Black Faction's Homunculi.]]
* PoorCommunicationKills: Gordes ordered Siegfried to never speak, to conceal his identity, and Siegfried nodded in agreement. Gordes saw the nod as "your will be done, master" while Siegfried meant it more as "sure, why not?". The narration notes that this misunderstanding is going to become a big factor in the future.
** It does, Gordes arrogantly assumes that Siegfried is merely a tool at his disposal, and this arrogance causes him to [[spoiler: not only waste ''two'' command spells and nearly expose Siegfried's Noble Phantasm so early in the war, but it causes Siegfried to act on his own to save the Homunculus's life at the cost of his own.]]
* PowerTrio: [[VillainousFriendship Shirou Kotomine, Shakespeare and Semiramis]].
* PurpleIsPowerful: [[spoiler:When Sieg's and Mordred's {{Sword Beam}}s collide, they produce a massive purple energy wave that's as strong as both of their Anti-Army Noble Phantasms combined. The first time they do it is during their battle against each other where they create a purple SphereOfDestruction, and the second time they use it as their FinishingMove against Caster of Black's ultimate golem Adam as a SwordBeam that tears it apart]].
* QualityOverQuantity: [[InvertedTrope Inverted for]] the Yggdmillennia. They are stated to favor quantity over quality in terms of their magi and their homunculi.
* QuantityVsQuality: The Yggdmillennia are Quantity while the group gathered by the Clock Tower are Quality.
* RealPlaceBackground: In the anime, as seen [[https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DEmGsCyV0AAOtW2.jpg:large here]].
* RedBaron: ''Fate/complete material'' gives one to each of the planned game's original 14 Servants. But new novel servants Chiron, Avicebron, Mordred, and Achilles do not have them.
* RuleOfSeven: Seven Masters and Servants each, in both the Black and Red factions.
* ShoutOut: In the anime's Episode 11 preview, Astolfo calls Mordred a "female [[Franchise/FridayThe13th Jason]]".
** The more human sized golem in the anime bare resemblance to the B1 battle droid.
* ShownTheirWork:
** Berserker of Black getting annoyed when [[IAmNotShazam people refer to her as "Frankenstein" makes sense when one remembers that technically she's only known as "Frankenstein's monster" and the name is actually her creator's]]; also, considering their [[{{Understatement}} falling out]] it makes sense she would hate being associated with him anymore than necessary. The fact that she's been {{Gender Flip}}ped aside, her cute appearance is also more accurate to the original novel: apart from his eye color and a general unnerving nature about his appearance, the monster is described as physically attractive, intelligent, and articulate, a stark contrast to Boris Karloff's iconic groans and "green brick" look.
** In the anime, Trifas is extremely accurate to Sighișoara, the town it's based on--down to the interiors of public buses, even.
* SpannerInTheWorks: Things start diverging from everybody's plans the moment Rider of Black saves Sieg, something he does purely because in his worldview, rescuing people in need of help is simply what heroes ''do''.
* SpoilerOpening: At the end of the opening, the [[spoiler:black command seals on Shirou's body]] are clearly shown.
* TheStinger:
** In the first episode, a young girl is shown praying to Jeanne d'Arc...right before Jeanne is summoned and takes over her body.
** In Episode 14, Kairi and Fiore meet in a plain, both of them noting that neither of them are enemies, at least for the time being.
** In Episode 18, Shakespeare is writing in his book and dramatically narrating the events that happened, then he addresses the audience and asks how Jeanne's conflict with Shirou will go, and what role Sieg will play.
** In Episode 21, an injured Astolfo comes to and muses over his surroundings, which is engulfed in flames. Achilles appears before Astolfo, entrusting one of his Noble Phantasms to him as part of [[spoiler:a dying]] Chiron's wish.
* StoryBreakerPower:
** In the second volume, we see the true extent of just how overpowered Karna can be: [[spoiler: despite the story going to great lengths to describe just how powerful Vlad III had become thanks to the Holy Grail War's location and the Demonic Defender of the State, Karna was still able to overpower Vlad III for the majority of their match without bothering to use Brahmastra or Vasavi Shakti. Even when Vlad III bypassed the effects of Karna's legendary armour by ''skewering him from the inside of his body'', Karna merely shrugged it off and incinerated the stakes that were within his body. Had Karna uses his [[FantasticNuke Brahmastra]] there, Vlad will be incinerated just like that.]]
** [[spoiler: Vlad III's vampire form also demonstrates this trope, where it is shown that he is able to take on '''six Servants at the same time'''--including the aforementioned Karna. This is despite the fact that Vlad III had just lost his double-layered HomeFieldAdvantage and that the six Servants were empowered by Jeanne herself. One can only imagine how powerful Vlad III's vampire form might have been had he retained both layers of his HomeFieldAdvantage.]]
* SuperpowerLottery: Even for Servant standards, Karna, Achilles, Siegfried, Vlad III and Shakespeare have absolutely absurd abilities and Noble Phantasms. Especially Karna and Achilles. The former is regarded as one of the strongest Servant ever, and the latter is so well-known he's basically on HomeFieldAdvantage everywhere in the world.
* ThoseTwoGuys: Red Rider and Red Archer are rarely seen apart from each other, partially because they are from the same time period/region, and partially because they don't trust Shirou and Red Assassin.
* ThrowingYourSwordAlwaysWorks:
** Mordred demonstrates this in at least one instance, during the fight against the sentry golems and homunculi just outside Yggdmillenia territory.
** As a member of Eighth Sacrament Assembly, Shirou wields the Black Keys and can use them like this.
* WhiteAndGreyMorality: With the exception of Shakespeare and Avicebron, literally every "villainous" character is either sympathetic or a WellIntentionedExtremist. Even Vlad the Impaler is portrayed in a sympathetic manner.
* WhiteHairBlackHeart:
** Black Assassin (Jack the Ripper) and Shirou Kotomine both certainly count as this.
** Subverted with Black Saber (Siegfried) and Red Lancer (Karna) in that while both of them are certainly noble characters, they have the unfortunate luck to serve a morally ambiguous Master. (Gordes Yggdmillenia and Shirou Kotomine respectively).
* TheWorfEffect: Despite the unfathomable power that Black Lancer wields, and the fact that he was the Black Faction's trump card, [[spoiler: he is taken out relatively early in the story by Amakusa Shirou. It wasn't even a decent battle: He was attempting to reach the Grail and prematurely activate it after Shirou deliberately cut the mana connection to the other Red Servants to make Dracula make a break for the Grail, only for Shirou to annihilate him with Black Keys and the Baptismal Sacrament. For extra irony, said weapons wouldn't have affected him nearly as drastically had he not been forced to assume his vampiric form, which overwrote his Servant nature into that of a vampire and gave him the crippling weakness to [[HolyBurnsEvil holy miracles]].]]
* WorldOfBadass: This is the Franchise/{{Nasuverse}}, after all.
* WorthyOpponent: After their first encounter, Red Lancer (Karna) and Black Saber (Siegfried) consider each other as this. They hope to a have a rematch in the future, [[spoiler: which is rather tragic as Siegfried would later go on to perform a HeroicSacrifice and thus miss any opportunity to battle Karna again.]] On the other hand, [[spoiler:said result of that sacrifice, Sieg, eventually does do battle with Karna one last time]].
----