Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MagnusChaseandtheGodsofAsgard

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Meanwhile, (if I remember right) Magnus points out that some bearded ladies exist when he's told about what the original rope's paradoxes were.



** Ragnarok doesn’t really destroy the world. The world’ll still be there once Ragnarok is over. If Apophis ends the world, Ragnarok either won’t matter or immediately trigger (Fimbulvinter sounds a lot like something that would happen if the sun got turned off, followed by wars for resources, and if Apophis’s WierdnessCensor manifests as an Earthquake, those vibrations reverberating across Yggdrasil would cause Jormungandr and Fenrir to break free) because the world would cease to exist in its entirety.

to:

** Ragnarok doesn’t really destroy the world. The world’ll world'll still be there once Ragnarok is over. If Apophis ends the world, Ragnarok either won’t matter or immediately trigger (Fimbulvinter sounds a lot like something that would happen if the sun got turned off, followed by wars for resources, and if Apophis’s WierdnessCensor WeirdnessCensor manifests as an Earthquake, those vibrations reverberating across Yggdrasil would cause Jormungandr and Fenrir to break free) because the world would cease to exist in its entirety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Ragnarok is [[YouCantFightFate inevitable]], meaning that no matter what anyone does it will happen. Does this mean the world can't end any other way? Like, say, if the [[Literature/TheKaneChronicles Kane children]] weren't around to stop Apophis from eating Ra and ending the world, would he still be stopped because the world can't end any other way but Ragnarok?

to:

* So Ragnarok is [[YouCantFightFate inevitable]], meaning that no matter what anyone does it will happen. Does this mean the world can't end any other way? Like, say, if the [[Literature/TheKaneChronicles Kane children]] weren't around to stop Apophis from eating Ra and ending the world, would he still be stopped because the world can't end any other way but Ragnarok?Ragnarok?
**Ragnarok doesn’t really destroy the world. The world’ll still be there once Ragnarok is over. If Apophis ends the world, Ragnarok either won’t matter or immediately trigger (Fimbulvinter sounds a lot like something that would happen if the sun got turned off, followed by wars for resources, and if Apophis’s WierdnessCensor manifests as an Earthquake, those vibrations reverberating across Yggdrasil would cause Jormungandr and Fenrir to break free) because the world would cease to exist in its entirety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking Not So Different as it is now a disambig.


*** It seems like the real estate is both cultural and metaphysical. So the Greek pantheon has tied it's power to various aspects of Western Civilization, and that lets them place a certain portion of the underworld under their power. Similarly, the Egyptian pantheon is invested in the culture of Egypt, which continues to have aspects in the modern day. And how, in a throwaway gag, [[NotSoDifferent we learn that certain monsters embodied blights on the modern world that undermining civilization]] [[TakeThat E.G fast food chains and similar institutions]] But the gods have existence and power beyond just their cultural ties: this is why they can take on different aspects, such as the Greek and Roman manifestations of the same god. [[AFormYouAreComfortableWith The power is manifested in a context appropriate to the culture they have bound themselves too.]] And, of course, there are beings like [[EldritchAbomination Apothis]]. So Maat, the order that maintains the universe in the midst of Chaos, is a power that both the Greek and Egyptian pantheons could see and interact with. But because the Egyptian culture has such a close connection to it, it has the best "tools" to interact with and manipulate it. Basically, the clearest vision we have of what's ''really'' going on is when Annabeth sees into the Duat using Egyptian magic or Percy sees the world through the eyes of Nekhbet.

to:

*** It seems like the real estate is both cultural and metaphysical. So the Greek pantheon has tied it's power to various aspects of Western Civilization, and that lets them place a certain portion of the underworld under their power. Similarly, the Egyptian pantheon is invested in the culture of Egypt, which continues to have aspects in the modern day. And how, in a throwaway gag, [[NotSoDifferent we learn that certain monsters embodied blights on the modern world that undermining civilization]] civilization [[TakeThat E.G fast food chains and similar institutions]] But the gods have existence and power beyond just their cultural ties: this is why they can take on different aspects, such as the Greek and Roman manifestations of the same god. [[AFormYouAreComfortableWith The power is manifested in a context appropriate to the culture they have bound themselves too.]] And, of course, there are beings like [[EldritchAbomination Apothis]]. So Maat, the order that maintains the universe in the midst of Chaos, is a power that both the Greek and Egyptian pantheons could see and interact with. But because the Egyptian culture has such a close connection to it, it has the best "tools" to interact with and manipulate it. Basically, the clearest vision we have of what's ''really'' going on is when Annabeth sees into the Duat using Egyptian magic or Percy sees the world through the eyes of Nekhbet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**That, my friend, [[DontExplainTheJoke is the joke]]

to:

**That, my friend, [[DontExplainTheJoke is the joke]]
joke]].




to:

*** If so though, that could be awkward. Say he gets dressed as a guy in the morning, then shifts.



*** Indeed Sigurd's slaying of Fafnir to be precise.

to:

*** Indeed Indeed. Sigurd's slaying of Fafnir to be precise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More accurate.


** Well, Loki is the Norse archetype of TheTrickster. Can't be a very good trickster if you can't get people to trust you. This also fits with the Norse myths-right up until he kills Balder, he's more-or-less welcome in Asgard. As [[Creator/NeilGaiman another book on Norse mythology]] put it, you were grateful to him even when you hated him the most.

to:

** Well, Loki is the Norse archetype of TheTrickster.TricksterGod. Can't be a very good trickster if you can't get people to trust you. This also fits with the Norse myths-right up until he kills Balder, he's more-or-less welcome in Asgard. As [[Creator/NeilGaiman another book on Norse mythology]] put it, you were grateful to him even when you hated him the most.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Well, Junior is really old. Maybe he made the rope way back in the 90s. PlusNorse stuff seems to have a thing for the 90s, like the sword Magnus got from Hotel Valhalla turning into a chain.

to:

* ** Well, Junior is really old.does mention that he's had a replacement rope ready for a while. Maybe he made the rope way back in the 90s. PlusNorse Plus Norse stuff seems to have a thing for the 90s, like the sword Magnus got from Hotel Valhalla turning into a chain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Well, Junior is really old. Maybe he made the rope way back in the 90s. PlusNorse stuff seems to have a thing for the 90s, like the sword Magnus got from Hotel Valhalla turning into a chain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The Greek gods seem a bit more spread out, though. Medusa's in New Jeresy and the Lotus Hotel and Casino is based in Nevada. It's possible this is because the Greek and Roman gods are just different versions of each other. Plus the two examples I just listed are very close to Manhattan (Greek) and San Francisco (Roman) respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Indeed Sigurd's slaying of Fafnir to be precise.

to:

*** Indeed Sigurd's slaying of Fafnir to be precise.precise.
* So Ragnarok is [[YouCantFightFate inevitable]], meaning that no matter what anyone does it will happen. Does this mean the world can't end any other way? Like, say, if the [[Literature/TheKaneChronicles Kane children]] weren't around to stop Apophis from eating Ra and ending the world, would he still be stopped because the world can't end any other way but Ragnarok?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's a mythological reference to a german myth I believe.

to:

** It's a mythological reference to a german myth I believe.believe.
***Indeed Sigurd's slaying of Fafnir to be precise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Magnus drops Mr. Alderman's dragon heart into the fire on accident, he licks the blood off of his fingers and somehow gains the ability to understand animals. Was this added for the sake of the {{Rule of Funny}}? It struck me as rather anti-climatic.

to:

* When Magnus drops Mr. Alderman's dragon heart into the fire on accident, he licks the blood off of his fingers and somehow gains the ability to understand animals. Was this added for the sake of the {{Rule of Funny}}? It struck me as rather anti-climatic.anti-climatic.
** It's a mythological reference to a german myth I believe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Confused about something.


** It may be subconscious shapeshifting on her part.

to:

** It may be subconscious shapeshifting on her part.part.

* When Magnus drops Mr. Alderman's dragon heart into the fire on accident, he licks the blood off of his fingers and somehow gains the ability to understand animals. Was this added for the sake of the {{Rule of Funny}}? It struck me as rather anti-climatic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I understand that printer trouble can be irritating, but the joke itself seems kind of dated...I haven't experienced the kind of printer trouble that would make it a paradox since the 90s.

Added: 52

Changed: 440

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The guy has only been an orphan for around two years at the start of Magnus Chase and the God of Asgard. Given that it takes place just after Blood of Olympus. That puts his time of being an orphan at Battle of the Labyrinth. Besides Annabeth both live thousands of miles away.

to:

** The guy has only been an orphan for around two years at the start of Magnus Chase and the God of Asgard. Given that it takes place just after Blood of Olympus. That puts his time of being an orphan at Battle of the Labyrinth. Besides Annabeth both live lives thousands of miles away.




to:

** Well, Loki is the Norse archetype of TheTrickster. Can't be a very good trickster if you can't get people to trust you. This also fits with the Norse myths-right up until he kills Balder, he's more-or-less welcome in Asgard. As [[Creator/NeilGaiman another book on Norse mythology]] put it, you were grateful to him even when you hated him the most.




to:

** Printer trouble can be a real pain in the neck. It's happened to me, as well.



** I always assumed she was physically transforming too, but that was just my belief.

to:

** I always assumed she was physically transforming too, but that was just my belief.belief.
** It may be subconscious shapeshifting on her part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The fact that there may not be as many Norse demigods is probably why those from other pantheons, as well as mortals, are also allowed into Valhalla - if it were restricted to children of the Norse gods, there'd probably be a lot less people there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So Alex has made it clear that, being genderfluid, she has no control over what her mental gender is, but can she change her physical sex to accommodate said gender? I don't recall the text being clear on that.

to:

* So Alex has made it clear that, being genderfluid, she has no control over what her mental gender is, but can she change her physical sex to accommodate said gender? I don't recall the text being clear on that.that.
** I always assumed she was physically transforming too, but that was just my belief.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Remember that Annabeth tells him about the Greek and Roman myths being real later. The story is narrated in past tense, so he could mention Jason in the title, and what he meant was that he had never heard of him at that time. At least, that's how I saw it.

to:

** Remember that Annabeth tells him about the Greek and Roman myths being real later. The story is narrated in past tense, so he could mention Jason in the title, and what he meant was that he had never heard of him at that time. At least, that's how I saw it.it.

* So Alex has made it clear that, being genderfluid, she has no control over what her mental gender is, but can she change her physical sex to accommodate said gender? I don't recall the text being clear on that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rick Riordan has always had a tendency to be a bit meta in his chapter titles don't worry about it.

to:

** Rick Riordan has always had a tendency to be a bit meta in his chapter titles don't worry about it.
** Remember that Annabeth tells him about the Greek and Roman myths being real later. The story is narrated in past tense, so he could mention Jason in the title, and what he meant was that he had never heard of him at that time. At least, that's how I saw
it.

Top